Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be a bit perturbed by somebody taking a small girl to the gents loo?

139 replies

FourArms · 27/10/2008 09:29

On a family day out last Saturday, I saw a bloke take a small girl (over 5, under 10 - rubbish with ages!) into the blokes loo. I think that there was some kind of single dad's trip on - lots of blokes with kids came off a coach at the same time. I can understand him not letting her go to the ladies by herself, but there was a vacant disabled/baby changing loo which they could have used.

I've got no problems with boys of any age being taken by their mums into the ladies - there's nothing to see after all, but I'm not sure about a girl being taken into the gents where she might see other blokes using the urinals.

AIBU to be a bit wierded out by this? Luckily for me I've got two boys, so will continue to take them to the ladies with me / use a disabled loo as appropriate. I know that there was another thread about letting boys use a gents by themselves recently, but this feels a bit different to me.

OP posts:
DustyTv · 28/10/2008 05:43

I have only read the op....but here goes.

Double standards spring to mind.

So if there isn't a baby chaning room (and not all have toilets in them) and the disabled toilet is being used then where is a dad supposed to take his DD to use the toilet.

Also surely she undersatnds that men have a willy and has no doubt seen her dads, I also doubt that she would come to any unwanted attention/harm with her dad there FGS.

FourArms · 28/10/2008 05:27

Well, I went to a different place yesterday, which had just the sort of loos that 80'schick was describing. They were labelled children's toilets/disabled toilets/baby changing and it was a room with 4 cubicles, all disabled friendly and with changing mats dotted round the outside. Ideal for everyone!

Now that I'm much more enlightened about the lack of willy waving that goes on, I don't think I'd worry so much about a little girl going in there. However, human body or not, I'm still not entirely sure that a little girl should be seeing a load of willies doing a wee if they could be seen. Maybe that makes me prudish? I wouldn't have said that I was, but there you go. The hygiene angle is interesting and something that I've never even considered. If we're out with DH, then he takes DS1 to the loo if needs be (I have no DD's). I usually do DS2 who's still in nappies. However, DH is usually away, so I normally sort both of them. Although I'm not keen on the state of men's loos (have cleaned a few in my time with bar work and working at McD's), I don't think me taking them to the ladies because of this is a valid option. Hopefully if they were too gross, then DH would have the sense to find somewhere different.

OP posts:
EightiesChick · 27/10/2008 23:30

The OP has been heavily criticised here but, while I agree that it ought to be fine for a man to take his small daughter to the gents with him, it is common for people to think that's a bit odd, so she is hardly unusual. Obviously MNers are a very enlightened bunch but I think a lot of people do tacitly assume that taking kids to the toilet if women's work, for some of the reasons mentioned - gents being less hygienic, moral panics about paedophilia, all that. As a result, men and women get a bad deal, and men really can't win whichever toilet they use.

In one large store that's recently opened near me, they have 'family' toilets as well as the ladies, gents, disabled and baby change rooms, which seems like the best solution to me as there's plenty of room to get a parent, child and potentially a buggy in there. It's a shame that so few places actually have any kind of commitment to providing good, clean public toilets. There has recently been an MPs' report about how bad this has got that recommended councils should be made to do more - AFAIK councils are no longer obliged to provide public toilets at the level they used to be. It probably sounds like a trivial matter to many people but it isn't at all (speaking as someone with a medical condition where good toilet access is important). We should all be pushing for better toilet facilities for everyone.

sleepycatonabroomstick · 27/10/2008 22:52

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

PottyCock · 27/10/2008 22:47

nope, it's another one! keeping my cocky name though have grown strangely attached to it (something to do with penis envy, perhaps )

nappyaddict · 27/10/2008 22:47

don't see the problem.

FrankAwenstein · 27/10/2008 22:45

lol - is that you poppy in disguise again? I keep flitting into mn at this time of nite.. when i should be climbing those stairs

forevercleaningwithmybesoms · 27/10/2008 22:45

YABU - he had no choice and probably did not want her to go alone into the ladies. This way he could keep an eye on her.

PottyCock · 27/10/2008 22:37
FrankAwenstein · 27/10/2008 22:37

yabu fgs tis perfectly normal.

PottyCock · 27/10/2008 22:32

lol, an mn classic.

what the f else should the poor guy have done!

