Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think this is inappropriate homework for an 11 year old? **MNHQ adding content warning for CSA**

167 replies

ProwlingD · 19/06/2023 19:14

I run a homework club once a week from my home where I oversee and assist students with their homework. This afternoon, one of my 11 year old students (year 7) brought this short story. She had to read it and then write a summary of what the story was about, how she thinks the characters felt etc.

After she had read it and written her summary, I then read it and was shocked at what the story is about / is suggesting. Her summary was completely wrong - she read the story as one of a happy step family - and I didn't feel it appropriate to explain to her what the story is actually suggesting. I then showed it to my DP (he is not in education) and he also felt it was inappropriate.

I'm am English Literature teacher (but left working in schools a couple of years ago) and I am not easily shocked or surprised by the texts my students are reading. Had this been a student in KS4 I would have felt them mature enough to explain the connotations, but 11 seems far too young.

AIBU to think 11 is too young to be getting this as homework?

To think this is inappropriate homework for an 11 year old? **MNHQ adding content warning for CSA**
To think this is inappropriate homework for an 11 year old? **MNHQ adding content warning for CSA**
OP posts:
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 19/06/2023 20:56

Chachachachachachacha · 19/06/2023 20:55

I think it’s inappropriate to set as a self guided task for kids that age as they won’t understand what it means but I absolutely think that kids should be taught about predators and what tactics they may use. Avoiding the subject altogether and pretending they don’t exist put them at more risk of abuse.

I don't think anyone on here is saying kids shouldn't learn about SA in an age appropriate manner.

This story is absolutely not that.

icelollycraving · 19/06/2023 20:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Anniessong · 19/06/2023 20:55

Whenconfusionsetsin · 19/06/2023 19:46

makes me wonder about the teacher to be honest that they think this is ok. Has it been used as some warped grooming exercise.

Even if it was a mistake by the teacher who had not read it in advance, it could still potentially cause harm to the children reading it. It doesn’t have to be grooming to be safeguarding- it’s failing to protect children from harm. This teacher’s possible lack of care/ attention to the text is neglecting their safeguarding duties

Chachachachachachacha · 19/06/2023 20:55

I think it’s inappropriate to set as a self guided task for kids that age as they won’t understand what it means but I absolutely think that kids should be taught about predators and what tactics they may use. Avoiding the subject altogether and pretending they don’t exist put them at more risk of abuse.

angelikacpickles · 19/06/2023 20:54

Totally inappropriate for an 11 year old. My DD is 12 and I'm fairly sure the meaning of that story would go entirely over her head TBH.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 19/06/2023 20:54

Absolem76 · 19/06/2023 20:35

How the hell can Amnesty International get away with printing that? I
There is nothing wrong with the story which is by a good author
What is wrong is giving it to an 11 year old.

We will have to disagree. I think there is everything wrong with that story. It doesn't do enough to demonstrate that abuse is wrong. It isn't a social story designed to open discussion about consent and abuse etc. It's creepy as fuck and as a single short story serves zero purpose apart from to shock and disgust

Singleandproud · 19/06/2023 20:50

@beatrice14 if it didn't have a negative impact on you that's great but statistically there will be students in your class living very similar circumnstances that have experienced SA that will have a very negative impact on them.

ThroughGraceAlone · 19/06/2023 20:49

WOW this was hard to read! OP, please please update on the school's response! Makes me terrified to send my children to school!

beatrice14 · 19/06/2023 20:47

The story is troubling because it's for a human rights collection and wants to portray the brutality of abuse. I think it should be troubling. It is completely clear the abuse is wrong-much more so when you know the context of the anthology. I think if you have a story when the abuse is not acknowledged as wrong, it shouldn't be read as promoting abuse necessarily, it could be showing how people can be groomed and remain trapped. But that would not be appropriate for many 11-year-olds to read, and there is the worry that a creepy teacher would give such a story for alterior reasons.. There are support materials on the Amnesty website for this collection further acknowledging the abuse as wrong. These issues should be discussed, but age and the way the teacher does it is important.

Ywudu · 19/06/2023 20:43

Actually at the end of the book Damien takes the stand and gives evidence to protect his little brother and it makes reference to another abuser being jailed too. I still find the reading quite troubling but at least its a nod in the right direction.
Still wholly unsuitable for a year 7 or 8 child.

beatrice14 · 19/06/2023 20:42

17-year-old here. I read this entire collection, which also deals with sex trafficking, fgm, suicide, death of parents etc when I was 12. Obviously the stories were disturbing, but I suffered no ill effects. (However I was probably a bit old for my age - I also read things like Sue Lloyd-Roberts THe War on Women and Gloria Steinem texts, both of which had disturbing bits which I just turned the page on, but probably did mean my disturbance threshold was higher).

However, I appreciate that some children would not be ready for that sort of material at all, and Y7 is too young. Schools can discuss really tough books like The Bluest Eye, and school should be a safe place to discuss these issues, but not that young.

