Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Great Dane now on the attack - please can we do something? *Distressing content warning*

341 replies

Stryke · 27/04/2023 10:17

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/boy-7-suffers-horror-injuries-29801234#amp-readmore-target

Boy, 7, suffers horror injuries after dog bites him in face and head at pet shop
WARNING - DISTRESSING CONTENT: Little Mitchell Neville was allegedly attacked by the shop owner's Great Dane after going to buy dog food in Belfast, Northern Ireland

YANBU - enough is enough, change the law

YABU - but chihuahuas are more aggressive

Boy, 7, suffers horror injuries after dog bites him in face and head at pet shop

WARNING - DISTRESSING CONTENT: Little Mitchell Neville was allegedly attacked by the shop owner's Great Dane after going to buy dog food in Belfast, Northern Ireland

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/boy-7-suffers-horror-injuries-29801234#amp-readmore-target

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Nordicrain · 27/04/2023 13:17

KittyAlfred · 27/04/2023 13:02

I was saying it’s harder to teach kids to avoid dogs now than it used to be, because they’re everywhere. Bit like telling them to avoid stepping on the cracks in the pavement when you live in a city.

I’m not sure why you find this hard to understand, and why you feel a need for an eye-roll emoji.

As I said, we tell our kids not to walk on the road because of cars, so they walk on the pavement. Then we tell them to stay away from dogs, who are on the pavement. So where do they go? Maybe you think the kids should stay at home so the dogs can freely go out to cafes and playgrounds!

And don’t give me this rubbish about teaching them not to pet dogs being the thing to do. It’s evident from multiple posts on here that it’s often the dogs initiating the contact, which usually involves their teeth.

As I said, it’s victim blaming.

Because you are accusing me of victim blaming when I am not.

Teaching safety is important. Taht doesn't eliminate all risk. To use your car example - we teach kids to be careful crossing the road. That doesn't mean that drivers don't have to be careful and look of for kids. But of course we would blame a driver less for an accident where they were driving carefully and a child darted into the road. The same is the case for dogs. Obviously the situation is different where a child is bitten just walking along minding their own business vs grabbing a sleeping dog by the tale when they've been warned by the owner not to touch it. It doesn't absolve the owner of being responsible but it is a different situation.

And by the way, cars are much more dangerous for children than dogs are.

Srin · 27/04/2023 13:17

Dogs do bite for all sorts of reasons, it is what dogs do. Pretending that dogs can be trained not to, and that people can ‘read’ them accurately is definitely part of the problem. A lot of dog owners seem to believe that their dogs think like human, when research suggests that this is far from the truth.

RandomGeocache · 27/04/2023 13:16

People need to stop focusing on the tail and look at other body language. Don't let your kid stroke dogs they don't know, or approach dogs they don't know, regardless of what the owner says

Agree with the second part of this. My kids were always told that if they wished to approach or stroke a dog, to ask the owner first.

But I very much disagree with the second part, which is victim blaming. I have zero interest in finding out about dog body language. I don't have a dog, I don't want a dog. It is the OWNER'S responsibility to take steps to make sure that their dog is not in the position to be able to attack/bite me, not my responsibility to learn all about body language.

DarkDarkNight · 27/04/2023 13:15

It must have been awful for him, poor thing. It will probably give him a lifelong fear. Any dog can potentially harm but I’m more bothered about a law against dogs like American XL Bully type dogs and other similar breeds. Why anybody is happy to have a dog like that around their kids is beyond me.

I think rescue centres need looked at to be honest. Too many stories of these stories in the last few years where the dog has very recently been brought in to the family. I know sometimes that might be through Facebook ads and things but a few times it has been rescue dogs. There was a case recently where a woman was attacked by a dog she had very recently rescued, she wasn’t told of its history and even when she contacted them to say the dog had tried to bite her they didn’t remove it. Some dogs aren’t suitable to be re-homed especially with people who aren’t properly trained and not even aware of the dog’s history.

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/woman-mauled-rescue-dog-loses-29760364.amp

Woman loses arm as she's mauled by rescue dog to sue RSPCA 'who didn't warn her'

Joanna Harris, 49, has told how a one-year-old American bulldog she was fostering from the RSPCA attacked her leading to such severe injuries that she needed to have her arm amputated

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/woman-mauled-rescue-dog-loses-29760364.amp

IAmAlreadyRegrettingMyGreyColourScheme · 27/04/2023 13:10

IVFNewbie · 27/04/2023 10:21

although it looks bad, I wouldn't describe it as 'horror' injuries. Mind you , I do think we need a law re. dogs now. I don't know how it would work though. Ban certain breeds without a muzzle?

Anyone questioning this poor boys injuries only needs to click on the link.
Those are some huge holes under the dressings. Poor boy.

VickyEadieofThigh · 27/04/2023 13:10

I'd be happier if those dog owners who let their dogs off leash in open spaces actually obeyed the signs that say "Dogs must be on leash at all times". Many seem to think there's a hidden bit of the sign that only they can see which says "EXCEPT YOU!"

