Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think teachers do not need birthday gifts from pupils.

35 replies

livingontheedge · 24/06/2010 21:42

Last year it was the teacher's 40th Birthday and the kids all clubbed together (well the parents did) and bought her a cake.

This year I was a bit surprised to learn that their teacher had shared her birth date with the kids too! Yesterday morning half the class tripped in with Birthday Gifts for the teacher - I clearly didn't - but my dd was very embarrassed and I bit upset that she didn't have a gift for her teacher.

So now at our school the expectation is that you buy the teacher a Christmas Gift, an Easter Egg, a End of Year Gift and now a bloody Birthday Present too and because the vast majority do it - you look mean or unhappy with the teacher if you don't.

I really think the school should put an end to all this present nonsense - a homemade card or a drawing is fine, but don't you get the feeling this has all gone a bit mad?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FallacyTide · 08/11/2022 21:44

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster

helenwombat · 25/06/2010 12:42

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

helenwombat · 25/06/2010 12:38

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

lazarusb · 25/06/2010 12:33

I take cakes in for my class & staff on my birthday, certainly don't expect anything back!
Any staff leaving, having babies, getting married have staff collections but parents often have their own collections. As far as my dcs are concerned we keep gifts small & inexpensive!

MrsGangly · 25/06/2010 12:31

At secondary school, we held a birthday party (complete with presents and cake) for our A level maths teacher in one of the lessons after she had accidentally revealed her birthday. She was a very strict, old-fashioned teacher who really ensured that we knew our stuff but we knew that underneath that tough exterior, she really did like us and was very touched by our surprise.

Annner · 25/06/2010 12:23

Your child spends a lot of his or her time with their teacher. Particularly in Reception/ KS1 they come to adore them. I see my DD's teacher almost as I would her CM or nanny - she is her main carer during the day.

My DD knows that you mark the birthdays of people you care about, so if she had been told that it was her teacher's birthday, she would have wanted to make her a card or take her some wobbly chocolate muffins - in exactly the same way that she would for her other carers. It's healthy to think about making other people happy, and when you are five or six, you can't imagine anything making you more happy than having a birthday, or more sad than your birthday passing unmarked. That's all it is. Taking in presents at Easter has started, I think, because people have started to buy their DCs Easter presents in recent years and DCs assume that this is what is done.

Marking a birthday doesn't have to imply a consumer shopping fest. All teachers love to receive handmade / written notes, even if they don't have room to keep them all for ever.

I think that far too many people overlay their views with their own hang-ups from being surly adolescents who were certain that their teachers hated them (even though most of us don't have the time or energy to expend that strong an emotion on a single pupil!) It's an expression of attachment; no more; no less, which generally tapers out at the end of the primary years - reflected in how we secondary teachers rarely get anything, as by then we are taken for granted and just about tolerated.

LadySharrow · 25/06/2010 07:54

As a teacher, I can take or leave presents from my students. But I treasure, and have never ever thrown away, cards and thankyou messages.

A simple, personal message written by hand by the child that thanks the teacher for the impact he or she has had on them is priceless beyond all measure. I also keep thankyou notes from parents too.

mummytime · 25/06/2010 06:26

I actually liked one US teacher gift tradition that I heard occurs some places (definitely state school). That is the teachers hae a "wish list" of things like: Glue sticks, coloured pencils, fluffy pom poms, googly eyes, tissues, etc. So when parents wanted to buy a gift, they bought something off that list and it helped the class.
So much better than a Best Teacher mug from a kid who hates you! My kids usually give something edible, preferably home made. So its not expected to hang around for ages.

seenyertoeslately · 25/06/2010 06:06

You are definitely not being unreasonable. This teacher does not want your gifts! I have enough picture frames and candles to start a shop. These are often presented at the end of the year, when all I want to hear is how much the child has enjoyed school.

I really don't want birthday presents as well. Thank you. I consider that announcing your birthday to your class is very unprofessional.

Chil1234 · 25/06/2010 05:39

Anyone else get this one? Constant requests from other parents to chip into collections. The e-mail gushes that 'most people are giving £10' at Christmas and then one teacher got married, another one had a baby and the replacement teacher left at the end of the term. Birthdays they haven't cottoned onto yet, thank god.

I'm not anti-gifts in principle but I think they should be voluntary and down to the individual.... not some kind of unofficial cash bonus.

Henny1995 · 24/06/2010 23:50

As a teacher myself, I might share that today was my birthday with my kids, but would never expect a gift. I'd be mortified if I got one tbh, so would never tell in advance. But if I had a particularly excitable year 8 on my birthday for example, I might joke that they give me a really nice birthday by being ever so ever so good. Usually works, lol.

Goblinchild · 24/06/2010 23:39

I suppose treating gifts as unsolicited bribes might work.
Punish the child and prosecute the parent.

tethersend · 24/06/2010 23:26

I am always shocked at US maternity leave.

CarmenSanDiego · 24/06/2010 23:23

Tethers, you're probably right although it's the same for everyone. The job market is horrible and maternity pay is practically non-existant.

I think we were probably a bit our of our league

tethersend · 24/06/2010 23:18

Carmen, don't teachers get paid really badly in the US? I know their maternity leave etc is appalling. They probably need the money

I have never been bought a birthday present, but if a child should happen to buy me one in the future, rest assured I will thrust it straight back into their hands along with a tersely worded note about professional standards. Then give them detention. Twice.

mitochondria · 24/06/2010 22:58

YANBU.

I'm a teacher. I don't tell the pupils when my birthday is.
One year some found out.
They sang me "Happy Birthday"

EvilTwins · 24/06/2010 22:57

NetworkGuy - nah, I teach secondary. No one bothers to get secondary teachers presents. Ever. Unless they leave. And I think you're being totally OTT to suggest that something "official" should be done. What do you suggest? A new law?

CarmenSanDiego · 24/06/2010 22:56

Judy... It's a San Diego 'Montessori' school although I use the term 'Montessori' very loosely.

Goblin. I agree. These sorts of gifts should be entirely personal and optional otherwise they're pretty much meaningless. It's the same argument as for tipping.

Goblinchild · 24/06/2010 22:53

No, all it needs is parents to grow a backbone and say no to excessive demands from other parents. Do they crumble in the face of high-pressure sales pitches in other aspects of their lives?
Are they shallow enough to think that teachers will punish their child if tribute is not offered like some petty deity?
Just don't follow the herd and the cult will wither away.

judytzuke · 24/06/2010 22:50

carmen - where is this school and how can I apply??

Have never had a birthday card or present in 18 years of teaching.

It's all very kind but I don't want the end of term ones/Xmas ones either - rather parents spent it on their children esp. we are all now strapped for money. and some parnets always go to far and make it all about how they give a bigger/better present tha others which is horrible for the children.

NetworkGuy · 24/06/2010 22:49

I think YANBU. It certainly should have something 'done' officially to put a stop to it.

EvilTwins - you say you knew of no teachers getting birthday gifts, but did they get an Easter Egg or other seasonal gifts? What if some teacher does not celebrate Christmas (or Easter) ?

From the OP : "Christmas Gift, an Easter Egg, a End of Year Gift and now a bloody Birthday Present too"

Yes, I think maybe an end of year gift (esp if the teacher might not see the pupils again, either teacher moving on, or pupils changing school) but two of the others are for Christian festivals, and might even offend, and the birthday gift is surely unwarranted (and if solicited, unprofessional, too).

CarmenSanDiego · 24/06/2010 22:39

Let me cut and paste the last 'teacher appreciation' email from my children's former school....

"Dear parents,
I wanted to thank you so very much for your generous donations to our Room 8 teacher appreciation fund. We had 20 out of 22 families participating and collected a total of $1180.
During the room 8 holiday party, Ms Teresa received your gift of $400. She was so delighted and appreciative. Additionally, our special subject teachers were given $50 holiday gifts from our class. Thank you for showing our teachers your appreciation through your generosity."

This was in addition to cakes, flowers etc. for birthdays. The fundraising in US private schools is absolutely out of control. Yet another reason I'm very, VERY glad we're HEing nowadays.

Goblinchild · 24/06/2010 22:31

I do admire parents who don't follow the herd.
I've had lovely and expensive gifts from parents and children that have actively disliked me and I found that very odd.
Not the disliking you understand

MrsC2010 · 24/06/2010 22:30

Some people know when my birthday is, but I certainly wouldn't expect presents. Do you know for definite that the teacher expected presents? If she didn't then YABU, it is up to the individual. I think the 40th thing is different, 'milestone' birthdays are nice to celebrate.

cat64 · 24/06/2010 22:27

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn