Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Great Dane now on the attack - please can we do something? *Distressing content warning*

341 replies

Stryke · 27/04/2023 10:17

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/boy-7-suffers-horror-injuries-29801234#amp-readmore-target

Boy, 7, suffers horror injuries after dog bites him in face and head at pet shop
WARNING - DISTRESSING CONTENT: Little Mitchell Neville was allegedly attacked by the shop owner's Great Dane after going to buy dog food in Belfast, Northern Ireland

YANBU - enough is enough, change the law

YABU - but chihuahuas are more aggressive

Boy, 7, suffers horror injuries after dog bites him in face and head at pet shop

WARNING - DISTRESSING CONTENT: Little Mitchell Neville was allegedly attacked by the shop owner's Great Dane after going to buy dog food in Belfast, Northern Ireland

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/boy-7-suffers-horror-injuries-29801234#amp-readmore-target

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Missingmyusername · 28/04/2023 07:19

“I came under a lot of criticism for suggesting that the dog should not be rehomed at all.
In my opinion once a dog is aggressive to humans it should be PTS immediately”

I’m not surprised you came under fire for your uneducated comment. Guarding behaviour can be managed, many rescues rehome dogs with it. Sometimes it’s humans that have caused the guarding by being abusive to the animal. Of course, common sense is needed (lacking in mn world) and the dog should not be rehomed with children.

OfTheNight · 28/04/2023 07:18

I’ve got two Labs. One is 11 and has been a therapy dog at the local children’s hospice. One is a puppy who will also attend therapy dog training.

I love dogs. My 9 year old DS loves dogs. We are a dog family.

Things I would love to see happen:

  1. Heavy criminal penalties for dog owners. If your dog injures someone - you should get jail time. Watch how quickly that would solve the lackadaisical attitude some owners have.

  2. A licensing and registration programme. If you want a dog, you should register it with the local authority. Prove that it is microchipped, vaccinated, wormed. Prove that it is insured. Attend mandatory training classes. Prove that you have a suitable environment to live in. Prove that you have the finances to provide the right care.

  3. Dog parks to exercise dogs away from play parks. Insist all dogs are on lead in any other environment.

  4. Ban s/m posts of dogs being crawled on by babies/dressed up like dolls/any other stupid nonsense that makes a dog seem like some benign accessory.

This would make owners far more responsible, reduce the number of people who shouldn’t own a dog in the first place, improve dogs’ lives by ensuring they are cared for properly, remove dogs from spaces where children should be able to run and play uninhibited and hopefully encourage fewer people to see dogs as a fashion item.

Nordicrain · 28/04/2023 06:33

AlloPeciaMam · 27/04/2023 23:40

Not necessarily. One human death by dog mauling is one too many. We could do it humanely.

One rape is too much, why don't we castrate all men.

One car accident is too much, let's ban all cars.

One chocking on a grape is too much, lets ban grapes.

Loads of people die every year due to alcohol. Ban it? What about all the people dying and displaced due to climate change - are you getting rid of your car and uninstalling your central heating?

Proportionality is key.

Missingmyusername · 28/04/2023 06:19

@PassTheDuckie @AlloPeciaMam but humans caused the problem, didn’t we? We domesticated dogs. Now you want to solve it? Always address the source!
Perhaps it’s us that need that little syringe you refer to, eh? We kill and abuse so many creatures.

Anyway- killing all dogs isn’t going to happen. What a stupid post 😂are you always prone to THAT type of overreaction.

What a cave man like mentality.
“Me no like it, me kill it and eat it”🤣🤣🤣 these posts are batshit, pointless engaging with you. Silly.

I don’t know anyone in real life who hates dogs. Nobody. 🤷🏼‍♀️But if they did they might support muzzling, leashing, not mass murder- because it’s a disproportionate response to say the least.

StepAwayFromTheBiscuitJar · 28/04/2023 04:45

Great Danes don't tend to be aggressive normally. They're usually pretty aloof.

Timetochangetheoil · 28/04/2023 01:24

I have zero interest in learning to read a dog's body language, I just want them kept away from me and my children. I find it crazy that as a society we're constantly putting the "rights" of people to own massive dogs without any regulation or oversight above our children's right to go about their lives without being attacked or killed.

