Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Waste of a name?! *(TW - miscarriage)

117 replies

SoVerySophie · 24/06/2023 11:51

Very sadly my sister lost her little boy at 15 weeks last year. He was called Milo, it's always been a favourite name for her.

I was chatting with a friend yesterday and she said the most awful thing (or at least I think so). She basically said that it's wasting a name to use it on a baby that you know isn't going to survive. WTAF??? I immediately said that I totally disagreed with her and a name is
special regardless of who you give it to. It didn't shift her opinion though, even when I made it clear that I thought it was a totally inappropriate thing to say. And I'm still upset about it today.

AIBU here or was she?

(Please note: the thread title has been edited by MNHQ - it originally said 'baby loss')

OP posts:
Highfivemum · 24/06/2023 23:20

A cruel thing to say although I have know someone who changed the name she was going to use for her DD (who sadly she miscarried ) as she wanted the name to carry on in the family.
sometimes in life, even if we think it , we shouldn’t say it.

Alwayswonderedwhy · 24/06/2023 23:18

So she miscarried at 15 weeks? She didn't loose a 15 week old baby!

WimpoleHat · 24/06/2023 23:15

I just admit that I find it very odd when people “name” an unborn child - but it would be crass beyond measure to say so out loud in the circumstances you describe. If she’s a good friend, it may just have been an “engaged mouth before brain” moment. We have all had those and would want the benefit of the doubt ourselves; if she’s usually a good friend, I’d just put it down to that.

Justsomehousestuff · 24/06/2023 23:10

Blossomtoes · 24/06/2023 23:02

Me too. My second son was stillborn at 34 weeks, this is trivial compared with some of the crass things people said to me.

I am so sorry ❤️

Blossomtoes · 24/06/2023 23:02

BigButtons · 24/06/2023 16:31

Yes- I agree with the friend too. I wouldn’t say it but I would think it.

Me too. My second son was stillborn at 34 weeks, this is trivial compared with some of the crass things people said to me.

GoOnGoOnGoOnGoOnGoOn · 24/06/2023 22:49

ohfook · 24/06/2023 14:31

I'm a bit sick of reading this to be honest. It may be usual to have a name ready when you're 15 weeks pregnant but it is not unusual to want to name your baby you have lost after carrying for months. Women that lose beyond the first trimester will see and probably hold their baby once it is born. I and many others certainly do give them names.

Same here. I'm not sure some here quite understand what's involved in a 2nd trimester loss. Women absolutely would know the sex of the baby when they're holding them in their hands!

At 15 weeks an unborn baby is around the size of a pear (see pic). Their eyes are sensitive to light and they can start to hear too. They have eyebrows and eyelashes. The bones in their skeleton are hardening and they can kick, wave arms and legs and curl toes. By the end of the 1st trimester (12 weeks) all the organs, muscles, limbs and bones are in place, and the sex organs are well developed. The baby mostly just gets bigger and fatter after that point. This is not just a "bunch of cells".

I for one am sorry for your sister's loss.

Waste of a name?! *(TW - miscarriage)
Theraffarian · 24/06/2023 17:02

I would never have said what your friend did , however I wouldn’t have named a pregnancy so early on , so if I felt the need to at miscarriage I would have used a name I loved but would not have been used for a living child .

However if your sister had thought of the baby as Milo from day one , I can quite understand she wouldn’t have been able to use that name for another baby later on .

I would suggest that as we all deal with miscarriages in our own ways , possibly your friend hasn’t had that experience and as such just thought more pragmatically that if the name was your sister’s favourite she would have wanted to use it another time .

BigButtons · 24/06/2023 16:31

Yes- I agree with the friend too. I wouldn’t say it but I would think it.

GalileoHumpkins · 24/06/2023 16:28

Kitcaterpillar · 24/06/2023 16:09

There is something wrong with the wording when a number of posters think it's a 15 week old baby and not a 15 week old pregnancy which are, respectfully, entirely different.

I agree, I based my post on thinking it was the loss of a 15-week-old baby. I still think it was a crass thing to say though.

Kitcaterpillar · 24/06/2023 16:09

Lonevoiceasusual · 24/06/2023 13:58

Nothing wrong with the wording at all. This was a wanted baby so 15 weeks pregnant or 15 weeks or 15 years since it’s not any different The only difference is the size . You wouldn’t say a 2 year old was any less of a person than an adult just because there is a size difference.

This was a wanted baby, a loss. The loss of a child .

There is something wrong with the wording when a number of posters think it's a 15 week old baby and not a 15 week old pregnancy which are, respectfully, entirely different.

PonyPatter44 · 24/06/2023 15:38

Bluestoat · 24/06/2023 12:48

I used up my favourite girl name on my first daughter who was still born unexpectedly at term. I’ve had two more daughters and a son since. I don’t regret giving my dead daughter the “best” name. I had nothing else I could give her.

This made me well up. Such a beautiful sentiment.

flimsywhimsy · 24/06/2023 15:34

She shouldn't have said that, but tbh, I understand why she might feel that way... Using a name that's particularly important to you when you know you won't be using it in the same way that you would if your child had survived... There's absolutely nothing wrong with doing that, if it's what feels right to you—every baby 'deserves' a name, and you can't really 'waste' a name, as such—but I can imagine it might cause hurt feelings if, for instance, it were a special family name, such as a name honouring a father, grandmother, favourite aunt, etc. If someone else might have wanted to use that name, now they may feel that it's been taken and 'wasted', since it won't be used in the same way that it could/would have been.

