Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How deprived do you have to be to move in a man into your home a day of ‘knowing’ him on Facebook? *[Content warning: concerns child abuse]

442 replies

EddyF · 04/04/2023 19:05

When you have children? Why isn’t the wider conversation in the media about the why/causes and PREVENTIONS of mothers doing this not being discussed on a wider platform? In the below case, again it’s the fault of SS and not the mother who moved a man from online to her home. It’s beyond sickening and I genuinely have no sympathy for any of these so called mothers. I don’t care about these men because it’s not hard to keep them out of your home/children’s lives.

This country has resources for when you can’t cope with your children. You can even give them up. These women behave as if they can’t date safely and that it’s completely natural to take in any old scruff even a murderous one into your children’s lives. It’s like they have never heard of the concept of dating partners NOT meeting your kids for a length of time UNTIL you can access a situation?

Not all these mums that do this are mentally challenged.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/lola-morgan-dyfedpowys-police-adhd-pembrokeshire-b2313875.html

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11937439/Mother-monster-boyfriend-guilty-death-two-year-old-girl.html

Timeline in death of two-year-old Lola James

Lola suffered 101 bruises and scratches to her body, damage to both her eyes and extensive brain damage in the early hours of July 17 2020.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/lola-morgan-dyfedpowys-police-adhd-pembrokeshire-b2313875.html

OP posts:
TruffleWaffle · 06/04/2023 14:55

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 14:33

Quite a few in Europe have stats similar to the general population raised by parents. Those in Denmark marginally exceed the general population, because they fund it properly. It's a choice to have horrific care homes in the UK.

Someone always says a Scandinavian country 🙄

They can't be compared to the UK. They have smaller populations, better standards of living, have higher incomes and pay more tax.

So better healthcare, less crime, better schools, fewer drug problems, better and more accessible housing, better and more affordable childcare, better parentl leave and on and on. Plus there's cultural differences too.

Denmark in particular is rated as one of of the best places in the world to have a child.

So of course there's less social care intervention needed and it's better when it is needed because there's more money available to cover a smaller number of cases.

It's incomparable to the UK because the need for social care intervention is greater because of poverty, poorer healthcare, housing, more crime, more drugs etc.

We have more social problems so public funds are spread more thinly.

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 14:52

IQ - well no, you can't give someone higher IQ. But if you identify someone with low IQ struggling you can support the,, educate them, touch base on a regular basis, but them in support programs.
Drugs - there's loads of programs to help people come off drugs, but I assume they are not always easily accessible or people avoid them due to fear or stigma. Also, you can give people opportunities and education to avoid them getting involved in drugs in the first place.
Mental illness - treat it, clearly.

In general, social/ commuity support, education, opportunities to make money, easily accessible health case (including for drugs and mental health), these things - if invested in properly - could make a huge difference. Reducing poverty and deprivation in society generally.

Sigh. These people all have access to education just like everyone else. They do not want it. They spent 14 years of compulsory education wilfully not engaging with it. Social services and in this particular case domestic violence programmes had engaged with the mother and tried to support her. She had the Freedom Program twice then stopped attending and ignored what they'd taught her. No cure for low IQ as you admit. There is so much support for these people already. Benefits, their rent being paid, social workers, free education, free adult courses offered, support offered to help them find work or retrain, offer to pay almost all of their childcare if they work, charities offering support with life skills, free healthcare and on and on. You cannot teach psychopaths who prioritise men over their child, who hear their child screaming in the middle of the night and do nothing about it, who see them covered in bruises and do not care and actively cover it up rather than seeking medical attention, to be good parents. Nothing you have suggested is new. None of it would change anything, as we have seen by doing exactly what you suggest for decades.

Itsbytheby · 06/04/2023 14:48

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 14:44

Those in Denmark marginally exceed the general population, because they fund it properly.

Are you saying here that in Denmark the outcome of children in care is BETTER than that of the general population?

By a small margin, yes. Because they are given such intensive support, therapy and other support to deal with trauma, lots of opportunities, a very good education, a small and stable children's home to live in throughout their childhood with long-term carers and also crucially they are removed at a much earlier stage of neglect before so much damage is done. The approach is to give them even more opportunities and support than the general population might have, to compensate for their early life experience and give them every chance at a decent life as adults just like everyone else. And it works.

That is surprising, but amazing. Shows what good social funding can do. I am sure part of the motivation to make such an effort is also to avoid the societal consequences of the outcome of children are not supported.... kind of like I was suggesting. Obviously not just to do with abuse, but everything else that can stem from a really bad childhood.

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 14:44

Those in Denmark marginally exceed the general population, because they fund it properly.

Are you saying here that in Denmark the outcome of children in care is BETTER than that of the general population?

By a small margin, yes. Because they are given such intensive support, therapy and other support to deal with trauma, lots of opportunities, a very good education, a small and stable children's home to live in throughout their childhood with long-term carers and also crucially they are removed at a much earlier stage of neglect before so much damage is done. The approach is to give them even more opportunities and support than the general population might have, to compensate for their early life experience and give them every chance at a decent life as adults just like everyone else. And it works.

Itsbytheby · 06/04/2023 14:37

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 14:33

Quite a few in Europe have stats similar to the general population raised by parents. Those in Denmark marginally exceed the general population, because they fund it properly. It's a choice to have horrific care homes in the UK.

Those in Denmark marginally exceed the general population, because they fund it properly.

Are you saying here that in Denmark the outcome of children in care is BETTER than that of the general population?

Itsbytheby · 06/04/2023 14:36

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 14:30

but in many it can with the right social and support measures.

So explain what they are then please, these measures which will fix low IQ, psychopathy/ sociopathy, etc?

I'm starting to think you aren't actually interested in the answers, only in trying to catch me out at being "wrong". Which is really rather boring.

Itsbytheby · 06/04/2023 14:35

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 14:28

And now you are just being rude. I can eye roll too you know 🙄

Good for you. I notice that your reply ignored the part of the post where you were asked to explain how you will implement your genius policy ideas.

How are you going to give people with low IQs high IQs?

How are you going to "cure" the psychopaths and sociopaths and make them loving, caring, empathetic parents?

How are you going to convince all of the addicts to stop taking drugs and prioritise their children?

How are you planning to get all of these low IQ people who have no interest in education to engage in it and gain qualification and careers so they can provide decent, stable homes for their children and engage in their children's educations, too?

Very interested to hear exactly how you believe these "factors" that you listed can be "resolved", as you suggested they can?

IQ - well no, you can't give someone higher IQ. But if you identify someone with low IQ struggling you can support the,, educate them, touch base on a regular basis, but them in support programs.
Drugs - there's loads of programs to help people come off drugs, but I assume they are not always easily accessible or people avoid them due to fear or stigma. Also, you can give people opportunities and education to avoid them getting involved in drugs in the first place.
Mental illness - treat it, clearly.

In general, social/ commuity support, education, opportunities to make money, easily accessible health case (including for drugs and mental health), these things - if invested in properly - could make a huge difference. Reducing poverty and deprivation in society generally.

I don't have all the answers (I am not, as you - sarcastically - commented, holding myself out to be a public policy genius). But it's a far better outcome (and investments) to avoid the abuse happening by helping people not turn into abusive parents in the first place, than it happening and then removing children (if it is happening obviously intervention is required).

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 14:33

Quite a few in Europe have stats similar to the general population raised by parents. Those in Denmark marginally exceed the general population, because they fund it properly. It's a choice to have horrific care homes in the UK.

TruffleWaffle · 06/04/2023 14:30

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 14:22

Every single outcome that can be measured is worse for children that have been in care

That's only because the UK care system isn't funded properly. That's not the case at all in other countries: where it is funded properly where they have outcomes matching the general population. This is not an argument for leaving children in abusive homes. The answer is to fund care properly.

Which countries do not have poorer outcomes for children in care?

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 14:30

but in many it can with the right social and support measures.

So explain what they are then please, these measures which will fix low IQ, psychopathy/ sociopathy, etc?

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 14:28

And now you are just being rude. I can eye roll too you know 🙄

Good for you. I notice that your reply ignored the part of the post where you were asked to explain how you will implement your genius policy ideas.

How are you going to give people with low IQs high IQs?

How are you going to "cure" the psychopaths and sociopaths and make them loving, caring, empathetic parents?

How are you going to convince all of the addicts to stop taking drugs and prioritise their children?

How are you planning to get all of these low IQ people who have no interest in education to engage in it and gain qualification and careers so they can provide decent, stable homes for their children and engage in their children's educations, too?

Very interested to hear exactly how you believe these "factors" that you listed can be "resolved", as you suggested they can?

Itsbytheby · 06/04/2023 14:24

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 14:22

Every single outcome that can be measured is worse for children that have been in care

That's only because the UK care system isn't funded properly. That's not the case at all in other countries: where it is funded properly where they have outcomes matching the general population. This is not an argument for leaving children in abusive homes. The answer is to fund care properly.

But the ideal situation is to leave children in non-abusive homes. Prevent the abuse from ever taking place. Again acknolwedging that in some cases it cannot be prevented - in which case removal for the children's safety should of course be prioritised over e.g. the cost of adequately housing them after removal as was mentioned earlier - but in many it can with the right social and support measures.

