Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to exaggerate DD's illness

31 replies

sevenkeystomysoul · 27/06/2010 23:13

XP has DD on Sundays, but his plan for today was to drive her long distance to a family bbq. I was worried, as I know he'll have a drink and think it's ok (he drinks when they're local but at least then he gets taxis). Then he told me the house they're going to has a pool. I have concerns about how well he supervises DD when he has her anyway, but the pool factor just hit me in that instinctive, mother, gut reaction way. DD has been a little under the weather, but nothing that would normally make me say she can't go with him. But I did exaggerate how she was in order to stop him having her today. He didn't believe me, of course, said he was coming round to see her himself, but I made excuses (she'd been up all night, was now sleeping). I've never stopped him seeing her before, and I do feel bad for both him and her, but I just couldn't let her go with him, knowing what he's like, and having the fears about today that I had. I just couldn't face having another argument with him about his drinking, had I told him my concerns. BTW, DD and I had a fantastic day today, she's too young to know today is 'daddy's' day. So AIBU when my gut reaction is 'no'?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FallacyTide · 08/11/2022 21:49

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

chitchat07 · 28/06/2010 23:05

Oh OP, I feel for you. My sister had this problem for years. The police wouldn't do anything and the court's wouldn't either. She put up with this for years until the children were old enough to say no to seeing their dad themselves because he was such a raving lunatic who had killed his braincells with alcohol who embarrassed them.

differentnameforthis · 28/06/2010 22:45

Opps, sorry foureleven. Didn't see that!

scottishmummy · 28/06/2010 19:25

you do need to address concerns you have in a constructive way. if need be someone get support or mediate for you

naturally you are worried about dd welfare, but only so many illnesses you can feign.avoidance is short term.long term you need a plan

if you can give concrete examples,dates of lapses this will support to your concerns

foureleven · 28/06/2010 14:34

Sorry different name, I apologised because I only read the first post in which the OP's ex didnt come across too badly.

I think if she has real concerns that she should stop access and have it investigated. If there is a real problem there's no point in sending the child sometimes and not others. I mean, I get that the swimming pool is a worry but what about roads, open windows, sharp objects in the kitchen etc etc either he's capable of caring for her or not.

differentnameforthis · 28/06/2010 08:59

Oh yes, she is very lucky that she "has concerns about how well he supervises DD when he has her anyway", that he drinks & drives, that he wants to see his daughter, (but can't stay sober for what sounds like a few hours while she is there), that he seems to think he doesn't have a problem with drink! So lucky that she should ignore her instincts & let her go where OP knows her ex will be drinking & not watching their dd v well.

Yes, she needs to face this head on, but I can't believe how many of you are telling her she is BU when all she is doing is making sure her daughter is safe, because it seems like her ex couldn't give a shit!

Fwiw, I would stop access until he can prove he can not drink for the duration of her visit...if she is that important to him, he needs to prove it.

foureleven · 28/06/2010 08:37

ok, missed that post. The first one made it sound like the fact he might have a drink will mean he cant look after her.

gingernutlover · 28/06/2010 08:19

"An example, he asks me why I won't let him have DD overnight, I tell him it's because he is generally in a drink-induced coma by 8pm and would be incapable of looking after her during the night. He doesn't even bother to try telling me that he won't drink if he has her overnight, just says that his 10-year-old son would hear her and deal with her"

sounds to me like a drink problem. He may be a doting dad but I don't think the OP feels lucky at all.

GiddyPickle · 28/06/2010 08:19

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

foureleven · 28/06/2010 08:17

Doe she have a drink problem or does he jioust like a drink?

I always drink at family occassions but am able to look after the kids.

I think you are very fortunate that your DDs dad wants her so much that he doesnt believe you when you say shes too ill to go and comes round to check. My DDs dad would be like - great! A day off!!

AlfredaMantolini · 28/06/2010 08:13

I think he's lucky to have any access at all if he has a drinking problem. I would not let my daughter go, and if it meant lying, then so be it.

gingernutlover · 28/06/2010 08:09

I dont think YWBU

The gut feelings happen for a reason IMO.

you know he deinks and drives, therefore whyon earth should you have let her go somewhere where he would probably do this?

I think you are being accomodating to let him look after her on his own, bearing in mind the alcohol - has the access been agreed through a court? Do they know about the drinking?

whoneedssleepanyway · 28/06/2010 06:51

My cousin and her DP took their DS (2 at the time) and his other 2 DCs on holiday to a villa with a pool. One evening they were all having drinks and had some friends over, both thought the other was watching him, someone heard a little "plop" and he had wandered out onto the patio and fallen in the pool, luckily they heard ran out fished him out and he was ok, they were both very very scared, this could easily have had a much unhappier outcome.

i think you were right to have been concerned about this but like others have said you can't lie every time you don't want him to have her, you need to talk to him about his drinking. drinking and driving is totally unacceptable.

thumbwitch · 28/06/2010 06:04

Under the circs of there being a pool there, I totally agree with what you did, even though lying isn't the best way to do it.

