Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

that huge buggies should be banned from buses

188 replies

donkeyderby · 04/03/2010 00:37

I was on the bus yesterday, and a woman got on pushing her child in an oversized buggy that took up four fold-up seat spaces.

AIBU to think that if you travel regularly by bus, you should invest in a cheap umbrella-style pushchair that takes only one space up?

OP posts:
OtterInaSkoda · 04/03/2010 11:36

Of course someone with a wheelchair has first dibs on the space over unfolded pushchairs, but I wouldn't want someone with a large pushchair filled with shopping to have to unload all their stuff, and the baby, and then try to fold it unecessarily.

Large pushchairs are often easier to push, allow you to carry plenty of grocery shopping and are often a better place for a baby to be than some piddly little buggy.

YABU.

DorotheaPlenticlew · 04/03/2010 11:31

Crossed posts between me and LittleMrsHappy illustrate how very differently designed the buses are in different towns.

LittleMrsHappy · 04/03/2010 11:29

Even a standard buggy, will take up for seats due to the way the buses are designed around here, as does a wheelchair, due to the design off the buses!

I never unfold my pushchair, as simply those spaces are allocated for pushchair/wheelchair users, I never sit on a bus, and I cannot handle two children getting onto a bus, folding down ds pushchair, while the fucking idiot driver drives off with me trying to get pushchair into holding, carrying ds 7 months, and trying to guide dc 4 so he doesn't fall over because the idiot driver refused to wait till everybody is seated! countless times this has happened even tho I have complained numerous times to the bus company!

My children's safety far far over rides a seat for a abled bodied passenger, which is why I use the space which is designed for pushchair passengers!

I couldn't care what anybody else thought, I use and pay for a service that is provided for me and my pushchair (loola)

DorotheaPlenticlew · 04/03/2010 11:29

MillyR, what if it's a young baby? Usually in a big buggy, that's who's travelling. Or a toddler, technically old enough to sit up, but fast asleep?

"A buggy is not a person" -- OK, but the occupant is.

And surely taking up the seats of 4 adults is very much the exception? In most cases the buggy takes up only one more space than a regular passenger would. Actually most of the time I found that me and my "big" buggy together still only took up 2 normal passenger spaces.

Again I think one can't make massive generalizations, they just don't ring true enough. The variety of circumstances in which they have to apply is just too great for it to ever work.

What a futile thread, not sure why I am getting so caught up in it really! Must return to RL ...

Alicetheinvisible · 04/03/2010 11:29

I think Strue was using SARCASM to make a point.

I wonder wrt safety of toddler/baby in a buggy or sat on a bus seat. Does anyone know of any research?

MillyR · 04/03/2010 11:23

Strue, I think you need to justify that analogy. At the moment it just sounds like you are comparing black people to what is essentially an item of luggage.

MillyR · 04/03/2010 11:21

Why Mazzy? Why should people stand on a bus because a parent cannot be bothered to fold their buggy up? A buggy is not a person and a toddler in a buggy can sit on one seat rather than take up 4. It is is just selfishness to believe your child should be able to take the seats of 4 adults.

DorotheaPlenticlew · 04/03/2010 11:20

Nope, in Edinburgh it has been thus ever since I had DS at least, a few years ago. One unfolded buggy at a time. There are signs and the drivers constantly restate it to anyone boarding with a second buggy, size notwithstanding.

I just think it's the kind of thing where it's impossible to make a blanket condemnation; it would be better if everyone (buggy users included, but also other passengers) stepped up their efforts to realize that the bus is meant to be for everyone insofar as possible, and to behave accordingly rather than tutting (in the case of other passengers) or barging around inconsiderately (in the case of buggy users).

"Banning" buggies that are "too big" ... well, ok, how do you do that exactly? Issue measurements for height, width and length? Get the driver to enforce them to the centimetre? Not plausible, so you'd have to take the Lothian Buses angle that all unfoldable buggies are banned, which brings problems of its own as illustrated with that young girl with the new baby in a hand-me-down pram and no other way of getting into town. Any outright ban just serves to alienate a lot of people who are regular paying bus users and genuinely need the service; and the wider benefits are questionable.

As long as everyone knows, and signage makes clear, that wheelchair users absolutely have priority (and sadly not everyone does know this, as per this thread I guess) then I think that's enough in terms of regulation. The rest is down to people not being arses to each other (sadly unenforceable, hey ho)

mrsruffallo · 04/03/2010 11:18
Hmm
thedollshouse · 04/03/2010 11:16

What????

strue · 04/03/2010 11:13

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

mrsruffallo · 04/03/2010 11:06

Really? Here in London two buggies are allowed on the buses unfolded

swanandduck · 04/03/2010 11:04

YANBU. You have made it perfectly clear that you are talking about 'unnecessarily' large prams, not people with disabled children/twins/baby and tiny toddler.

