Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Note from MNHQ: please note OP's post @ 19.08 on 22 Jan. The OP has admitted this is a reverse but we are leaving this thread up so they continue to receive advice. Inheritance money - AIBU to be p*ssed off?

546 replies

snoozum · 21/01/2023 02:38

What should my FIL do?
Background: my DH's parents divorced when he was a child, and years later FIL met and married his second wife. Second wife had two small children already, who called FIL "dad", although they were not his by blood. After 25 years of marriage, FIL and his second wife divorced fairly acrimoniously. The divorce courts ruled that FIL and ex-wife #2 must split their assets 50:50, with FIL allowed to keep anything that was his before the marriage. FIL worked extremely hard throughout the marriage and financially contributed massively more, with the ex-wife only working full-time for around 5-6 years. FIL was able to stay in the matrimonial home by paying ex-wife #2 50% of its value. Fast-forward 5 years and ex-wife #2 passed away without a will. The son of ex-wife #2 struggled with her death and so his children (his own wife had died a few years previously) went to live with FIL (their grandfather) temporarily. However, before any inheritance was claimed, the son also died. Ex-wife #2 died with most of the money she received in the divorce, in the bank. The ex-wife #2's daughter, who doesn't have children, has therefore inherited all of ex-wife #2's money, which in reality is pretty much all of my FIL's money. My FIL is now bringing up the grandchildren, therefore my DH and my FIL's thoughts are that the daughter should give all of this money back to FIL. However, she has only given back 50% of it. AIBU to think she should give FIL 100% of it, as it was his money to begin with?

OP posts:
Weddi · 21/01/2023 07:10

50% is generous of her when it’s legally her money so she didn’t have to hand a dime over. FIL’s choice to altruistically raise non biological grandchildren.

Pipsquiggle · 21/01/2023 07:09

TBH the distribution of money sounds correct.

FIL and ex wife 2 were married for a long time so assets/money were split 50:50.

Your FIL has no more say what happens to that money. I am glad the DC's aunt has given them 50% of the inheritance, it sounds like they will be getting more money soon due to her terminal diagnosis.

I would focus on getting the right support for those DC and your FIL. How old is your FIL and how old are the DC he is raising? Sounds like a sad situation for those DC - they are orphans and their aunt will soon die. Can the grandparents on the other side help? Did their mother have any siblings? Sounds like FIL has a lot on his plate

Aprilx · 21/01/2023 07:09

renonovice · 21/01/2023 07:00

@Aprilx do you think it would be better for the dc to go into care?

The sister is entitled to 50% as it was legally her mums money. However I know I would contribute to raising nephews & nieces if anything happened to my siblings.

I don’t think the children should go to whomever is willing to take them on the proviso they get to keep the orphaned children’s inheritance for themselves. Do you?

hopelesslydevotedtoGu · 21/01/2023 07:08

snoozum · 21/01/2023 03:34

The children's mother died a few years before their father. The daughter (their aunt) has terminal cancer and is too unwell to look after the children herself.

Is this the daughter who inherited the money and is gifting 50%?

She has been thoughtful to give 50% for the up bringing of the children. I think it's morally the right thing to do (would have likely been what her mother wanted had she written a will) although not legally required.

I would advise your FIL is nice to her rather than messaging a list of reasons asking for more now! Perhaps she will want to leave money to the grandchildren in her will. Less likely if he pisses her off.

If the 50% Is given as a gift, rather than a variation of the will, there may be inheritance tax to pay should she die within 7 years.

IncompleteSenten · 21/01/2023 07:07

Does it matter what you think she should do 'morally'?

You can't go to court and say Mumsnet said morally she should hand it over so I want you to make her!

You can't go to her house and say the same.

Your dad was entitled to the grand total of fuck all and still she gave him half. You need to stop sniffing around for the rest.

JudgeRudy · 21/01/2023 07:06

I dont understand what this has to do with you. Ex wive"s money all went to the daughter (no will) when morally I feel 50% of it should have been shared between the children of the dead son. It's them I feel sorry for. Their Nan and their Mum dies then their Dad has a breakdown and can't cope. They go to live with their Grandad then their Dad dies. Their Auntie then snaffles all of Exs inheritance but then relents and passes on 50% to her nibblings.
Sounds fair money wise. Why do you think Auntie should give her inheritance to your FIL? Of course in other ways lifes been incredibly unfair on these two and I'm pleased your FIL felt able to fulfil this parenting role. I'm imagining they're older children and it doesn't seem unreasonable that some of their money could be offset against living expenses. Is your FIL acting as a trustee?
What this really sounds like is you think FIL divorce settlement was unfair. That's a shame....and irrelevant. BTW FIL sounds like he has a wonderful close relationship with his grandchildren. Don't assume his everything's coming to your husband when he's gone. I know someone who's jumped a generation and left everything to his grandchildren!

Aprilx · 21/01/2023 07:06

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 21/01/2023 06:59

It's bizarre to me that people think those kids he didn't create are his responsibility, yet he should happily give up half the wealth he created.

I honestly don’t think one single person has said that the children are his responsibility. Of course they are not, but he has decided to take on responsibility. That is good of him, but it doesn’t mean he can take what is rightfully theirs.

I honestly do not know how so many people think that this is an option. You cannot just take other people’s money because you think you deserve it.

As to giving up half his wealth, well assets get split when people divorce after a long marriage. Have you really never heard that before? You must be living under a rock.

gamerchick · 21/01/2023 07:06

snoozum · 21/01/2023 03:22

50% didn't go to the children because it would have meant it going in trust and they need the money to be available to them now. FIL is struggling bringing up the children on his pensions, so he was banking on having all the money.

