Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How deprived do you have to be to move in a man into your home a day of ‘knowing’ him on Facebook? *[Content warning: concerns child abuse]

442 replies

EddyF · 04/04/2023 19:05

When you have children? Why isn’t the wider conversation in the media about the why/causes and PREVENTIONS of mothers doing this not being discussed on a wider platform? In the below case, again it’s the fault of SS and not the mother who moved a man from online to her home. It’s beyond sickening and I genuinely have no sympathy for any of these so called mothers. I don’t care about these men because it’s not hard to keep them out of your home/children’s lives.

This country has resources for when you can’t cope with your children. You can even give them up. These women behave as if they can’t date safely and that it’s completely natural to take in any old scruff even a murderous one into your children’s lives. It’s like they have never heard of the concept of dating partners NOT meeting your kids for a length of time UNTIL you can access a situation?

Not all these mums that do this are mentally challenged.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/lola-morgan-dyfedpowys-police-adhd-pembrokeshire-b2313875.html

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11937439/Mother-monster-boyfriend-guilty-death-two-year-old-girl.html

Timeline in death of two-year-old Lola James

Lola suffered 101 bruises and scratches to her body, damage to both her eyes and extensive brain damage in the early hours of July 17 2020.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/lola-morgan-dyfedpowys-police-adhd-pembrokeshire-b2313875.html

OP posts:
JMSA · 05/04/2023 15:34

I agree with you, @Nepmarthiturn

JMSA · 05/04/2023 15:32

But there is no helping some people. Truly. Their scumbag traits run too deep.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 15:31

Ok, yes. But you help them by removing them. Your earlier posts seems to be implying that we should try to understand why these parents do this and help them learn skills. They won't. Remove the children so they can be raised in a decent environment and then yes, they will learn very different skills.

I really don't understand what part of this is unclear to you @Itsbytheby ?

These people shouldn't be parents and will never be adequate parents no matter what you do. So you need to remove the kids at a much lower threshold, as I've said repeatedly.

You were talking about trying to "understand" the parents and teach them "skills". I said they are not capable of doing so and why they do what they do is irrelevant and the focus should be on removing and safeguarding the children and giving them a decent childhood. And then those children will have a very different life and learn very different life skills because they'll have a decent upbringing away from their abusive parents.

I really don't understand how you could possibly have misunderstood what I've said, it's very clear.

I'm going to step away from this thread now as it's making me so angry and upset and I feel like I'm being gaslit.

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 15:29

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 15:27

@Itsbytheby yes. Which part of it do you not understand? It says they won't learn skills, the children need to be removed.

ConfusedConfusedConfused

No need to be rude.

But I find it quite a shocking concept that you - generally - think SS should go around assessing pregnant mothers and if they think they won't be great parents should remove their children at birth.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 15:27

@Itsbytheby yes. Which part of it do you not understand? It says they won't learn skills, the children need to be removed.

ConfusedConfusedConfused

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 15:26

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 15:23

Which, to your point, could also help identify parents that need help BEFORE they do damage. IF this woman had been helped to cope with her life and parenting early on MAYBE she would not have allowed this guy into her home. MAYBE if she had confidentence and support and some opportunity in life she wouldnt' have caused this in the way she did.

No.

It is blatantly obvious which parents should not be parents.

Social services do not have the power to remove the children or anywhere appropriate to send them.

Lower the threshold. And provide decent upbringings for them. That is the answer.

The "mother" in question in this case DID have a lot of support. She had the Freedom programme, twice. Social services. A domestic violence worker. She was not capable of being a parent. Social services knew this. They saw the squalid house. They knew she'd subjected her children to violent people previously. They didn't remove the children. This woman was NEVER going to be a fit parent and I highly doubt this wasn't obvious to everyone involved. If it wasn't then they're not fit to be in those roles.

So now Lola is dead. And her siblings will grow up traumatised knowing their mother was complicit in the abuse and murder of their sister.

