Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

that huge buggies should be banned from buses

188 replies

donkeyderby · 04/03/2010 00:37

I was on the bus yesterday, and a woman got on pushing her child in an oversized buggy that took up four fold-up seat spaces.

AIBU to think that if you travel regularly by bus, you should invest in a cheap umbrella-style pushchair that takes only one space up?

OP posts:
NormalityBites · 04/03/2010 18:09

My DD is 105cm and 44lbs I'm by no means a martyr, don't carry her for long these days but if she needs up, she can go up and it is comfortable and fun for both of us. Gets a little tiring after an hour or so but when she was under two I could carry her all day on my back without a problem if it was required.

ToccataAndFudge · 04/03/2010 18:04

Jenny - what do you think a stranger on the bus is going to do to your baby????

Normality - nice that you have a 3.5yr old small enough to comfortably carry in a sling .

DS1 HATED slings, DS2 didn't mind them (but I never needed to use one really with him as he was so chilled out and could just be put down, and walked pretty early), DS3 also hated slings. And DS3 isn't yet 3 and there's no way I'd be carrying him around a 3 1/2yrs old (even in a sling on my back) when he's already up to my waist in height

sarah293 · 04/03/2010 18:03

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

runnybottom · 04/03/2010 18:03

What do you think the middle aged woman/ little old man/ teenager would do with the baby in the 30 seconds they were holding it? On a bus, where they are surrounded by people and can't go anywhere?

FFS. Its not really an issue is it? Buggies go on where they fit, make sure you're not annoying anyone, clear out for wheelchairs/the elderly/additional needs passengers, fold if you need to...or fuck off the bus. Not really rocket science is it?

NormalityBites · 04/03/2010 17:58

Yep my alternate means of getting around is a sling, and I've been using it from newborn onwards (3.5 years currently and still using it) Never had a pushchair so never taken one on pt

JennyPenny22 · 04/03/2010 17:55

I would never hand my baby to a stranger! No matter how friendly or old they look!

KERALA1 · 04/03/2010 16:29

I hand the baby to the nearest friendly looking person while I fold/deal with the myriad of bags/toddler etc. Due to free bus passes and times when I use the buses the buses here are usually rammed with elderly people who love getting involved .

What annoys me is vacant unencumbered twentysomethings who sit in the folding seats at the front when there are lots of other seats at the back for them.

sarah293 · 04/03/2010 16:20

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

ToccataAndFudge · 04/03/2010 16:06

Riven - what do you do if your 1yr old isn't walking yet .

You know all these "this is how you do it" posts are making me

it's all so subjective, it depends on so many things how "easy" (or not) it is, the particular children, the sort of bus it is, how arsey the bus driver is (I wouldn't DARE let any of my children go and find a seat in front of me on the local buses if they were under about 4/5yrs old as none of the local drivers seem to like to pull of nicely and I usually nearly get thrown......), how busy the buses are, etc etc etc.

LJBrownie · 04/03/2010 16:00

Several issues with that apparently simple approach on my local London buses:

  1. Rarely room in luggage rack for any shopping and certainly not to stowe a whole pushchair
  1. Unlikely to be seats near front of bus for me and toddler+baby and able bodied adults usually quite happy to see 2 year old standing (understandable in that she is quite capable of it and I'm happy to hold her hand but more difficult while also standing holding baby)
  1. Bus drivers here never wait until you're seated before setting off, not even for people with obvious mobility issues - cue toddlers falling all over the place
  1. If driver does wait, whole bus tuts with irritation about the delay while I load all my stuff separately on board

So, overall, it'd be far quicker for me to manoeuvre my umbrella fold maclaren with baby and shopping into the space which'll fit at least 2 buggies (or a buggy and wheelchair) and keep holding my 2 year old's hand throughout (and in fact use up zero seats in the process). Not sure why anyone would have a problem with this - I just don't understand the ardent, pushchairs-must-be-folded-brigade. Of course, except where wheelchairs are involved.

sarah293 · 04/03/2010 15:50

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

LJBrownie · 04/03/2010 15:47

Totally agree that most of the time, there is no need for folding to enable able-bodied adults to sit - they could just walk a little further down the bus or shock-horror, upstairs and take a seat with ease.

I am genuinely not sure how MillyR managed her shopping, folded pushchair, toddler and baby. I am no pussy, really I'm not, and I think that's a pretty challenging undertaking! In fact, on buses near us I have had several tuts for allowing my 2 year old DD to stand holding my hand next to my umbrella fold buggy laden with baby and shopping because apparently she was in the way. Less tutting, more smiling/pleasantness/tolerance for everyone else would be much appreciated!!

KERALA1 · 04/03/2010 15:46

No YANBU I totally agree. Makes practical sense for parents that regularly use public transport to get a small foldable buggy. For their own sakes and all the other travellers. You can get 2 Mclarens in the space taken up by 1 of these huge buggies and if its me left in the rain because someone has chosen to get a swanky red designer thing that hogs the whole buggy space its hard not to feel a little peeved.

