Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how the bloody hell people afford private education for their kids?

456 replies

HarderToKidnap · 25/06/2010 19:58

Thinking about TTC and getting WAY ahead of myself I idly googled the local private schools. Bloody hell!! HOW do people afford this? My DH and I earn 100k between us every year so certainly not poor, but with a mortgage (on a two bed terrace) and other, what I consider to be reasonable, outgoings there is just not a way it could be done. So all these children being privately educated, do their parents earn masses and masses? Or am I missing a trick?

(Incidentally I wouldn't send my kid to private school - comprehensive was brilliant for me and if a child is going to do well they will do well, I believe. Was just wondering.)

OP posts:
allbie · 29/06/2010 13:15

Pixie- just interested, does your partner/husband work very long hours to finance your family and if this is the case, does he see your children much?

MadameBelle · 29/06/2010 12:32

Our 3 dc go to private school and there is a huge variety of people there - from those who pay the bill without blinking, to those who really really struggle. We sit somewhere in the middle. Oh, and gp pay for one child.

We have a joint income of considerably less than 100k. My salary pays fees and the cleaner and any babysitting. dh does mortgage, bills, and holidays.

We run one old car, and use the bus if we have to be in different places at the same time. We all have good quality bikes and the elder ones can bike to rugby training on their own now. Our holidays consist of going to my parents in the countryside which they love, and costs nothing. We also go to France every summer - drive down and stay in mil's house. That holiday usually costs us about £400.

But our mortgage is miles lower than op's at about £1200 a month, and fees round here are about £7500 a year for primary rising to £12000 for secondary, up to £15000 for sixth form.

It is doable, and the dc do not feel that they miss out on stuff, but although we would like to move to a bigger house, that's not going to happen.

We would have been more comfortable and felt more financially secure to use state schools until secondary (they are terrible in this city) but after 2 years in the local Ofsted Outstanding primary my eldest ds was miserable, withdrawn and learning nothing, and the school was totally unwilling to help in any way.

It means that my dc will not ski until they can pay for it themselves, and their holidays will not get more glamorous and exciting. Poor them

maltesers · 29/06/2010 09:33

I could never afford it myself as i am asingle parent, but my Ex pays for our DS of 9 yrs to go to a very good Chorister prep school and its about £4950 per term at the moment and increasing every year. On top there is school uniform and trips etc. My Ex may have been a total bastard but he is doing right by our son and paying for an excellent private Education. Ds has come on in leaps and bounds and his behaviour has improved immensely. An Education is something you can NEVER take away from someone.
My older two grown up kids had to go to a state comprehensive and i wish they had not. I went to private school and feel privalaged that i did. My parents were not rich. They scrimped and saved and had not holidays. We lived in a small 3 bed house. My sister got to Oxford and a top class Degree because of public school!!

SanctiMoanyArse · 29/06/2010 09:32

Sonnet- I think it is about income as well as expenditure: here in Wales I don't know anyone who makes enough to budget £25k without stopping eating and paying rent; an average salary for a decent job (say, transport manager with HND quals as DH used to do before Uni) pays in region of £18k (he commuted to England for more money, but not everyone lives close enough to do that). OTOH there are very few decent privates here as a result; only ine in immediate locality and not one I would personally choose.

Luckily we have some stunning satte schools here: DS3's is amazing despite being probably very low income in it's intake; ds1's is perfection and private equivalent if youa re academic- most aprents move ehre rather than paying private fees. OTOH ds2 doesn't suit the state school as he falls into that gap where he's not academic or sufficiently SEN (bad dyslecxia / dyspraxia) to get real help so if we ahd the option we'd pay private for him like a shot.

I think it's about knwoing your children, where they'd thrive and the local school provision inside out to amke best matches.

SanctiMoanyArse · 29/06/2010 09:25

VA schools work differently- at ours, all kids take an RE exam each year 9and some face to face with the Bishop- ds3 had this last week, no idea why they chose him ) and if they pass, according to some will made in about 839BCE, the school gets a payment from the trust. And we get a letter as aprents whinging there's not enough God mentioned in maths and that if he has to do the inspection next year could someone give him some hemlock. Seriously.

Ours is a catchment VA school unlike a Jewish school so not really on to ask for cash in that we didn't have a real choice in where they attended.

MumNWLondon · 29/06/2010 09:08

Its a voluntary aided school - I assumed all VA schools worked the same, way all jewish schools work on same model, but some ask for less money if the amount of religious studies they offer is less. It is voluntary which is why its from pre tax salary. If you are on lower income you call school and say the contributions are too much and they don't ask again.

The government know about this, not a tax loophole as you don't actually have to pay. Your child gets the same education whether you pay or not. They need the money to pay the religious teachers as this is not paid for by the state, plus they also have to raise some of their building costs.

They are not allowed to ask if you can afford it when offering places - they are bound by admissions code - so distance or lottery etc. But it is self selecting a bit - eg poorer parents put off because everyone else pays and other schools are "cheaper".

BeenBeta · 29/06/2010 07:38

MumNWLondon - I am genuinley bemused by this. I have never heard of state (faith) primary school where you effectivley pay a fee. Is this only in London?

Surely £1200 fee plus book costs etc are just fees. That surely is a selection/exclusion policy on the basis of ability to pay - and in the state sector! Surley this is just private school with a state discount?

Me and DW are in the process of emigratng to New Zealand and the Prep School we are sending DSs to gets state aid (all Prep schools do) in recognition of the fact that parents are not using the state sector and the fee structure is the same as the (faith) primary school you have described.

TBH I think a lot of private schools in the UK may well go to this grant maintained model by opting back into the state sector but not under LEA control under the Gove Plan while still charging a 'voluntary top up fee' as a sort of quasi selection policy.

Quattrocento · 28/06/2010 22:41

I think that's the pattern of a lot of jewish schools and some islamic ones too.

Not sure about quasi-compulsory voluntary contributions being taken from pre-tax income. If legal, it sounds as though it's a loophole that needs closing down.

MumNWLondon · 28/06/2010 22:34

I said earlier in this thread. At my DCs state (faith) primary school we are expected to pay £1,200 per child per term as a voluntary contribution (paid from pre-tax salary though) - DH has a GAYE account at work.

Plus we are asked for money the whole time. eg school cookbook, school calender, PTA fundraising social event every quarter, money for new school reading books, mathletics. I would estimate I've given the school another £500 or so this year on top of the VCs

Its all voluntary, but we are "invoiced" each term, and the rumour is that if you don't pay and don't call to explain why you can't OR they think you can afford it (ie they see new car / foreign holiday / extension / new house etc) they make things difficult for you.

Meanwhile between the government money and the parental top ups I'm sure the quality of education is as good at, if not better than many private schools.

FiveOrangePips · 28/06/2010 22:31

The only people I know who send their children to private school are part funded by the state (RAF).

islandofsodor · 28/06/2010 22:28

We are on a joint income of about £50-60k a year. We have two children and fees are around 7k each a year.

It is hard but we manage it. We considered home educating but school suits our children. There would have to be serious changes in policy for us to consider state education. Dh works in the state system.

stickylittlefingers · 28/06/2010 22:20

what do you mean by "hefty voluntary contributions" MumNWLondon?

MumNWLondon · 28/06/2010 22:18

Yes, but day nursery for for 3 years, private school for 10+. Unlikely to have 3DC at a day nursery at once (a nanny would be cheaper)

Also, need to afford day nursery (or nanny) for younger DC and private school for older ones?

As I said before I am extremely lucky that DCs at great faith state school (albeit with hefty voluntary contributions) and I have a choice of 2 or 3 equally excellent secondary schools. we may pay for private schools but not sure it is really worth it, if the state schools are so excellent.

stickylittlefingers · 28/06/2010 22:15

2 25 year old newly qualified solicitors living together in London could easily pull in in excess of 100k. Not in the North East - but then, everything costs much less up here! The bare figures don't tell you much, really.

allbie · 28/06/2010 22:09

I was privately educated and ended up with 10 o'levels then 3 A'levels. I became a sodding nurse. My brother went to a rough comp then to a slighly better college and ended up at london poly where he got a 2:1 degree.He's a very successful millionaire....with several businesses!

AlfredaMantolini · 28/06/2010 22:03

MumNW: if 100K will pay for a private day nursery, it will surely pay for a private junior school.

MumNWLondon · 28/06/2010 21:56

snobear, £100k is not shitloads, esp in London.

A very modest 3 bedroom semi in a very average suburb costs £500k. Even with a decent deposit that can still cost £2,500 a month, which is close to half of salary.

If its £100k combined then once you add in childcare costs which in London costs around £65 per day per child in a private nursery.

abr1de · 28/06/2010 21:43

There are big advantages for boys in leaving them at prep school until they're 13: they're much more mature at that stage and ready to move on. At eleven, some of them are still little boys.

archstanton · 28/06/2010 21:31

Traditional public schools all start at 13 and places are offered subject to how well children do in the CE exam. In some areas of the country such as the South East, almost all independent schools will be preps to 13 then senior school. Though you often find the boys schools change at 13 whilst the girls do 11+. It can be confusing.

In other areas of the country the 11+ will be the standard transfer time. Either because it's a grammar school area or because they just do 11+ rather than CE.

belledechocolatefluffybunny · 28/06/2010 21:27

I think the plan is to move them to public school at 13 as they go from 13+

archstanton · 28/06/2010 21:27

Yes, it depends on the secondary schools in the area. If they don't do CE and therefore all start at 11 then the primaries or 'preps' will only go up to 11.

Personally, I think this model is much fairer on the bright state school children. In areas that do CE, state school children are at a huge disadvantage. Far less so with 11+.

PosyPetrovaPauline · 28/06/2010 21:25

surely most children go to grammar etc at 11? I have always though Malsis a bit odd having children there until 13....they seem too old to not be in secondary education

chandellina · 28/06/2010 21:23

we are interested in our local pre-prep, but then it seems our son will be a bit lost going on to enter a state primary at 8.

belledechocolatefluffybunny · 28/06/2010 21:20

Ds's first school went up to 11, it has prep on the sign outside the school. Ds's current goes up to 13. All of his friends are moving at 11 though so it'll be unfair to leave him there with no friends and move him at 13 so he's moving in September.

PosyPetrovaPauline · 28/06/2010 21:20

I see
Just looked one of ours up it 'says' prep school but only runs to 11?