Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want to make my own will without DH knowing??

34 replies

Chocmad · 12/08/2008 17:35

Really bizarre question i know, but since that newly married couple were killed on honeymoon have really been thinking that i should get a will organised ( something i've been meaning to do since getting married / having DC's but just never got round to ). But.....I'm not entirely sure that if something happened to just me, whether i would want my DH to have total control over how the kids are brought up - awful thing to say and he's lovely most of the time but i just know that if i wasn't here his parents would get hugely involved in their upbringing and i really wouldn't want that ( always had issues as they don't particularly like me and i don't agree with some of their parenting / granparenting methods!! ) Just wondered what everyones opinion is? It's probably not even legal to ask that my DC's have a 'guardian' anyway seeing as we're married and really do feel awful saying it but it's been running round my head for a few days now and was wondering... views would be good please?

OP posts:
nametaken · 12/08/2008 18:04

Well, i'm sorry but you do sound very controlling and unreasonable.

You choose him to be the father of your children no-one forced you too.

BitOfFun · 12/08/2008 18:03

ooh, tricky issue this - hopefully some more legaleagles will come on and enlighten us. I can see that the beyond the grave ruling is impractical, but I must admit I would hate it if my children ended up with their respective grandparents on their dads' side if the exes were to pop it too (I have 2 dcs, different dads).

I would like my dcs to stay together though, but in my situation, maybe they wouldn't be allowed?

Sorry for hi-jack, but you have made me think!

Chocmad · 12/08/2008 18:02

I know exactly what you all mean, and i do feel awful thinking it - i do have faith in him and we have a pretty good marriage most of the time ( although we've gone through the usual rocky patches ) it just shocked me a bit that my intial thought when i thought of making my will was 'i'm not sure if i'd want him to have total say in their upbringing'. It is a totally hypothetical question as in reality i'm sure he'd be a great dad if i weren't here, as like a lot of men i know he doesn't DO anything because i'm here to do it all for him. I am being unreasonable and would hate for him to have the same thought about me, but felt i just wanted to air it somewhere without the risk of sounding like a complete control freak bitch!

OP posts:
ChasingSquirrels · 12/08/2008 17:55

as Twig and wannaBe say.
I think what worries me is that if I did die and the kids went to live with ex (and I agree he IS their parent and that is how it should be) then they could very well lose contact with my family - and my mum in particular is very very close to them having looked after them while I work.
I didn't have the same concerns before we split - but now there is lines drawn and it would be much more difficult between my family and ex.

nametaken · 12/08/2008 17:50

And the fact that your in-laws don't like you won't matter to you if your dead will it?

wannaBe · 12/08/2008 17:49

If you appointed a guardian, would you want your children to live with them? would you prevent your dh from having access? to stop him from taking them to his parents? because tbh I think that he could contest that and as he is their father he would be successful.

They are his children too. If he died how would you feel if he appointed his parents guardians over your children?

If you have so little faith in his parenting abilities and clearly think so little of him maybe you should question whether you even still want to be in this marriage while you're still alive.

But yabu.

Twiglett · 12/08/2008 17:49

I don't think you can leave kids to people other than a surviving parent can you? Surely a parent's rights supercede everything subject to no legal bar to contact with children of course.

nametaken · 12/08/2008 17:46

I think that although you can leave your money and (perhaps) your children to whoever you want in the event of your death, you can't do this "with conditions".

For example, you can't say

"I would like my dh to have £1 million, provided he doesn't spend it on sports cars"

or

"I would like my dh to have the kids, provided he doesn't take them to his parents and give them junk food"

It's called "ruling from beyond the grave" and can't be done.

You have to give your bequests unconditionally, as far as I know.

For arguments sake, lets just for a minute say it is allowed - so you say "I would like dh to have kids provided he doesn't give them junk food at the grandparents".

  • Now, suppose he does give them junk food at the grandparents, what happens next?

You see how impossible it would be to enforce. You'd have to have an army of people watching everybody else to ensure they stuck to the agreement 24/7 and it just can't be done.

ChasingSquirrels · 12/08/2008 17:42

It would be interesteing to know - I wouldn't have thought that you could appoint a guardian as he presumably has equal parental responsibility and if you died he would be responsible.

I have been thinking similar (but different as have recently split), about what I could put in my will.

Need to see a solicitor I guess.