We've had various incidents over the years when walking one of our dogs (we only ever have one at once!) in various parks,where the leash rule is clearly stated all over the place (especially AT THE ENTRANCE) and people allow theirs to gallop about. This includes the grounds of a local stately home in which deer are roaming.

OrlandointheWilderness · 27/04/2023 13:08

Personally speaking @legalwotnot as a mother I'm not about to leave my child with a potential danger in the hope the owner has the situation covered! A child doesn't have a right to stroke any dog they want, and common sense needs to be in place. Completely agree that the dogs owner should always be supervising the interaction, but so should the parent.
I own dogs - I would never turn my back on them and leave them being stroked by a child.
I have a daughter - I would never leave her stroking a dog without watching she is safe.

Goes two ways.

Thesharkradar · 27/04/2023 13:06

Maybe you think the kids should stay at home so the dogs can freely go out to cafes and playgrounds!
Yep she totally does think that!
They think their 'fur baby' comes before human children, the reason dog owners are so keen to let the dog in the children's playground is they think it's not fair that their fur baby can't use the same equipment that the human children do.

takealettermsjones · 27/04/2023 13:04

OrlandointheWilderness · 27/04/2023 12:59

@takealettermsjones Great Danes are generally very soft, nice natured dogs.

I don't doubt it. But their capacity to injure if they should turn is much greater, because of their size and strength.

I hear black bears are normally quite placid creatures, too. 😉

LaughingCat · 27/04/2023 13:02

I don’t think mass muzzling is the answer but at the same time I do think licensing should be brought back. There will always be dickheads who ignore it, just like there are dickheads who drive cars without a licence, but they will be far fewer. In return, we’ll see the vast majority of people who own dogs actually learning how to handle them. While it won’t stop dog attacks entirely, it should reduce them.

KittyAlfred · 27/04/2023 13:02

Nordicrain · 27/04/2023 12:54

🙄

I am not saying it's the answer. I was responding on to the poster (was it you) saying there was not point in teaching kids about dog safety because there are dogs everywhere. Dog owners need to be responsible for their dogs. Parents need to teach their children to be safe to minimise risk of harm (with dogs and in general).

I was saying it’s harder to teach kids to avoid dogs now than it used to be, because they’re everywhere. Bit like telling them to avoid stepping on the cracks in the pavement when you live in a city.

I’m not sure why you find this hard to understand, and why you feel a need for an eye-roll emoji.

As I said, we tell our kids not to walk on the road because of cars, so they walk on the pavement. Then we tell them to stay away from dogs, who are on the pavement. So where do they go? Maybe you think the kids should stay at home so the dogs can freely go out to cafes and playgrounds!

And don’t give me this rubbish about teaching them not to pet dogs being the thing to do. It’s evident from multiple posts on here that it’s often the dogs initiating the contact, which usually involves their teeth.

As I said, it’s victim blaming.

legalwotnot · 27/04/2023 13:01

OrlandointheWilderness · 27/04/2023 12:58

The only thing absolutely wrong in this situation is why on earth was the child left unattended with the dog. People have GOT to start taking responsibility- a dog is not a human, and putting expectations that it will not carry out a natural behaviour is unfair to the dog and the child. Children (and a lot of adults!) cannot recognise the information a dog is giving off, they are incredibly expressive with their body language but often the first point someone will notice they aren't happy is a growl or bite, having missed the plethora of indicators given off before it.

Or, why was the dog left unattended with a child.

The dog's owner is the responsible party here. If a dog can be dangerous, which even dog lovers here are acknowledging, then if you choose to have a dog, you need to be absolutely 100% responsible for it not attacking anyone.

You can't own something dangerous, whether a dog or a gun, and then blame a child for being hurt by it. It is always the owner's responsibility.

Thesharkradar · 27/04/2023 13:00

We are arrogant enough to think that our supposed intelligence makes us better than other animals
Human intelligence means that we are able to make moral choices, that's the difference.

funinthesun19 · 27/04/2023 13:00

Mind you, even then people still minimise it.

OrlandointheWilderness · 27/04/2023 12:59

@takealettermsjones Great Danes are generally very soft, nice natured dogs.

funinthesun19 · 27/04/2023 12:59

IVFNewbie · 27/04/2023 10:21

although it looks bad, I wouldn't describe it as 'horror' injuries. Mind you , I do think we need a law re. dogs now. I don't know how it would work though. Ban certain breeds without a muzzle?

Of course it’s horrifying. A child was bit in the face and it should be happening at all. Any bite is horrifying.

Does it only become horrifying if the child dies?

Thesharkradar · 27/04/2023 12:58

The answer is to legislate against dogs roaming around everywhere, and for people to stop having dogs that they can’t control, and bringing them to places where they don’t belong
Agree, it's become the norm/the done thing to let your dog roam about as it pleases off the lead, mostly this is dog owners following the herd and doing what other dog owners do.
This means that outdoor spaces are dominated by dogs and the people whose lives revolve around their dogs, and ruined for the rest of us.
I wish there were dog-free areas but at the very least we need to reverse this trend whereby off-lead is the default for dogs.