But it's a very tricky one, imo, and I wouldn't presume to comment on someone's choice, either way!

JudgeRudy · 24/06/2023 15:24

I don't think your friend is wrong to think this way. I have a similar opinion. I realise that people feel differently though and perhaps wouldn't have verbalise my thoughts, but I don't think there's anything outrageous about what she said. A lot of people would view a 15 week miscarriage very differently to the loss of a born child and its very early to be naming a baby.

Silvergoldandglitter · 24/06/2023 15:23

I agree with her, I often think this myself but would NEVER say it out loud to anybody.

BravoMyDear · 24/06/2023 15:22

ButImNotOldEnough · 24/06/2023 12:18

I think that anyone who has experienced a loss during pregnancy can call their baby whatever they want and anyone that thinks otherwise ought to keep their ignorant mouth shut.

Absolutely this

OldTinHat · 24/06/2023 15:20

The friend is being VU.

I named my baby but lost him to a miscarriage. When I eventually gave birth, I still gave my DS the same name as the one I lost. I loved the name and it felt like the baby who had gone had come back but at the right time.

Zezet · 24/06/2023 15:18

... 15 weeks pregnancy is not the same as losing a 2 year old, because a 2 years old is as valuable as a 17 years old.

Just like losing your mother at 92 isn't the same as losing her at 32.

And it is obvious that, if you express the sentiment that they are the same, most people might not be so crass as to say it to you that that is over the top/ridiculous/outrageous to the mother who lost her child, as opposed to a pregnancy..., but a majority will be thinking it.

Justsomehousestuff · 24/06/2023 15:15

CoreyTaylorsSoggyTshirt · 24/06/2023 12:18

People say all sorts of shit when talking about child loss.

Over the years I've had the deaths of my children compared to the death of a pet, told I didn't know real pain as I could have children so I was luckier than her as she couldn't conceive at all (5 days after my daughter died), then the many "at least your young enough to have more" even the HV when I had my 2nd ds after my first son died walked in and said "so, does he look anything like your dead son then" and many, many more.

People can be utter dickheads.

Oh my goodness.. 😟 People can be so inconsiderate.

lakesummer · 24/06/2023 15:12

I kind of agree with the friend but I absolutely wouldn't say it out loud.

It's entirely up to an individual how they deal with their miscarriage, there isn't one right way.

I had bump names and then proper names once they were born. I wouldn't have given either dc a birth name at 15 weeks but that is just my personal preference.

FortofPud · 24/06/2023 15:12

Her opinion isn't unreasonable, but the voicing of it to someone else about their situation is juat dreadful.

Justsomehousestuff · 24/06/2023 15:12

What an insensitive terrible thing to say.... I'd ditch that 'friend'.

HelterSkelter224 · 24/06/2023 15:11

SoVerySophie · 24/06/2023 11:51

Very sadly my sister lost her little boy at 15 weeks last year. He was called Milo, it's always been a favourite name for her.

I was chatting with a friend yesterday and she said the most awful thing (or at least I think so). She basically said that it's wasting a name to use it on a baby that you know isn't going to survive. WTAF??? I immediately said that I totally disagreed with her and a name is
special regardless of who you give it to. It didn't shift her opinion though, even when I made it clear that I thought it was a totally inappropriate thing to say. And I'm still upset about it today.

AIBU here or was she?

(Please note: the thread title has been edited by MNHQ - it originally said 'baby loss')

What an asshole!!

That baby has a name and will be part of your sister's family forever, even though he has died.

Jesus Christ what the fuck is wrong with people.

BubziOwl · 24/06/2023 15:09

Even if you think it's unusual to name a baby in pregnancy (and FWIW, I don't think it's unusual at all), surely you'd have the good sense and common decency to keep your trap shut about it?

mayorofcasterbridge · 24/06/2023 15:07

I have to say, I kind of agree with the friend's opinion.... how close a friend is she? Is she generally lacking in filters? Is she normally a good friend? She shouldn't have said that out loud to you, but if this is a 'blip' in an otherwise good friendship, I think you have to put it out of your mind and let it go. People say absolutely fucking stupid things sometimes.

I also find it strange to have named a 15 week foetus tbh. I had two miscarriages and quite apart from the fact I never got to find out the gender (I wish I could have known), and while I regarded them as my much-wanted babies, it would never have occurred to me to give them a name.

ItsBritneyBitchhhh · 24/06/2023 14:50

DietrichandDiMaggio · 24/06/2023 12:28

I think the OP was misleading- I read it as her little boy died at 15 weeks old and thought the friend was being really horrible, even if they had known he wouldn't survive for long, as he was their child that they loved and cared for through his short life. Other posters expressed sorrow for the OPs loss, because something like that would be distressing for the whole family.
I'm sorry but a miscarriage at 15 weeks, whilst upsetting for the parents, is not uncommon and does not compare at all. Even so, if the sister had decided on that name, I think it would be strange to think about saving it in case she had another son who survived and think of a different one this time.

I thought the same thing!