Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Great Dane now on the attack - please can we do something? *Distressing content warning*

341 replies

Stryke · 27/04/2023 10:17

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/boy-7-suffers-horror-injuries-29801234#amp-readmore-target

Boy, 7, suffers horror injuries after dog bites him in face and head at pet shop
WARNING - DISTRESSING CONTENT: Little Mitchell Neville was allegedly attacked by the shop owner's Great Dane after going to buy dog food in Belfast, Northern Ireland

YANBU - enough is enough, change the law

YABU - but chihuahuas are more aggressive

Boy, 7, suffers horror injuries after dog bites him in face and head at pet shop

WARNING - DISTRESSING CONTENT: Little Mitchell Neville was allegedly attacked by the shop owner's Great Dane after going to buy dog food in Belfast, Northern Ireland

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/boy-7-suffers-horror-injuries-29801234#amp-readmore-target

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Newnamefor23 · 27/04/2023 12:52

My Mum, 91, loves dogs. We have just about got her to ask before stroking a stranger’s dog. But she still forgets and hands a flutter comes in to pat its head.

I’ve told her no/pushed her hand aside as I’m quicker/better at reading a dog’s mind.

Now this is my Mum - an adult. Children shouldn’t be expected to know this - not fully.

Its up to all to prevent upset. Responsible owners, training/bringing up their dogs responsibly. And parents - keeping children away, particularly from unknown, dogs.

Thesharkradar · 27/04/2023 12:50

Any breed of dog could attack a human
A small dog you can easily overpower it, kick it off, kill it.
A large dog you've got no chance.
One could argue that a rat is as likely to attack as a bear, or a feral cat is as likely to attack as a puma. A small animal with a small jaw is much less of a problem.

It is disingenuous in the extreme to focus on on the propensity to attack whilst ignoring the ability to cause damage.

KimberleyClark · 27/04/2023 12:50

We were once in a tea shop in Cornwall with DB’s lab who was chilling under our table. We suddenly noticed a baby was crawling determinedly over the floor towards the dog, mum nowhere in sight. The baby had almost reached the dog, who was just thumping his tail slightly, hadn’t raised his head, and I was getting up, when mum finally appeared and scooped baby up. Could have been a very different outcome with a different dog.

SashaAlabaster · 27/04/2023 12:49

@CuriousMoo
He had a giant dog possibly twice the size of him clamping its jaw around his face! And is now possibly scarred for life.
If that's not the stuff of 7 year old nightmares Idk what is.

@Cheapcookies
There are about 14 different tail wags and only 2 of them mean a dog is genuinely happy, assuming the rest of the dog's body language is saying the same time. People need to stop focusing on the tail and look at other body language.

....EVERYONE who owns a dog or cares for them in any way should be able to.

@FixMyEyebrows
Someone I know has the dogs trust go into their school and teach children about being safe around dogs.
I'm not saying that this would have solved that issue but so many times I see body language being ignored or just not recognised.

....All of my children have been taught about what a dog (or other animal) is saying with their body and 'listen' to that way before they approach a dog. On holiday a few years back a dog owner forcibly held her dog in place so that they could stroke it. Everything in the dogs body language was screaming 'I don't want this' and yet the owner pushed it forwards saying 'you can stroke her, she's friendly'
My eldest was 14 at the time and said 'oh thank you but she doesn't look like she's interested right now' and walked away with her 12 year old sister and 6 year old brother. We talked about it afterwards and went through all the different signs the dog gave us from the minute we were walking past.

All very excellent points.

Hope the little boy soon recovers, and gets help in re-building his confidence around dogs. Poor chap. Must have been terrifying.

kitsuneghost · 27/04/2023 12:48

There is no need for any of this
Perhaps we need to address why people feel the need a non-human 'companion'
It is a weird mentally to keep another animal just for the fun of it.

Cheapcookies · 27/04/2023 12:48

Keeping pets is a hobby that you indulge yourself in for your own amusement.
Your hobby should not mean that in order to avoid harassment, intimidation, injury or death I have to educate myself on the body language of the creature that you decide to keep.

