Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Great Dane now on the attack - please can we do something? *Distressing content warning*

341 replies

Stryke · 27/04/2023 10:17

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/boy-7-suffers-horror-injuries-29801234#amp-readmore-target

Boy, 7, suffers horror injuries after dog bites him in face and head at pet shop
WARNING - DISTRESSING CONTENT: Little Mitchell Neville was allegedly attacked by the shop owner's Great Dane after going to buy dog food in Belfast, Northern Ireland

YANBU - enough is enough, change the law

YABU - but chihuahuas are more aggressive

Boy, 7, suffers horror injuries after dog bites him in face and head at pet shop

WARNING - DISTRESSING CONTENT: Little Mitchell Neville was allegedly attacked by the shop owner's Great Dane after going to buy dog food in Belfast, Northern Ireland

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/boy-7-suffers-horror-injuries-29801234#amp-readmore-target

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Nordicrain · 27/04/2023 13:45

Thesharkradar · 27/04/2023 13:25

It's true that cars are responsible for more deaths than dogs are by a long chalk, however we take extensive measures to mitigate the risks, and without motor vehicles how would we transport people and goods?
Keeping a dog is a hobby, a thing that you do for your own personal amusement, a way of indulging yourself, if your hobby is a menace, causes a nuisance, may result in serious injury or death to others then it needs to be heavily regulated. You should not be able to let your potentially dangerous animal roam about freely and the rest of us just have to put up with it🤬

Chill out with the angry face. Jeez.

Noone on here is, as far as I can see, arguing to let angry dogs roam free. What they are saying is that not all dogs need to be muzzled and locked away.

Groggygymdodger · 27/04/2023 13:45

This is very unusual for a Great Dane and the article states there is an investigation , which could indicate rhe little boy did something to make the dog react, it was extremely foolish of both the owner and the parent to leave them alone unwatched.

YouTarzan · 27/04/2023 13:45

Fair enough, hadn't seen all the pics!

3BSHKATS · 27/04/2023 13:45

I absolutely was not appologising for the dog by suggesting lack of exercise btw. But I do think all factors need consideration if this is to be avoided. What can be done differently going forward.

katyperryseyelid · 27/04/2023 13:44

Acheybreakyhead · 27/04/2023 10:25

This is only going to get more common as more and more places let dogs in and people continue to not treat their dogs as dogs.

The amount of people you are treating dogs like they are children is astounding.

I know a couple of people who treat dogs as if they are human, with human feelings.

Thats really bloody confusing for a dog. They need to be treated like animals, not humans.

But there are people who don’t bother to learn about the breed they have, dog behaviour, signs of stress, on and on and on.

Instead, well meaning people buy a dog, treat it like a child and wonder why it’s unstable and unhappy.

Oysterbabe · 27/04/2023 13:43

Hopefully that dog will be destroyed shortly.

A friend took on a dog recently. It was being rehomed as the family had a new baby and it was showing 'guarding behaviour'. She doesn't have children herself but regularly has visits from friends and family that do. It became immediately apparent that the dog is aggressive to small children and now she's posting on FB trying to rehome it again. I came under a lot of criticism for suggesting that the dog should not be rehomed at all.
In my opinion once a dog is aggressive to humans it should be PTS immediately.

Runrowchill · 27/04/2023 13:43

In the last 3 weeks I’ve had the following experiences : been jumped at by a large dog while running - I felt it’s claws on my neck , seen my friend leave her puppy on a sofa in a restaurant , seen dogs running free and paddling in nature ponds in a nature reserve with signs up asking they stay on lead (due to ground nesting birds which I could hear) and out of the ponds , seen a deer run across the path in front of me being chased by two dogs while the owner called their names ineffectively. The simple solution to most of it is that dogs stay on lead in public places

kitsuneghost · 27/04/2023 13:43

YouTarzan · 27/04/2023 13:28

That child’s got nothing more than a couple of scratches, to call them ‘horror injuries’ is ridiculous.

If a man came up to you in the street and gave you a few scratches with a knife would you still just dismiss it as easily

SnackSizeRaisin · 27/04/2023 13:42

takealettermsjones · 27/04/2023 10:51

Ridiculous for anyone to own a Great Dane imo, even more ridiculous to parade it around in a shop.

It's disheartening reading about these attacks again and again, and then seeing the inevitable comments:

• It's all about the owner/training
• Children should be taught not to approach
• People need to learn to read a dog's body language

While all of those things may be true to some extent, they are not the most important thing here. The glaringly obvious point is that people are clearly NOT reading dogs well, children ARE approaching, and the owners are either crap or not bothering to train at all. So in that context, something else needs to be done!

I have zero interest in learning to read a dog's body language, I just want them kept away from me and my children. I find it crazy that as a society we're constantly putting the "rights" of people to own massive dogs without any regulation or oversight above our children's right to go about their lives without being attacked or killed.

Yes. Dogs should be kept under control by their owners. It's not up to children (or their parents) to read the dog's body language.

Great Danes are huge and often aggressive. If somebody wants to own one they should not let it loose in a shop.

CandlelightGlow · 27/04/2023 13:39

@YouTarzan Wtf, have you seen the picture without the bandages on?

ThisSingleMama · 27/04/2023 13:39

I have dogs as colleagues ( yes really)

We work together, but they are not to be stroked/petted. They are working dogs.

Even so, I worry when they have to sniff young kids/babies. You just never know.

Thesharkradar · 27/04/2023 13:37

YouTarzan · 27/04/2023 13:28

That child’s got nothing more than a couple of scratches, to call them ‘horror injuries’ is ridiculous.

You should be ashamed of yourself for minimizing that poor child's injuries

adularia · 27/04/2023 13:36

takealettermsjones · 27/04/2023 10:51

Ridiculous for anyone to own a Great Dane imo, even more ridiculous to parade it around in a shop.

It's disheartening reading about these attacks again and again, and then seeing the inevitable comments:

• It's all about the owner/training
• Children should be taught not to approach
• People need to learn to read a dog's body language

While all of those things may be true to some extent, they are not the most important thing here. The glaringly obvious point is that people are clearly NOT reading dogs well, children ARE approaching, and the owners are either crap or not bothering to train at all. So in that context, something else needs to be done!

I have zero interest in learning to read a dog's body language, I just want them kept away from me and my children. I find it crazy that as a society we're constantly putting the "rights" of people to own massive dogs without any regulation or oversight above our children's right to go about their lives without being attacked or killed.

This, especially the last paragraph.

There’s a park near here where dogs are supposed to be kept on leads, but they rarely are. When my DD was a baby we had dogs jumping up on her pram which really scared me, and then when she was a toddler they ran up and jumped up at her a couple of times, almost knocking her over - she was petrified of dogs for a while due to this. Dogs need to be muzzled as there are too many irresponsible owners.

CandlelightGlow · 27/04/2023 13:36

takealettermsjones · 27/04/2023 10:51

Ridiculous for anyone to own a Great Dane imo, even more ridiculous to parade it around in a shop.

It's disheartening reading about these attacks again and again, and then seeing the inevitable comments:

• It's all about the owner/training
• Children should be taught not to approach
• People need to learn to read a dog's body language

While all of those things may be true to some extent, they are not the most important thing here. The glaringly obvious point is that people are clearly NOT reading dogs well, children ARE approaching, and the owners are either crap or not bothering to train at all. So in that context, something else needs to be done!

I have zero interest in learning to read a dog's body language, I just want them kept away from me and my children. I find it crazy that as a society we're constantly putting the "rights" of people to own massive dogs without any regulation or oversight above our children's right to go about their lives without being attacked or killed.

I do agree with this.

I understand and agree with dog owners needing to understand their own dog's body language but we cannot rely on this as a solution to these problems.

I grew up with dogs and really like dogs (I'm more of a cat person and small pet person though tbh) but I don't have a dog because I have DC and I don't want them at risk.

I am growing more and more fearful of other peoples' dogs. The expectation shouldn't be on the general public who may have no interest at all in dogs, and children who cannot be expected to understand animal body language, it should be on owners.

I'm an animal lover and it does pain me to switch my side of the fence from "it's an owner problem" to "it's also a dog problem".

Stryke · 27/04/2023 13:34

Porkandbeans1 · 27/04/2023 13:32

Imo, if a dog can bite, it shouldn't be in public. If people want to take the risk with their own children within their homes, I feel very sorry for those children.

Any dog can bite. My DC loved growing up with a dog and it taught them so much. What a silly blanket statement.

What did it teach them?!

How do children who grow up without dogs kesr whatever it is that your dog taught yours, manage in life without learning such skills?

OP posts:
Irequireausername · 27/04/2023 13:33

Maybe society should stop pushing the idea that dogs are perfect for young families. They're animals and people should start understanding what that actually means.

Stryke · 27/04/2023 13:33

YouTarzan · 27/04/2023 13:28

That child’s got nothing more than a couple of scratches, to call them ‘horror injuries’ is ridiculous.

Really??? Scratches?!

OP posts:
Porkandbeans1 · 27/04/2023 13:32

Imo, if a dog can bite, it shouldn't be in public. If people want to take the risk with their own children within their homes, I feel very sorry for those children.

Any dog can bite. My DC loved growing up with a dog and it taught them so much. What a silly blanket statement.

YouJustDoYou · 27/04/2023 13:31

No dog can ever, ever be fully trusted. And yes, that includes your little darling who wouldn't hurt a fly. you never know.

Stryke · 27/04/2023 13:29

Sorry I posted then disappeared, thought I had time then something came up.

Appalled as usual by the dog apologists onbere, those saying it's hardly a horror bite, or that the child/mother were a fault.

Imo, if a dog can bite, it shouldn't be in public. If people want to take the risk with their own children within their homes, I feel very sorry for those children.

I dont think dogs should be in shops, cafes or any such place. I absolutely love going to theme parks and my local sports club as dogs are banned.

I wish people would stop attributing human characteristics to pets. They don't think like us. They don't have morals. They have sharp teeth and can't be trusted not to use them on us. We are meat, after all.

As got stopping looking for horror stories about dogs, I didn't go looking, it's a regular occurrence, so if you want to stop these things happening, we need to stop people having risky breeds, stop dogs being everywhere in public, muzzle when out. You might be happy in blissful ignorance, but I'd rather my kids grow up safely.

OP posts:
YouTarzan · 27/04/2023 13:28

That child’s got nothing more than a couple of scratches, to call them ‘horror injuries’ is ridiculous.

Thesharkradar · 27/04/2023 13:25

It's true that cars are responsible for more deaths than dogs are by a long chalk, however we take extensive measures to mitigate the risks, and without motor vehicles how would we transport people and goods?
Keeping a dog is a hobby, a thing that you do for your own personal amusement, a way of indulging yourself, if your hobby is a menace, causes a nuisance, may result in serious injury or death to others then it needs to be heavily regulated. You should not be able to let your potentially dangerous animal roam about freely and the rest of us just have to put up with it🤬

cheekyffer · 27/04/2023 13:19

I was going to make both of these points.

"@fourelementary lementary · Today 10:30
Not pleasant but I don’t think a Great Dane attack is anywhere near as savage as the Pitt/mastiff/bull type of attacks that kill…"

"@Cheapcookies ookies · Today 10:28
It really shocks me how many dog owners are completely unable to read their own dogs."

It is a horrible attack and terrible for the poor little boy, but luckily nowhere close to the type of mauling from a dog-type like the pitbull/XL Bully with a fighting pedigree. The breed that urgently needs to be banned is the XL Bully as they are responsible for multiple deaths and related to pitbulls. A question is whether it was a genuine Great Dane, in which case the attack would be unusual, or one of the mixes - Great Danebulls are a mix with a bull breed. There really needs to be more awareness that dogs with a fighting pedigree can cause severe damage and have a high prey drive. Herders will herd, retrievers will retrieve, etc. A breed that historically will fight to the death and is capable of killing a bull can obviously do serious damage.

Am regularly horrified by the inability of people to read their dog's signals. We don't let our DC play at a friend's house where they have a very large dog which is clearly anxious and aggressive, but they insist is 'mad/playful'. Also 'cute pictures' of young kids with large dogs giving the whale eye.

Thesharkradar · 27/04/2023 13:18

I feel extremely sorry for poor Joanna Harris, but at the same time don't you have to be a bit stupid to think that an animal capable of dismembering an adult human would make a good pet?
I hope she successfully sues and I hope the negative publicity makes the RSPCA reform its practices

Nordicrain · 27/04/2023 13:18

RandomGeocache · 27/04/2023 13:16

People need to stop focusing on the tail and look at other body language. Don't let your kid stroke dogs they don't know, or approach dogs they don't know, regardless of what the owner says

Agree with the second part of this. My kids were always told that if they wished to approach or stroke a dog, to ask the owner first.

But I very much disagree with the second part, which is victim blaming. I have zero interest in finding out about dog body language. I don't have a dog, I don't want a dog. It is the OWNER'S responsibility to take steps to make sure that their dog is not in the position to be able to attack/bite me, not my responsibility to learn all about body language.

Or just stay away from the dog, then you don't need to worry (clearly the owner needs to keep the dog away from people too).