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 14:23

Most cases won't meet the thresholds to be removed

Yes, at the moment. Because the thesholds are too high and need to be lowered. That's what a lot of this discussion has been about.

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 14:22

Every single outcome that can be measured is worse for children that have been in care

That's only because the UK care system isn't funded properly. That's not the case at all in other countries: where it is funded properly where they have outcomes matching the general population. This is not an argument for leaving children in abusive homes. The answer is to fund care properly.

Itsbytheby · 06/04/2023 14:16

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 12:27

But lack of skills, lack of opportunity, lack of normal emotional development, inability to cope with their feelings, not having coping mechanisms, lack of resources, lack of education, drugs, untreated mental illness, below average intelligence these things all contribute to the likelihood of someone not being able to cope as a parent... If you improve or remove those factors, the likelihood of at least some of those people become awful parents is be reduced.

It's common sense re prevention, not just "cure". I suspect this would be much more efficient and lead to much better outcomes than going around taking away children once they have already been abused to some extent. For the children, for the parents and for the state.

Right, ok. So, in your view, let the children who are at huge risk right now continue to live where they are. Don't remove them. Too late for them, tough. Just focus on "removing or improving" the "factors" you listed because then allegedly other people won't also become abusive and neglectful parents.

So, how exactly to you plan to give people with low IQs higher IQs? How are you going to turn sociopaths/ psychopaths into normal, empathetic and balance human beings with "normal emotional development"? Convince drug addicts not to take drugs? Convince people who have never had any intention of engaging with education and come from families where nobody does so to suddenly change their mind and study and get qualifications and careers so that they have more "resources"? Clearly you are a public policy genius, sounds like a really effective plan that can be implemented immediately and then we won't even need child protection social workers anymore. 🙄 I look forward to the utopia populated solely with well-balanced, intelligent, responsible and well-educated people, providing for and caring for all of their children and giving them wonderful, enriching and secure childhoods.

Back in the real world, children need to be safeguarded from people incapable of even sorting their own lives out let alone providing for and caring for a child adequately and who will never be capable of doing so.

"Right, ok. So, in your view, let the children who are at huge risk right now continue to live where they are. Don't remove them. Too late for them, tough. Just focus on "removing or improving" the "factors" you listed because then allegedly other people won't also become abusive and neglectful parents."

No. I literally never said or even implied this. The two things aren't mutually exclusive and we should be doing both. Of course there are measures that can be taken to improve outcomes for people in the sitautions I mention.

I find it really surprising that people don't think it's better to do our utmost to try avoid the abuse in the first place than only to intervene once it's happened.

"Clearly you are a public policy genius, sounds like a really effective plan that can be implemented immediately and then we won't even need child protection social workers anymore. 🙄"

And now you are just being rude. I can eye roll too you know 🙄

lemmein · 06/04/2023 14:07

Doingmybest12 · 04/04/2023 20:37

The other half of this equation are the men who basically are looking for someone to take them in. Housing for single men, with various issues is few and far between and they prey on woman who are vulnerable to take them in. It is a recipe for disaster.

I 100% agree with this and feel it's something that is rarely considered. They prey on these women because a lot of the time they have nowhere else to go.

TruffleWaffle · 06/04/2023 13:53

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 12:27

But lack of skills, lack of opportunity, lack of normal emotional development, inability to cope with their feelings, not having coping mechanisms, lack of resources, lack of education, drugs, untreated mental illness, below average intelligence these things all contribute to the likelihood of someone not being able to cope as a parent... If you improve or remove those factors, the likelihood of at least some of those people become awful parents is be reduced.

It's common sense re prevention, not just "cure". I suspect this would be much more efficient and lead to much better outcomes than going around taking away children once they have already been abused to some extent. For the children, for the parents and for the state.

Right, ok. So, in your view, let the children who are at huge risk right now continue to live where they are. Don't remove them. Too late for them, tough. Just focus on "removing or improving" the "factors" you listed because then allegedly other people won't also become abusive and neglectful parents.

So, how exactly to you plan to give people with low IQs higher IQs? How are you going to turn sociopaths/ psychopaths into normal, empathetic and balance human beings with "normal emotional development"? Convince drug addicts not to take drugs? Convince people who have never had any intention of engaging with education and come from families where nobody does so to suddenly change their mind and study and get qualifications and careers so that they have more "resources"? Clearly you are a public policy genius, sounds like a really effective plan that can be implemented immediately and then we won't even need child protection social workers anymore. 🙄 I look forward to the utopia populated solely with well-balanced, intelligent, responsible and well-educated people, providing for and caring for all of their children and giving them wonderful, enriching and secure childhoods.

Back in the real world, children need to be safeguarded from people incapable of even sorting their own lives out let alone providing for and caring for a child adequately and who will never be capable of doing so.

They didn't say children shouldn't be removed, they said that basically it's shutting the stable door after the horse is bolted.

Every single outcome that can be measured is worse for children that have been in care. It's not a case of anyone saying don't remove children, it's saying the damage is already being done and then being in care often exacerbates existing damage.

That poster is absolutely correct that preventative intervention is far more useful in the bigger picture than what currently happens. Which is where children are born into families who are ill-equipped to parent and then we wait until things have become extremely dangerous before those children are removed.

And then those children grow up and because of all they've been through, they are ill-equipped to be parents and the same things happen to their children. And down the generations.

Most cases won't meet the thresholds to be removed and in weighing up the damage caused by staying at home or going into care, staying at home often seems less damaging. So it’s a choice between shit or shit.

Rarely, those decisions result in the death of a child and then everyone wants to blame the authorities for not doing enough. But this is end-stage stuff. The causative factors began years or generations before.

That's what that poster was getting at.

myteethwerefine · 06/04/2023 12:42

@Itsbytheby I just wanted to say that as a victim of an abusive childhood you haven't said anything to offend me personally. You are right in that understanding is crucial. You are also right in that the generational cycle of abuse is very real and those coming from such families are far more likely (but as you pointed out, not destined) to perpetuate this cycle.

Also, it irritates me when people say 'well, I had an abusive childhood and I would never do such a thing.' Every single 'abusive childhood' is unique. In fact, I would say even my own sibling had a different childhood to me. Yes there are common themes but there are so many factors, big and small, that dictate outcome and differentiate one child's experience from another's. How old was the child at onset of abuse? Was there at least one adult the child could safely attach to, a grandparent for example? Did the environment outside of the immediate family provide safety or more abuse? What are the intelligence levels of the parents? What is the intelligence level of the child? What was the relationship of the abuser to the child (father, step-father, family friend etc)? Was the abuse known about and acknowledged or covered up? Was the child believed if they spoke out or disbelieved or even blamed? Were substances involved? Mental illness? And on and on and on even before we get to individual personalities and socio-economic factors.....endless possibilities to cause terrible damage, each in their own particular way.

People have mentioned Baby P. Here is a harrowing article about the family and the generational layer upon layer of violence, deprivation and neglect that he was born into:
Baby P: born into a nightmare of abuse, violence and despair, he never stood a chance | Baby P | The Guardian

Baby P: born into a nightmare of abuse, violence and despair, he never stood a chance

Death of Peter Connelly is graphic warning of horrors that generations of neglect can visit on lives of children

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2009/aug/16/baby-p-family

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 12:27

But lack of skills, lack of opportunity, lack of normal emotional development, inability to cope with their feelings, not having coping mechanisms, lack of resources, lack of education, drugs, untreated mental illness, below average intelligence these things all contribute to the likelihood of someone not being able to cope as a parent... If you improve or remove those factors, the likelihood of at least some of those people become awful parents is be reduced.

It's common sense re prevention, not just "cure". I suspect this would be much more efficient and lead to much better outcomes than going around taking away children once they have already been abused to some extent. For the children, for the parents and for the state.

Right, ok. So, in your view, let the children who are at huge risk right now continue to live where they are. Don't remove them. Too late for them, tough. Just focus on "removing or improving" the "factors" you listed because then allegedly other people won't also become abusive and neglectful parents.

So, how exactly to you plan to give people with low IQs higher IQs? How are you going to turn sociopaths/ psychopaths into normal, empathetic and balance human beings with "normal emotional development"? Convince drug addicts not to take drugs? Convince people who have never had any intention of engaging with education and come from families where nobody does so to suddenly change their mind and study and get qualifications and careers so that they have more "resources"? Clearly you are a public policy genius, sounds like a really effective plan that can be implemented immediately and then we won't even need child protection social workers anymore. 🙄 I look forward to the utopia populated solely with well-balanced, intelligent, responsible and well-educated people, providing for and caring for all of their children and giving them wonderful, enriching and secure childhoods.

Back in the real world, children need to be safeguarded from people incapable of even sorting their own lives out let alone providing for and caring for a child adequately and who will never be capable of doing so.

Parsley1234 · 06/04/2023 09:37

I worked at a refuge 30 years ago when I still had belief in change being possible when one woman’s bf was held on remand who knows what for. She decided to run what can only be described as a dating agency she was taking other women on VOS to meet other men on remand with their children from the refuge 🤯

Itsbytheby · 06/04/2023 08:50

TruffleWaffle · 06/04/2023 08:48

I've thought for many years that this is another consequence of how men are at a disadvantage in terms of social care or housing.