The parent of the child in the article has a dog. She should be able to read a dog.
Anyone that owns dogs should be able to read them. That was my point.

legalwotnot · 27/04/2023 12:45

CleverLilViper · 27/04/2023 11:49

Oh come off it.

it’s sad the child was hurt but the way you lot go on every time is as if it’s an epidemic.

teenagers stab each other. Should something be done about ALL teenagers because of the actions of a few?

there’s countless threads like this on this site all fearmongering and all I think is thank fuck I wasn’t raised by any of you or I’d be terrified of every dog going.

What a ridiculous comment. We made it illegal to carry knives to prevent stabbings. The equivalent with dogs would be to keep them on leads and muzzled. That should happen.

Thesharkradar · 27/04/2023 12:45

But there are about 14 different tail wags and only 2 of them mean a dog is genuinely happy, assuming the rest of the dog's body language is saying the same time. People need to stop focusing on the tail and look at other body language. Don't let your kid stroke dogs they don't know, or approach dogs they don't know, regardless of what the owner says (because 90% of people can't read their own dog)

Keeping pets is a hobby that you indulge yourself in for your own amusement.
Your hobby should not mean that in order to avoid harassment, intimidation, injury or death I have to educate myself on the body language of the creature that you decide to keep.
Keep your hobbies to yourself, don't let them encroach upon and cause damage to other people.

Nordicrain · 27/04/2023 12:43

KittyAlfred · 27/04/2023 12:42

Plenty of people are attacked by dogs that they weren’t petting, including my 6 year old son, just minding his own business in a park and hospitalised and scarred for life due to a random dog attack.

Telling people to teach their kids not to pet dogs is like telling women not to go out alone in the evening. Victim blaming.

Are you saying it’s OK to walk around with a dangerous dog because people should know not to come hear it?

No, I am saying that people still need to teach their dogs about approaching dogs safely. Toddlers approaching dogs unexpectedly is dangerous even if the dog is otherwise well behaved/ under control.

mamnotmum · 27/04/2023 12:43

It's scary. But change the law to what I wonder? Because any breed of dog could attack a human.

I had a Yorkie. Gorgeous. Unusual colour but small and so cute. She Hated other people though. Kids used to try and stroke the cute doggy and I'd warn them 'don't shell bite' occasionally she did bite because they insisted on stroking her after been told not to. She did no harm, just shocked them but it just highlights the importance of knowing your dog and asking a dog owners permission before stroking them.

KittyAlfred · 27/04/2023 12:42

Nordicrain · 27/04/2023 12:38

We have a dog ourselves and both my kids know (and have know since they were little) that you never pet a dog without asking the owner first. More dogs being around makes this even more important.

Plenty of people are attacked by dogs that they weren’t petting, including my 6 year old son, just minding his own business in a park and hospitalised and scarred for life due to a random dog attack.

Telling people to teach their kids not to pet dogs is like telling women not to go out alone in the evening. Victim blaming.

Are you saying it’s OK to walk around with a dangerous dog because people should know not to come hear it?

Nordicrain · 27/04/2023 12:42

Twisting · 27/04/2023 12:39

As a runner, it's just one more thing to think about.
Run the streets? Have to avoid cyclist and escooters on the pavement.

Run the canal path? Too many dealers the police are ignoring.
Run the woods? What do I do if Mr fluffy bollocks decides to chase after me? I know you say he wouldn't hurt a fly, but does he like to chase moving things? Keep it on a fucking lead if it's going for a walk. And not a massive long one that trips people up.

I do, of course, run all these places, but it would nice if I could do it without having to work out my strategies first.

I've had an alsation run at me and paw me whilst running. That scared the shit out of me.
I've had numerous small yappy things try to weave through my legs. What happens if I trip and break a bone? What happens if I fall and squash the dog?

I actually like dogs. I'd have one if work permitted. But their right to run free shouldn't supercede actual humans' rights to run free.

I am a runner and dog owner. I would never let my dog chase a runner. If it did I would not be offended if they got a kick.

legalwotnot · 27/04/2023 12:40

greenacrylicpaint · 27/04/2023 11:02

I have zero interest in learning to read a dog's body language, I just want them kept away from me and my children. I find it crazy that as a society we're constantly putting the "rights" of people to own massive dogs without any regulation or oversight above our children's right to go about their lives without being attacked or killed.

absolutely this.
I don't hate dogs for thinking this. I can admire them from afar. but this humanisation of pet animals has to stop. it's ridiculous.

Agree. Dogs should be muzzled and on leads in public.

Twisting · 27/04/2023 12:39

Runaway0 · 27/04/2023 12:19

I was mouthed by a dog while out running I shouted no get off still wouldn't get off so I kicked it. The owner said I was injuring their dog wtf if a grown human started biting me randomly I'd do the same it's self defence. Some dog owners are nuts 😳 . I hope the covid dog boom ends soon and it returns back to normal so many shit owners there.

As a runner, it's just one more thing to think about.
Run the streets? Have to avoid cyclist and escooters on the pavement.

Run the canal path? Too many dealers the police are ignoring.
Run the woods? What do I do if Mr fluffy bollocks decides to chase after me? I know you say he wouldn't hurt a fly, but does he like to chase moving things? Keep it on a fucking lead if it's going for a walk. And not a massive long one that trips people up.

I do, of course, run all these places, but it would nice if I could do it without having to work out my strategies first.

I've had an alsation run at me and paw me whilst running. That scared the shit out of me.
I've had numerous small yappy things try to weave through my legs. What happens if I trip and break a bone? What happens if I fall and squash the dog?

I actually like dogs. I'd have one if work permitted. But their right to run free shouldn't supercede actual humans' rights to run free.

Nordicrain · 27/04/2023 12:38

KittyAlfred · 27/04/2023 12:35

You see this was OK in the days when there weren’t so many dogs around. You could teach kids that something they saw now and then, in the park, was not a toy. Now they’re everywhere. It’s normalised. There’ll be a dog by the next table in a restaurant. A dog walking past them in a supermarket aisle. A dog on the adjacent seat on a bus. A dog by the swings. A dog in the pub garden. A dog in the museum, soft play, school pick up. They are everywhere, making it much harder to tell kids that these things, which they can’t actually avoid, are potentially dangerous and need to be avoided. We already tell kids to stay on the pavement because of the risk from cars, but what happens when half the people on the pavement walking towards them have a dog?

We have a dog ourselves and both my kids know (and have know since they were little) that you never pet a dog without asking the owner first. More dogs being around makes this even more important.

Boughtitdownthemarket · 27/04/2023 12:38

There are just too many dogs everywhere now. My neighbour has two small toddlers and two massive mongrels. She seems to know what she's doing but I would never take that risk with children. Animals just can't be trusted.

Cheapcookies · 27/04/2023 12:38

Or just leave your dog at home

We were on holiday and the pub had a great big sign saying dogs welcome. We also sat outside. My dog was on a lead asleep under our table. His dogs were walking around untethered. Did you miss the part where I was concerned about my DD?

Nordicrain · 27/04/2023 12:37

QuintanaRoo · 27/04/2023 12:32

Change the law to what?

banning big dogs?

muzzling all dogs?

This is what I was going to ask.

It's unusual to hear about a Great Dane attacking someone though.

Astrabees · 27/04/2023 12:36

Nice to see a thread for the anti dog brigade. Business owners with cafes and hotels are having a hard enough time already, if dogs were banned many would go out of business.

KittyAlfred · 27/04/2023 12:35

MissyB1 · 27/04/2023 11:59

The general public don’t need to be dog experts - they do however need to teach their kids not to touch/pat others people’s dogs. They also need to very closely supervise their kids around any animals. Dogs are not toys.

You see this was OK in the days when there weren’t so many dogs around. You could teach kids that something they saw now and then, in the park, was not a toy. Now they’re everywhere. It’s normalised. There’ll be a dog by the next table in a restaurant. A dog walking past them in a supermarket aisle. A dog on the adjacent seat on a bus. A dog by the swings. A dog in the pub garden. A dog in the museum, soft play, school pick up. They are everywhere, making it much harder to tell kids that these things, which they can’t actually avoid, are potentially dangerous and need to be avoided. We already tell kids to stay on the pavement because of the risk from cars, but what happens when half the people on the pavement walking towards them have a dog?

Redebs · 27/04/2023 12:34

Cheapcookies · 27/04/2023 10:28

This line from the article:
"One minute she said he was patting the dog and the dog’s tail was wagging and the next, the dog had Mitchell’s head in its jaws."

She also mentions they looked away from the dog & child to look in a freezer.

I am not making excuses for what happened.

But there are about 14 different tail wags and only 2 of them mean a dog is genuinely happy, assuming the rest of the dog's body language is saying the same time. People need to stop focusing on the tail and look at other body language. Don't let your kid stroke dogs they don't know, or approach dogs they don't know, regardless of what the owner says (because 90% of people can't read their own dog).

I feel really terrible for the child that this happened.

It really shocks me how many dog owners are completely unable to read their own dogs. We were on holiday once and in a pub. The owner (of the pub) was telling everyone about his wonderful serbian rescues that were now pub dogs. Both appeared. The MOMENT they looked at my toddler DD (walking about) I told DH (next to her) to pick her up. Everything about their body language said "not happy" and they went straight in to very hard staring, which is just a few steps away from snapping/potentially biting. The second one did the same thing to my dog once he looked at him.
I told the landlord that his dogs were not suitable to roam free in a pub and we promptly left.

Not enough people have any idea how to read dogs. Equally, there needs to be changes to laws around dog control, and how easy it is to have & own dogs.

Or just leave your dog at home

Quveas · 27/04/2023 12:33

Dogs are animals, they’re not humans

I don't believe in treating dogs like children or people. They are dogs. But humans are animals too! We are arrogant enough to think that our supposed intelligence makes us better than other animals.

There are approximately 13 million dogs in the UK, and approximately 22,000 reports of out of control dogs per year - that is 0.17%. If you talk about deaths, it is 0.00002308%. There are 34 million men in the UK and approximately 1.5 million domestic violence attacks each year, mostly on women - that's 4.41%, and that is only domestic violence alone not including all violence, most of which is perpetrated by men. Theer are, on average 235 women killed by men every year - that is 0.00069118%. Men are far more dangerous than dogs. 0.16% of chidren are estimated to be abused by their parents / a close family member every year. Families are very dangerous for children.

Knee jerk reactions to isolated incidents do not make good law or policy on anything.

QuintanaRoo · 27/04/2023 12:32

Change the law to what?

banning big dogs?

muzzling all dogs?

Runaway0 · 27/04/2023 12:30

takealettermsjones · 27/04/2023 12:22

Similarly, a dog went for my daughter once and I kicked it. I then had the police at my door because the owner called them. I explained the situation (which the owner hadn't denied, by the way) and the police were actually great, but the owner still thought I should be prosecuted for kicking his dog even though he knew and freely admitted the dog had lunged for my one year old.

That is actually crazy of course a human would step in and protect a baby against a dog. We are supposed to just sit back and let the dog keep attacking. The law is quite clear it's legal to protect yourself and loved ones. It's poor owners who see the dog as a pseudo human.

Eckyftang · 27/04/2023 12:28

Stryke · 27/04/2023 10:17

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/boy-7-suffers-horror-injuries-29801234#amp-readmore-target

Boy, 7, suffers horror injuries after dog bites him in face and head at pet shop
WARNING - DISTRESSING CONTENT: Little Mitchell Neville was allegedly attacked by the shop owner's Great Dane after going to buy dog food in Belfast, Northern Ireland

YANBU - enough is enough, change the law

YABU - but chihuahuas are more aggressive

You said this needs to stop... have you done anything proactive other than asking MN about it?

Swipe left for the next trending thread