Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Spencer Matthews: Finding Michael *MNHQ adding spoiler alert on this one*

89 replies

Moonicorn · 08/03/2023 22:19

AIBU to think there’s something a bit distasteful about this documentary? Filming dead bodies, risking the lives of Sherpas to find his brother who has long passed… okay I know they’re being paid, but it seems a bit exploitative, or is it me? Very sorry for his loss of course, but endangering more lives for the film just seems a bit 😐

I haven’t actually seen it by the way, I don’t have Disney+ but I also feel it would be a bit ‘ghoulish’. Maybe it’s just me.

OP posts:
CatsShittyArses · 08/03/2023 23:40

I've just watched it. I've read up about Everest a while ago and so wasn't surprised by the number of bodies up there.

You should watch this before giving judgement.

I guess he was trying to do this for closure, the same as somebody wanting to retrieve a body in a murder case etc. Unless you've lost somebody dear to you and not had their body to bury/cremate then it would be hard for you to appreciate the loss. If you watch the documentary you will be able to witness the closure that it brings another family by retrieving the body.

I thought it was a very moving documentary and whilst I didn't previously like Spencer or Vogue, he comes across very likeable in the documentary and I had nothing but sympathy for him and his family. Having read up about Sherpas previously I also had a lot of respect for the hard work they did too and am glad that Spencer was able to honour a Sherpa family at the end.

MarshaMelrose · 08/03/2023 23:24

DH was horrified there were so many bodies just laying around and after some Googling , it seems they are just literally scattered around even on the routes people pass .

We were there a few years ago just for a 12 day holiday. In just those 12 days time five people died. They let anyone go up as long as they can pay the licence and they keep increasing the number of passes because they want the money. The people going up are in a long line and they're just not accustomed to atmosphere. You could see on the film and photos they showed, people just walking past the dead bodies, filing their way to get to the top. But, reasonably, what else could they do? There's just no way to take them back down without serious risk to yourself. The Nepalese officials said they would get them removed but who knows.

UdoU · 08/03/2023 23:21

Oakorn · 08/03/2023 22:47

Yes, rich people are bad, we get the message. Let them all die.

🙄

I’m struggling to see what the ‘important issue’ is with rich people who choose to go mountain climbing? ‘Let them all die’ is pithy but doesn’t answer my question.

murasaki · 08/03/2023 23:07

@Moonicorn thought so, just checking own memory!

murasaki · 08/03/2023 23:06

I may have my time.frames a bit off there, but not by much.

Moonicorn · 08/03/2023 23:06

murasaki · 08/03/2023 23:06

'Because it's there' was George Mallory, I think? Who was only found in the nineties, having climbed in the twenties.

Yes I was referencing him!

OP posts:
murasaki · 08/03/2023 23:06

'Because it's there' was George Mallory, I think? Who was only found in the nineties, having climbed in the twenties.

Genevieva · 08/03/2023 23:05

@Moonicorn Modern Nepal is very different from 1990s Nepal. Many people have gravitated rom rural areas like Solukhumbu to towns and cities, particularly Kathmandu. My closest friend from my time there has a very impressive job in Kathmandu, despite coming from the sort of background in which you might imagine there was no choice at all. Her mother died of TB. Unthinkable these days.

Moonicorn · 08/03/2023 23:04

purpleme12 · 08/03/2023 23:03

I cannot understand why people climb it

Because it’s there…

OP posts:
purpleme12 · 08/03/2023 23:03

I cannot understand why people climb it

AnonymousArabella · 08/03/2023 23:02

DrMeredithGrey2023 · 08/03/2023 22:26

As someone who has watched it, I can confirm that although the bodies may have been filmed, they certainly weren't shown.

It's actually a very interesting watch.

Apparently it was edited at the very last minute (they pushed the release date back a couple of days when Spencer was already doing press about the show) to remove the bodies - they were visible in the original edit.

It’s not my usual sort of programme but it was quite interesting - the way they matched up the search on the mountain with the old video footage of his brother was very poignant.

i was quite shocked by the amount of bodies clearly just lying around…I knew it on an intellectual level but to see / hear about it in the programme was quite startling.

LesserBohemians · 08/03/2023 23:00

JamMakingWannaBe · 08/03/2023 22:49

I read an article in the weekend newspapers that there were two bodies in a cave climbers sheltered in. One was just called "Green Boots". They were eventually moved, but just out-of-sight and not off the mountain. Sad.

I don’t think you understand how dangerous and freakishly expensive it is to get bodies off the mountain — people have died in the past trying to retrieve a body — and that all climbers sign something that says to try and repatriate them/get them to somewhere they can be cremated, or to leave them on the mountain. Many opt to be left. Climbers are realists, mostly. They will have had to consider the risks well in advance, and to have made a decision.

Litter and overcrowding is another, not unrelated matter, of course.

