Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to want to make my own will without DH knowing??

34 replies

Chocmad · 12/08/2008 17:35

Really bizarre question i know, but since that newly married couple were killed on honeymoon have really been thinking that i should get a will organised ( something i've been meaning to do since getting married / having DC's but just never got round to ). But.....I'm not entirely sure that if something happened to just me, whether i would want my DH to have total control over how the kids are brought up - awful thing to say and he's lovely most of the time but i just know that if i wasn't here his parents would get hugely involved in their upbringing and i really wouldn't want that ( always had issues as they don't particularly like me and i don't agree with some of their parenting / granparenting methods!! ) Just wondered what everyones opinion is? It's probably not even legal to ask that my DC's have a 'guardian' anyway seeing as we're married and really do feel awful saying it but it's been running round my head for a few days now and was wondering... views would be good please?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheCranberriess · 15/01/2023 01:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ChairmumMiaow · 13/08/2008 10:09

Also, if I died but DH didn't at least I know SIL would step in to be surrogate mummy

ChairmumMiaow · 13/08/2008 10:08

This is all really interesting. DH and I are planning to make a will soon - the main reason for this being that if we both died we wouldn't want DS to live with any of our parents or siblings.

We want to arange for DS to go to his auntie - my brother's soon-to-be-ex-wife. She was at his birth and babysits him at least once a week when I am at work. They have a relationship, and his cousins love him. I'd also trust her to let him see DH's family (who aren't bad, but who wouldn't give him the sort of upbringing we want for him)

Would our families be able to contest this?

sorry if its a bit of a hijack!

Chocmad · 13/08/2008 09:56

Thanks everyone for your thoughts.I think the whole process of making a will just made me question things that i'd never really thought of before..like if me and DH weren't here, who other than my parents would i trust with my children?? Had a chat to DH last night and told him my thoughts ( held my breath in case he asked for divorce!! ) he understood what i meant and didn't take it as a slight on him...he is a great dad but isn't really involved at all with their day-to-day lives, leaves for work just after they wake up and usually comes home after bedtime ( weekends as well as weekdays ) so he gets that if i weren't here i would like my mum to take over a large part of my role ( which i've spoken to her about and she's happy to - she's still relatively young ). I was just really asking if anyone else had this kind of thought as it's such a huge thing to have to think about, and as AbbeyA said there's no guarantee how long any of us are here for. Quite a morbid and depressing post though so promise next time i'll ask about something a bit more upbeat!!!

OP posts:
ChukkyPig · 12/08/2008 22:45

Interesting. Made me think about god-parents, who I was brought up to believe were there to look after you if your parents died (cheery!).

Friends tell me this is out dated and god-parents are now just for giving presents. But it shows that in days gone by where people died younger people did think about it.

I would say, make a will money-wise and check the status of your house if you have a joint mortgage/property. There are two ways of doing it, one where you die it all automatically goes to the other person. The other, where you die it goes to people you have named. Usually married/partners are put on the first sort but if you are worried look into changing it so your half can go to the kids rather than the partner.

Me and my mum both have arrangements where if we die the share of the house goes to the kids not the husband. The men have arrangements where if they die their halves go to us. Bonus!!

laweaselmys · 12/08/2008 22:26

Will's are really about reassigning your possesions after your death. Your DC's are not your posessions, they're your kids, even if you tried to come up with a loophole that gave your DP control and also meant the control their GPs had was minimal, it would be very unlikely to be unheld if contested. If you're that worried and you own your house I would leave your 'share' of the house to your kids under the guardianship of somebody who is not your DP until they come of age, then at least you know he's can't sell up and move in with the GP's without your guardian's consent [my father did something similar, but we were over 18 at the time so no guardian's required don't know how much this would complicate things]. This still might well leave your DP feeling hurt and not trusted.

Hulababy · 12/08/2008 22:19

Guardianship in a will isn't legally binding. Your DH would be entitled to contest the will and would be highly likely to win.

hotCheeseBurns · 12/08/2008 22:12

I had a will made recently to say that I would like my parents to be guardians of my son if i died.

As far as I'm aware, whatever you say in your will about your children isn't in any way binding, it's just your wishes made formal.

My son's biological father has never met him and has actively avoided any contact with us, so I hope that noone would suggest he should get custody over my parents, who have helped bring ds up.