EsmeSusanOgg · 19/06/2023 20:41

Blanketpolicy · 19/06/2023 19:20

It's a little boy being abused. Damien.

And still inappropriate.

Yup. With the implied threat of more abuse for the baby when it is old enough.

Awful. Totally inappropriate for 11.

Absolem76 · 19/06/2023 20:35

How the hell can Amnesty International get away with printing that? I
There is nothing wrong with the story which is by a good author
What is wrong is giving it to an 11 year old.

Singleandproud · 19/06/2023 20:34

The rest of the book isn't any better, if I can remember rightly the other stories include quite graphic stories of being a refugee in a camp and crossing the border, a trans story about having body parts removed, a story on FGM etc. There is no guarantee that this was chosen by an individual teacher, it's probably the same task set by the English department for all classes. Or like my school, a-okayed by the multi academy Trust bigwigs and enforced on the staff.

PimmsandCucumbers · 19/06/2023 20:34

Safeguarding is a serious, sensitive and important area for children. This story could be something a predator would enjoy, I think that is the point. It is confusing for a child who might read it and think secrets are OK. It is quite creepy. This is not part of a careful, evidence based and sensitive safeguarding lesson, it is a big error and could open up all kinds of feelings of shame or confusing for kids reading it, with no adequate expert follow up.

Hardtime · 19/06/2023 20:30

Whenconfusionsetsin · 19/06/2023 19:46

makes me wonder about the teacher to be honest that they think this is ok. Has it been used as some warped grooming exercise.

This is what struck me. The normalisation of the idea of helpful, secret rituals that will protect a loved one, marked by a person in authority who gets to see how dozens of innocent children interpret it.

NoSquirrels · 19/06/2023 20:28

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 19/06/2023 20:21

I think I need more of the story to make a call - what happens next in Damien's story. For example, does he learn that the abuse is wrong and have a supportive adult to report to. That could be a good modelling experience.

I think at 11 I was very gullible and would not have understood the implications shared in these 3 pages and wanted to know more about what this amazing game is that can save people.

Someone posted the whole story upthread. It doesn’t get more appropriate for an 11 year old, I’m afraid.

BCCoach · 19/06/2023 20:23

INeedAnotherName · 19/06/2023 20:06

I started reading the next couple of stories and they aren't much better.

What is the point of this book? It's styled as easy to read for children but the content is adult. It's sickening if this is being promoted for schools by Amnesty.

It's not being promoted to schools by Amnesty. It's a YA short story compilation.

CurlewKate · 19/06/2023 20:22

It's from a collection of YAshort stories published by Amnesty International. I suspect whoever set it hasn't read it-just thought Oh yes- the Boy in the Striped Pyjamas writer-that'll be OK. I'm very liberal in my approach to children's reading, but I think that is entirely unsuitable for an 11 year old.

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 19/06/2023 20:21

I think I need more of the story to make a call - what happens next in Damien's story. For example, does he learn that the abuse is wrong and have a supportive adult to report to. That could be a good modelling experience.

I think at 11 I was very gullible and would not have understood the implications shared in these 3 pages and wanted to know more about what this amazing game is that can save people.

SittingNextToIt · 19/06/2023 20:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ywudu · 19/06/2023 20:18

I wouldn't be happy with my 13 year old reading this without some discussion from the school first at 11 I'd be furious.

Ghosttofu99 · 19/06/2023 20:17

IAmAnIdiot123 · 19/06/2023 19:27

It's a little boy getting sexually abused and the step dad insinuating he will also be abusing his beautiful brother when older too.

I found it hard to read and I am 33. The minute the special game was mentioned, I had to put it down for a minute. However, I am not a teacher and my children are very young so I have no idea if this is considered okay for that age group yet. Sadly there are many children, much younger than 11, who actually live through these awful events.

I don't think it should have been set as homework, this sort of passage should be read and discussed straight away in a lesson.

This

The way abusers manipulate is very insidious. I think it’s important for children to be taught how to recognise abuse and ask for help but the text should be discussed as part of a lesson and with the appropriate age group.

Im also not a teacher so no idea if this is appropriate for 11yo. I can remember when I was 11 (back in the dark ages) reading An Inspector Calls which is pretty brutal while top set read Of Mice and Men. At 12 or 13 we read Tess of the D’ubervilles, which I still occasionally think about as some of the themes in that were quite hard going.

dancinginthesky · 19/06/2023 20:16

This is a teacher.

We don't give predators the benefit of the doubt- report report report

You can't just accidentally fuck up and give eleven year olds homework on sexual abuse as a teacher

JaukiVexnoydi · 19/06/2023 20:16

Whoever set this homework for an 11yo is a safeguarding risk themselves. They may mean well but it's totally inappropriate and traumatising for so young a child to be expected to grapple with these kinds of complexities, and they may have done some serious psychological harm already. It's important that this is reported to their employers, don't just complain to the person responsible themselves.