Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Spencer Matthews: Finding Michael *MNHQ adding spoiler alert on this one*

89 replies

Moonicorn · 08/03/2023 22:19

AIBU to think there’s something a bit distasteful about this documentary? Filming dead bodies, risking the lives of Sherpas to find his brother who has long passed… okay I know they’re being paid, but it seems a bit exploitative, or is it me? Very sorry for his loss of course, but endangering more lives for the film just seems a bit 😐

I haven’t actually seen it by the way, I don’t have Disney+ but I also feel it would be a bit ‘ghoulish’. Maybe it’s just me.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Rinoachicken · 16/03/2023 10:10

There were some parts that didn’t make sense to me - like the fact they go all the out out there, trek for days to base camp, on the back of a single photograph, only to show it to the Sherpas there and they immediately say nope, that’s X. Base camp has wifi, email - could they not have emailed the photo over and asked that questions BEFORE arranging it all?? There are a number of extremely experienced and well resourced commercial teams (Himex and Adventure Consultants come to mind particularly) who have people up and down that mountain, every year, laying the ropes, clearing the route every season (of bodies as well) - would it not have made more sense to ask them first??!!

Also, when they were checking MH the bodies, it made me think about the families of those bodies - what if that was your loved one, you had no idea where they were until this documentary and then suddenly, this team has found them…and then left them there! They rule the bodies out as Michael, but was any effort made to ID them for the sake of others? Other families who may have welcomed the opportunity or knowledge of exactly where their loved one is lying. If they do it’s not shown.

Like a PP, I think it became clear as soon as they got to base camp that they were not going to find him. So why risk more lives sending people up there to literally poke around in the snow on the off chance they might find a body that’s been unsighted for over 20yrs??

MollyRover · 15/03/2023 23:30

I think that at this point a prerequisite of anyone summiting Everest should be bringing a body back with them. Anyone attempting to summit Everest is an egomaniac, we shouldn't be applauding them.

WestOfWestminster · 15/03/2023 21:57

thebellagio · 15/03/2023 14:54

@Potatomashed I just find it hard to believe that any school could be cruel enough to invite someone into talk about climbing Everest in front of a pupil who had experienced an immediate family member's death doing the same thing. It stuns all reason

Good point, I hadnt even thought of this

Justinripley · 15/03/2023 17:12

I genuinely have had to make a new account on here so that I have somewhere to voice my opinions on this documentary.

YANBU. But you should probs watch to form your opinion.

I have many reasons why I found it bizarre:

• he left his wife with a newborn baby and two very young children to go to Nepal for weeks.
• when in Nepal he sat on the gravel at the bottom of the mountain for days on end, trying to contact the Sherpa’s about their progress on a walky talky which was too far out of range.
• I don’t believe for a second anyone believed they could recover Michael. I also can’t imagine the state that he would have been in and actually what that would have done to the family to have seen him look like that - there’s images on google of the bodies and some are quite harrowing. I think they always planned to bring down the other body.
• he came across as extremely entitled. I understand the Sherpa are paid etc but the programme made it feel exploitive (although since having a nosy on IG since watching I’ve fallen in love with one of them a little bit!)
• I really struggle to understand why rich people feel the desire to engage in such activities. If you’re in somewhere called the death zone and require oxygen, but even with o2 you’ll die pretty quickly - WHY ARE YOU THERE? The amount that had children and have passed away on this completely unnecessary task (maybe that’s just me though because I’m a massive wimp)
• I know they did bring down a body in the end but I found it quite upsetting from when they left the first body. Bypassing someone else’s loved one feels wrong (I know they can’t possibly bring them all down)
• the ending with the girl crying was horrible and again, the mountaineering brings in a lot of money to area but at what price?

All of that being said, I did actually find it enjoyable and learned loads googling after!

Side note: their pronunciation of Gigi wound me up.

user1471543094 · 15/03/2023 16:53

I watched it and thought it was excellent.

