Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How deprived do you have to be to move in a man into your home a day of ‘knowing’ him on Facebook? *[Content warning: concerns child abuse]

442 replies

EddyF · 04/04/2023 19:05

When you have children? Why isn’t the wider conversation in the media about the why/causes and PREVENTIONS of mothers doing this not being discussed on a wider platform? In the below case, again it’s the fault of SS and not the mother who moved a man from online to her home. It’s beyond sickening and I genuinely have no sympathy for any of these so called mothers. I don’t care about these men because it’s not hard to keep them out of your home/children’s lives.

This country has resources for when you can’t cope with your children. You can even give them up. These women behave as if they can’t date safely and that it’s completely natural to take in any old scruff even a murderous one into your children’s lives. It’s like they have never heard of the concept of dating partners NOT meeting your kids for a length of time UNTIL you can access a situation?

Not all these mums that do this are mentally challenged.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/lola-morgan-dyfedpowys-police-adhd-pembrokeshire-b2313875.html

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11937439/Mother-monster-boyfriend-guilty-death-two-year-old-girl.html

Timeline in death of two-year-old Lola James

Lola suffered 101 bruises and scratches to her body, damage to both her eyes and extensive brain damage in the early hours of July 17 2020.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/lola-morgan-dyfedpowys-police-adhd-pembrokeshire-b2313875.html

OP posts:
Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 19:56

Ludo19 · 05/04/2023 18:16

When I was younger I trained as a nursery nurse. I was in a placement where there were two brothers. The mother knew that her husband and BIL sexually abused these two little boys but kept saying "it's better to have a man in your life than none at all." At 19 it absolutely horrified me and still does. Mental health and/or learning difficulties isn't an excuse. The women that say "they didn't know what was going on" do and they lie. You'd need to be blind to not know what was going on under your own roof.

Jesus. That is heartbreaking. I hope the nursery reported them and SS removed those poor boys. 😓

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 19:54

People like that will never, ever be able to keep a child safe with any amount of "support". Let alone give them a good childhood. We need to raise the bar of what is expected, a lot. And lower the threshold for removal, a lot.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 19:53

@FlatWhiteExtraHot sorry.

I totally agree.

FlatWhiteExtraHot · 05/04/2023 19:36

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 13:30

Supported accommodation like this…?

https://www.brightonandhovenews.org/2020/10/23/safeguarding-review-launched-into-death-of-toddler-at-supported-housing/

That woman left a defenseless baby alone for days with mo food or water knowing that she would die, so that she could go and get drunk. It was clear that she was not capable of being a parent even if she'd had more support and that poor child should have been removed at birth.

Yes I know that. My point was in answer to posters upthread who seemed to think that putting women and children in supported accommodation would stop shit things happening. It won’t.

Yerroblemom1923 · 05/04/2023 19:08

@QuertyGirl interesting question about Surestart centres. Our local one was a good 3 mile walk away in a deprived area. Me and my friend used to walk there and back in the summer with our babies/toddlers as it was a lovely place. Sadly the parents it was aimed at, those right on the centre's doorstep, weren't interested in attending the "stay and play"s etc
The workers there tried so hard to reach out, door knocking etc to try to get the parents to engage. I really felt for them.
Like a pp said, sometimes we forget not everyone thinks/acts/ parents like we do. A day at home with a baby/toddler is a looooong day so I'd try to get out of the house every day for our sanity and would attend any baby group going. I assumed everyone and anyone would bendigo from this - mothers and babies.

Ludo19 · 05/04/2023 18:17

Oneiros · 05/04/2023 18:10

I am talking about understanding why to provide the help and support so it doesn't happen to others.

People capable of doing this to a child can't be helped.

This

Ludo19 · 05/04/2023 18:16

When I was younger I trained as a nursery nurse. I was in a placement where there were two brothers. The mother knew that her husband and BIL sexually abused these two little boys but kept saying "it's better to have a man in your life than none at all." At 19 it absolutely horrified me and still does. Mental health and/or learning difficulties isn't an excuse. The women that say "they didn't know what was going on" do and they lie. You'd need to be blind to not know what was going on under your own roof.

Oneiros · 05/04/2023 18:14

I said we should understand why they turn into abusers so we can help people (OTHER PEOPLE!*) develop the skill and access the support they need to be good parents and avoid the creation of further bad parents to the extent it is possible. Because often prevention is better than cure.

They are not "bad parents" who can be somehow "helped" to be better. The level of intervention these people have and still do this shows that quite clearly. The "extent it is possible" is next to zero, hence repeated child deaths. The children's needs should be prioritised over the adults' "rights" to force children to endure abusive and neglectful childhoods and the resources should be focused on removing the children not "supporting" the adults doing this to them.

Oneiros · 05/04/2023 18:10

I am talking about understanding why to provide the help and support so it doesn't happen to others.

People capable of doing this to a child can't be helped.

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 17:37

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 16:50

So you are proposing removing children at birth then? Even before people become parents?

What's next, we just sterilise them before they even become pregnant? Maybe at 16 SS could visit all girls, assess whether they would be bad mums.

Omg I've just seen this.

What on Earth are you talking about?? I never said anything of the sort, at all.

Aaargh I know I said I'd not reply to that poster again but WTAF.

First accusing me of saying that we should support abusive parents more Hmm when I'd criticised their comment about how we should try to "understand" the abusers and "help" them, and I'd responded by saying that children should be removed immediately that abuse becomes apparent. And then this poster claiming this meant I was saying that children should be assessed at 16 for whether they should have compulsory sterilisation. ShockHmmConfused

Unbelievable. And just so utterly ridiculous given what I have actually said in my posts.

I do wonder - when people like this appear and make such self-contradictory comments and pretend other posters have said the opposite of what they have stated clearly - where this motivation to defend abusers comes from.

I am going to hide this now as I said, came back because someone else tagged one of my posts.

I'm so sorry for little Lola, these cases haunt my thoughts. This could have been prevented so easily, she didn't have to be left with these monsters.

You keep coming back though - and when you do you ignore the vast majority of what I say and then accuse me of being stupid and offensive. I am neither.

I get you are upset, I get you don't want to engage. In which case don't. But there really is no need to suggest I am saying or doing something I am not.

For the last time - because I've said in in different ways several times now, which you repeatedly ignore - I didn't say we should help the abusers. I said we should understand why they turn into abusers so we can help people (OTHER PEOPLE!) develop the skill and access the support they need to be good parents and avoid the creation of further bad parents to the extent it is possible. Because often prevention is better than cure.

NotAnotherBathBomb · 05/04/2023 17:36

Sugarfree23 · 05/04/2023 16:17

You do realise that is often part of the cycle of abuse? Keeping the partner pregnant and therefore vulnerable difficult for her to up and leave with a tiny kid and another on the way.

Maybe this is all stuff girls should be taught in school

Maybe. Because men are at fault for being abusive but women have to protect their children. They can’t keep being given a free pass, it does no one any favours. It did Lola no favours.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 16:50

So you are proposing removing children at birth then? Even before people become parents?

What's next, we just sterilise them before they even become pregnant? Maybe at 16 SS could visit all girls, assess whether they would be bad mums.

Omg I've just seen this.

What on Earth are you talking about?? I never said anything of the sort, at all.

Aaargh I know I said I'd not reply to that poster again but WTAF.

First accusing me of saying that we should support abusive parents more Hmm when I'd criticised their comment about how we should try to "understand" the abusers and "help" them, and I'd responded by saying that children should be removed immediately that abuse becomes apparent. And then this poster claiming this meant I was saying that children should be assessed at 16 for whether they should have compulsory sterilisation. ShockHmmConfused

Unbelievable. And just so utterly ridiculous given what I have actually said in my posts.

I do wonder - when people like this appear and make such self-contradictory comments and pretend other posters have said the opposite of what they have stated clearly - where this motivation to defend abusers comes from.

I am going to hide this now as I said, came back because someone else tagged one of my posts.

I'm so sorry for little Lola, these cases haunt my thoughts. This could have been prevented so easily, she didn't have to be left with these monsters.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 16:35

Yes @Sugarfree23 that's probably the only way to do it if you are going to remove all the children who should be removed because there would not be enough foster carers to make that viable. But in those children's homes the children have secure, stable and good quality places to live in a family-like environment, generally very good long-term consistency in carers, proper pastoral care and support, therapy needed, lots of extra-curricular opportunities and educational support and generally every possible help they can (and should) be given to help them recover from neglect and trauma and have a stable upbringing where they feel safe and cared for. Hence the outcomes for those children being indistinguishable from the general population of children raised by parents (which in Denmark are high anyway) and obiously a far preferable childhood than being raised in squalor, abuse and neglect. It can be done, we just have to change the law, remove the children as soon as neglect and abuse becomes appararent and fund their care properly.

Sugarfree23 · 05/04/2023 16:29

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 13:54

Exactly. You hear loud noises in the middle of the night, your child is crying. And a person who you know has injured the child multiple times already says "oh it's all fine" so you go back to bed?!? Not remotely believable, unless she is a sociopath or psychopath herself.

These people are both absolute scum and whatever "issues" they had are irrelevant really. Those children should have been taken away long before.

If the LA had had to explicitly tell her not to move random drug-addicted men she didn't know into her children's home, then clearly this was an existing issue. Yet despite support she did it again. The house was disgusting. It was plain as day that she was neither safeguarding nor caring for the children long before they killed Lola.

Sadly because children do not vote funding for appropriate services and care isn't a priority. The adults responsible for them won't campaign for it. So the rest of us need to pressure MPs to ensure that funding for children's services is provided. That the penalisation of single parents through tax is removed so single mothers have a genuine route out of poverty without involving random men in their lives, that children living in situations like this are removed far, far earlier. In Denmark the children who grow up in children's homes have outcomes on a par with those living with parents. So it can be done. People get all outraged when reading these stories but how many have written to MPs demanding these tax changes and a much lower threshold for child removal and Denmark-style children's homes so that these children can be removed and have a decent life? That's how you break the cycle.

Very easy to wave your hands in the air and say it can't be fixed but it can. And for those parents who aren't complete monsters but are irresponsible and selfish, knowing that their children would be removed permanently at a far lower threshold might focus their minds and encourage them to prioritise their children's needs and not move unrelated adults into their homes. And if they do, well, then the children have a proper escape route and they can be left to continue their scummy lives alone.

Denmark does have very good outcomes for their 'looked after children' but it focuses on stability with in small children's homes rather than Foster carers.

Sugarfree23 · 05/04/2023 16:17

NotAnotherBathBomb · 05/04/2023 10:45

I agree. Sick of reading thread after thread of women in awful relationships who then throw in at the end 'and I'm heavily pregnant'. Usually with a second or third. But they are validated on here so there's no reason for them to expect more for themselves, let alone their poor children, who didn't choose any of this

You do realise that is often part of the cycle of abuse? Keeping the partner pregnant and therefore vulnerable difficult for her to up and leave with a tiny kid and another on the way.

Maybe this is all stuff girls should be taught in school

Sugarfree23 · 05/04/2023 16:13

JaneFondue · 05/04/2023 10:18

Indeed..Teen pregnancy is not a good thing. And encouraging your teens to keep unplanned babies is not being a supportive mum.

Teenage Pregnancy might not be the best thing in the world, but it's certainly not the worse. And it's not exactly something new it's always happened and always will.
shotgun marriage has always been a thing.

The vast majority of teenage mums kids turn out OK.
The best guide to how well a child will do in life is how well the Grandparents did. Even if one generation go astray the Grandparents can step up and provide a safety net for the kids.

