Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How deprived do you have to be to move in a man into your home a day of ‘knowing’ him on Facebook? *[Content warning: concerns child abuse]

442 replies

EddyF · 04/04/2023 19:05

When you have children? Why isn’t the wider conversation in the media about the why/causes and PREVENTIONS of mothers doing this not being discussed on a wider platform? In the below case, again it’s the fault of SS and not the mother who moved a man from online to her home. It’s beyond sickening and I genuinely have no sympathy for any of these so called mothers. I don’t care about these men because it’s not hard to keep them out of your home/children’s lives.

This country has resources for when you can’t cope with your children. You can even give them up. These women behave as if they can’t date safely and that it’s completely natural to take in any old scruff even a murderous one into your children’s lives. It’s like they have never heard of the concept of dating partners NOT meeting your kids for a length of time UNTIL you can access a situation?

Not all these mums that do this are mentally challenged.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/lola-morgan-dyfedpowys-police-adhd-pembrokeshire-b2313875.html

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11937439/Mother-monster-boyfriend-guilty-death-two-year-old-girl.html

Timeline in death of two-year-old Lola James

Lola suffered 101 bruises and scratches to her body, damage to both her eyes and extensive brain damage in the early hours of July 17 2020.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/lola-morgan-dyfedpowys-police-adhd-pembrokeshire-b2313875.html

OP posts:
QuertyGirl · 05/04/2023 14:40

Never mind trying to unpick if the mother or randomtwatshegotofffacebook is to blame, why didn't any of the medical, social or child services pick up on this situation before she was beaten to death?

Lack of funding? High work loads? What?

There will always be twats, some of them will have children.

We need to do something about protecting the kids

Comii9 · 05/04/2023 14:31

It boils down to self responsibility and character. Some people are stronger than others and some people are more easily led or the party type. There's many many variants here and unfortunately there is not 1 solution fits all.

There is only so much SS can do. Once you are an adult the expectation is that you look after your kids. It doesn't always happen hence OP.

I honestly don't know what could be done because there's just so many issues in this case. Where was the woman's own family and support network? Thr list is endless it really is sad.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 14:25

MNbingo · 05/04/2023 14:08

Controversial opinion, but when Nicola Sturgeon was “apologising” to mothers of forced adoptions from back in the day I had a random thought flash through my head that maybe things haven’t really progressed since then and there should be a return of it as in a lot of cases we have had kids being dragged up for years by immature parents with no idea and end up with cases like this. 😢

Yes, I know it’s not every young parent before I get started on.

This "mother" was 30.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 14:23

"So no, awful childhoods and abuse and neglect does not necessarily mean people become "less than ideal parents".

I know. I never said it did.
^
But you did:
^
All I am saying is that, surely, it is understandable why people who have awful childhoods, where they are not cared for or learn what love is, where their own development is curtailed because of bad parenting, turn out to be less than ideal parents themselves.

Maybe you meant "in some cases". But per my earlier posts, obviously it isn't a sufficient condition because it isn't the case for many, many people who live through such childhoods, quite the opposite. And then on top of that we are stigmatised in this way.

Ultimately it doesn't matter why these monsters brutalised this little girl. What matters is what measures should be put in place to protect children like her and make this a very, very rare occurrence, which sadly at the moment it isn't. My earlier post described how that could be achieved. It's not an insoluble problem. Things will never be perfect and mistakes will happen but there are changes that can be made to the tax, social services and children's care system that will make such tragedies much rarer and will also give such children an opportunity to have a stable childhood and good life outcomes on a par with other children in society. The fact is that the UK public doesn't pressure its politicians to do this, so it doesn't happen.

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 14:13

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 14:09

Urgh. I knew this was going to be brought up and lazily didn't address it, which i now regret.

To clarify, OF COURSE not all abuse victims become abusers or bad people. All I am saying is that, surely, it is understandable why people who have awful childhoods, where they are not cared for or learn what love is, where their own development is curtailed because of bad parenting, turn out to be less than ideal parents themselves.

But I had a childhood like that. Obviously it did huge damage and left huge scars.

I am an excellent parent. I provide everything for my children and they have a safe and caring home full of love and laughter. They are my absolute priority and exactly because of my childhood, now that I'm a lone parent, I would never, ever even consider introducing them to a man let alone moving one into their home. I am quite happy to be single and will remain so.

Many other posters have told similar stories on this thread.

So no, awful childhoods and abuse and neglect does not necessarily mean people become "less than ideal parents".

So no, awful childhoods and abuse and neglect does not necessarily mean people become "less than ideal parents".

I know. I never said it did. But for those that are, you can understand why it might have. We all know how important childhood is for how we develop as adults and we often repeat family dynamics. You are a great parent, that's great for you and for your kids. Sounds like you have overcome a lot of adversity. Had you not been, had you struggled, I would have understood how your childhood might have impacted you.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 14:09

Urgh. I knew this was going to be brought up and lazily didn't address it, which i now regret.

To clarify, OF COURSE not all abuse victims become abusers or bad people. All I am saying is that, surely, it is understandable why people who have awful childhoods, where they are not cared for or learn what love is, where their own development is curtailed because of bad parenting, turn out to be less than ideal parents themselves.

But I had a childhood like that. Obviously it did huge damage and left huge scars.

I am an excellent parent. I provide everything for my children and they have a safe and caring home full of love and laughter. They are my absolute priority and exactly because of my childhood, now that I'm a lone parent, I would never, ever even consider introducing them to a man let alone moving one into their home. I am quite happy to be single and will remain so.

Many other posters have told similar stories on this thread.

So no, awful childhoods and abuse and neglect does not necessarily mean people become "less than ideal parents".

MNbingo · 05/04/2023 14:08

Controversial opinion, but when Nicola Sturgeon was “apologising” to mothers of forced adoptions from back in the day I had a random thought flash through my head that maybe things haven’t really progressed since then and there should be a return of it as in a lot of cases we have had kids being dragged up for years by immature parents with no idea and end up with cases like this. 😢

Yes, I know it’s not every young parent before I get started on.

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 14:04

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 13:59

Please read my posts. I know many do, but it is so offensive to those of us who survived horrific childhoods and have become the most fiercely protective and committed parents to our children for this precise reason, when people make comments like this as though it's somehow an inevitability that abuse survivors will become abusers. It isn't.

Urgh. I knew this was going to be brought up and lazily didn't address it, which i now regret.

To clarify, OF COURSE not all abuse victims become abusers or bad people. All I am saying is that, surely, it is understandable why people who have awful childhoods, where they are not cared for or learn what love is, where their own development is curtailed because of bad parenting, turn out to be less than ideal parents themselves.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 14:00

Other posters here with similar experiences have also shared the same.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 13:59

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 13:56

It's just horrifying what some kids go through. But in a way is it a wonder that (those that survive) grow up to be really fucked up adults themselves? Not that that is an excuse, but surely it contributes....

Please read my posts. I know many do, but it is so offensive to those of us who survived horrific childhoods and have become the most fiercely protective and committed parents to our children for this precise reason, when people make comments like this as though it's somehow an inevitability that abuse survivors will become abusers. It isn't.

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 13:56

It's just horrifying what some kids go through. But in a way is it a wonder that (those that survive) grow up to be really fucked up adults themselves? Not that that is an excuse, but surely it contributes....

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 13:54

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 10:42

The mum has been convicted of causing or allowing the murder. So I wouldn't say anyone is saying it's not her fault.

I have to admit when I read the account, how she heard bumps and crying and came into the room at midnight and he said don't worry I'm sorting the daugther, and she just went back to bed, I found that a very odd account. But like others have said she's obviously not a good mother, she likely has issues herself, and she is most definitely to blame.