I know of 5 London first time mums who bought bugaboos, quickly realised that taking those on public transport is tough so then bought and used McClarens. They basically wasted £600 apiece. Marvellous for the makers of Bugaboos but expensive mistakes for new parents.

tw888 · 04/03/2010 15:44

YABU

ToccataAndFudge · 04/03/2010 15:38

"Irrelevant to me as I've never ever needed to take a chair on pt, with just the one kid."

well you obviously have other means of getting around then - as those of us who rely on our feet and pt do invariably at some point have to go on pt with a pushchair

ToccataAndFudge · 04/03/2010 15:33

well yes Riven folding works - if there's somewhere to put the folded pushchair

sarah293 · 04/03/2010 15:31

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Asana · 04/03/2010 15:21

Blah, blah, blah. Have Stokke Xplory, take bus, would get off for wheelchair user or if bus extremely busy i.e. no available seats. My Stokke actually takes up just one fold-up seat space despite other uneducated idiots' people's opinions, yet I get nasty comments from all and sundry on buses that AREN'T full/have empty seats just because people are rude knobheads want to find something to whine about.

I love my Stokke. My DS is high up which, given my chronic back pain, removes the need to bend over continuously to adjust his clothes/pick him up/put him down/comfort him etc, it moves like a dream and has a humongous shopping bag for the occasions where I have to do emergency grocery/assorted shopping which means I don't have to carry/balance massive shopping bags on it or on my person, I use it as a highchair when I need to feed my DS when out and about etc etc etc. Those who don't like it simply because they have their humoungous judgey pants on can lump it. Just my tuppence on the matter ...

Tiredmumno1 · 04/03/2010 14:52

I certainly do not want another umbrella buggy, i hate the bloody things, mine is like the 4x4 of buggies and i love it, thinking back to those poor buggers trying to pull theirs through the snow, where as mine handles any surface i wouldnt give it up for no bugger . Cant we all just agree to disagree, and the next time it happens just dont judge first.

TottWriter · 04/03/2010 14:49

My god, Riven, where do you live? Am that lots of your buses have no wheelchair access at all. Around here they all have that - I thought it was a legal requirement.

sarah293 · 04/03/2010 14:40

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

nannynobnobs · 04/03/2010 14:37

Our bus service has a mixture of good and crap buses. The good ones allow three unfolded buggies on, the crap ones no unfolded buggies at all. The bus company has just bought four new buses for the route I live on; they are much smaller and take either one unfolded buggy or one wheelchair. However the drivers are fairly flexible; last week a woman in a wheelchair got on when there was a pregnant woman with a sleeping toddler in the space, and they both fitted in without difficulty with plenty of room to get on and off.
Personally I utterly fail to see the point that an able- bodied person should get the folding seat instead of the child in the buggy. It's called a buggy space- it says so on the window! They provide handles for standing people. If my DD is asleep and I have heavy shopping hanging off my buggy, like fuck am I going to wrestle with the whole bloody shebang just so someone perfectly able to stand for the short journey can sit.

MoChan · 04/03/2010 14:23

You know what I'd like to ban from buses? Those people who refuse to go and sit upstairs because they're not going very far. They take up all the standing space downstairs, and mean that the bus driver then can't let people get on to go upstairs to take the spare seats.

Sorry, tangent.

TottWriter · 04/03/2010 14:16

I'm just grateful that I live in the centre of town with all these judgey people about. I can't drive at the moment (epilepsy), and if I had to use a bus to get my shopping home, I would clearly be one of these wicked people who take up lots of space on a bus with 'bags hanging all over the place', despite having an umbrella fold now my DS is bigger.

Mind you, we need to move, as I'm 20wks and our house isn't big enough. So soon I'll have two young children and probably be further out. Yes, I will be taking up space with my 'oversized' pram so that my new DC isn't harmed (I've never seen a cheap umbrella fold which lies flat, and can't afford more than the cheap prams) and I will have another child with me, so am not prepared to fart about folding it up after unloading all the shopping into the undersized bay. Thank christ all the busses here have enough room for two buggies (well, not huge ones) and a wheelchair.

Yes, the spaces are for disabled people, but why should I have to physically get off a bus and wait (in what weather would you deem it unreasonable?) because I have a malfunctioning brain and therefore can't drive? I agree with you Riven that the priority must be for your disabled child, but I think it's too black and white to have a blanket 'you get off' statement. In a situation where the bus comes every ten minutes, fine. But living further out often means waiting for half an hour to an hour. Why should any mother with a small child be simply ejected onto the roadside because the bus system is so unflexible? There should be additional legislation to provide as much space in the front as we have here on ALL buses.

And to the poster who was angered by the prams making people stand, why should people without children present object to standing because a small child needs the space? I used to catch a very oversubscribed bus service which ran every hour between my village and the town, then onto another town which actually had proper shops. The bus drivers were (mostly) excellent, and did not stop people getting on even when (very often) they were jammed standing in the aisles because of several prams on at once. It was a poor area - clearly the people using the service could not afford to drive. If they had not been allowed on the bus, they would have been confined to their homes. Very nice.

proudestmummyever · 04/03/2010 13:34

Yeah riven you knw that I have Jack too who is severely disabled, and cannot sit in a seat, can't hold himself up, so yeh Jack and other disabled ppl come first.

But I feel it's not right to put a newborn in a bloody umbrella fold buggy that is not comfy for them, I have always had a big pram for both my kids and thts my right