Women with children are giving priority understandably. But there are thousands upon thousands of young single men who have been in care, drug users, victims of abuse, mentally ill, neurodevelopmental disorders, involved with the criminal justice system etc not able to get work or not employable who are last on the list for any type of social care or housing.

It's not just 'why would she move someone in that she barely knows?'. It's also why would he do that?

So what happens? They (men) meet someone who is just as troubled as they are but has a flat they're willing to let them move into. Whereas they are otherwise homeless/sofa surfing.

So shitty dysfunctional relationships with both parties having mental health/drug/other problems. He won't want to leave because he has nowhere to go and she won't want to kick him out because he has nowhere to go (or feels manipulated by him saying that).

So men with psychological/mental/drugs problems who won't be in a position to get adequate help for them are suddenly acting as a 'parent' to a child they have no connection to, probably don't want to have a connection to and can't/don't want to care for.

And domestic and child abuse happens. I'm not excusing the perpetrators in any way but when someone is in 'survival mode' and there is little or no alternative for them having a roof over their head, these are the tragic consequences.

I agree. We can pretend these people are "just" born evil monsters all we like, but there is a reason that this sort of thing happens much more in some elements of society than others.... And if we recognise (or, theforbidden word, understand) that, we can do things to prevent those abuses happening in the first place.

TruffleWaffle · 06/04/2023 08:48

I've thought for many years that this is another consequence of how men are at a disadvantage in terms of social care or housing.

Women with children are giving priority understandably. But there are thousands upon thousands of young single men who have been in care, drug users, victims of abuse, mentally ill, neurodevelopmental disorders, involved with the criminal justice system etc not able to get work or not employable who are last on the list for any type of social care or housing.

It's not just 'why would she move someone in that she barely knows?'. It's also why would he do that?

So what happens? They (men) meet someone who is just as troubled as they are but has a flat they're willing to let them move into. Whereas they are otherwise homeless/sofa surfing.

So shitty dysfunctional relationships with both parties having mental health/drug/other problems. He won't want to leave because he has nowhere to go and she won't want to kick him out because he has nowhere to go (or feels manipulated by him saying that).

So men with psychological/mental/drugs problems who won't be in a position to get adequate help for them are suddenly acting as a 'parent' to a child they have no connection to, probably don't want to have a connection to and can't/don't want to care for.

And domestic and child abuse happens. I'm not excusing the perpetrators in any way but when someone is in 'survival mode' and there is little or no alternative for them having a roof over their head, these are the tragic consequences.

uggmum · 06/04/2023 08:19

I worked for an advice charity.
I had a client that came in with her new boyfriend.

She had been with him for 6 months. He had moved in straight away.

She came in for advice as her 5 children had been removed from her care that day.

She said her boyfriend was lovely with the kids. But had kicked off at the kid's school and been banned. Said social services had been involved but she refused to interact with them. From memory it went from a child in need to a child protection order. Then the police came and took the kids.

He told me that he had 7 children that had previously been taken into care but was completely innocent and was a great Dad. Apparently it was his Ex that had a grudge.

She was so so convinced that he was a victim. Totally put him before her children.

I just can't understand women like this.

QueenBeaver · 06/04/2023 08:18

EddyF · 04/04/2023 19:05

When you have children? Why isn’t the wider conversation in the media about the why/causes and PREVENTIONS of mothers doing this not being discussed on a wider platform? In the below case, again it’s the fault of SS and not the mother who moved a man from online to her home. It’s beyond sickening and I genuinely have no sympathy for any of these so called mothers. I don’t care about these men because it’s not hard to keep them out of your home/children’s lives.

This country has resources for when you can’t cope with your children. You can even give them up. These women behave as if they can’t date safely and that it’s completely natural to take in any old scruff even a murderous one into your children’s lives. It’s like they have never heard of the concept of dating partners NOT meeting your kids for a length of time UNTIL you can access a situation?

Not all these mums that do this are mentally challenged.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/lola-morgan-dyfedpowys-police-adhd-pembrokeshire-b2313875.html

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11937439/Mother-monster-boyfriend-guilty-death-two-year-old-girl.html

I know, who does this?? Tbh, she doesn’t look like the sharpest tool in the shed.

LemonPeonies · 06/04/2023 08:15

I agree, all too often women introduce new men into their children's lives without thinking of the risk. They are stupid and I agree with a pp about lacking the fundamental protective streak you should feel for your children.