I'm not sure what the deal would be with my boyfriend though, who we've lived with for a year and my son calls daddy.

stoppinattwo · 12/08/2008 22:09

I currently have parental responsibility of my DC's as DP and I are not married....the shared parental responsibility rule only came in after DD was born. If I were to die DP would not have a say with regard to financial matters as by his own admission he has no ability with money....my sister would take care of everything financial that involved the kids, and would carry out my wishes as much as she could with discussion with DP....she would in effect be their gurdian. DP knows this and feels very ok with it. DP would however be responsible for being a dad ....so nothing really would change except I wouldnt be there

elmoandella · 12/08/2008 22:04

i've been thinking about this also. me and dp are obviously not married.

he has gambling issues, and i would rather appoint my sister as legal guardian with him having access. my dp is also a lot older than myslef. and i wouldn't want my kids being uprooted again is he passed away before they were adults.

perhaps op has her reasons for not choosing dh to look after kids.

QuintessentialShadows · 12/08/2008 21:58

So, let me get this straight, if you were to die, you dont want their father to bring them up? You want them orphaned? You want them to not just lose their mum, but have only rudimentary contact with their father?

Are you just keen on being petty towards your dhs family from beyond the grave? Or are you thinking of your childrens best interests?

mumeeee · 12/08/2008 21:53

YABU. They are his children to and he should be allowed to bring them up if you aren't aound.

ChasingSquirrels · 12/08/2008 21:34

quatro - how different, can the resident parent will that the children don't live with the NRP??

Quattrocento · 12/08/2008 18:59

The situation is very different where parents are divorced

bunchoflowers · 12/08/2008 18:56

I mean should anything happen to me

bunchoflowers · 12/08/2008 18:55

Dunno, I think I would want a blood relative to look after my kids should anything happen to them. Rather than a guardian who would probs feel a tad burdened with responsiblity of bringing up someone else's kids!!

Is your relationship with your DH/ILs is making you think of death??????

AbbeyA · 12/08/2008 18:47

You could discuss it with a solicitor to find out how it would stand, but I imagine that it would be meaningless because your DH is an equal parent.

wannaBe · 12/08/2008 18:26

I think you need to think of the wider implications of making a will like this without your dh's knowledge.

Imagine if your dh died, and when the will was read it appointed someone else as guardian of your children, and stipulated that you weren't to have full say in their upbringing. Wouldn't that raise serious questions for you as to whether your dh had any respect for you? whether you meant anything to him? because it would for me. I would wonder what he really thought of me if he didn't respect me enough to bring up our children without input from someone else.

AbbeyA · 12/08/2008 18:22

I find it a bit worrying that you have all the power as surviving parent, it is quite common to lose touch with dead parent's family, especially if the relationship was a bit rocky in the first place.Nametaken was right in that you can't have control beyond the grave and so it is best to give your wishes before-and hope they are acted on.

Chocmad · 12/08/2008 18:18

So sorry to hear about your DH AbbeyA, sounds like you've been a brilliant mum to your little one and kept all of the family involved..i guess this would be my fear that my family would lose contact with my DC's. Will definitely talk to him as we really need to get something sorted.

Am not overly worried about dying ( no more than anyone else i guess ) but obviously thinking about making a will does make you ask questions about certain things.

OP posts:
AbbeyA · 12/08/2008 18:17

I think any parent has to be worried about dying, nametaken-it can happen to anyone at any time. My DH was fit and healthy and never reached 30yrs-it hadn't crossed my mind that I would be a widow so young.

AbbeyA · 12/08/2008 18:14

I would say that your DH's rights as a parent would be set above anything that you wrote in a will. As a surviving parent it would be entirely up to him.
My DH died when my DS was a baby. I have always involved the whole of his family in our lives, even after remarrying. I wouldn't dream of cutting them off and luckily DH2 is supportive, but it would be very easy not to visit, have them to stay, talk about them with DS etc.
You need to talk to your DH about it and make a joint will.Make sure that he knows your concerns.

nametaken · 12/08/2008 18:13

Why are you worried about dying, anyway?

Chocmad · 12/08/2008 18:09

Thanks for your opinion nametaken, it is an unreasonable thing to think which is why i haven't spoken to anyone in RL about it - think i am a bit of a control freak where DC's are concerned ( am not the only one am i!!? ) He's a great dad but since thinking about the whole 'will' issue it's just made me think - obviously completely pointless as if i'm dead i can hardly come back and complain!!

OP posts:
stitch · 12/08/2008 18:07

i completely understand what you are talking about.
however, i think that making a will such as you are suggesting would cause the chilfren more problems