DontKillMeBaby · 27/10/2008 22:28

Blimey. Never even occurred to me that someone might look askance at DH taking DD into the loos. Good job, or I'd have to take her every time, and then it'd be MY food going cold at the table. But I figure you match the sex of the grown-up to the loos - I do think that a man taking his DD to the ladies' isn't on, and neither is sending your son into the ladies on his own. And as for insisting that mum takes DS to the ladies' cos the gents' loos (ALL gents loos) aren't clean enough - that DH is onto a winner isn't he? His dinner won't be going cold.

Thomcat · 27/10/2008 21:48

Hopefully you'll feel better about a dad taking his daughter to the loo now FourArms and hopefully you will be less unreasonable in the future

Ronaldinhio · 27/10/2008 21:45

sorry think you sound like a nutter in this post

i'm sure you aren't rweally

why not try switching off and switching back on to see how you feel then

vvunreasonable

BarcodeZebra · 27/10/2008 21:42

I take both my wee girls to the gents. I'm a gent. I'm not going into the ladies on account of my gender. I take them into a cubicle because, clearly, dangling them over the urinals is considered a bit off. Strangely, whilst in the loos with me neither of them have had anyone's trouser snake waved at them or indeed even caught a glimpse of a penis. We don't tend to wander around in there with them hanging out as a rule.

I think you're a bit odd, frankly. Either you are weirdly prudish or so PC that you've met yourself coming back.

Tee2072 · 27/10/2008 15:43

Wow. How sexist. YABtotallyU.

Cheesesarnie · 27/10/2008 14:57

op-read the responses from male mners on here.dont you think its sad that theyre made to feel this way?theyre parents too.

onager · 27/10/2008 14:56

Oh and yes I know changing nappies in a public place is frowned upon, but I know I couldn't win anyway.

Cheesesarnie · 27/10/2008 14:54

yabu.what are men supposed to do?im sure theyd be millions of complaints if he took her into ladies tiolets.the men in the loos will be weeing -whats so bad about that?

onager · 27/10/2008 14:54

Are men even welcome in baby changing rooms? I always figured they'd be used for BF too and that I'd be screamed at. I always made do with a public bench for changing nappies and holding little ones over drains for peeing.

I would take a child in the mens toilets if there was one handy and they were getting too big to hold over the gutter.

I wouldn't dare walk into the women's even with a child and I know nothing about the rules for using disabled toilets. I don't even know if they have stalls as such in there or if they are all open for practical reasons.

Pity we can't start all over again from scratch and just not teach kids to be ashamed/embarrassed and then it would be simpler all round.

nooonki · 27/10/2008 14:50

What do you think will happen if she does see a willy? It's hardly like she is being flashed at she is with her Dad

michymama · 27/10/2008 14:35

When I was little I used to go swimming with my dad and he always took me into the mens changing rooms. There were always private cubicles so we would go in there. there was no where else to take me, I was too young to be left by myself and the disabled was usually occupied.

Peachy · 27/10/2008 14:34

Even forgetting the whole ahrdhat disabled loo thing, increasingly a radar key is required to use them and as such they cannot be used by random people whatever nee they may have (this includes random disabled people if they don't have a key- and we always forget ours!)

DaDaDa · 27/10/2008 14:30

Jesus. We might as well all just give up.

nannynick · 27/10/2008 14:27

Oh this is just getting silly... what are us men to do when our DD (or in my case a girl I care for) want's the loo.

Being a man, as someone already has said, in mens loos, those using the urinals do so discretely... they don't wave their willy around for everyone to see.

When I've taken girls in the men's... they are quickly escorted to the nearest cubical, where I then wait by the door to that cubical.

Use a Disabled Loo - No. I care for disabled children on occasion, and then Yes we may use a disabled loo. Sometimes I have used a disabled loo with a non-disabled child, due to the baby changing being located in disabled, not in the mens. THAT MUST CHANGE - Why can't there be baby changing in all men's toilet blocks. Legoland manage to provide it OK, why can't anywhere else?

Baby changing room - these don't always have toilets in (Royal Landscape, Savile Garden for example does not provide baby changing in the mens... only in a separate room with no loo - not very practical with baby and a 4-year-old.)

Sending girl into women's toilet's on their own - I've done this on occasion, but it can have it's own problems... 1. What if there is some strange women in there, who may abuse a child? 2. What if said girl decides they need assistance? 3. What if said girl goes in, but can't then open the door to get out (this happens quite often I find, why do they make toilet block doors so heavy). 4. If a girl I care for goes into a toilet block alone, I'm not covered under my insurance, as the child is not in my direct care.

So what are men supposed to do exactly - not take the girl to the toilet and let her wet her knickers?

Swipe left for the next trending thread