Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Children playing in the garden

241 replies

Boytwinmum · 28/05/2023 16:34

Hi everyone.
My children, who are young teenagers, love being outside. I encourage it to avoid them being on screens too much.

We've lived in our current house for almost 3 years - this is our third summer here. Recently, my neighbours (I only have neighbours on one side) have taken a huge disliking to them playing in the garden. I spoke to the gentleman and we agreed a mutually acceptable time for them to stop playing was 10pm. I enforce this if they forget, but they are very conscious of the time limit.

Last night (Saturday) they went over by 2 minutes, so got really told off by the neighbour. I could hear the lady screaming at them that they are disrespectful and should be in bed by 10pm. My younger one was mortified and couldn't apologise enough, but she was livid. The screaming attracted my attention to the time, so I also apologised, but she said she was calling the police as we were disturbing their peace. Her and her husband then spent the next 20 minutes shouting at each other.

Well the police turned up today to speak to me, unfortunately we were out, but I saw them on my cameras.

What do I do? I really do dislike falling out with anybody. I understand that we all have different tolerance limits. I want to address it with them, but without making it worse or getting into a neighbour feud. I'm almost tempted to say that when they let their dog out to bark from 6am onwards, or do their glass recycling before 8am at a weekend is outside of my tolerance limits, but I say nothing to keep the peace - but if I say that does it look like tit for tat?

Any advice welcome please.

OP posts:
Lovetotravel123 · 28/05/2023 19:09

I think it’s great that your kids are out doing sport rather than computer games etc. I also think up to 10pm is fine, unless the neighbours have a baby they are trying to get to sleep.

Boxofsockss · 28/05/2023 19:09

Tbh 10pm at night hearing my neighbours regularly would piss me of.

AmytheDancingBrick · 28/05/2023 19:08

We have teen boys and 10pm is far too late for them to playing football and basketball. 9pm is my absolute limit, but I've usually had enough of my own making a noise by 8pm and tell them to stop.

Absolem76 · 28/05/2023 19:04

I think 10pm is too especially as it sounds very frequent (every night?). Your poor neighbours probably can't relax in their own home.

Boytwinmum · 28/05/2023 19:01

@CleverLilViper *Honestly-OP, you don't sound like a good neighbour.

Ball games at 10PM on a regular basis? Fuck that. That kind of noise goes right through you and can really disturb and disrupt your peace. Especially when it's night and you're trying to unwind and all you can hear is a fucking ball banging about and no doubt the ensuing shouts/screams/cheers. I doubt they're silent as they're playing.*

It's usually on average 3 out of 14 nights, on a 2 weekly basis. Albeit more in the good weather, and may-sept as that is when nights are light. As I've said in a previous post, they tend to play until 9pm then talk until 10 then come in, though the gentleman neighbour said he was fine with 10pm even for the ball.

We are respectful neighbours, hence we agreed it with him, but quite clearly something has changed and I need to discuss it with him. I am thinking now that he agreed with it but his wife didn't as they argued for a further 20 mins after the altercation.

He could have popped round and asked them to stop at 9, I'd have got on board. They don't play Sunday evenings as he works early on Mondays- I am not unreasonable.

I asked for guidance, and the second part of your post is helpful. Thank you.

I've also said I take full responsibility and will rectify it. I'm so conscious of annoying others that I've been fretting about it all day.

OP posts:
Mossstitch · 28/05/2023 19:00

It is an annoying noise but for goodness sake teenage boys could be doing much worse! I speak as mother of three grown up ones and basketball net attached to house for one of them when he was about 14. Your neighbours are totally out of order and I would reassure your boys that they are not in the wrong. One of my old neighbours shouted at one of my then 9 Yr old for riding his new bike on the pavement, he'd just got it and I'd told him to stay on the pavement for safety reasons........he never rode it again as she frightened him! The neighbours need to move to somewhere with no neighbours if they can't take normal family noise. I would be withdrawing any support from them after that💐

MayThe4th · 28/05/2023 18:57

CleverLilViper · 28/05/2023 18:51

Honestly-OP, you don't sound like a good neighbour.