DrMeredithGrey2023 · 08/03/2023 22:57

WestOfWestminster · 08/03/2023 22:56

I thought it was a very kind thing to do for the Sherpa's family of the man they bought home.
I wasnt sure whether the offer to bring him home was dependant on them being unsuccessful in the search for Michael though, because if it was that seems like a very cruel thing to do to a poor family. Perhaps it was the way it was edited but they could have made it clearer.

I don't agree the sherpas in this particular search party were exploited, it looked like they were very organised, professional and well briefed, and it was clear they weren't going to take unnecessary risks just to recover a body.

I think the film highlighted the issues surrounding Everest though, and perhaps make people more interested in the reality of what goes on there.

Yeah, it was dependant on them it finding Michael.

He said to his brother that they were still hoping to find him, but if not would like to help his family out instead

Moonicorn · 08/03/2023 22:56

It must’ve been awful when his brother went missing to his certain fate, and I understand the desire to find him.

The Sherpas are hugely impressive but I find their ‘choice’ to be not much of a choice - take on these huge risks or live in poverty 🤷🏼‍♀️ Although they’re much better adjusted to the conditions and biologically adapted (fascinating!) it’s still very dangerous for them.

I read Into Thin Air, I thought it was excellent but chilling how quickly even the most meticulously planned expedition can descend into chaos and disaster up there.

OP posts:
WestOfWestminster · 08/03/2023 22:56

I thought it was a very kind thing to do for the Sherpa's family of the man they bought home.
I wasnt sure whether the offer to bring him home was dependant on them being unsuccessful in the search for Michael though, because if it was that seems like a very cruel thing to do to a poor family. Perhaps it was the way it was edited but they could have made it clearer.

I don't agree the sherpas in this particular search party were exploited, it looked like they were very organised, professional and well briefed, and it was clear they weren't going to take unnecessary risks just to recover a body.

I think the film highlighted the issues surrounding Everest though, and perhaps make people more interested in the reality of what goes on there.

derbylass81 · 08/03/2023 22:55

Thank you @DrMeredithGrey2023

How very sad Sad

pristinesurfacesGBTD · 08/03/2023 22:54

Genevieva · 08/03/2023 22:39

Note - I have never seen Spencer Matthews in anything previously.

The Sherpa population are adapted to high altitude living. Professional guides within the Sherpa community know the mountain like the backs of their hands. I would imagine this particular journey was safer than most because everyone will have been properly insured etc. No short cuts.

Insurance doesn't keep you safe, it pays out money to relatives of the dead

DrMeredithGrey2023 · 08/03/2023 22:54

derbylass81 · 08/03/2023 22:53

I haven't seen it yet but keen to do so.

Very sad. I knew there were bodies on Everest, but I didn't realise they were in plain sight and still just left. That is horrifying.

So when his brother died then, they know nothing? As far as they know he was on Everest and then.....nothing. Is that right?

They now the general area that he was last seen in - his guide went in front of him due to higher than normal winds I believe, and turned round at some point to find him gone

derbylass81 · 08/03/2023 22:53

I haven't seen it yet but keen to do so.

Very sad. I knew there were bodies on Everest, but I didn't realise they were in plain sight and still just left. That is horrifying.

So when his brother died then, they know nothing? As far as they know he was on Everest and then.....nothing. Is that right?

ISpyCobraKai · 08/03/2023 22:52

There's a great documentary on Netflix about the Sherpas, called, Sherpa, so easy to remember.
I'd also recommend Everest, the film.

grosslyunfair · 08/03/2023 22:51

I enjoyed it. Spencer is a bit of a twat in my view and 'his story' was the weakest part of it but it showed the damage that such an early loss can do and also, clearly, the dangers and reality of Everest. I know it was a good narrative but I thought bringing at least one body home was a humane thing to do. Also showed that even with massive resources it's impossible to bring most people down if they die up there.

It showed the beauty of the area, the impressiveness of the Sherpas, the folly of attempting it casually and how ruined the mountain has been by tourism.

JamMakingWannaBe · 08/03/2023 22:49

I read an article in the weekend newspapers that there were two bodies in a cave climbers sheltered in. One was just called "Green Boots". They were eventually moved, but just out-of-sight and not off the mountain. Sad.

DrMeredithGrey2023 · 08/03/2023 22:48

I had thought today that I'd cracked the reason it's release was pushed back - Mr Matthews Senior has some historical allegations made against him.

Turns out, Disney were concerned about all the dead people. Wonder if it was originally unblurred.

Oakorn · 08/03/2023 22:47

UdoU · 08/03/2023 22:46

What is the important issue? Rich people going mountain climbing?

Yes, rich people are bad, we get the message. Let them all die.

Carriemac · 08/03/2023 22:46

YABU . It's a really interesting documentary and I really warmed to him and his family