DorotheaPlenticlew · 04/03/2010 11:03

I think it's like anything, there are shades of grey and it really depends on your attitude and how much effort you make to be considerate. It is not necessarily the case that getting on a bus with a larger buggy causes other passengers a problem. Often times it is totally fine, there is enough space and as for bashing knees/shopping, I've not been aware of that happening (and believe me I would have noticed as I'm quite self-conscious about these things).

If you are polite and considerate with your buggy, and willing to try and be a bit flexible about avoiding the most crowded buses, I can't see why anyone should be tutting. Different buggies suit different families, not everyone makes their selection based purely on the convenience of bus passengers they might one day encounter.

As for leaving no room for another buggy well, here at least, there is officially only one buggy allowed unfolded on the bus at a time regardless of size so having a small one doesn't mean there is "room" for another, they'd still have to fold down. It's an insurance thing, apparently.

mazzystartled · 04/03/2010 11:00

No way Milly

I agree with 1 & 2 (and would extend number 2 to elderly people and pregnant women)

Able-bodied people can stand. Or gosh, even go and sit a little bit further back.

mrsruffallo · 04/03/2010 10:53

Tired mummy, yes, it is a free country but we all need to be considerate of others.
Why didn't you choose a slimmer model if you knew you were going to use a bus on a regular basis?

mrsruffallo · 04/03/2010 10:52

YANBU
If you know you are regularly going to use a bus it most inconsiderate to use onwe of these buggies as;
They don't fold up easily

They bash everyone's knees and shopping as they go past

They hold everyone up as they manouvre the bloody thing down the aisle

There is no room for another buggy to fit in

MillyR · 04/03/2010 10:48

The order of use for a wheelchair space should be:

  1. A wheelchair user or a child in a disabled buggy.
  2. A disabled person using the fold down seats.
  3. Able bodied people using the fold down seats if the other seats are all full.
  4. A baby or toddler in an unfolded buggy.

It is absurd that parents are prepared to prevent a wheelchair space, or make 4 people stand, just because they won't fold their pushchair.

I had a big 3 wheel pushchair and a folding double buggy. I folded them up before the bus arrived and put them in the parcel area. So I don't think pushchairs should be banned from buses, but I think bus drivers should be able to have some discretion over an unfolded buggy being allowed on a bus.

DorotheaPlenticlew · 04/03/2010 10:47

A year or two back, I was on a bus (without DS) in a very run-down area of Edinburgh (dilapidated low-income housing with a sad look about it and no local shops to speak of) and saw a teenage girl with a baby in a big old-fashioned pram, obviously handed down, getting turned away from the bus because this was the period when the Lothian bus company had its Great Buggy War and banned anyone with an un-foldable buggy or pram. Hers clearly could not fold.

She also clearly was upset and clearly had no other way of getting into the bit of town where you might wish to purchase, I dunno, food, or nappies or whatever . I remember thinking, WTF is she supposed to do? Use her copious disposable income to get a taxi? I wasn't on the same bus btw, I was on the one behind and could see/kind of hear the situation from the window while we idled waiting to pull in. I still feel bad thinking about it.

sarah293 · 04/03/2010 10:41

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

DorotheaPlenticlew · 04/03/2010 10:39

Rollmops, I think that a wheelchair has a legal right to that space over anyone else. It's just free for buggies as long as a wheelchair user doesn't need it. Which seems reasonable. Although some of the very new buses here in Edinburgh have a wheelchair space AND a buggy space, which is handy.

I had a buggy that some people probably considered "huge" (can we have an actual definition of huge, please? No? Thought not, 'cos everyone has an opinion on what is Unacceptably Big, usually if it gets in their way) and I don't drive so was on buses a lot. Would always get out of the way for a chair if needed though. It was a Quinny Buzz so folding was PITA and more often than not I just hopped off and waited for a bus with free space.

Tiredmumno1 · 04/03/2010 10:29

Oh bloody hell, this is a free country anyone can get on the bloody bus with what they want, you see its you that is the sort of person that makes me not want to go on a bus and i have to walk miles to get to town, its a bloody disgrace, i dont hear you moaning about others that take up a whole seat with shopping, god i am angry.

mazzystartled · 04/03/2010 10:23

YABU

No-one who is sane would use a mega buggy on public transport for the FUN of it. If you have several small children, but no car, what are you meant to do?

It's not a problem as long as people behave considerately, and move for wheelchair users.

Morloth · 04/03/2010 10:19

Agree with Riven it is a wheelchair space which buggies can use if a wheelchair user doesn't need it, not the other way around. There are signs on London buses saying exactly that.

People with kids in buggies have choices, those choices may be a massive PITA but someone in a wheelchair doesn't have the same ones.

PurpleCrazyHorse · 04/03/2010 10:19

We got a Quinny Zapp precisely because I'd be regularly using public transport and I didn't want to inconvenience other people by having a huge buggy. However, I would say that I still had trouble getting it into the pram space so I think buses could be better designed too. It was brilliant on The Tube last week, I'm not sure I could have done that with a big pram.

Swipe left for the next trending thread