Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To complain to the school.

82 replies

honeymom · 21/06/2010 11:22

That they think it's appropriate to take children on an educational trip to the beach today, where there is very little shade and the children will be exposed to the midday sun for nearly 5 hours, even with good suncream reapplied regually I would never keep my children in the sun for that long, So why on earth would the school think it's a good idea?

It seems that if you are a school you can just ignore Every bit of sun safety information out there? should I complain or am I be unreasonable?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FallacyTide · 08/11/2022 21:41

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster

majafa · 22/06/2010 10:23

Sorry to be a bit here,
but not all schools have the sense, not ours thats for sure, imo.
Our school playing field is in full sun, no shade all day. There are no trees, just bushes around the perimiter.
A couple of years ago whilst working at said school, our sports day was unusually hot, they put up, 1 (no sides) gazebo for approx 200 kids, plus parents and staff.
This was from 1.30 - 3.30,
I cant see why they couldnt have held it in the morning, when its cooler.

GetOrfMoiLand · 21/06/2010 14:01

I think that the school would be sensible enouugh to make sure that there was anough shade on the beach, surely, for those which needed it.

Mind you people are still not as vigilant as they could be. This stuff does concern me (grew up on a beach, had skin cancer at 30).

I know it's easy to take the piss and say that people are over zealous about stuff like this, but I think it is a valid concern.

MmeLindt · 21/06/2010 13:55

Risk Assessment?

Jeez. I am glad we don't live in UK.

I do not sunbathe. I put cream on myself and on the DC if we are going to be out in the sun. We live in Geneva where we do get hot summers and we are used to the dangers of the sun.

It can be 25°C at 10am here, and over 30°C at 6pm.

Should I not let my DC play outside all summer because of that?

As to going to the beach in the Spring, I seem to remember reading that the sun is more dangerous in Spring because it is closer to the earth. Not sure if that is true though.

Morloth · 21/06/2010 13:32

Trees shed branches honeymoon, more than one child has been killed by a falling tree branch.

Shade can be dangerous as well.

Life is dangerous you can't protect them from it.

You picked them up in the car? My god, how could you take such a risk!

tyler80 · 21/06/2010 13:20

I was camping at the weekend and saw one parent putting sun lotion on their kids at 7.30 in the evening because they were sat in the sun eating their dinner!

I think it's important that people take the sun seriously but stuff like the above isn't a proportional response.

honeymom · 21/06/2010 13:09

My garden is very shady , and yes I do seriously avoid any long periods in the midday sun between late may Early September , No they didn't take tents and umbrellas, they are in year 3 so 8 years old,

I just think the school should be more sun aware they could have done this trip easily in spring when the sun isn't as dangerous,

OP posts:
kerstina · 21/06/2010 13:04

I think you are worrying too much . I think the teachers will be very aware of keeping the kids safe. It really would be a shame for them to miss out on a trip to the seaside.
I hardly ever but some cream on my son unless it is really hot and we are out in it for a long period. He has not burnt. I think sometimes cream does more harm than good as it stops you building up the skins natural protection .You just have to be sensible.

luciemule · 21/06/2010 13:03

If the school weren't going to literally be on the beach for all 5 hours, then perhaps they should have written more details in a letter; giving parents more of an idea and thus not making them worry.

Greensleeves · 21/06/2010 13:01

yes it IS because they are lazy

Vallhala · 21/06/2010 13:01

Honeymom, the chances of succumbing to skin cancer by a child whose parents are forewarned of a single one day trip and thus are prepared and can take sensible precautions are, I would imagine, almost nil.

Surely too, the children are not going to be on a beach for 5 hours solid? What the hell will the staff do with them, kids get bored, even on a beach. I'd imagine that if only for this reason the sitting on the beach will be interdispersed with other activity.

I'm tempted to ask about your opinion of your DD crossing the road to make my point clear but that would make this thread descend into chaos and besides I have work to do!

Suffice to say that despite all the worst case scenarios and, imo, "scared to live" attitudes, I remain convinced that in the particular circumstances you've described you are over-reacting.

choccyp1g · 21/06/2010 13:00

I think YANBU at all. All the sun-safe advice is to stay out of it around the hours of 11-2, especially on the beach. Apart from sun burn and heat stroke, the bright midday sun can also damage eyes.
Personally I would hate to be forced onto a hot beach all day, even covered in sun-cream. (and hat and long sleeves). Even the very high factors all say you should re-apply every half-hour.

luciemule · 21/06/2010 13:00

being in the garden/school playground with canopies/shelter/trees and shade is very different than being on an open beach at midday with no shelter.
Honeymom is very sensible and is only doing what govt.guidelines tell everyone to do.
It doesn't mean she's not letting her kids have fun - she's just doing other stuff in the really hot hours when the sun is far more damaging.
What about the spanish having siestas for 2 hours at lunch time - it's not because they're lazy.

OrmRenewed · 21/06/2010 12:59

BTW I don't sunbathe. Ever. It's boring and too hot. But I do subject myself to the sun whilst doing something else. With lotion and hats etc.

MrsC2010 · 21/06/2010 12:58

I would certainly never sunbathe over lunchtime, in fact I never sunbathe at all. I wear suntan lotion at all times once the sun is out, and despite spending all of my summers (literally) on the beach or on the water I can count the number of times I have burnt on one hand. As said, I'm not trying to dismiss your worries, but don't dismiss others as idiots. Tell the school you are not giving permission for your child to be taken out of school.

luciemule · 21/06/2010 12:57

Think they wouldn't have a leg to stand on if you mentioned them being on the beach in the midday sun.

tell them to take it off your 10 days allowance for the year - then it's authorized.

GettinTrimmer · 21/06/2010 12:57

did the school take umbrellas, tents, etc for protection?

Haggisfish · 21/06/2010 12:57

Oh tosh - you won't get a fine for one unauthorised absence. They only fine repeat offenders, after the local council attnedance officer has been involved. I am quite sure if the school tried to make an issue of this, you could write to the head of governors and express your (quite sensible) concerns and explain why you got your DD.

Greensleeves · 21/06/2010 12:56

honeymom what about playing outside at school over lunchtime for up to an hour?

what about playing in the garden?

do you REALLY keep your children out of direct sunlight unless it's dawn or twilight?

have you seen "The Others"?

Morloth · 21/06/2010 12:55

Not exactly rocket science.

honeymom · 21/06/2010 12:55

I did go and get them in the end, and now I risk a fine for keeping them off unauthorized can't bloody win,

my children love trips to the beach, but I take them early morning or later in the afternoon I would never take them over lunch time,

OP posts:
OrmRenewed · 21/06/2010 12:54

Quite morloth.

I have no issue with people protecting their skin and that of their children, but not at the expense of actually doing things. Suncream, long sleeves and hats?

luciemule · 21/06/2010 12:53

okay - was generalising - some people worry more than others but that doesn't mean OP is worrying without reason.

Morloth · 21/06/2010 12:52

So keep your children home and let everyone else get on with their fun trip.

GeekOfTheWeek · 21/06/2010 12:52

honeymom, if you were that concerned you should have kept her off.