I completely agree. I was mauled by a family pet dog as a child and I am open with my children about the scars on my face being a result of that. If she’d latched on to my throat and not my face I may well not be here. I teach them to be wary and not approach dogs or respond to dogs that approach them and I tell owners to get them away from my kids. We don’t owe stranger’s dogs a pat on the head. And I’m not interested in getting to know them. The dogs of friends or family I warmly make a fuss of. We’ve had dogs since and I’ve loved them! But I am terrified of a strange dog attacking one of my children. They’ve been knocked over by them in the woods. It’s not ok. I guess all we can do for now is teach our children the safest rules (don’t run/scream/get in their face/approach etc) until the laws are tightened on this.

PassTheDuckie · 28/04/2023 01:09

Asiatoyork · 28/04/2023 00:54

Given the few dog attack deaths that have been happening, I am not surprised that the press are reporting on lower level stuff like this... that happens all the time

I think that’s the problem….in your words ‘it happens all the time’ I love dogs, but it blows my mind how glib and unfeeling people are about kids injuries/allergies/being in fear

Exactly. She admits it happens all
the time, yet thinks this is an acceptable way to live, with kids maimed and scarred, day in, day out. I’m appalled with such recklessness and disregard for humans.

PassTheDuckie · 28/04/2023 01:07

XenoBitch · 27/04/2023 23:34

Given the few dog attack deaths that have been happening, I am not surprised that the press are reporting on lower level stuff like this... that happens all the time.

A bit like then the Smiler ride in Alton Towers had that horrific crash where someone lost a leg.... afterwards, the press was reporting the smallest rollercoaster breakdown.. the sort of stuff that happens all the time.

Lower level??? If you think a gaping head wound is low level, you’re totally lacking in wisdom.

PassTheDuckie · 28/04/2023 01:06

XenoBitch · 27/04/2023 23:50

Do what humanely? Kill all dogs?

What an absolute over reaction! Typical from the MN dog haters. Happens every time on dog threads.

Why is it extreme? This country kills millions of animals every day. In worse ways than a shot of pink juice in a syringe. We could easily eradicate the dog problem in a week. They could even be usefully fed to the big cats in the zoos, save a few cows for a change.

Asiatoyork · 28/04/2023 00:54

Given the few dog attack deaths that have been happening, I am not surprised that the press are reporting on lower level stuff like this... that happens all the time

I think that’s the problem….in your words ‘it happens all the time’ I love dogs, but it blows my mind how glib and unfeeling people are about kids injuries/allergies/being in fear

XenoBitch · 27/04/2023 23:50

AlloPeciaMam · 27/04/2023 23:40

Not necessarily. One human death by dog mauling is one too many. We could do it humanely.

Do what humanely? Kill all dogs?

What an absolute over reaction! Typical from the MN dog haters. Happens every time on dog threads.

AlloPeciaMam · 27/04/2023 23:40

Nordicrain · 27/04/2023 14:51

Which seems to be muzzling or killing them all.

Bit extreme, no?

Not necessarily. One human death by dog mauling is one too many. We could do it humanely.

XenoBitch · 27/04/2023 23:34

Given the few dog attack deaths that have been happening, I am not surprised that the press are reporting on lower level stuff like this... that happens all the time.

A bit like then the Smiler ride in Alton Towers had that horrific crash where someone lost a leg.... afterwards, the press was reporting the smallest rollercoaster breakdown.. the sort of stuff that happens all the time.

AlloPeciaMam · 27/04/2023 23:29

Oysterbabe · 27/04/2023 13:43

Hopefully that dog will be destroyed shortly.

A friend took on a dog recently. It was being rehomed as the family had a new baby and it was showing 'guarding behaviour'. She doesn't have children herself but regularly has visits from friends and family that do. It became immediately apparent that the dog is aggressive to small children and now she's posting on FB trying to rehome it again. I came under a lot of criticism for suggesting that the dog should not be rehomed at all.
In my opinion once a dog is aggressive to humans it should be PTS immediately.

I agree with you.

Ichosetheredpill · 27/04/2023 23:05

I’ve always had dogs, always taken them to the pub. If I don’t know the pub, I phone before to ask whether it’s okay to bring the dog and have been told several times after arriving “oh, we thought you were bringing a dog” because they were so quiet under the table. I wouldn’t dream of taking my dog to a supermarket but she does occasionally come into appropriate shops with me, usually if I would otherwise be out all day and have to leave her. She’s a Springer and extraordinarily gentle, but I would never leave a child alone with her. I am constantly astounded at the stupidity of parents. I once had a child of about 4 crawl up to her at face level with his teeth bared, making growling noises while she was lying under the table in a pub garden. Fortunately she’s pretty bombproof and I intervened long before he was within range, but I took the child back to his parents and got blank looks when I told them they needed to keep more of an eye before he picked a dog that would do more than look up at its owner for guidance on how to react.

blackberriesaretheonlyfruit · 27/04/2023 18:49

The Dog in this case belongs to the owner and goes to work with them. I buy my dog treats in it occasionally. First I heard about the incident was on the news.

HappiestSleeping · 27/04/2023 18:42

Acheybreakyhead · 27/04/2023 10:25

This is only going to get more common as more and more places let dogs in and people continue to not treat their dogs as dogs.

This 👆

Especially the second part. I am a dog owner, but they shouldn't be allowed everywhere. There have been other threads on this topic, the real solution is heavier punishments for the owners and the breeders.

LaughingCat · 27/04/2023 18:19

AriannasGuitarCase · 27/04/2023 14:24

This attack took place in Northern ireland, which has dog licensing

Fair enough! I didn’t know that.

I’ll have a dig around the English hospital episode stats and DHNI’s hospital activity stats and see what the difference is for dog bites admissions (per capita). Will be interesting to see if there is any.

hiredandsqueak · 27/04/2023 17:34

Well I rescued my dog had home check, vet reference and everyone in the household had to be met. They didn't exactly throw a dog my way. People who want a dog for nefarious reason's or who are likely to be irresponsible owners aren't going to jump through hoops. It will push backyard breeders further underground, there will be more interbreeding of dogs from questionable backgrounds with no thought given to their welfare available at great cost to anybody who wants a dog without any of the hassle.

Thesharkradar · 27/04/2023 17:26

Wtfishappeningandwhy · 27/04/2023 16:00

Maybe a solution could be making it harder to own a dog.
So, stricter rules on breeding. Dog license. Dog free town centres. Off lead walking only in designated areas, etc etc. this would all make owning a dog less attractive.

it should be much harder to own a dog, if it were so I think things would likely shift such that only those who were responsible would jump through the extra hoops.
This would also reduce the numbers of dogs and that would hurt the profits of the pet industry who will lobby hard against any such measures.
One reason we are so Laissez-faire is that there is money to be made out of dog owners.

CrotchetyCrocheting · 27/04/2023 17:18

NorthStarRising · 27/04/2023 12:24

How does a well-fitted muzzle worn for a few hours distress a dog?
Surely it’s a matter of training, positive reinforcement and associating wearing it with being out and about for a walk. Providing dog parks would give them the opportunity to play without one.

There were people that couldn't wear a mask for 5 mins to walk in a shop. You can't see how a muzzle could be distressing to a rescue dog with a history of abuse? What would be the point in muzzling a dog that can't even bite through a sausage? Where is the sense in that? Surely people can just get over their irrational fear of all dogs, a few treats, and some positive reinforcement they'll be good to go.

KittyAlfred · 27/04/2023 17:07

Bananarama77 · 27/04/2023 14:38

I have never in my entire life been anywhere & have seen dogs roaming around, dramatically over exaggerating. Just because you don’t like dogs doesn’t mean you are right. I hate cats but I accept they will be roaming about because that’s the nature of cats & I ignore them

I’ve got nothing against dogs. I have nothing against any animals. I think it’s lovely for people to keep pets if that’s what they want, and they’ve got the wherewithal to care for them properly. But the explosion in dog ownership since lockdown means that dogs are now everywhere, and owned by idiots, and we are expected to somehow accept the inherent risk that they pose. And anyone who objects to that is told it’s their fault for not educating their children!

VincentVaguer · 27/04/2023 16:38

margegunderson · 27/04/2023 14:51

And yet another dog apologist.

Yep. I love dogs and think some of the posts on here are irrational to the point of mania.

Saz12 · 27/04/2023 16:12

I know so many people with nice natured BUT incredibly badly trained dogs.
Jumping up, barking, no recall whatsoever.

Many of these same people seem to believe that the onus is on others to do whats needed to facilitate their dogs behaviour. But its not up to passers by to (eg) stand still with arms at their sides if they dont want to interact with a random dog, its up to the owner to call their dog away and not allow it to approach random strangers.

Chuckydidit · 27/04/2023 16:10

Remove their teeth.

Swipe left for the next trending thread