Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I saw something yesterday

57 replies

mrspir8 · 20/06/2010 23:13

My freind has a son who is 5, we were at a BBQ of another mutual friend. The boy was playing with my DD (2yr10mnth) and he would not share his toys with her and took one back from her. My dd wasn't at all bothered by this, it was a very minor scuffle, no anger involved but cue this boys dad, who is also a freind by default but I have very little to do with him, we used to be avery close pair of couples, but we have drifted apart and the lads are no longer freinds.
He comes storming from end of garden, dragged boy up to the top of the lawn proceeded to tell him off in a very quiet voice while gripping his wrist really tightly the whole time. The lad came back with horrid red marks all over his wrist.

I was very very uncomfortable and felt this was both excessive and cruel.
So putting on my judgeymcJudgey hat I pass the floor over for your comments.

OP posts:
Vallhala · 20/06/2010 23:58

The "I shall totally ignore my darling older child snatching from smaller one and get terribly offended if the other child's parents find it unacceptable" technique is well known too, Colliecross.

The child behaved in an unacceptable manner. Whilst I don't agree with the red arm, admonishing him was perfectly appropriate imho.

Had the father not, a less tolerant parent than the OP would have been terribly cross and offended. Had he made a big, loud fuss about his son's actions, I'm sure that someone would have complained that he was behaving inappropriately by humiliating the boy.

My DC, when they were 5, would have also been in the mire from snatching and refusing to share. I am one of those who have experienced damn family members overindulged children who were allowed to snatch and refuse to share as the parent believed that "they're his toys, why should he have to share them". I know which way I'd rather my DC behaved and which type of child and parent I'd rather be with.

Tombliboob · 20/06/2010 23:49

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

booyhoo · 20/06/2010 23:39

red marks not ok but the rest sems normal.

i have taken to the gritted teeth warning several times with ds1. he is almost 5.

Colliecross · 20/06/2010 23:36

I thought this adult bullying technique was well known - grip little hand excruciatingly tightly while saying "Not long now darling; shopping's nearly finished and we can go home, why are you crying?' etc in a really really sweet voice.
Honestly it can't be new to all of you?

DSM · 20/06/2010 23:24

Don't see the problem either.

IYO the grip was too tight, but it doesn't sound like he lost his temper, you said he spoke quietly to him, not shouting etc, seems okay to me?

Tombliboob · 20/06/2010 23:20

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Vallhala · 20/06/2010 23:18

I guess if Dad had left it or laughed it off some parents would (understandably) complain. Sometimes you can't win.

At 5 the lad is old enough to know to share, and who knows, maybe he'd been told off for the same actions only earlier or the previous day? I'm not justifying Dad making a mark on the lad but I think I can understand his outlook, to a point.

The telling off wasn't excessive, the marks on his arm were, imho.

Swipe left for the next trending thread