Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that repeating a nasty comment

34 replies

BAFE · 29/06/2010 18:10

that someone else made about another person is as bad as saying it yourself.

Today, one of my friends (well, I thought she was my friend) thought that she would tell me of a nasty bitchy comment that someone made about my teeth.

Now, I'm willing to go with the majority of you here, but I'm thinking, there's no need to repeat nasty comments and that people who do so are just using that as an excuse to make the nasty comment themselves and be hurtful.

I mean, why else would someone do that?

OP posts:
Jamieandhismagictorch · 29/06/2010 18:18

X post - well then BAFE, seems like your instinct was correct.

Wordsonascreen · 29/06/2010 18:17

whats wrong with your teeth?

scurryfunge · 29/06/2010 18:17

A good friend would protect people from hurtful comments, not reinforce them.

Jamieandhismagictorch · 29/06/2010 18:16

-- just to add, - I would expect a good friend to tell me something like this if I asked them, but otherwise, I wouldn't expect it (and nor has it ever happened to me).

I don't think I've ever told anyone else that someone's been speaking about them, but then that generally wouldn't happen anyway, as people don't generally slag off people in front of their friends

BAFE · 29/06/2010 18:16

I honestly think she enjoyed telling me, and seeing my face.

Another women who is not a personal friend of mine but I do socialise with her because she's in our group and I've always got on well with made the comment. I'd rather not have known. tbh.

OP posts:
Ladyanonymous · 29/06/2010 18:15

I feel she had more to gain by repeating it that you did by knowing -

If it was me I would stop the person making the remark, or walk away and then if the person they were slagging off ever spoke about what a great friend/wonderful person they were I would just tell them nicely to watch themselves.

The only thing she had to gain by telling you was causing you to be hurt.

So no YANBU.

MathsMadMummy · 29/06/2010 18:15

YANBU. It's like when people say "no offence, but..." they clearly DO mean 'offence' - otherwise they wouldn't think of saying "no offence" would they!

Jamieandhismagictorch · 29/06/2010 18:13

I think it really depends.

If a good friend, they may want you to have a heads up that someone you think is nice, is actually talking about you behind your back

OTOH - I think someone who reports something like this may be deemed a gossip, and therefore not to be trusted.

sethstarkaddersmum · 29/06/2010 18:12

I'm with you OP. In some circumstances it is helpful to warn the person who is being bitched about but most of the time it is just stirring and often done in a fundamentally dishonest way - 'I am your friend so I think you ought to know....' etc.