Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be a bit perturbed by somebody taking a small girl to the gents loo?

139 replies

FourArms · 27/10/2008 09:29

On a family day out last Saturday, I saw a bloke take a small girl (over 5, under 10 - rubbish with ages!) into the blokes loo. I think that there was some kind of single dad's trip on - lots of blokes with kids came off a coach at the same time. I can understand him not letting her go to the ladies by herself, but there was a vacant disabled/baby changing loo which they could have used.

I've got no problems with boys of any age being taken by their mums into the ladies - there's nothing to see after all, but I'm not sure about a girl being taken into the gents where she might see other blokes using the urinals.

AIBU to be a bit wierded out by this? Luckily for me I've got two boys, so will continue to take them to the ladies with me / use a disabled loo as appropriate. I know that there was another thread about letting boys use a gents by themselves recently, but this feels a bit different to me.

OP posts:
QuintessentialShadows · 27/10/2008 11:57

I disagree with the OPs astonishment.

However, I dont get why a child of reception age cant go to their gender specific toilets by themselves, with mum/dad/carer waiting outside. It is not as if their teachers are coming with them to the toilet in school, so clearly they can do the business by themselves.

Kewcumber · 27/10/2008 11:57

I think how you feel about this will be influenced by how you feel about your children seeing nudity generally. If it isn;t something you are relaxed about at home then I can quite understand that you might feel uncomfortable about it.

Personally I don;t think its a big issue if your DD was with her father and presumably she was using a cubicle and not attmepting to use a urinal!

If the DD was over 5 she was also able to comminucate with her dad. Can't imagine many 5-10 year olds not letting their fatehr very clearly know if they felt uncomfortable with something, they're not reknowned for keeping their opinions to themselves

ewwwmy2shoesarefullofblood · 27/10/2008 11:53

read the op and agree with theSuburbanDryad@s second post

FAQ · 27/10/2008 11:50
leaxx · 27/10/2008 11:48

i agree ping ping, something must have happend in there lives to make them so suspicously worried about girls usin the fellas toilets with there dad

TheFallenMadonna · 27/10/2008 11:48

I find the OP rather disturbing actually. I think it is an unpleasant thing to think.

pingping · 27/10/2008 11:47

TBH I always thought it was weird that people would think any thing into these situtions. Maybe something about them aint right.

tiredsville · 27/10/2008 11:46

My DH didn't even like my DS going to the gents up until he was around 7. He always made me take DS to ladies claiming the mens toilets were filthy and hand washing was non existent. He is obsessed with hygiene and a complete bossy boots on the subject of cleanliness. Yawn

Fennel · 27/10/2008 11:44

My DP regularly takes some or all of our 3 dds to the men's loo, what else would he do?

I had a run-in with an angry woman recently who totally disapproved of me taking my desperate 4yo into a disabled loo. She argued that adults got desparate too. She was very cross indeed, it put me off using the disabled loos with children.

pingping · 27/10/2008 11:44

YABU! FGS I don't know what the problem is I am pretty sure if a Father took his DD in the toilet and another man started to wave his bits at her the Father would deal with it.

Not all men are Paedophiles

leaxx · 27/10/2008 11:42

i cant get over this, there is nothing wrong with an innocent little girl goin to do a pee with her father, and why i mother would feel any different is beyond me!!!

PsychoAxeMurdererMum · 27/10/2008 11:40

My DH has had to take our DD's into the mens while out with them on his own.

I trust his judgement, and it is not as tho they would be able to see much anyway. if it is his child, YABU.

RideEmCowboy · 27/10/2008 11:39

Not sure I understand your problem tbh. Is it:

a) girls shouldn't see penises?
b) all men are paedophiles?

mumeeee · 27/10/2008 11:37

YABu, If he was own his own with the child that was the best thing to do. The disabled toulet might have ben locked.

mrsgboring · 27/10/2008 10:25

Ladies loos are always crowded because they're full of children (who would be traumatised by going in the men's ). Men's loos are always disgusting because they rarely have the civilising influence of men needing to take their kids in and therefore requiring it to be less revolting in there. Can anyone suggest a simple solution to this?

FWIW I wandered into a men's loo on my own aged about 5 and lived to tell the tale. Twas only quite a lot later on that I realised it was quite unusual to have a chat with a friendly male stranger whilst washing my hands.

ratherbesleeping · 27/10/2008 10:24

Agree, agree, agree

There is nothing wrong with it and I'm sorry but you come across as ever so prissy.

NomDePlume · 27/10/2008 10:23

YABU

weird for it even to occur to OP imo

joyfuleyes · 27/10/2008 10:22

YABU & very silly really.

RedOnHerBeheadedHead · 27/10/2008 10:21

@ "how far you can piss contest!"

TheWomanWhoAteTraffic · 27/10/2008 10:15

Unless a group of rugby boys having a 'how far can you piss contest' were in there first no issue at all.

RedOnHerBeheadedHead · 27/10/2008 10:13

"Although being inside the cubicle with him would have been even worse"

WHAT?????
HE WAS HER FATHER FGS!!!!!

I have an almost 4yr old and I bath with him and he sees me changing and naked quite regularly! I see nothing wrong with this, and would think that many people feel the same. We have had the talk about inappropriate touch and private parts, but theres nothing disgusting about the human body. Men have penises women have vaginas and breasts - GET OVER IT!

There is nothing wrong with a father taking his daughter into the gents with him. I've been in the gents and they don't show anything! At that age, all a willy is used for is weeing!

Buda · 27/10/2008 10:06

DH hates having to take DS into the gents! He reckons they are never clean and it is better for me to take DS to the ladies. DS is 7 and I still take him to the ladies with me and will continue doing so. If we are out and he wants to go by himself I send him to the ladies too.

Re the OP - it does feel a bit odd that a Dad would take a DD to the Gents but it shouldn't really. I do remember years ago a friend took his 3 yr old DD into the gents showers/changing rooms and she was excitedly pointing out all the men with willies. Bar one. She never commented on him. Friend said he felt a bit sorry for him!

CapnJadetheKnife · 27/10/2008 10:06

YABU and weird.

I wouldn't have thought twice about it.

Moomin · 27/10/2008 10:05

(I only used the NOTW as an example as they were the ones who were campaigning for Sarah's Law and it drove the pitchfork-wielders into a frenzy on some estates a few years back)

bozza · 27/10/2008 10:05

My DH takes DD into the gents if I am not there. She is only 4 mind you and I think they use a cubicle together as I do when I take DD. If we are all out together DH would take DS and I would take DD. But DS is 7 and will go in a cubicle on his own.