OrlandointheWilderness · 27/04/2023 12:58

The only thing absolutely wrong in this situation is why on earth was the child left unattended with the dog. People have GOT to start taking responsibility- a dog is not a human, and putting expectations that it will not carry out a natural behaviour is unfair to the dog and the child. Children (and a lot of adults!) cannot recognise the information a dog is giving off, they are incredibly expressive with their body language but often the first point someone will notice they aren't happy is a growl or bite, having missed the plethora of indicators given off before it.

whyhere · 27/04/2023 12:57

Quveas · 27/04/2023 12:33

Dogs are animals, they’re not humans

I don't believe in treating dogs like children or people. They are dogs. But humans are animals too! We are arrogant enough to think that our supposed intelligence makes us better than other animals.

There are approximately 13 million dogs in the UK, and approximately 22,000 reports of out of control dogs per year - that is 0.17%. If you talk about deaths, it is 0.00002308%. There are 34 million men in the UK and approximately 1.5 million domestic violence attacks each year, mostly on women - that's 4.41%, and that is only domestic violence alone not including all violence, most of which is perpetrated by men. Theer are, on average 235 women killed by men every year - that is 0.00069118%. Men are far more dangerous than dogs. 0.16% of chidren are estimated to be abused by their parents / a close family member every year. Families are very dangerous for children.

Knee jerk reactions to isolated incidents do not make good law or policy on anything.

This ^

Curtains70 · 27/04/2023 12:56

I don't have strong feelings either way really but dogs have always bitten. I remember my brother being bitten as a child. I think the issue comes when people are being killed by dogs. This really isn't the same thing.

mamnotmum · 27/04/2023 12:56

Thesharkradar · 27/04/2023 12:50

Any breed of dog could attack a human
A small dog you can easily overpower it, kick it off, kill it.
A large dog you've got no chance.
One could argue that a rat is as likely to attack as a bear, or a feral cat is as likely to attack as a puma. A small animal with a small jaw is much less of a problem.

It is disingenuous in the extreme to focus on on the propensity to attack whilst ignoring the ability to cause damage.

Indeed a small dog. But even a medium dog would be difficult to overpower. Particularly for a child. And therefore I questioned where you draw the line on which dogs are acceptable and which are not.

Although I see the argument for muzzles I just can't see how it would be enforced. It's illegal not to pick up your dogs poo but there's still an awful lot of dog poo about. Police absolutely would not have the time to start dealing with complaints about dogs without muzzles.

Keeping dogs on a short lead all the time isn't allowing them to run and play - perhaps if we had more designated off lead spaces this would be more feasible.

Nordicrain · 27/04/2023 12:54

KittyAlfred · 27/04/2023 12:52

Well I taught my kids about not approaching dogs and a dog just came and took a chunk out my child’s arm anyway. So I don’t understand why you think educating kids is the answer.
The answer is to legislate against dogs roaming around everywhere, and for people to stop having dogs that they can’t control, and bringing them to places where they don’t belong.

I’ve never approached a dog in my life but they still run at me every fucking time I go for a run.

🙄

I am not saying it's the answer. I was responding on to the poster (was it you) saying there was not point in teaching kids about dog safety because there are dogs everywhere. Dog owners need to be responsible for their dogs. Parents need to teach their children to be safe to minimise risk of harm (with dogs and in general).

skitt · 27/04/2023 12:53

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 27/04/2023 10:43

All dogs should be muzzled outside their home and in every public space. It doesn’t matter if you are a super vicious chi, or the worlds most laid back mastiff, if you are muzzled, you can’t bite.

This was the rule in the part of France I lived in. The local police enforced it in the Sunday market etc. It made for a much more pleasant and safer environment l

I've lived in France for over 20 years and never seen this. Where were you?

legalwotnot · 27/04/2023 12:52

MissyB1 · 27/04/2023 11:59

The general public don’t need to be dog experts - they do however need to teach their kids not to touch/pat others people’s dogs. They also need to very closely supervise their kids around any animals. Dogs are not toys.

Look, having had young children, my experience was that dogs keep coming up/ chasing or snarling and snapping at my children. My eldest's hand was bitten by a dog. And, in most instances, useless owners didn't bother to retrieve their dogs. I was in a group recently where a man with two labs had bought leads saying ' friendly dog' (which he held whilst his dog ran free) that was his 'solution' to the problem of his dog recently chasing small children.

My kids had no interest in going near anyone's dogs after becoming scared of them from those incidents. It didn't stop dogs from approaching them though. Or stop dog owners from being, in the main, utterly fucking useless at controlling their dogs. Largely because they seemed to have no interest in controlling the dogs.

KittyAlfred · 27/04/2023 12:52

Nordicrain · 27/04/2023 12:43

No, I am saying that people still need to teach their dogs about approaching dogs safely. Toddlers approaching dogs unexpectedly is dangerous even if the dog is otherwise well behaved/ under control.

Well I taught my kids about not approaching dogs and a dog just came and took a chunk out my child’s arm anyway. So I don’t understand why you think educating kids is the answer.
The answer is to legislate against dogs roaming around everywhere, and for people to stop having dogs that they can’t control, and bringing them to places where they don’t belong.

I’ve never approached a dog in my life but they still run at me every fucking time I go for a run.