Although it became very apparent as soon as he got there that it was highly unlikely that they would find Michael. It was just so long ago.

Who had sent them the pic believing it was Michael? Was there not a way they could have just got in contact with a few highly trained Sherpas who had climbed the mountain many times who could have very quickly told him that this was not in fact Michael - the way they did so quickly once they had arrived.
I know that is over simplified but jeez if they could do a documentary and have Spencer there for weeks doing nothing then surely they would have had the ways and means to contact a few sherpas to simply ask. Their knowledge of the mountain and the bodies was incredible.

I listen to Spencer and Vogue's podcast (thank God this is an anonymous forum!) and I am sure he has said that he was having therapy for his complete lack of empathy...might go some way to explaining why he was so oblivious to the fact that not bringing Michael home may have hurt his family.
Although to me it never really occurred to him that he wouldn't find him. All the "its an impossible task" to me seemed like it was hype to the camera - he very, very much believed that it was a very possible task.

He was alot more likeable on this than on his pod. I find when he talks about his brother it is the once time when he is truly humble and I feel for him and 10 year old Spencer so much. The loss is so evident.

Boussa · 15/03/2023 15:55

Very uncomfortable with the "othering" of sherpas on this thread.

2PintsOfCidernaBagofCrisps · 15/03/2023 15:47

UdoU · 08/03/2023 23:21

🙄

I’m struggling to see what the ‘important issue’ is with rich people who choose to go mountain climbing? ‘Let them all die’ is pithy but doesn’t answer my question.

The documentary didn't really cover the environmental and problematic issues that are a concern about the Everest tourism. There are lots of other documentaries out there about it which I've found fascinating. One on Netflix is called "Death Zone" and is all about sherpas doing a clean-up operation, I'd highly recommend it. The key issues that the Everest tourism is causing are:

  • the amount of litter/waste that is left. Thousands of abandoned tents, human waste, gas cannisters, clothing etc. There is zero effort put in by the excursion companies to ensure that everyone who is taking this stuff up the mountain brings it back down again. The responsibility then lies with the Nepalese government to form clean-up operations which costs money and risk lives.
  • the (many) dead bodies are (slowly) decomposing on the mountain. That's tainting the water supply that feeds into the Khumbu drinking water
  • The quantity of people who climb the mountain is rising year-on-year. This causes pressure on the Nepalese infrastructure and threatens the health of the local people.
thebellagio · 15/03/2023 14:54

@Potatomashed I just find it hard to believe that any school could be cruel enough to invite someone into talk about climbing Everest in front of a pupil who had experienced an immediate family member's death doing the same thing. It stuns all reason

Potatomashed · 15/03/2023 14:46

thebellagio · 15/03/2023 14:30

This is what I posted on the telly addicts thread...

It felt very much like two programmes joined into one.
the first half was absolutely stunning. The way they had the footage of Michael and replicating exactly with Spencer and interspersed with the interviews with the other climbers was brilliant. I actually wish they’d shown more of their reactions after it was confirmed they hadn’t found Michael.

then when it became apparent that they wouldn’t be able to find him (even before they set off beyond base camp) it felt so intrusive. I’m gobsmacked that allegedly Disney hadn’t blurred the bodies and I really hated the scene talking to the Sherpa’s mum where she broke down, and also the scene with his daughter crying. It felt overly personal and intrusive for that poor family.

I do think that Spencer had been over romanticising the whole thing and hadn’t really truly understood the scale of the mountain and the number of bodies. I hope that he’s had some counselling because that must have opened up huge trauma memories for him.

there were a few odd things though.

a). If the footage was readily available of Mike on his climb, I find it weird that 24 years later Spencer had never seen it. Surely the first thing you would do is give a copy of any film footage and photos to a family after they got back so they could see for themselves?

b). If the Matthew recieved the photo in 2017, why did it take so long to go to Everest to try and find the body? Surely waiting 4-5 years would be a huge issue in terms of snow fall/body decomposing? Also wouldn’t Spencer have needed to train for the climb? It felt very much like “see you later darling, I’m just heading out to climb a mountain…”

c). The Bear Grylls but was remarkable. What school would be so insensitive that they would invite a man to come in an do a talk about climbing Everest when one of the pupils in that room had a brother who had died during the exact same thing? Surely the teachers would have known that?????

The bear grylls bit shocked me too! Like he had to eat his words after claiming a glory which wasn’t his?!

thebellagio · 15/03/2023 14:30

This is what I posted on the telly addicts thread...

It felt very much like two programmes joined into one.
the first half was absolutely stunning. The way they had the footage of Michael and replicating exactly with Spencer and interspersed with the interviews with the other climbers was brilliant. I actually wish they’d shown more of their reactions after it was confirmed they hadn’t found Michael.

then when it became apparent that they wouldn’t be able to find him (even before they set off beyond base camp) it felt so intrusive. I’m gobsmacked that allegedly Disney hadn’t blurred the bodies and I really hated the scene talking to the Sherpa’s mum where she broke down, and also the scene with his daughter crying. It felt overly personal and intrusive for that poor family.

I do think that Spencer had been over romanticising the whole thing and hadn’t really truly understood the scale of the mountain and the number of bodies. I hope that he’s had some counselling because that must have opened up huge trauma memories for him.

there were a few odd things though.

a). If the footage was readily available of Mike on his climb, I find it weird that 24 years later Spencer had never seen it. Surely the first thing you would do is give a copy of any film footage and photos to a family after they got back so they could see for themselves?

b). If the Matthew recieved the photo in 2017, why did it take so long to go to Everest to try and find the body? Surely waiting 4-5 years would be a huge issue in terms of snow fall/body decomposing? Also wouldn’t Spencer have needed to train for the climb? It felt very much like “see you later darling, I’m just heading out to climb a mountain…”

c). The Bear Grylls but was remarkable. What school would be so insensitive that they would invite a man to come in an do a talk about climbing Everest when one of the pupils in that room had a brother who had died during the exact same thing? Surely the teachers would have known that?????

dogpig · 12/03/2023 09:26

I actually liked it and thought it was moving. Particularly the side by side footage with his brother's journey.

I watched Sherpa after this and apparently if the body isn't recovered they believe that the soul cannot be reincarnated/move on to Nirvana so, knowing this, I think it is actually a good thing that they brought him down. Agree though that the way it was filmed was quite jarring - I definitely thought that it is quite uncomfortable that they could have given them hope and then not ended up doing it.

derbylass81 · 11/03/2023 13:00

@Lavender14 yes, I understand it was those logistics that made it a bit of a jarring conversation. But yes, I can see it had to be that way.

The returning of the Sherpas body still doesn't sit well with me. I don't think they really considered the impact on the Sherpas family and whether this would be in their best interests (which I don't particularly think it was, per my post above). I feel it was done so that the search for Michael wasn't in vain. So that they could still say they achieved something.

Lavender14 · 11/03/2023 12:28

derbylass81 · 11/03/2023 12:21

I also found the initial conversation with the brother of the dead Sherpa a bit odd.

" if we don't find my brother, we'll look for yours"

Seems maybe that conversation could have waited until they had concluded Michael couldn't be found.

I found this really strange and quite hurtful initially, but I've realised it was because they only had one more run at the mountain and the search, so for the team to come down and then go back up for the other body when they'd exhausted their search for Michael would have put them at more risk so they needed a clear plan beforehand and the permission of the family that they would want that. So in that respect it made sense just a bit brutal though. I imagine it would have been strange watching another family have the emotional reaction that you wanted for your family. I found it odd that he hadn't considered the impact on his family if he didn't find the body he seemed a bit maybe naieve in that respect or like he hadn't fully thought it through if it didn't go to plan.

derbylass81 · 11/03/2023 12:21

Sinamin · 09/03/2023 00:20

YANBU

It's extremely distasteful. The family are not short of money so could have done this privately but it's all about the media and £££s for Spencer.

That may sound harsh but family friends lost their son on Everest and would never have turned their numerous searches for his body into a media circus.

I also found the initial conversation with the brother of the dead Sherpa a bit odd.

" if we don't find my brother, we'll look for yours"

Seems maybe that conversation could have waited until they had concluded Michael couldn't be found.

derbylass81 · 11/03/2023 12:20

Christmascracker0 · 09/03/2023 00:17

I haven’t watched it but I’d really like to! It must be so difficult to think about your big brother just being out there. I’m sure if anyone else had the time, money and access to a film crew they would do the same as Spencer.

He has really mellowed since being in MIC. He’s completely sober now which must make a big difference. Also I think a lot of his behaviour on the show was an act..

I hadn't seen him on Made in Chelsea so had no opinion of him prior to watching it.

I didn't think he came across particularly well. I appreciate he was in a highly stressful, emotional situation but he spoke to people (Sherpas, mostly) quite sharply a few times. I could sense an arrogance and a lack of graciousness that people either have or they don't.

But, as I say, was a highly stressed situation and possibly not fair to judge him on it.

derbylass81 · 11/03/2023 12:17

CatsShittyArses · 08/03/2023 23:40

I've just watched it. I've read up about Everest a while ago and so wasn't surprised by the number of bodies up there.

You should watch this before giving judgement.

I guess he was trying to do this for closure, the same as somebody wanting to retrieve a body in a murder case etc. Unless you've lost somebody dear to you and not had their body to bury/cremate then it would be hard for you to appreciate the loss. If you watch the documentary you will be able to witness the closure that it brings another family by retrieving the body.

I thought it was a very moving documentary and whilst I didn't previously like Spencer or Vogue, he comes across very likeable in the documentary and I had nothing but sympathy for him and his family. Having read up about Sherpas previously I also had a lot of respect for the hard work they did too and am glad that Spencer was able to honour a Sherpa family at the end.

I saw it differently.

I could understand Spencer and his family wanting closure and wanting to bring his body back to the UK.

But I didn't see that it did any good for the Sherpas family. The brother was very gracious in thanking Spencer for doing it, but watching the Sherpas daughters crying was painful and I just don't see the benefit.

For a lot of people in the mountaineering community - if you die on Everest, you stay on Everest. I guess it's kind of like a captain going down with his ship, or a Vikings burial at sea. Whilst there is no "burial" on Everest, the snow and ice does bury many.

It would have cost a lot of money retrieving that body and I feel the money would have been better going directly to the Sherpas family.

When Spencer said he wouldn't be able to forget the daughters crying, he looked shocked and I think he suspected maybe he hadn't done the right thing.

Lavender14 · 10/03/2023 00:24

"While Western Guides make around 50,000 dollars each climbing season, Sherpa Guides make a mere 4,000, barely enough to support their families. Although this is more money than the average person in Nepal makes, their earnings do come at a cost – Sherpas risk their lives with every climb." There's a massive wage gap that was as of 2021.

Lavender14 · 10/03/2023 00:22

"The money they get from foreigners is huge in comparison to their wages. Just small increases in money can maKe a big difference to their lives."

@MarshaMelrose my point is just that while it can make a difference to their lives I still don't think it is equal to the risks they take in doing their work. Which means they are still being underpaid as a result and that is exploitative. They are highly skilled and trained but those are the exact reasons why they should be earning a fair wage for the job, the danger and their skill set. To say otherwise is almost like saying oh it's fine because they're poor they should be happy with what they get. The bulk of the money made from everest goes into a corrupt government, not to the people in those communities.

footstoop · 09/03/2023 22:36

Does that mean they shouldn't be offered work doing what only they can do? Does it mean that they should never be offered those choices?
I'm not really sure what your point is or what you think the situation should be.

I made the point that I felt it somewhat exploitative & linked an article I had read from a sherpa's pov. You don't think it is so we will have to agree to disagree.