LexMitior · 05/04/2023 15:59

Tbh the defining factor is the mother who moves a strange man into the house. Or a woman.

That person is given huge privileges over the children, the money, given sex, and quickly takes the role they want, being in charge of the household. They then discipline or beat the children to death in these cases.

I am glad that these women, who do nothing to protect their children are also being prosecuted. They allow and permit these murders to happen, and socially, I don't know what you do. A sane person knows introducing a stranger into their household with children is a big risk.

These mothers do not care about that. They can't protect their children because they don't have the insight or maturity to do it. They won't magically get it from a few courses either. There a lot of these cases where these women meet men online who say they will look after them. And those women just accept it.

slowquickstep · 05/04/2023 15:54

Doingmybest12 · 04/04/2023 20:37

The other half of this equation are the men who basically are looking for someone to take them in. Housing for single men, with various issues is few and far between and they prey on woman who are vulnerable to take them in. It is a recipe for disaster.

This is so true.

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 15:51

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 15:48

@Itsbytheby I've explained the policies I think need to be implemented very clearly, several times now.

These are based on international evidence of what works in other countries. Abuse and neglect should always result in child removal. Your comments about sterilising adolescents before they have children are ridiculous and nothing to do with anything I have said, which is that when there is evidence that somebody is not parenting properly children should be removed immediately.

I'm not going to respond to you anymore when your comments show you are incapable of/ haven't bothered to read what I've written already.

As a survivor of an abusive childhood I'm finding this thread very upsetting. I thought it worth engaging in the hope people would listen and pressure for changes to policies but I can't cope with being attacked like this and accused of saying the opposite of what I've said so I am hiding the thread now.

I am sorry you feel this way and for your experiences.

I am not attacking you, I am disagreeing with you on some points which kind of is the nature of the AIBU game. And we are talking cross purposes - you are clearly not reading my posts/ points properly either, but there really is no need to insinuate I am stupid as you have now done repeatedly.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 15:48

@Itsbytheby I've explained the policies I think need to be implemented very clearly, several times now.

These are based on international evidence of what works in other countries. Abuse and neglect should always result in child removal. Your comments about sterilising adolescents before they have children are ridiculous and nothing to do with anything I have said, which is that when there is evidence that somebody is not parenting properly children should be removed immediately.

I'm not going to respond to you anymore when your comments show you are incapable of/ haven't bothered to read what I've written already.

As a survivor of an abusive childhood I'm finding this thread very upsetting. I thought it worth engaging in the hope people would listen and pressure for changes to policies but I can't cope with being attacked like this and accused of saying the opposite of what I've said so I am hiding the thread now.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 15:42

Nolemonade · 05/04/2023 15:37

I’m tired of reading about murdered kids whilst we collectively figure out how to “help” or “prevent” their parents from carrying out such heinous acts. After many years working with “hard to help” families the conclusion I’ve come to is that some people just can’t be helped. The best outcomes for the children in those families is to be removed from their care from an early age and or at birth and allow them a chance at a happier and healthier life away from the feckless adults who continue to have babies they can’t or won’t look after properly.

A lot of women will and do choose men over their kids, a lot of women I’ve worked with prioritise their own needs to feel loved/desired /wanted/taken care of over the needs and safety of their children. You can implement as many interventions as you want, Freedom programme/parenting course/1:1 family and parental support but some adults can’t and won’t choose to prioritise their kid over some feckless useless partner who goes on to kill their child whilst they either look the other way or actively enable it.

I agree completely.

I am sick of people making excuses for these people and trying to "help" them instead of prioritising child safeguarding and preventing many of these tragedies by removing the children much, much earlier and - as a society - insisting we fund a good life for children in care.

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 15:41

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 15:34

So take kids away at birth? Or better yet, steralise them at puberty when it is so blatantly obvious what awful parents they would be?

FFS. What?

