Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how the bloody hell people afford private education for their kids?

456 replies

HarderToKidnap · 25/06/2010 19:58

Thinking about TTC and getting WAY ahead of myself I idly googled the local private schools. Bloody hell!! HOW do people afford this? My DH and I earn 100k between us every year so certainly not poor, but with a mortgage (on a two bed terrace) and other, what I consider to be reasonable, outgoings there is just not a way it could be done. So all these children being privately educated, do their parents earn masses and masses? Or am I missing a trick?

(Incidentally I wouldn't send my kid to private school - comprehensive was brilliant for me and if a child is going to do well they will do well, I believe. Was just wondering.)

OP posts:
ManicMother7777 · 26/06/2010 16:17

Agree BeenBeta about the false dichotomy, but the point I'm making is that for most of us there is no debate to be had, private education is just out of the question. There seems to be a lack of basic maths on the part of some people (and I'm not saying anyone on this thread, just the sort of thing you read in the papers), - the cost of sending a child to private school exceeds your total income. Full stop. End of story. Especially with more than one child. So talk of sacrifice is just daft. It's this view you come across of 'oh if only you give up all your fripperies you too could send yours to Winchester!' that makes me .

In principle I have absolutely no problem with private education .

PixieOnaLeaf · 26/06/2010 15:47

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

BeenBeta · 26/06/2010 15:29

ManicMother - I can see what you mean. My parents 'sacrficed' to send me to private secondary after state Primary.

What they sacrificed for was a not very good private school (actually quite awful) but it was better than appaling state Comp that was the alternative. If I had lived 20 miles further West I would have been going to a state grammar school that was better than my private school - no question about it.

That is why I feel quite agnostic and annoyed about the whole state versus private debate. It is a totally false dicotomy.

Morloth · 26/06/2010 15:19

From my bedroom I can see directly into the classrooms of the state school across the road. The crossing is literally within 10 metres of my front gate.

Could. Not. Get. In. and have heard nothing whilst being on the waiting list for 2 years - when I used to call (gave up), they would say there was still a waiting list, sorry.

It is especially frustrating as I pass the same people going to that school every day on my school run going the other way.

ManicMother7777 · 26/06/2010 15:15

I get very irritated by the 'sacrifice' argument. Many families could sacrifice housing and eating and still not have the money.

Maisiethemorningsidecat · 26/06/2010 15:12

Oops, one too many states there..

Maisiethemorningsidecat · 26/06/2010 15:11

Yes, but some parents truly believe that private = better, and it would not matter if there was an excellent state primary or secondary state school in their catchment, they would go private regardless.

Which is their choice, obviously, but a fool and their money are soon parted, as dear old Granny was fond of saying.

BeenBeta · 26/06/2010 15:04

Honestly, the whole state private debate on MN does my head in.

Our DSs will go to which ever school I think will educate them best, which will deliver the services I need (after school care is very important to me) and will have the right culture because I want well behaved well brought up young men who are a credit to themselves.

So far, our DSs have gone to girls' private Prep schools with vey few boys and thay have benefited from small classes and better concentration and behaviour. They will likely go to single sex boys grammar school with a public scool ethos of excellence in future.

It is not about state versus private it is about good schooling. The state can deliver it but politicians are too frightened to make it happen. I want every parent to have the choices I have but the sad fact is they don't. It takes money and sacrifice by parents to make it happen as things stand.

Sorry but it i about wealth and politicians will not admit that. That is the travesty of our UK education system. Not state versus private. We need to move the debate on.

[polemic emoticon]

Maisiethemorningsidecat · 26/06/2010 14:55

No, they are not over-subscribed with catchment children, but it's not usual to get in if you're outside catchment. AFAIK it's slightly different up here in Scotland, with primary schools serving their immediate area.

BeenBeta · 26/06/2010 14:52

On the other hand I went to state Primary so maybe thats why I am thick.

BeenBeta · 26/06/2010 14:51

I went to private chool which is why I cant do emoticons properly

GiddyPickle · 26/06/2010 14:51

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

BeenBeta · 26/06/2010 14:50

UQD - state school chidren smell funny though. Thats why mine go private. hmm

BrandyAlexander · 26/06/2010 14:48

lowenergy if both people work and earn say £50k, then a household income of £100k is about £72k net of tax so roughly £6k per month. Assuming that the mortgage eats about a third of income then there is £4k left. Once you take away £2k for private school that then leaves £2k for all other expenses. I don't think there would be much room for luxuries. Looking at the maths, I can see why someone with a household income of £100k would be questioning how they could afford it.

Maisiethemorningsidecat · 26/06/2010 14:46

It's happening here as well, Eurostar. One of our local private schools has gone into receivership, and a private primary school is losing pupils at a rate of knots, so has had to increase the number of bursaries.

It's bizarre - we have the top 2 state primaries for our region in our catchment whose results are far higher than the national average, but some parents will insist on sending their children to this primary school which is 8 miles away. Lovely facilities, and a beautiful building, but my goodness, why on earth would anyone pay that sort of money for the kind of education you get for free 5 minutes walk away?

Eurostar · 26/06/2010 14:36

People will probably become less and less able to afford private fees, it's happening around where I live, state schools over subscribed. Young families have mostly unfortunately had to take on massive mortgages due to the insane growth in house prices. I hear young people (I'm talking twenties here, as I'm quite old :-) ) constantly say that they have no security in the private rented sector, and can't even put up a shelf and there is no council/HA housing available. Hence they take on horribly large mortgages. All well and good in our low interest environment but historically this has never lasted. When interest rates go up surely a lot of families are not going to be able to afford private school fees anymore?

GiddyPickle · 26/06/2010 14:27

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

bibbitybobbityhat · 26/06/2010 13:21

lowenergy - it is not as simple as £100,000 - £20,000 = £80,000 left to live on. The £100,000 is taxed the £20,000 is paid in full.

Someone earning £85,000 pa brings home about £4,600 per month. Fees for two children at a reasonable private secondary will take about half of that, leaving £2,300 for a family of four to live on. I don't know about you but our standing orders alone add up to £2,100 per month and we don't have a huge mortgage.

No wonder only 7% go to private school. And many of those fees aren't paid fully out of parental income anyway.

lupo · 26/06/2010 12:32

we are on about 55k a year with large mortgage and one ds - fees currently £640 a month, I earb about £1000 after tax, and pay fees out of that. It is a sacrifice but well worth it. What's left goes in to emergency fund and any some savings for secondary if he does not make a grammar

BarmyArmy · 26/06/2010 12:31

When I was in the Army, I was the only officer in the Mess who went to a state school. Got teased a bit for going to 'free school' until my enquiries revealed that my A level grades (A, B, B, D) were better than most of my privately educated colleagues.

I turned the teasing around, pointing out that they had all gone to expensive schools for children with special needs.

I think home environment and upbringing make a huge difference - parents always read to me and I had a wall-to-floor bookshelf right next to my bed crammed with books.

Having said all that, I think private education does give you a hunger for success/ambition that a lot of state education lacks - there is too much catering for the lowest common denominator in state schools nowadays.

lowenergylightbulb · 26/06/2010 12:21

It works out at 10K per child per annum where I am. If someone was on 100K then if you take off the school fee's for 2 kids they'd be on 80K. So I'd say that it's pretty do-able round here on that sort of salary.

We have a combined income of 40K and I'm not sure where we could cut back to find the 10K a year for 1 child.

One of my kids will be attending the local national challenge comp in september, if I had a theoretical 10 grand I'd rather spend it on fun stuff for the whole family (holidays, gadgets, days out etc..) than on one set of school fee's.

sarah293 · 26/06/2010 12:01

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

janajos · 26/06/2010 11:45

It works out at 2-3000 per term where we are, depending on age and stage. It is cheaper than nursery at first, but a strange argument since children are only at nursery for a couple of years, the commitment to private prep is up to 10 years!!

We have a similar income and spaced out children, but manage to send 3 of them privately for prep, on the understanding (hope!!) that they will make the local grammar school (which is excellent). One of them has graduated already, and by the time the third starts, the second will be there too (we hope!!). My salary, by far the smaller, pays for the fees!!

I think it is worth paying the price as they benefit so much from the extra curricular activities and the sport is excellent. I also think it gives them a confidence that they don't necessarily get in the state sector. I am a teacher in the state system (grammar school) and I think both have pros and cons, but this is what we have chosen and it is possible to do it comfortably. We don't live a luxurious existence, but have an annual holiday and pay for tennis, swimming etc for boys as well as music outside school. It does depend on priorities and the time you have available.

Good luck on your decision.

GrungeBlobPrimpants · 26/06/2010 11:34

My quiet sensitive DH went to big rough comp

My quiet sensitive dcs go to big (good but with rough edges) comp. We're well 'ard

2rebecca · 26/06/2010 11:34

Our local private school offers bursaries to kids whose parental income combined is below an amount (I think 35kish)depending on performance in the entrance exam sat at 11/12 before starting S1. I suspect many parents just aren't aware of the bursary system though as state primaries don't mention it to parents of kids in P7.