Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How deprived do you have to be to move in a man into your home a day of ‘knowing’ him on Facebook? *[Content warning: concerns child abuse]

442 replies

EddyF · 04/04/2023 19:05

When you have children? Why isn’t the wider conversation in the media about the why/causes and PREVENTIONS of mothers doing this not being discussed on a wider platform? In the below case, again it’s the fault of SS and not the mother who moved a man from online to her home. It’s beyond sickening and I genuinely have no sympathy for any of these so called mothers. I don’t care about these men because it’s not hard to keep them out of your home/children’s lives.

This country has resources for when you can’t cope with your children. You can even give them up. These women behave as if they can’t date safely and that it’s completely natural to take in any old scruff even a murderous one into your children’s lives. It’s like they have never heard of the concept of dating partners NOT meeting your kids for a length of time UNTIL you can access a situation?

Not all these mums that do this are mentally challenged.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/lola-morgan-dyfedpowys-police-adhd-pembrokeshire-b2313875.html

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11937439/Mother-monster-boyfriend-guilty-death-two-year-old-girl.html

Timeline in death of two-year-old Lola James

Lola suffered 101 bruises and scratches to her body, damage to both her eyes and extensive brain damage in the early hours of July 17 2020.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/crime/lola-morgan-dyfedpowys-police-adhd-pembrokeshire-b2313875.html

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Biilie82 · 14/04/2023 19:01

EffortlessDesmond · 06/04/2023 21:37

I didn't click the link above. I already know far more about child abuse than I ever wanted to know. I am as angry as all of you. And no, I am 67, and I am not going to be the person who intervenes and rescues a small child. I could be, but I am not going to. We. have. done. our. bit.

What on earth are you talking about?

Mimilamore · 14/04/2023 17:21

TruffleWaffle absolutely this! Prevention and early intervention is key. Isn't this why Surestart centres were set up? To a) help struggling parents and b) intervene as early as possible if they thought children were being abused.
Unfortunately, like I noticed with our nearest centre, the parents it was aimed at didn't engage with it and were wary of it ( presumably because they thought it was closely aligned with SS)

Saw this happen with my own eyes in an affluent town nearby but where I live, huge depravation and poverty Sure start did wonderful work. My jaw hit the floor when they lost funding

Nepmarthiturn · 11/04/2023 13:49

I am so sorry to heat that. I hope your life is now one of safety and contentment. You are right the bar needs to be lowered.

Thank you. The emotional wounds can heal but the scars never go away. I am one of the "lucky" ones and have a great life now but it's very distressing that this is still being allowed to happen to children on such a scale. Nothing seems to have changed. It is a choice: with earlier removal far fewer children would suffer or die.

Lovanna · 09/04/2023 13:07

The bar certainly does need lowering to help more children.

Unfortunately, that means the Tory government funding public services.

It won't happen.

slowquickstep · 08/04/2023 13:25

Nepmarthiturn · 07/04/2023 15:24

Don't assume SS will always remove a child in danger. Too many times i have been told by SS that it is upsetting for a child to know it is their fault Uncle Bob no longer lives with them and that makes Mummy sad and that sometimes it is better if SS monitor the situation. Many times i have told SS that they are worse than abusers for leaving a child in harms way.

I know @slowquickstep 😔

I was one of those left to see how much more abuse would happen, when I was covered in bruises already. School knew, SS knew, the police knew. Nobody did anything.

The threshold for removal needs to be far, far lower.

I am so sorry to heat that. I hope your life is now one of safety and contentment. You are right the bar needs to be lowered.

Merryoldgoat · 08/04/2023 13:15

Another three just this morning in AIBU alone.

Two with horrible partners whilst pregnant and another with multiple kids even though a dick before having children.

Parsley1234 · 08/04/2023 08:59

Yes that is why surestart was set up and a lot of parents wouldn’t engage and now they’re gone there’s nothing of a similar ilk.

Yerroblemom1923 · 08/04/2023 08:45

@TruffleWaffle absolutely this! Prevention and early intervention is key. Isn't this why Surestart centres were set up? To a) help struggling parents and b) intervene as early as possible if they thought children were being abused.
Unfortunately, like I noticed with our nearest centre, the parents it was aimed at didn't engage with it and were wary of it ( presumably because they thought it was closely aligned with SS)

Merryoldgoat · 07/04/2023 16:10

The utter inadequacies are just so awful and wrong and unfair.

@Nepmarthiturn I’m so sorry you went through such horrors. They let you down so badly.

Nepmarthiturn · 07/04/2023 15:24

Don't assume SS will always remove a child in danger. Too many times i have been told by SS that it is upsetting for a child to know it is their fault Uncle Bob no longer lives with them and that makes Mummy sad and that sometimes it is better if SS monitor the situation. Many times i have told SS that they are worse than abusers for leaving a child in harms way.

I know @slowquickstep 😔

I was one of those left to see how much more abuse would happen, when I was covered in bruises already. School knew, SS knew, the police knew. Nobody did anything.

The threshold for removal needs to be far, far lower.

slowquickstep · 07/04/2023 15:16

Cirque1 · 07/04/2023 14:15

Well, that would entirely depend on why "uncle bob" was considered a risk and whether he is low risk and can therefore live with a child. I think SS probably know more about situations than we as outsiders.

Physical abuse. Child had bruises every week and a broken arm that couldn't be explained. Man in question had already done time for child abuse, SS looked in on the family now then and insisted he was not allowed to be alone with the children at any point, the Mother ignored the ruling. Yes i knew the case as the child was in my class and it was myself and my manager that reported the abuse. Took him setting the family home on fire for the mother to kick him out. New man in the house within weeks. And the merry go round started again. Child never stood a chance in life.

Cirque1 · 07/04/2023 14:15

slowquickstep · 07/04/2023 14:09

Don't assume SS will always remove a child in danger. Too many times i have been told by SS that it is upsetting for a child to know it is their fault Uncle Bob no longer lives with them and that makes Mummy sad and that sometimes it is better if SS monitor the situation. Many times i have told SS that they are worse than abusers for leaving a child in harms way.

Well, that would entirely depend on why "uncle bob" was considered a risk and whether he is low risk and can therefore live with a child. I think SS probably know more about situations than we as outsiders.

slowquickstep · 07/04/2023 14:09

Nepmarthiturn · 05/04/2023 19:56

Jesus. That is heartbreaking. I hope the nursery reported them and SS removed those poor boys. 😓

Don't assume SS will always remove a child in danger. Too many times i have been told by SS that it is upsetting for a child to know it is their fault Uncle Bob no longer lives with them and that makes Mummy sad and that sometimes it is better if SS monitor the situation. Many times i have told SS that they are worse than abusers for leaving a child in harms way.

OlympicProcrastinator · 07/04/2023 10:23

Itsbytheby · 05/04/2023 15:29

No need to be rude.

But I find it quite a shocking concept that you - generally - think SS should go around assessing pregnant mothers and if they think they won't be great parents should remove their children at birth.

They do do this already. Plenty of women are assessed prior to giving birth. All of us were by doctors, health visitors, midwives. If a concern is raised, children’s services go and make an assessment. Plenty of mums are made to hand over their babies at birth based on a court order instigated by children’s services.

Sillybanana · 07/04/2023 09:43

controversial to say, and obviously not the case for everyone..but I think in some areas and cultures, it’s normal to have a child/children as it’s the only way they can get accommodation and benefits. They never really wanted the child, are often young when they had them, have missed out on life and fun..I think they then resent that child, never bond with it, see them as a barrier to them having fun/sex..happy to palm them off on anyone that will have them, like men they hardly know.

Parsley1234 · 06/04/2023 22:32

@EffortlessDesmond @TruffleWaffle yes she is and sadly those people will disproportionately occupy more time resources money than others with no perceived improved outcome

Comii9 · 06/04/2023 22:07

@TruffleWaffle you have made some excellent points especially ones about generational poverty and MC families. It's true indeed.

EffortlessDesmond · 06/04/2023 21:44

@TruffleWaffle is telling everyone the truth. There are people who do not even begin to follow normal standards. And they will disproportionately (by number) fill prisons and occupy social services.

EffortlessDesmond · 06/04/2023 21:37

I didn't click the link above. I already know far more about child abuse than I ever wanted to know. I am as angry as all of you. And no, I am 67, and I am not going to be the person who intervenes and rescues a small child. I could be, but I am not going to. We. have. done. our. bit.

TruffleWaffle · 06/04/2023 16:43

Itsbytheby · 06/04/2023 15:25

And just one last thought from me here @Oneiros - for all your sarcasm and insults, sighs and eyerolling all I actually want is for children not to be abused in the first place. That doesn't happen by removing those that have already been abused. You need to address the route cause, and prevent the abuse from happening in the first place.

So how do you do that? You could take all children away at birth - putting them in lovely Danish style homes - so noone is at risk. Or given how controversial and extreme that is, maybe only those prospective parents who are indicating risk factors and remove at birth? Or prevent them having children in the first place? Again, not great from a human rights angle. So then the only option left is what I have suggested. Investing in and doing what we can - as a society - to make sure that those parents who are not evil sadistic child abusers by nature, are given the support and circumstances to be the best parents they can be. So they hopefully raise children who have the tools, skills and circumstances to be better parents themselves.

Most of us get exactly what you meant.

I work with the demographic of families described here. And have often called for children to be removed far earlier than they are.

But that doesn't mean that I think the problem is then solved and the children will go on to have great lives. Because in most cases they don't, and then I see those children getting older and having their own children and the cycle begins again.

Because we're not talking about 'psychopaths' who just sprang from the ground and had every kind of resource and benefits thrown at them and they couldn't be arsed to engage.

I can say 100% that sometimes they have been offered everything available and my compassion and patience runs out. But that doesn't mean I don't know that often, the people involved have been failed by social care/education/healthcare etc for years previously and often, their parents were and so we're dealing with generational issues caused by the social problems we have in the UK.

There are very, very few incidences like the one described here where it's a family who are middle class, earning, in adequate or good housing, well educated etc.

Same as there are few individuals in prison from those families.

And before anyone jumps on to say what a shit childhood they had but they still wouldn't do x, y or z. We know that having a shit childhood or life doesn't mean it is inevitable that means a shit adulthood or being a child abuser or shit parent.

But it happens. Often. The correlation is undeniable.

Itsbytheby · 06/04/2023 15:25

And just one last thought from me here @Oneiros - for all your sarcasm and insults, sighs and eyerolling all I actually want is for children not to be abused in the first place. That doesn't happen by removing those that have already been abused. You need to address the route cause, and prevent the abuse from happening in the first place.

So how do you do that? You could take all children away at birth - putting them in lovely Danish style homes - so noone is at risk. Or given how controversial and extreme that is, maybe only those prospective parents who are indicating risk factors and remove at birth? Or prevent them having children in the first place? Again, not great from a human rights angle. So then the only option left is what I have suggested. Investing in and doing what we can - as a society - to make sure that those parents who are not evil sadistic child abusers by nature, are given the support and circumstances to be the best parents they can be. So they hopefully raise children who have the tools, skills and circumstances to be better parents themselves.

TruffleWaffle · 06/04/2023 15:09

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 14:52

IQ - well no, you can't give someone higher IQ. But if you identify someone with low IQ struggling you can support the,, educate them, touch base on a regular basis, but them in support programs.
Drugs - there's loads of programs to help people come off drugs, but I assume they are not always easily accessible or people avoid them due to fear or stigma. Also, you can give people opportunities and education to avoid them getting involved in drugs in the first place.
Mental illness - treat it, clearly.

In general, social/ commuity support, education, opportunities to make money, easily accessible health case (including for drugs and mental health), these things - if invested in properly - could make a huge difference. Reducing poverty and deprivation in society generally.

Sigh. These people all have access to education just like everyone else. They do not want it. They spent 14 years of compulsory education wilfully not engaging with it. Social services and in this particular case domestic violence programmes had engaged with the mother and tried to support her. She had the Freedom Program twice then stopped attending and ignored what they'd taught her. No cure for low IQ as you admit. There is so much support for these people already. Benefits, their rent being paid, social workers, free education, free adult courses offered, support offered to help them find work or retrain, offer to pay almost all of their childcare if they work, charities offering support with life skills, free healthcare and on and on. You cannot teach psychopaths who prioritise men over their child, who hear their child screaming in the middle of the night and do nothing about it, who see them covered in bruises and do not care and actively cover it up rather than seeking medical attention, to be good parents. Nothing you have suggested is new. None of it would change anything, as we have seen by doing exactly what you suggest for decades.

🙄

Itsbytheby · 06/04/2023 15:08

TruffleWaffle · 06/04/2023 14:55

Someone always says a Scandinavian country 🙄

They can't be compared to the UK. They have smaller populations, better standards of living, have higher incomes and pay more tax.

So better healthcare, less crime, better schools, fewer drug problems, better and more accessible housing, better and more affordable childcare, better parentl leave and on and on. Plus there's cultural differences too.

Denmark in particular is rated as one of of the best places in the world to have a child.

So of course there's less social care intervention needed and it's better when it is needed because there's more money available to cover a smaller number of cases.

It's incomparable to the UK because the need for social care intervention is greater because of poverty, poorer healthcare, housing, more crime, more drugs etc.

We have more social problems so public funds are spread more thinly.

Yes, agree with all this. And in particular this:

It's incomparable to the UK because the need for social care intervention is greater because of poverty, poorer healthcare, housing, more crime, more drugs etc.

When I first came to the UK many years ago I was SHOCKED at the level of poverty and deprivation I saw. I am am in the sunny south. There are of course problematic pockets in Denmark, but it's just not comparable. Not even a bit.

Itsbytheby · 06/04/2023 15:06

Oneiros · 06/04/2023 14:52

IQ - well no, you can't give someone higher IQ. But if you identify someone with low IQ struggling you can support the,, educate them, touch base on a regular basis, but them in support programs.
Drugs - there's loads of programs to help people come off drugs, but I assume they are not always easily accessible or people avoid them due to fear or stigma. Also, you can give people opportunities and education to avoid them getting involved in drugs in the first place.
Mental illness - treat it, clearly.

In general, social/ commuity support, education, opportunities to make money, easily accessible health case (including for drugs and mental health), these things - if invested in properly - could make a huge difference. Reducing poverty and deprivation in society generally.

Sigh. These people all have access to education just like everyone else. They do not want it. They spent 14 years of compulsory education wilfully not engaging with it. Social services and in this particular case domestic violence programmes had engaged with the mother and tried to support her. She had the Freedom Program twice then stopped attending and ignored what they'd taught her. No cure for low IQ as you admit. There is so much support for these people already. Benefits, their rent being paid, social workers, free education, free adult courses offered, support offered to help them find work or retrain, offer to pay almost all of their childcare if they work, charities offering support with life skills, free healthcare and on and on. You cannot teach psychopaths who prioritise men over their child, who hear their child screaming in the middle of the night and do nothing about it, who see them covered in bruises and do not care and actively cover it up rather than seeking medical attention, to be good parents. Nothing you have suggested is new. None of it would change anything, as we have seen by doing exactly what you suggest for decades.

Oh come off it - and no need to sigh in exasperation. We all know that access to those services aren't universally great in the UK but are much much more difficult to access in derpived areas of if from a deprived background.

And I am not talking about psychopaths. I've ackonwoledge that some people are just bad, there is likely to use helping them. But loads of people will not be inherently bad, but will become abusive due to the factors I have already mentioned makign them struggle with parenthood, and life in general.

I would be interested to know if the threshhold for removing children in Denmark is lower. I would suspect not. I would also be quite certain that a lot less children are removed because their parents have the social support, eduacation and health care that I mention. Those elements are priorited and the provision is good. Poverty and deprivation is also lot rarer than in the UK. For full disclosure I'll tell you I am Danish, so despite not knowing about this subject specifically I have a rather good insight into public policy there and how the welfare provision is prioritised.

Sugarfree23 · 06/04/2023 15:03

While I've heard that about Denmark having better outcomes for care children. And they focus on care homes rather than Foster carers.

I also wonder if Denmark has the level of deprivation, poverty, drugs, alcohol abuse, generation after generation who don't work, who are disengaged with social services.
People living in deprived areas with little work, and no hope of being able to pull themselves out of it.

The UK needs to do better for kids in the care system before raising the bar.
How often do you see FB posts looking for the same teens who are in care who've tried to go home. That tells you all you need to know for lots of these kid they'd rather be with mum than in care.