These children were living in a filthy house, clearly neglected. Their mother had subjected them to random males in their home and witnessing domestic violence and then moved in another random man. Social services had even felt the need to warn her not to move random drug addicts into her children's home yet she did it again and still the children weren't removed. Child walking around with black eyes and covered in bruises.

How the fuck did you get from that to "sterilise them at puberty"?

I'm out.

So at what stage?

I am talking about help and support for children who did not learn the skills or have a good upbringing. To help them have the skills, tools and opportunity to not fall into a cycle of bad family dynamics. I am talking about BEFORE they have kids, BEFORE they become parents, nevermind bad parents. Which is why I don't get what you were saying about taking away kids "early on". It can't really be much earlier can it?!

I am not talking about understanding Lola's mother, to help Lola's mother with her future parenting. Jeez, even I can see that boat has sailed. I am talking about understanding why to provide the help and support so it doesn't happen to others.

So we are talking cross purposes here.

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 15:38

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 15:31

Ok, yes. But you help them by removing them. Your earlier posts seems to be implying that we should try to understand why these parents do this and help them learn skills. They won't. Remove the children so they can be raised in a decent environment and then yes, they will learn very different skills.

I really don't understand what part of this is unclear to you @Itsbytheby ?

These people shouldn't be parents and will never be adequate parents no matter what you do. So you need to remove the kids at a much lower threshold, as I've said repeatedly.

You were talking about trying to "understand" the parents and teach them "skills". I said they are not capable of doing so and why they do what they do is irrelevant and the focus should be on removing and safeguarding the children and giving them a decent childhood. And then those children will have a very different life and learn very different life skills because they'll have a decent upbringing away from their abusive parents.

I really don't understand how you could possibly have misunderstood what I've said, it's very clear.

I'm going to step away from this thread now as it's making me so angry and upset and I feel like I'm being gaslit.

So you are proposing removing children at birth then? Even before people become parents?

I am trying to understand what you are saying, because frankly sounds outrageous to me. What's next, we just sterilise them before they even become pregnant? Maybe at 16 SS could visit all girls, assess whether they would be bad mums.

Some will become very bad parents regardless, but I would think many people - with the correct help, support and intervention early on, not just with parenting but with life in general. This woman, maybe if she had had support much eaerlier in her life, her life (and that of her kids) could have been different too.

You are taking what i am saying as some kind of support or sympathy with the parents in these case, parents that abuse children. That's not what it is.

And please don't accuse me of gaslighting. I am doing nothing of the sort. We simply disagree and if you don't want to engage further that's absolutely your prerogative.

Nolemonade · 05/04/2023 15:37

I’m tired of reading about murdered kids whilst we collectively figure out how to “help” or “prevent” their parents from carrying out such heinous acts. After many years working with “hard to help” families the conclusion I’ve come to is that some people just can’t be helped. The best outcomes for the children in those families is to be removed from their care from an early age and or at birth and allow them a chance at a happier and healthier life away from the feckless adults who continue to have babies they can’t or won’t look after properly.

A lot of women will and do choose men over their kids, a lot of women I’ve worked with prioritise their own needs to feel loved/desired /wanted/taken care of over the needs and safety of their children. You can implement as many interventions as you want, Freedom programme/parenting course/1:1 family and parental support but some adults can’t and won’t choose to prioritise their kid over some feckless useless partner who goes on to kill their child whilst they either look the other way or actively enable it.

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 15:34

So take kids away at birth? Or better yet, steralise them at puberty when it is so blatantly obvious what awful parents they would be?

FFS. What?

These children were living in a filthy house, clearly neglected. Their mother had subjected them to random males in their home and witnessing domestic violence and then moved in another random man. Social services had even felt the need to warn her not to move random drug addicts into her children's home yet she did it again and still the children weren't removed. Child walking around with black eyes and covered in bruises.

How the fuck did you get from that to "sterilise them at puberty"?

I'm out.