Moonicorn · 09/03/2023 21:40

MarshaMelrose · 09/03/2023 21:35

I think you misunderstood my post. I've never said they aren't intelligent or capable of making their own decisions? One can be respectful of them & their abilities but acknowledge they don't have as many choices employment wise as many of the climbers they are employed by.

It's a developing country so of course many people have less employment choices than those in developed countries. Does that mean they shouldn't be offered work doing what only they can do? Does it mean that they should never be offered those choices?
I'm not really sure what your point is or what you think the situation should be.

I understand that position it’s just interesting that logic is never applied to sex work on MN. Which may seem random but it seems to be a big topic on here.

OP posts:
MarshaMelrose · 09/03/2023 21:35

I think you misunderstood my post. I've never said they aren't intelligent or capable of making their own decisions? One can be respectful of them & their abilities but acknowledge they don't have as many choices employment wise as many of the climbers they are employed by.

It's a developing country so of course many people have less employment choices than those in developed countries. Does that mean they shouldn't be offered work doing what only they can do? Does it mean that they should never be offered those choices?
I'm not really sure what your point is or what you think the situation should be.

footstoop · 09/03/2023 20:44

I don't think it's up to any of us to decide that they shouldn't do it so withhold the offer. They're grown men who make their living working on Everest. I have enough respect for them to let them make their own decisions.

I think you misunderstood my post. I've never said they aren't intelligent or capable of making their own decisions? One can be respectful of them & their abilities but acknowledge they don't have as many choices employment wise as many of the climbers they are employed by.

60smusic · 09/03/2023 18:53

I enjoyed the documentary. I can't comment on Spencer as I don't know him, but he came across as a lovely young man.

I think the family may have accepted 23 years ago that Michael wasn't coming home, much like the many thousands that unfortunately lost their lives. It was only when the photo was sent to them a few years ago, 2019 I think? That it stired up feelings about rescuing the body . Which many of us would want to do if we knew there was a chance of finding our family. I'm sure it took time to organise this too.

The sherpas were amazing, I found them to be respectful of the bodies, praying and blessing themselves. Unfortunately they have to dig ice on and around the bodies to identify the clothing, there was no other way to do this, they blurred it out but you could see they weren't hacking away at the bodies, they went gently on the body but more force around the bodies.

The sherpas went up and down Everest multiple times a day, these men were very experienced and knew the mountain inside out. Yes, they are risking their lives, they know this, they acknowledge this, they were like machines doing their job. Much respect to them.

It was lovely that Spencer was able to bring the young man down to his family, it doesn't matter who funded this, or who feels it was all publicly, you could see in Spencer's eyes he was upset speaking to them when the mother broke down and how humble he was when he seen the children crying at the end. A family got their loved one home.

Everyone knows about Everest, we all know that many climbers don't come down, we know that their bodies are 'buried' there and with weather changes etc a lot of the time they are visible, I think the makers of the programme were respectful at blurring out the bodies, I think there was a delay on the release of the programme surrounding this? It wasn't graphic and was very informative.

alltoowe · 09/03/2023 14:46

I thought it was a tremendous watch! I really disliked Spencer from his made in Chelsea days but he's actually turned out to be a very fine person.

MarshaMelrose · 09/03/2023 11:47

Moonicorn · 09/03/2023 10:10

We’re not deciding; we don’t have that power.

And okay, but I hope you feel similarly about escorting and other dangerous occupations where the person ‘could get another job’ but clearly feels the risk is worth the money. And don’t have contempt for the people who ‘employ’ them. That’s how I see this - an element of choice, but not a full choice.

Er, excuse me. I never said anything about 'they could get another job' nor I haven't shown contempt for anyone.
You're right, you don't decide. They do. I respect them for the job they do and believe they can make their own decisions. The alternative is banning all activity on Everest and I'm not sure they'd thank you for that.
Choice is a luxury many people don't have.