Ball games at 10PM on a regular basis? Fuck that. That kind of noise goes right through you and can really disturb and disrupt your peace. Especially when it's night and you're trying to unwind and all you can hear is a fucking ball banging about and no doubt the ensuing shouts/screams/cheers. I doubt they're silent as they're playing.

I don't expect pure silence out of my neighbours-I think we all have to tolerate each other but there's got to be something reasonable about it. Obviously-it's causing a disturbance to them if they're complaining about it.

Try and think about it objectively, OP. If you were your neighbour and had to listen to your kids, would you be happy about it?

As far as them shouting at your kids-that's not on. Any issues they have they should have took it up directly with you and not shouted at or berated your kids.

Nor should they have called the police. That was OTT. If I were you, I'd go over and be open to listening to them. Hear their concerns. If they've gone at 10:02PM they've obviously been chomping at the bit and been desperate to say something. So chances are it's been bothering them far longer than that.

I'd also advise them that you aren't happy about the way they spoke to your children or the fact that they contacted the police about a matter that could have been handled between you both. Don't roll over-but be open to listening to their concerns. Don't be the neighbour that just thinks their kids can do no wrong and as it's not 11PM it's all hunky dory. It's not.

Someone who threatens a child with physical violence on camera is not a reasonable person.

This isn’t a case of neighbours at the end of their teather, the OP had reached an agreement that the children would come in after 10 PM, and they were two minutes late.

Let’s get some perspective here. The children are just being children. He on the other hand sounds like an abusive cunt.

MayThe4th · 28/05/2023 18:53

I wouldn’t compromise. If he’d asked nicely I might, but given he essentially threatened your ds I’d prefer to play bagpipe music out there instead.

Americano75 · 28/05/2023 18:52

I just think they must be pretty stupid to act that way and then call the police!

theleafandnotthetree · 28/05/2023 18:51

Viviennemary · 28/05/2023 17:45

Teenagers are far too old to be 'playing' in the garden. Especially at 10 pm. No wonder your neighbour isnt happy.

What a sad post, nothing nicer than seeing siblings of any age hanging out together outside, playing sport etc rather than shut up in their rooms individually. OP, you and your children sound lovely and considerate and perfectly normal.

CleverLilViper · 28/05/2023 18:51

Honestly-OP, you don't sound like a good neighbour.

Ball games at 10PM on a regular basis? Fuck that. That kind of noise goes right through you and can really disturb and disrupt your peace. Especially when it's night and you're trying to unwind and all you can hear is a fucking ball banging about and no doubt the ensuing shouts/screams/cheers. I doubt they're silent as they're playing.

I don't expect pure silence out of my neighbours-I think we all have to tolerate each other but there's got to be something reasonable about it. Obviously-it's causing a disturbance to them if they're complaining about it.

Try and think about it objectively, OP. If you were your neighbour and had to listen to your kids, would you be happy about it?

As far as them shouting at your kids-that's not on. Any issues they have they should have took it up directly with you and not shouted at or berated your kids.

Nor should they have called the police. That was OTT. If I were you, I'd go over and be open to listening to them. Hear their concerns. If they've gone at 10:02PM they've obviously been chomping at the bit and been desperate to say something. So chances are it's been bothering them far longer than that.

I'd also advise them that you aren't happy about the way they spoke to your children or the fact that they contacted the police about a matter that could have been handled between you both. Don't roll over-but be open to listening to their concerns. Don't be the neighbour that just thinks their kids can do no wrong and as it's not 11PM it's all hunky dory. It's not.

Augend23 · 28/05/2023 18:47

I think basketball is more annoying (noise wise) than football - assuming no one is bouncing the football against the fence.

Could you maybe compromise with no basketball after e.g. 8:30 or something and switch to football til e.g. 9:30 and then sitting out til whenever they want really?

Boytwinmum · 28/05/2023 18:46

Americano75 · 28/05/2023 18:40

Holy shit, I'd be calling the police myself! In fact, is there any chance another neighbour heard him and called the police?

Perhaps? There are only a handful of houses, so I imagin all the nighbours could have heard. This couple do argue a lot. The child that sleeps at the front of the house said he hears a lady screaming and crying most nights (he's a real night owl so suspect it's when the outside world is totally silent). He can't pinpoint which house it is though.