With family members in his ears no doubt 🙄

Gh12345 · 21/01/2023 07:04

Nope sorry!

lifeinthehills · 21/01/2023 07:03

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 21/01/2023 05:56

But the inheritance only exists because of him. It's not like her mother did anything to create the wealth.

Why is he rearing the kids?

She supported him to do whatever he did to create the wealth. My own husband would have nowhere near the career outcomes he has if I hadn't given up so much myself and he'd had to step in and do half the stuff I did. This is true of many women. It's such a shame we undervalue the contribution of the spouse so much, especially when it's very real but just invisible.

renonovice · 21/01/2023 07:00

@Aprilx do you think it would be better for the dc to go into care?

The sister is entitled to 50% as it was legally her mums money. However I know I would contribute to raising nephews & nieces if anything happened to my siblings.

MrsDoyle351 · 21/01/2023 07:00

What age are the children and the FIL?

MrsDoyle351 · 21/01/2023 06:59

snoozum · 21/01/2023 03:34

The children's mother died a few years before their father. The daughter (their aunt) has terminal cancer and is too unwell to look after the children herself.

Wow - so many tragic events in one family. Your husband must be devastated.

WingingIt101 · 21/01/2023 06:59

Aprilx · 21/01/2023 02:53

You FIL got a fair deal when he divorced ex wife 2, all of what he had pre marriage and 50% thereafter, that is what is supposed to happen. What she had when she died was hers not his.

However when she died, it should have been split between her son and daughter, and as the son also passed away it should have been split between the daughter and the sons children. It sounds like that didn’t happen at first but now she has passed over 50% it all seems correct to me, but this should be given to the children not your FIL

So your FIL does not need to do anything other than hand back (or put in trust) what he received from the daughter to the children of the son.

This.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 21/01/2023 06:59

renonovice · 21/01/2023 06:54

See, with all of these suspicions and aspersions cast at FIL, he should just wash his hands of the matter. Turn the kids over to care and enjoy his retirement.

It's bizarre that putting them into care is the right option for many posters.

It's bizarre to me that people think those kids he didn't create are his responsibility, yet he should happily give up half the wealth he created.

renonovice · 21/01/2023 06:56

@MuthaHubbard but the gc are entitled to 50%.

Aprilx · 21/01/2023 06:56

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 21/01/2023 06:49

Yeah. Everyone slagging off the FIL is bonkers. He's stuck rearing the children late in life; the least their aunt could do is return the wealth that he created, to help with the costs. She should make a will leaving her estate to him.

I would concede that he is maybe being kindly in acting as guardian to the children. But this still does not mean he has any right to take money that belongs to other people. He has no more right to take money off these orphaned children than he does off me or you or to rob a bank.

The money should be in a trust, with an independent trustee who can decide whether any money should be used now or whether it ought to remain where it is until they reach adulthood.

MuthaHubbard · 21/01/2023 06:55

FFS, she's lost her mum and brother and is dying. Just leave her be. 50% is 50% more than he is entitled to

Tricolette · 21/01/2023 06:55

So fil already has half the money and is hassling a dying woman for the other half?
Has he already spent the first half?
If not then he needs to set up a trust fund for the dc, claim benefits and presumably the dc will inherit the second half sooner rather than later.

Yes, he's doing a good thing raising the dc but he needs to leave his sd alone.

HotToddyColdSauvignon · 21/01/2023 06:54

What a grasping thread OP

why on earth are YOU pissed off? It’s got nothing to do with you. Unless you’re worries about losing your share 🙄

renonovice · 21/01/2023 06:54

See, with all of these suspicions and aspersions cast at FIL, he should just wash his hands of the matter. Turn the kids over to care and enjoy his retirement.

It's bizarre that putting them into care is the right option for many posters.

AngelDelightUK · 21/01/2023 06:54

How old are the children?

I can understand FILs point of view, he took the children in because their Dad was struggling and wasn’t expecting his step-son to die.

The poor children probably wonder what’s going on. Did everyone die of different things? It’s a lot of deaths

emptythelitterbox · 21/01/2023 06:53

How old are the grandchildren?

renonovice · 21/01/2023 06:52

@Aprilx but even if it's in a trust can't the FIL access it to help raise them?

I certainly know if my mum ended up looking after my own dc she would need considerable financial help due to her own health needs & circumstances to give my dc a good life. I would rather that as opposed to them going into care though 🤷🏻‍♀️

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 21/01/2023 06:52

MountainSnow · 21/01/2023 06:45

This sounds dodgy. Sounds like the money should have been held in trust for the children (assuming they inherited). A trust can be set up to pay out for education and other purposes beneficial for the children (eg housing).

If the children did inherit their fathers money, it is possible that a constructive trust arises in law meaning FIL will need to show he has administered the funds for the benefit of the children and can be held to account for mis-managing funds.

Was a professional involved in administration of the estates?

I am also raising an eyebrow at FIL’s apparent impecunity - if FIL is astute enough to set up a profitable investment vehicle and received 50% of what appear to be substantial assets in the divorce (has has seemingly received 50% of other daughters’ inheritance), I wonder why he is now so short of money he needs to deprive the children of their inheritance.

See, with all of these suspicions and aspersions cast at FIL, he should just wash his hands of the matter. Turn the kids over to care and enjoy his retirement.

He's the only one stepping up so far, yet so many are quick to insult him.

However much wealth he has, he's not obliged to exhaust it on unrelated children who aren't his responsibility.

Swipe left for the next trending thread