So take kids away at birth? Or better yet, steralise them at puberty when it is so blatantly obvious what awful parents they would be?

I am talking much more generally (ref my earlier point), not just about this specific case. I think a lot of people could be helped BEFORE they become bad parents - before the become parents at all - although perhaps you are right, not this woman.

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 15:24

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 15:19

Your earlier posts seems to be implying that we should try to understand why these parents do this and help them learn skills

What? That's the precise opposite of everything I've been saying. Confused

Ok, yes. But you help them by removing them. Your earlier posts seems to be implying that we should try to understand why these parents do this and help them learn skills. They won't. Remove the children so they can be raised in a decent environment and then yes, they will learn very different skills.

That was a quote from you.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 15:23

Which, to your point, could also help identify parents that need help BEFORE they do damage. IF this woman had been helped to cope with her life and parenting early on MAYBE she would not have allowed this guy into her home. MAYBE if she had confidentence and support and some opportunity in life she wouldnt' have caused this in the way she did.

No.

It is blatantly obvious which parents should not be parents.

Social services do not have the power to remove the children or anywhere appropriate to send them.

Lower the threshold. And provide decent upbringings for them. That is the answer.

The "mother" in question in this case DID have a lot of support. She had the Freedom programme, twice. Social services. A domestic violence worker. She was not capable of being a parent. Social services knew this. They saw the squalid house. They knew she'd subjected her children to violent people previously. They didn't remove the children. This woman was NEVER going to be a fit parent and I highly doubt this wasn't obvious to everyone involved. If it wasn't then they're not fit to be in those roles.

So now Lola is dead. And her siblings will grow up traumatised knowing their mother was complicit in the abuse and murder of their sister.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 15:19

Your earlier posts seems to be implying that we should try to understand why these parents do this and help them learn skills

What? That's the precise opposite of everything I've been saying. Confused

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 15:17

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 15:10

Help children who are in less than ideal home situations have a chance to make a better future for themselves. Support them to learn the skills they need to take care of themselves and their kids and grow up to be happy and well balanced individuals with good opportunities.

Ok, yes. But you help them by removing them. Your earlier posts seems to be implying that we should try to understand why these parents do this and help them learn skills. They won't. Remove the children so they can be raised in a decent environment and then yes, they will learn very different skills.

The things we are saying aren't mutually exclusive. But you've somehow decided I hate and blame abuse victims for all ills. And I don't know why you are addressing me about single parents, I've said nothing against them (generally) or you as a single parent (specifically) at all.

I am not saying that at all. But this idea that it's "understandable" that some people abuse and kill their children because it happened to them is wrong. It never is. And frankly why they did it matters not. What matters is preventing it and safeguarding children properly which UK society does not do because nobody wants to fund child removal at an appropriate - much lower - threshold. Lola and many like her would still be alive if this was the case. And then fund proper upbringings for those children in care homes fit for purpose and designed to give those children more opportunities than most so that their outcomes can be equivalent to the general population and their trauma treated.

And support for single mothers to raise their children alone without involving random men and considering this the norm. People respecting single mothers rather than disparaging them, given they are the ones who stick around and are doing the work of two people. As I said, not taxing them double on the same household income as a two parent household, just levelling the playing field financially and make it viable for them to provide a decent standard of living for their children alone would be an obvious first step that would more than pay for itself hence other countries doing similar, and make it far less likely they'd get stuck on welfare or shack up with new partners for financial reasons.

And my comments weren't just to you but also referencing many of the other comments on this thread. I'm not attacking you. I'm frustrated with the same comments every time a tragedy like this happens and them people going down rabbit holes trying to dissect the psychology of people who were clearly never going to be capable of raising a child properly, and making excuses for them, rather than actually pressuring politicians to implement policies that would protect vulnerable children.

Ok, yes. But you help them by removing them. Your earlier posts seems to be implying that we should try to understand why these parents do this and help them learn skills. They won't. Remove the children so they can be raised in a decent environment and then yes, they will learn very different skills.

We are saying the same thing. Teach the children well so they don't end up repeating the disfunctions of their parents.

Understanding doesn't mean excusing, and I mantain it's key to preventing. I alsomaintain that the only way we can learn how to prevent this type of things happening in society (not in the individual family with the individual parents) is by understanding the factors for why it happened in the first place. Which, to your point, could also help identify parents that need help BEFORE they do damage. IF this woman had been helped to cope with her life and parenting early on MAYBE she would not have allowed this guy into her home. MAYBE if she had confidentence and support and some opportunity in life she wouldnt' have caused this in the way she did.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 15:12

Butyou can't catch it all. It's well known that prevention is in most cases better that cure.

I know. I've said that, too. But if you care about it you implement policies that will make it much, much rarer.

Yes you may have limited opportunity to prevent evil abusers. But there will be a huge amount of peoplewho aren't necessarily evil or "bad", but who can't cope or don't have the skills to provide a good home life for their kids.

Yep. And they never will. So you lower the removal threshold, substantially.

Lovanna · 05/04/2023 15:12

It feels aspects of society are broken.

I was a single parent after ExH left. Not my choice.

My own moral compass meant I did not ever consider more children with another man. I didn't want two sets of children with two different fathers’.
I put my children first. The more children I chose to have, the harder our lives would be.
I have a good education, a profession and ambition. Hard though it was I could support myself and my children. I had a choice to be independent, a earned enough to make up my ExH’s shortfall. I didn't need to rely on him. Freedom through having a choice.

I am in another relationship. A colleague. We already knew each other. We took it slowly, coffee, lunch, outings in a group. My DC’s met him as a friend from work, a brief coffee, a walk in the park.

He didn't stay at mine for months and months. When he did it was as a guest in the spare room, again, occasionally, over months and months.

I did want my DC’s to see that although damaged by my marriage, I could rebuild myself, I be respected, I could use my moral compass, my independence and education to recover.

I could rebuild our lives.

Toomanysquishmallows · 05/04/2023 15:12

I could be wrong, but I think parents had to want to be involved with sure start . An acquaintance of my partner’s had social services involvement, and they never took their children to any of the free activities avalible locally .

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 15:10

Help children who are in less than ideal home situations have a chance to make a better future for themselves. Support them to learn the skills they need to take care of themselves and their kids and grow up to be happy and well balanced individuals with good opportunities.

Ok, yes. But you help them by removing them. Your earlier posts seems to be implying that we should try to understand why these parents do this and help them learn skills. They won't. Remove the children so they can be raised in a decent environment and then yes, they will learn very different skills.

The things we are saying aren't mutually exclusive. But you've somehow decided I hate and blame abuse victims for all ills. And I don't know why you are addressing me about single parents, I've said nothing against them (generally) or you as a single parent (specifically) at all.

I am not saying that at all. But this idea that it's "understandable" that some people abuse and kill their children because it happened to them is wrong. It never is. And frankly why they did it matters not. What matters is preventing it and safeguarding children properly which UK society does not do because nobody wants to fund child removal at an appropriate - much lower - threshold. Lola and many like her would still be alive if this was the case. And then fund proper upbringings for those children in care homes fit for purpose and designed to give those children more opportunities than most so that their outcomes can be equivalent to the general population and their trauma treated.

And support for single mothers to raise their children alone without involving random men and considering this the norm. People respecting single mothers rather than disparaging them, given they are the ones who stick around and are doing the work of two people. As I said, not taxing them double on the same household income as a two parent household, just levelling the playing field financially and make it viable for them to provide a decent standard of living for their children alone would be an obvious first step that would more than pay for itself hence other countries doing similar, and make it far less likely they'd get stuck on welfare or shack up with new partners for financial reasons.

And my comments weren't just to you but also referencing many of the other comments on this thread. I'm not attacking you. I'm frustrated with the same comments every time a tragedy like this happens and them people going down rabbit holes trying to dissect the psychology of people who were clearly never going to be capable of raising a child properly, and making excuses for them, rather than actually pressuring politicians to implement policies that would protect vulnerable children.

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 15:02

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 14:58

You are a great parent, that's great for you and for your kids. Sounds like you have overcome a lot of adversity. Had you not been, had you struggled, I would have understood how your childhood might have impacted you.

We don't need to extend understanding to parents, adversity or not. We need to protect children.

Well understanding is the route to prevention. If we can understand why someone might turn out the way they do in these cases, or the factors contributing to that, we on a societal level might have a chance to reduce the risk of that happening to others.

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 15:00

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 14:54

Sorry first paragraph of that post was quoting @Itsbytheby

I thought you'd said "it does matter why".

It really doesn't.

What matters is better prevention measures that we know - from copious international data - would make such cases far rarer.

Butyou can't catch it all. It's well known that prevention is in most cases better that cure. Yes you may have limited opportunity to prevent evil abusers. But there will be a huge amount of peoplewho aren't necessarily evil or "bad", but who can't cope or don't have the skills to provide a good home life for their kids.

QuertyGirl · 05/04/2023 14:59

Have these cases increased since the abolition of Sure Start?

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 14:58

You are a great parent, that's great for you and for your kids. Sounds like you have overcome a lot of adversity. Had you not been, had you struggled, I would have understood how your childhood might have impacted you.

We don't need to extend understanding to parents, adversity or not. We need to protect children.

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 14:58

@Nepmarthiturn I agree with you but I would argue that inviting a stranger to come live with you and your kids stems from lacking skills or judgement in the first place.

And this:

Fund children's services properly per my earlier posts and provide nurturing care home environments that are more like a private school but with additional pastoral care and long-term therapy etc, like in Denmark, and them children in care have equivalent outcomes to those raised by their parents.

Is pretty much what I am saying. Help children who are in less than ideal home situations have a chance to make a better future for themselves. Support them to learn the skills they need to take care of themselves and their kids and grow up to be happy and well balanced individuals with good opportunities.

The things we are saying aren't mutually exclusive. But you've somehow decided I hate and blame abuse victims for all ills. And I don't know why you are addressing me about single parents, I've said nothing against them (generally) or you as a single parent (specifically) at all.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 14:56

QuertyGirl · 05/04/2023 14:40

Never mind trying to unpick if the mother or randomtwatshegotofffacebook is to blame, why didn't any of the medical, social or child services pick up on this situation before she was beaten to death?

Lack of funding? High work loads? What?

There will always be twats, some of them will have children.

We need to do something about protecting the kids

Exactly.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 14:54

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 14:50

And you know, it does matter why. Because spotting it and intervening isn't always easy - as we see time and time again - so it would be much better to prevent by helping people who lack them (due to their own childhood, or otherwise) develop the skills (or unlearn certain behaviours) that might put them or their children at risk.

I agree. It does not matter why these people do this. And in many cases no amount of trying to teach them "skills" will help. In this case the woman had plenty of such support and ignored it.

It is easy to spot. The problem is that the threshold for removal is much, much too high. It was obvious that this child and many others like her was not properly safeguarded yet she was left there.

Moving any unrelated adult into your home with children should instantly trigger a safeguarding assessment and ongoing regularl monitoring at intervals by multi-agencies.

Fund children's services properly per my earlier posts and provide nurturing care home environments that are more like a private school but with additional pastoral care and long-term therapy etc, like in Denmark, and them children in care have equivalent outcomes to those raised by their parents.

And for those single parents who aren't beyond help, stop penalising them financially on top of the inbuilt disadvantage so that they can provide for their children alone without paying double the tax on the same household income. And as @Hubblebubble says normalise that non-parent partners should not be living with you if you have full or part residency of a child.

Sorry first paragraph of that post was quoting @Itsbytheby

I thought you'd said "it does matter why".

It really doesn't.

What matters is better prevention measures that we know - from copious international data - would make such cases far rarer.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 14:51

Hubblebubble · 05/04/2023 14:41

@Nepmarthiturn you've summed things up so eloquently. It's shocking really, that even on a thread about a tiny defenseless toddler being murdered by her stepfather, those of us who have broken a cycle of abuse and are chosing to remain single to protect our children are called extreme and martyrs. I'm usually not one to tell people how to live their lives, but I wish this choice was seen as a sensible one and that moving unrelated males in was seen as what it is, a dangerous and risky decision.

I agree entirely. I am glad there are others who did. This hand-wringing and refusal to address the problem even though there areways to do so is so frustrating and is repeated every time something like this is publicised.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 14:50

And you know, it does matter why. Because spotting it and intervening isn't always easy - as we see time and time again - so it would be much better to prevent by helping people who lack them (due to their own childhood, or otherwise) develop the skills (or unlearn certain behaviours) that might put them or their children at risk.

I agree. It does not matter why these people do this. And in many cases no amount of trying to teach them "skills" will help. In this case the woman had plenty of such support and ignored it.

It is easy to spot. The problem is that the threshold for removal is much, much too high. It was obvious that this child and many others like her was not properly safeguarded yet she was left there.

Moving any unrelated adult into your home with children should instantly trigger a safeguarding assessment and ongoing regularl monitoring at intervals by multi-agencies.

Fund children's services properly per my earlier posts and provide nurturing care home environments that are more like a private school but with additional pastoral care and long-term therapy etc, like in Denmark, and them children in care have equivalent outcomes to those raised by their parents.

And for those single parents who aren't beyond help, stop penalising them financially on top of the inbuilt disadvantage so that they can provide for their children alone without paying double the tax on the same household income. And as @Hubblebubble says normalise that non-parent partners should not be living with you if you have full or part residency of a child.

Hubblebubble · 05/04/2023 14:41

@Nepmarthiturn you've summed things up so eloquently. It's shocking really, that even on a thread about a tiny defenseless toddler being murdered by her stepfather, those of us who have broken a cycle of abuse and are chosing to remain single to protect our children are called extreme and martyrs. I'm usually not one to tell people how to live their lives, but I wish this choice was seen as a sensible one and that moving unrelated males in was seen as what it is, a dangerous and risky decision.

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 14:41

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 14:23

"So no, awful childhoods and abuse and neglect does not necessarily mean people become "less than ideal parents".

I know. I never said it did.
^
But you did:
^
All I am saying is that, surely, it is understandable why people who have awful childhoods, where they are not cared for or learn what love is, where their own development is curtailed because of bad parenting, turn out to be less than ideal parents themselves.

Maybe you meant "in some cases". But per my earlier posts, obviously it isn't a sufficient condition because it isn't the case for many, many people who live through such childhoods, quite the opposite. And then on top of that we are stigmatised in this way.

Ultimately it doesn't matter why these monsters brutalised this little girl. What matters is what measures should be put in place to protect children like her and make this a very, very rare occurrence, which sadly at the moment it isn't. My earlier post described how that could be achieved. It's not an insoluble problem. Things will never be perfect and mistakes will happen but there are changes that can be made to the tax, social services and children's care system that will make such tragedies much rarer and will also give such children an opportunity to have a stable childhood and good life outcomes on a par with other children in society. The fact is that the UK public doesn't pressure its politicians to do this, so it doesn't happen.

But I didn't. And even if my first post suggested I did I clarified it quickly, yet you keep insisting otherwise.

Childhood and development of course have an impact on the adults we become. It's not abused = abuser, but of course it is understandable that someone who was not taken care of or loved may in some cases find it tricky to in turn take care of their kids, because they have not learnt those skills, or because certain behaviours or patterns have been normalised for them.

And you know, it does matter why. Because spotting it and intervening isn't always easy - as we see time and time again - so it would be much better to prevent by helping people who lack them (due to their own childhood, or otherwise) develop the skills (or unlearn certain behaviours) that might put them or their children at risk.

Swipe left for the next trending thread