It's so easy and little ones drown so much quicker than adults - I wouldn't have taken that chance either.

As far as the drinking and driving is concerned, you will have to try and work out a way to deal with this long term - perhaps look out a few articles (if you can stand it) on toddler injuries and worse when the parent has been DUI.

No doubt if your ex were more reasonable and easier to deal with you wouldn't have felt the need to lie - but the MAIN thing was to keep your DD safe and you did that.

differentnameforthis · 28/06/2010 05:50

You're welcome seven.

A little fib wouldn't have hurt. Who cares if he didn't believe you, bigger issue is, that you don't believe him to be capable of looking after her. I think maybe as a compromise, I would have suggested another day, if it was obvious he wanted to see her that badly.

SM, leave it now. The op has said that on this occasion she couldn't face a fight & in a way, pulling him up on it may have pissed him off more, made him drink more & therefore have even less 'control' over supervision.

OP is tackling this, long term, I am sure & she doesn't need to explain or justify her choices to you. We don't deal with her exp, she does. I am pretty sure she has her child's interests at heart!

scottishmummy · 28/06/2010 00:32

so what are you going to do?cant keep lying

ok,how will you address this
what corroborating evidence you got
he wont be put off by this long term

can you compromise on location,mode of transport etc

or if he is wholly unsuitable you got to get some corroboration going on

this wont go away he will want to see daughter

sevenkeystomysoul · 28/06/2010 00:28

StayFrostys, my DD is just three. She loves her daddy and he loves her, he just loves himself and alcohol more. I never stop him seeing her. but today the alarm bells were too loud to ignore. I can't 'give him a chance' to prove himself because that 'chance' could be my child's life. We have discussed his drinking till the cows come home, he won't stop, so I work around it (no overnight stays, taxis etc). For a myriad of reasons, I couldn't face another fight with him over today so I lied, a little bit. It's the first, but possibly not the last time, and I do feel bad about it but he's a passive-aggresive, as well as an alcoholic, so everything is my fault and he's perfect.

OP posts:
scottishmummy · 28/06/2010 00:10

what is your long term strategy?how will you address concerns.cant feign illness, make excuses for next 16years?

i completely understand misgivings,but you need an actual strategy. some corrobarating evidence

he wont be put off by your excuses.so what you going to do

WhereYouLeftIt · 28/06/2010 00:06

YANBU, in your shoes i would have listened to my gut too.

Dominique07 · 28/06/2010 00:04

You know him, trust your instinct, do the best for your child, I'm sure you make sure they spend lots of time together.

sevenkeystomysoul · 28/06/2010 00:03

differentnameforthis, thank you. I struggled hugely with this at the beginning and told him that if he ever put DD in the car when he had been drinking he would never see her again (he has history, he has admitted that he has driven while drunk with his DS in the car) and also that I would report him to the police. So, rather than not drink when he has DD, he gets taxis. It's not perfect, but at least I know she isn't being driven around by a drunk. However, today taxis wouldn't have been an option (too far) and sadly, I can't trust him not to have 'one or two' and get behind the wheel.

OP posts:
StayFrostysSockPuppetFriend · 28/06/2010 00:01

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

MrsRhettButler · 27/06/2010 23:56

hear hear diff i totally agree

the thing is, with the 'more eyes' thing, people always assume that 'someone else' knows where the child is.

scottishmummy · 27/06/2010 23:52

long term, lying isnt a strategy.if you have concerns address them.do something.making up excuses is avoidant

if he drink drives, report him

is this about drinking or other relationship issues

differentnameforthis · 27/06/2010 23:51

Imagine this

"XP has DD on Sundays and his plan for today was to drive her long distance to a family bbq. I was worried, as I know he'll have a drink and think it's ok. Then he told me the house they're going to has a pool. I have concerns about how well he supervises DD when he has her anyway, but the pool factor just hit me in that instinctive, mother, gut reaction way. But I decided to let her go anyway. Because it's 'his' day'

He just bought her home & tells me she fell in the pool, she is OK. Just shocked & scared, crying & clingly. He has been drinking & said he was only distracted for a few seconds, but he didn't see her go & wasn't the one to pull her out"

Posters on here would rip OP apart!! There would be all kinds of 'you shouldn't have let her go, you should have said she was too ill' etc. Yes, there would be sympathy, but way more recriminations, imo!

You do what you feel is right, only you know how you feel about certain situations. He'll have plenty of time to see her & one weekend won't matter.