Exactly. You hear loud noises in the middle of the night, your child is crying. And a person who you know has injured the child multiple times already says "oh it's all fine" so you go back to bed?!? Not remotely believable, unless she is a sociopath or psychopath herself.

These people are both absolute scum and whatever "issues" they had are irrelevant really. Those children should have been taken away long before.

If the LA had had to explicitly tell her not to move random drug-addicted men she didn't know into her children's home, then clearly this was an existing issue. Yet despite support she did it again. The house was disgusting. It was plain as day that she was neither safeguarding nor caring for the children long before they killed Lola.

Sadly because children do not vote funding for appropriate services and care isn't a priority. The adults responsible for them won't campaign for it. So the rest of us need to pressure MPs to ensure that funding for children's services is provided. That the penalisation of single parents through tax is removed so single mothers have a genuine route out of poverty without involving random men in their lives, that children living in situations like this are removed far, far earlier. In Denmark the children who grow up in children's homes have outcomes on a par with those living with parents. So it can be done. People get all outraged when reading these stories but how many have written to MPs demanding these tax changes and a much lower threshold for child removal and Denmark-style children's homes so that these children can be removed and have a decent life? That's how you break the cycle.

Very easy to wave your hands in the air and say it can't be fixed but it can. And for those parents who aren't complete monsters but are irresponsible and selfish, knowing that their children would be removed permanently at a far lower threshold might focus their minds and encourage them to prioritise their children's needs and not move unrelated adults into their homes. And if they do, well, then the children have a proper escape route and they can be left to continue their scummy lives alone.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 13:33

Social services are also a disgrace.

As a traumatised, homeless 16 year old they advised me that I should go and get pregnant and have a baby, then I would be housed. Obviously I didn't.

Sadly they don't appear to have changed much in the intervening years.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 13:30

Supported accommodation like this…?

https://www.brightonandhovenews.org/2020/10/23/safeguarding-review-launched-into-death-of-toddler-at-supported-housing/

That woman left a defenseless baby alone for days with mo food or water knowing that she would die, so that she could go and get drunk. It was clear that she was not capable of being a parent even if she'd had more support and that poor child should have been removed at birth.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 13:25

Every time you say LTB for a relationship involving biological children that is not abusive (including obviously to the children), you increase the chance that the poster's children will be abused by a step father. Food for thought?

Or if you are going to say LTB, make it clear that implicit in that is that you should remain single until your children are adults once you've done it.

I think that is conflating a number of issues.

Women need to raise their standards so they don't get involved with awful men in the first place when it's already clear that they are violent, thick or unpleasant, or even just lazy and misogynistic.

Sometimes this is all hidden until you're involved with someone. I was married to ex-H for years before we had children and he behaved like the model gentleman, shared all housework, etc. His true colours only appeared after the children were born.

Women will have crappy lives if they stay with lazy men who expect them to behave like a house servant (even when there's no abuse), so the advice to leave is correct if they've already discussed the issues, demanded change, even had counselling in some cases but the lazy man won't do his share.

However, another crucial plank of women being able to exert those boundaries - that they will not tolerate awful relationships - is them maintaining financial independence and not giving up careers so that they can exert those choices. We need to educate all young girls about this. And as many PPs have said, there also needs to be far more support for single mothers. Surestart reinstated, and also fix the tax system so that they aren't penalised and taxed more on the same household income than a couple meaning that building financial stability as a single mother is twice as hard, even if you do everything right. Of course compounding the inbuilt disadvantage of having only one parent to do all earning and caring in 24 hours per day by taxing them more as well will lead to negative outcomes, and dependency either on welfare or on men. This is obvious which is why other countries don't financially penalise single mothers in this way: it has terrible outcomes and costs everyone more.

I completely agree that it needs to be made far, far clearer in relationships education what a huge risk it is to children to move an unrelated adult into their house, particularly a man. The statistics need to be hammered home throughout secondary school. In many cases people hop between unsuitable relationships for financial reasons hence the need to sort out the tax system per above. But there should also be a huge social stigma about involving new partners with your children, it should not be normalised.

I'm always shocked at posts on here about "you deserve to be happy", "don't let the children dictate your life" 😒😡 etc. Even on this thread people being called "martyrs" for not moving unrelated men into their children's homes!! It is not normal and it's irresponsible and it should be an instant trigger for an SS assessment. If people must date, they can do that without co-habiting. "LTB" does not mean "shack up with other men". Even in cases where by luck it doesn't result in abuse, it is still hugely psychologically damaging to the child(ren) in most cases. We know this. It's not like there's a shortage of data on the topic.

I find the many posts about how people who grow up in abusive households very upsetting to read. I know that data shows this often happens, but there are also many of us who did who as a result of living through such a childhood ourselves actually become the best parents: often we are actually the single mothers who have left the father at the first sign of abusive behaviour and protect our children fiercely and would never, ever involve an unrelated male in their lives at all let alone move one into their home. The very people being called "extreme" and "martyrs". So while their own chaotic and abusive childhoods might be a factor in these women's behaviour, it's certainly not a sufficient condition: other factors must be at play. Perhaps very low IQ, perhaps sociopathy.

Whatever the reason, I hope these people both suffer a very painful and terrifying death like they inflicted on Lola.

Highlyflavouredgravy · 05/04/2023 13:03

userxx · 05/04/2023 12:40

Wow. Why is domestic violence so high? What is going on.

This! So much this!!!!

queenofthewild · 05/04/2023 12:49

I guess a number of factors are at play.

Substance abuse seems to be on the rise, some of the perpetrators are users, others are dealers. The users are out of control. The dealers use violence to control. There are cultural elements at play also - in some cultures it's considered reasonable for a man to control or discipline their wife or child. Then there's the families and communities where the cycles of abuse have gone on for generations - people don't know what healthy relationships look like and have incredibly low self esteem.

Parsley1234 · 05/04/2023 12:47

@queenofthewild yep

userxx · 05/04/2023 12:40

queenofthewild · 05/04/2023 12:26

Until you work in health, social care or education you have no idea the scale of this problem.

It's easy to assume that most people live like you. Do the best for their children and families and have similar values, with a few outliers.

Unfortunately the more time I spend around people the more I see the way so many families live. Despite sitting through safeguarding training every day it's heartbreaking to know how many children you come into contact with "do not meet the threshold" because the system is overwhelmed.

If you knew how much time your child's head teacher spends in child in need meetings and how many times a day they have to rearrange their diaries because of urgent child protection conferences it would make your hair curl.

I really don't know what the answer is, but far too many children are being raised in abusive, neglectful and trauma filled homes and there is an absolute epidemic of domestic violence. It's horrific.

Wow. Why is domestic violence so high? What is going on.

queenofthewild · 05/04/2023 12:26

Until you work in health, social care or education you have no idea the scale of this problem.

It's easy to assume that most people live like you. Do the best for their children and families and have similar values, with a few outliers.

Unfortunately the more time I spend around people the more I see the way so many families live. Despite sitting through safeguarding training every day it's heartbreaking to know how many children you come into contact with "do not meet the threshold" because the system is overwhelmed.

If you knew how much time your child's head teacher spends in child in need meetings and how many times a day they have to rearrange their diaries because of urgent child protection conferences it would make your hair curl.

I really don't know what the answer is, but far too many children are being raised in abusive, neglectful and trauma filled homes and there is an absolute epidemic of domestic violence. It's horrific.

BusterGonad · 05/04/2023 12:20

I'm not at all surprised by any of it. You read on here daily about women being treated like shit, told they're fat slags, abused daily by their 'partners'. Then the drip feed happens and they've got 3 kids by 2 different dad's, and the first dad was exactly the same as the 2nd. The advice falls on deaf ears, and then when something happens we're all suppose to act surprised and not blame the mother because it's obviously victim blaming.

RoobarbandCustud · 05/04/2023 12:19

@Clymene yes you are right. And sadly step mums too - RIP Arthur Labinjo-Hughes's and Star Hobson.

Toomanysquishmallows · 05/04/2023 11:55

I have to admit , I do worry inwardly , when I see those fb posts that say things like “ it’s not how long you’ve known someone , it’s the way you feel “ . I also agree with pp about the “ take a break “ stories .

moveoverye · 05/04/2023 11:52

Pepsipepsi · 05/04/2023 11:27

I come from a family with generational trauma and MH issues. Also from a very deprived area like Lola on this story.

My mum was low IQ, had personality disorders and was incapable of having a job, only left the house to do a food shop. She had 6 kids when she was aged 16 - 35. She was incapable of making sound decisions to better her life. All hope and fight had gone from here after years of domestic abuse from her first husband and crushing poverty with a mentally ill mother (my grandmother). Her only saving grace was not having a partner after the relationship with my dad broke down. He was an absent father after the split.

Half my siblings have gone on to continue the cycle. Ones been in and out of jail with kids by multiple women, another has severe learning disabilities with kids with two women, with the older children being shoved in Foster care due to "not getting on with a step dad". Not as bad as beaten and murdered children but I know for a fact that both of them carried out sexual abuse in their teen years. It wouldn't surprise me if they were abused themselves as kids (they're much older than me but I know they were beaten which luckily I never was).

The other half of us look functioning in society but all have the scars of our chaotic upbringing.
I can't tell you why half of us turned out "OK" and the other half didn't. I count myself very lucky that I have above average intelligence and never fell in with a bad crowd. Why is half my family capable of making sound decisions and the other half isn't? I'll never know.

I won't have kids and I feel strongly that not everyone deserves to be parents. However forced sterilisation is bordering on eugenics and is impractical. I find it a cruel irony of biology that almost anyone can have sex and give birth to a child but not everyone is granted the mental capacity to raise children well. I wish I knew the answer to prevent cases like Lola's.

Thanks for sharing your story, I hope you have people around you who can support you to deal with the scars of your upbringing.

Forced sterilisation is absolutely 100% eugenics. Not borderline. The Nazis did this. So entirely agree with you that it is wrong.

Pepsipepsi · 05/04/2023 11:27

I come from a family with generational trauma and MH issues. Also from a very deprived area like Lola on this story.

My mum was low IQ, had personality disorders and was incapable of having a job, only left the house to do a food shop. She had 6 kids when she was aged 16 - 35. She was incapable of making sound decisions to better her life. All hope and fight had gone from here after years of domestic abuse from her first husband and crushing poverty with a mentally ill mother (my grandmother). Her only saving grace was not having a partner after the relationship with my dad broke down. He was an absent father after the split.

Half my siblings have gone on to continue the cycle. Ones been in and out of jail with kids by multiple women, another has severe learning disabilities with kids with two women, with the older children being shoved in Foster care due to "not getting on with a step dad". Not as bad as beaten and murdered children but I know for a fact that both of them carried out sexual abuse in their teen years. It wouldn't surprise me if they were abused themselves as kids (they're much older than me but I know they were beaten which luckily I never was).

The other half of us look functioning in society but all have the scars of our chaotic upbringing.
I can't tell you why half of us turned out "OK" and the other half didn't. I count myself very lucky that I have above average intelligence and never fell in with a bad crowd. Why is half my family capable of making sound decisions and the other half isn't? I'll never know.

I won't have kids and I feel strongly that not everyone deserves to be parents. However forced sterilisation is bordering on eugenics and is impractical. I find it a cruel irony of biology that almost anyone can have sex and give birth to a child but not everyone is granted the mental capacity to raise children well. I wish I knew the answer to prevent cases like Lola's.