Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think this is inappropriate homework for an 11 year old? **MNHQ adding content warning for CSA**

167 replies

ProwlingD · 19/06/2023 19:14

I run a homework club once a week from my home where I oversee and assist students with their homework. This afternoon, one of my 11 year old students (year 7) brought this short story. She had to read it and then write a summary of what the story was about, how she thinks the characters felt etc.

After she had read it and written her summary, I then read it and was shocked at what the story is about / is suggesting. Her summary was completely wrong - she read the story as one of a happy step family - and I didn't feel it appropriate to explain to her what the story is actually suggesting. I then showed it to my DP (he is not in education) and he also felt it was inappropriate.

I'm am English Literature teacher (but left working in schools a couple of years ago) and I am not easily shocked or surprised by the texts my students are reading. Had this been a student in KS4 I would have felt them mature enough to explain the connotations, but 11 seems far too young.

AIBU to think 11 is too young to be getting this as homework?

To think this is inappropriate homework for an 11 year old? **MNHQ adding content warning for CSA**
To think this is inappropriate homework for an 11 year old? **MNHQ adding content warning for CSA**
OP posts:
Outofthepark · 20/06/2023 04:51

nocoolnamesleft · 19/06/2023 19:21

Bloody hell.

Jesus Christ OP what the hell is that?!

Yea definitely complain immediately that's disturbing!

Halpmer · 20/06/2023 04:21

*Is it possible that this exercise was intended as a "screening tool," to discover whether or not any of the children in that group have experienced sexual abuse? If they hadn't, they are more likely to "read" the story as OP described. If they had, their response to it would be quite different.
*
Quz... no, no, no and no again. This would be so wildly inappropriate... at 11 I would have understood this text for what it is - I was mature for my age - and I have never experienced abuse (of this nature anyway).

To suggest it could be a way of implementing a safeguarding system is insane.. and if that is the case then the whole school would need to be reported!

Halpmer · 20/06/2023 04:14

I'm a secondary English teacher and also teach PSHE type stuff a couple times a week. This should not have been set by the teacher, I feel like it's maybe a quick select from a book they thought was appropriate and they clearly haven't read... this is why it's very important to read/watch any text/video before students see it.

I think this should be flagged immediately with the school and parents of this child. It's a safeguarding concern at this stage...

QueenCamilla · 20/06/2023 02:16

Disgusting. Wtf is wrong with the education system in the UK?

It's a collection of pedo stories for pedos to enjoy. And if anyone on here thinks that a paragraph at the end of numerous stories "and then they all went to jail" makes this evil shite right somehow... You need your heads examining!

I was groomed by a family friend/tutor at 10-11 years old. It's very similar to a couple of these stories.
The way it's done in the book, is not how I'd choose to talk about it! It's harmful, it's emphasising "do not tell" & "somehow it's your own fault" angle.

I have a 9 year old. Should I describe to him next year in detail the grooming that happened to me? That would involve describing what a porn mag is, the adult content I read... 🤢 Should I mention that I was pretty, I wasn't wearing much and I didn't seem to mind 🤮 and I didn't tell?
I'd sound like a groomer myself, no? So why is this book OK? I'm convinced the author is a danger to children. I'd be like a hawk on the teacher too.

I'm sure I can educate my child on grooming and become a trusted & safe person to confide in (that's what I was lacking in childhood) without this pedo manual!

Cattenberg · 20/06/2023 01:44

I wouldn’t have understood the first part of the story (written from Damian’s point of view) when I was 11/12.

I think the whole story is too nuanced for children. So much is hinted at, but not spelt out (not that most people would want to read those details).

Also, the story is told by a series of unreliable narrators. Two are too young to understand their situations. The others are abusers who minimise their actions and blame the victims. The final narrator is a reliable one who provides important context and concludes the story. Even so, it must be very tricky for children to sort the “truth” within the story from the “untruths”. Might some of them be fooled for example, into thinking that Melissa isn’t an abuser?

I’m not saying it isn’t a good story. But I’m amazed it’s recommended for children aged 12+.

bridgetreilly · 20/06/2023 01:13

Even if the 11yos don’t get the sexual abuse side, they shouldn’t be reading about how children can stop their parents from get cancer and dying. Or, indeed, that cancer always means dying. This is wildly inappropriate on every level.

CurlewKate · 20/06/2023 00:31

"Is it possible that this exercise was intended as a "screening tool," to discover whether or not any of the children in that group have experienced sexual abuse? "
I fucking hope not!

beatrice14 · 19/06/2023 23:33

I also think it's a bit unfair to say the story didn't show the long-term consequences - one story can't tell everything. It did say Damien was often in detention so maybe that was a hint?

Quiverer · 19/06/2023 23:30

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 19/06/2023 20:21

I think I need more of the story to make a call - what happens next in Damien's story. For example, does he learn that the abuse is wrong and have a supportive adult to report to. That could be a good modelling experience.

I think at 11 I was very gullible and would not have understood the implications shared in these 3 pages and wanted to know more about what this amazing game is that can save people.

If you look at the longer extract linked above, yes Damien does learn that abuse is wrong - the last story is about him giving evidence in court against the stepfather to protect his younger brother.

I think it's a good story, in fact. Just not for 11 year olds.

PimmsandCucumbers · 19/06/2023 22:04

Chachachachachachacha · 19/06/2023 20:55

I think it’s inappropriate to set as a self guided task for kids that age as they won’t understand what it means but I absolutely think that kids should be taught about predators and what tactics they may use. Avoiding the subject altogether and pretending they don’t exist put them at more risk of abuse.

This is incredibly sensitive work though, and not really for untrained teachers to just delve into. I agree it is important for kids to be able to know about what is ‘OK’ and what is not OK. There are appropriate safeguarding age appropriate advice such as on the NSPCC website. It’s definitely an area where more harm than good can be done by doing this inappropriately, as is the case here.

beatrice14 · 19/06/2023 21:58

Not necessarily though- I hadn;t been abused but I understood and I agree with Jude that I think others would. It feels wrong to screen like that when it could cause upset

steevanseegall · 19/06/2023 21:56

Is it possible that this exercise was intended as a "screening tool," to discover whether or not any of the children in that group have experienced sexual abuse?

That's utterly batshit. Don't be so ridiculous.

Quz · 19/06/2023 21:52

Not particularly disagreeing with what anyone has said, but want to play a bit of Devil's Advocate here.

For the record, about 25 years ago I was a childcare worker at a large and very well-respected child services organization (mostly ages 8-16) for 3 and a half years. I worked in an after school program for children that were at risk of being taken out of the home for one reason or another. Many (way too many) of those children had been sexually abused and had behavioral problems as a result of that abuse that significantly contributed to their being able to stay at home/in school.

That said...Is it possible that this exercise was intended as a "screening tool," to discover whether or not any of the children in that group have experienced sexual abuse? If they hadn't, they are more likely to "read" the story as OP described. If they had, their response to it would be quite different.

JudgeRudy · 19/06/2023 21:39

Gosh, it's certainly a very serious topic but I'm less concerned about the subject matter than I am that your student appears to have missed the point. I appreciate people vary but I'd have fought most 11 year old would have understood what's being suggested here.
I'd just highlight this to the parent. They can decide for themselves if they think it's unsuitable material for their child and act accordingly.
My children are much older now but I'm confident they'd have both picked up on the covert message and I'd be happy for them to read this, particularly if there was to be refection/discussion.

Dontwanttowaitanymore · 19/06/2023 21:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

beatrice14 · 19/06/2023 21:23

I agree kids should be taught but by parents first. We don;t like to say this- but what if the parents are the abusers? That's why schools should discuss it. But not by using this sort of story first. This kind of creepy story should be for older teens to discuss.

Chachachachachachacha · 19/06/2023 21:15

I discussed abuse in an age appropriate way right from when my kids could understand. Teaching about which body parts were private and how if an adult asks you to keep certain things secret that is a sign they are not a good person. I don’t see the point in only starting to teach this to older teens who know it anyway. You need to teach it when kids are more susceptible to manipulation.
I understand it’s fiction but if the child in the story had a lesson about this at school or had discussed it with parents would they still keep the secret/be manipulated? Likely not. Often adults think that shielding kids from difficult topics is protecting them when it is actually putting them at more risk.

Oysterbabe · 19/06/2023 21:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Oysterbabe · 19/06/2023 21:11

It does at least have a positive ending.

To think this is inappropriate homework for an 11 year old? **MNHQ adding content warning for CSA**
beatrice14 · 19/06/2023 21:08

Yes, I agree that a child may have experienced SA and it could be triggering -that's part of the reason it shouldn't be given to younger children, but older teens. But should all difficult issues not be discussed in case of that? Or just some especially awful ones like SA? I think maybe such issues are better discussed without fictional material. They certainly shouldn;t be set as homework.

Chachachachachachacha · 19/06/2023 21:05

Maybe there is going to be a discussion at school about what the children think it means and why the character may have been using the emotive subject of her fathers death in order to manipulate alongside advice about how children can keep themselves safe? Who knows. I would hope it wouldn’t just be set as homework and left at that. That would be inappropriate.
I would also hope there would have been some prior warning before the subject matter was taught. It could be sensitive for a number of reasons for children who have been victims of abuse or suffered the loss of a relative.
But I’m getting the sense from a lot of the replies that the subject matter should be off limits altogether for this age group?

beatrice14 · 19/06/2023 21:03

I don't think the content is adult- I think it's for older teenagers. I read other books at school which dealt with difficult issues -e.g. After The Fire, which was about a cult, or The Color Purple which dealt with sexual abuse. I think these books should be read by older students, learning to confront about the worst aspects of the world should be part of education.

SeaSaltAir · 19/06/2023 21:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I’d like MN HQ to comment on this thread to assure they have no concerns about the OP. Their silence is deafening.

CurlewKate · 19/06/2023 21:01

It sounds to me like a mistake. It's an entirely appropriate boon for young adults-just not for year 7s. Talk to the school and get it sorted out.

dancinginthesky · 19/06/2023 20:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Daily mail probably getting a headline ready...