OP posts:
LaMaG · 28/05/2023 18:45

Can't believe some replies here - how dare a teenager play ball in their garden?? FFS better they find the local park where they can go smoking weed or join a knife carrying gang. Neighbours are being assholes. If they want silence they need to move to the country. 10pm garden curfew is v reasonable, maybe 9.30 to be generous. My kids don't come in til 10 in summer, it's bright til 10.30 here.

Hellno45 · 28/05/2023 18:43

Boytwinmum · 28/05/2023 18:34

Yep.back garden and front garden. He raised his fists at them and said they were f*cking annoying and he'd knock it out of them. I don't disagree they can be really annoying, but it's my place to deal with that, not his.

I'd park that behaviour straight away. He has no business shouting, swearing and threatening violence to kids. I would be very clear that it won't be tolerated. If the have a problem they can discuss it with you. They can also do it polite manner and how the expect to be addressed.

If the police do come round is show them the video footage.

Sianthomasisnothererightnow · 28/05/2023 18:41

Boytwinmum · 28/05/2023 18:34

Yep.back garden and front garden. He raised his fists at them and said they were f*cking annoying and he'd knock it out of them. I don't disagree they can be really annoying, but it's my place to deal with that, not his.

I’d have this handy, on my phone, ready to show the police if they pop round again.

OP you and your boys sound caring and considerate. Stop supporting your neighbours, they sound like nasty tossers.

ApolloandDaphne · 28/05/2023 18:41

Even though I quite like to go to bed early there is no way I would stop my neighbours enjoying their garden or ask their children to stop playing at that time. Up to 10pm is perfectly reasonable for teens to be out enjoying their garden.

thespy · 28/05/2023 18:40

*Neighbours

Americano75 · 28/05/2023 18:40

Boytwinmum · 28/05/2023 18:34

Yep.back garden and front garden. He raised his fists at them and said they were f*cking annoying and he'd knock it out of them. I don't disagree they can be really annoying, but it's my place to deal with that, not his.

Holy shit, I'd be calling the police myself! In fact, is there any chance another neighbour heard him and called the police?

thespy · 28/05/2023 18:40

Hmmm, now they are too scared to go out so basically the neighbour has bullied them into being afraid to use their own garden? Neighbour's sound like total bastards. No ball games after 9pm is a reasonable adjustment, and maybe limit the basketball. But I wouldn't actually tell the neighbours - they sound awful. It's not awful to be pissed off and ask politely for the kids to stop making a noise after 10pm but screaming at them, threatening them and having a Barney for another 20 minutes over it? Unreasonable and unnecessary since you sound like a generally very respectful neighbour. No more parcels either. Do not let them bully you.

ocs30 · 28/05/2023 18:37

excelledyourself · 28/05/2023 18:16

"Far too old"??

What's the cut off then?

Is it preferable to you that they be stuck indoors, glued to screens? Maybe even just shut in a cupboard? Or out wandering the streets maybe?

How bloody miserable.

The thing is, at 13 they're probably too big to be sent to sweep the chimneys 😂

FrangipaniBlue · 28/05/2023 18:36

They don't want me to host their birthday bbq tomorrow as they don't want to be out there.

Which shows that clearly are quite considerate natured in a way of it has affected them like this.

But no way would I allow a neighbour to make my teen DS feel like this.

newtowelsplease · 28/05/2023 18:35

I promise I'm not a bad neighbour! I take in all their parcels and mow their lawn.i rebuilt my wall when they hit it with the car and said nothing, I don't complain about their noise

Knock this all on the head OP. Your neighbours clearly think they are entitled to silence. They're not.

Boytwinmum · 28/05/2023 18:34

Americano75 · 28/05/2023 18:31

Did you get the neighbour screaming at them on camera?

Yep.back garden and front garden. He raised his fists at them and said they were f*cking annoying and he'd knock it out of them. I don't disagree they can be really annoying, but it's my place to deal with that, not his.

OP posts:
I8toys · 28/05/2023 18:33

I didn't realise there was an age limit to playing in your own garden. Mumsnet is batshit crazy sometimes.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread