Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Smoking in our own property.

518 replies

Teenagerantruns · 12/11/2026 22:09

Ok l know im probably going to be slaughtered for this but here goes.
We moved a week ago into a new flat, purpose built block. We both smoke, yes l know its disgusting but whatever.
So today upstairs neighbours came down and said smoke was bothering them, im not sure how as they are not directly above us, but above on other side. I guess none of our frount doors are that good , so smoke is going out of ours upstairs and to the left to thiers? Seems unlikely but obviously they can smell it, they accused us of smoking in communal area hall which obviously l would never do. Other upstairs neighbours directly above say that they can't smell anything.
Im not really sure what to do now, l did say sorry and normally we would smoke outside just been hectic week moving and so wet but if we smoked inside we would do it furthest room away from frount door and close all the doors in between so 3 doors.
Apprently that's not good enough , they also dont want us smoking in the communal garden?
Aibu to think actually we can do what we like in our flat, and to just ignore them.

OP posts:
Thegirlwhowent · 13/11/2026 18:47

Icecreammonster · 13/11/2026 18:07

I sympathise as nicotine is the worst addiction, and as an ex smoker I can't judge you for smoking. I now vape and am weaning myself off, but I don't have one of those which pumps out big clouds, I have a pod system which is more like a crutch for me now. I would suggest looking into this as I don't crave cigarettes at all now, in fact, I hate the smell, and it would solve your dilemma. I do think you should refrain from smoking in a flat though, I can completely imagine how it would permeate through the building. I still cringe at the days when I smoked indoors in a flat share, as the only smoker. It was 1995 but still I can't believe I was so selfish. To those who don't smoke and hate it, I agree but I can cut anything else (including alcohol) but it is the hardest habit to kick, especially if you have to deal with a lot of stress. And I tried every method going, including the actual Alan Carr course (twice). It was vapes which worked eventually and I guess many would judge that but it's bloody hard.

I'm similar. I remember once hitching a lift and lighting up (without asking) in a stranger's car! Giving up was perhaps the best thing I ever did. Alan Carr's book, 'The Easy Way...' was what worked for me - on my second reading. I booked a holiday for a week, took the book with me, and read a bit slowly every day. You have to keep smoking while you read it and, near the end, I couldn't wait to finish the book so I could stop. I threw away the fags I'd got left with a sense of relief and have never looked back. The freedom was exhilarating!

tommyhoundmum · 13/11/2026 18:42

Skippythemagnificent · 12/11/2026 22:21

Just stop smoking in a building other people also live in. Go outside. Or stop smoking altogether. Unless you’re very old, there is no reason for you to have started smoking in the first place.

What??

Thegirlwhowent · 13/11/2026 18:41

InterIgnis · 13/11/2026 18:35

As long as it is within the law, she could indeed just say that.

She could, if she didn't care about other people or getting on with neighbours. Some people seem to enjoy being antisocial and making other people's lives a misery.

lackofvitamindd · 13/11/2026 18:40

I used to live in a flat and the smell can go through vents in the kitchens and bathrooms as they’re connected.

MacNCheesie · 13/11/2026 18:39

glitterpaperchain · 13/11/2026 18:09

The signs don't work, I've given birth at two different hospitals and both of them had issues with people smoking directly next to the doors to the maternity units. One of them the building was both the maternity ward AND children's ward. Doesn't stop them.

That comes down the how well the system is managed.

Thegirlwhowent · 13/11/2026 18:39

Back21970 · 13/11/2026 14:10

It’s your property and smoking is not illegal - I’m a non smoker and I’m outraged on your behalf!

Of course it’s nice to keep on good terms with neighbours but I think they are being totally ridiculous and entitled.

Quite surprised at some of the responses on here, please don’t cave into pressure - I’m sure you are well aware of the risks of smoking but if you want to do it in your own home that’s totally your right and no one else’s business.

How would you feel if the neighbours played loud music or had loud sex all the time? Or if they had an incessantly barking dog? Or cooked something really smelly every day? Even if you're doing something legal in the confines of your own home, it's better to think of your neighbours. Being on good terms with neighbours is always a good idea. Falling out with them can make life a misery.

InterIgnis · 13/11/2026 18:35

ElevenBells · 13/11/2026 18:25

If your neighbour had complained about you playing music so loudly that it disturbed them would you still say as it’s your flat you can do what you want? Smell like noise is anti social. Why should your choices interfere with someone else’s enjoyment of their home? Also your decision to smoke could negatively affect your neighbours health, why should they put up with that because of your addiction?
Also a neighbour has basically told you that you, your partner and you flat smell fucking revolting. My reaction wouldn’t be to get defensive it would be a wake up call to kick the habit and stop stinking.

As long as it is within the law, she could indeed just say that.

PropertyD · 13/11/2026 18:35

It’s a truly vile habit and all smokers i know claim to say you cannot smell it (you bloody well can)

ElevenBells · 13/11/2026 18:25

If your neighbour had complained about you playing music so loudly that it disturbed them would you still say as it’s your flat you can do what you want? Smell like noise is anti social. Why should your choices interfere with someone else’s enjoyment of their home? Also your decision to smoke could negatively affect your neighbours health, why should they put up with that because of your addiction?
Also a neighbour has basically told you that you, your partner and you flat smell fucking revolting. My reaction wouldn’t be to get defensive it would be a wake up call to kick the habit and stop stinking.

TY78910 · 13/11/2026 18:12

Ultimately, it’s a nice neighbourly thing to do to stop smoking inside of the property. I don’t know if you have a balcony, or you’re able to pop outside but It’s probably best that you respect other people’s space too. There are probably air vents That connect those properties together.

gardenflowergirl · 13/11/2026 18:11

Your walls and ceilings are going to be heavily stained yellow within the year... If it's rented they're going to be taking a chunk of your deposit for repairs.

Pepperlee · 13/11/2026 18:10

Tryagain26 · 13/11/2026 16:10

Curry and incense are not unpleasant smells and not injurious to health

They both stink.

glitterpaperchain · 13/11/2026 18:09

MacNCheesie · 13/11/2026 15:54

Why are you so certain that you know who and what the neighbour is? They have a control complex? You know them, do you?

Of course minorities don't need to be controlled.

You're making illogical statements. You are not coming over as understanding some aspects of this.

80% of people do not smoke in the UK.
This is why there are laws around the risks of passive smoking.
This is why even outside of buildings there are signs saying NO SMOKING
eg outside hospitals. Because no one, even outside, wants to walk through a cloud of smoke going in or coming out of a building.

Are you unable to understand how smoke rises? How someone in the flat above will get the stench of smoke rising when OP opens her door? Because it's not just her smoking but her partner too.

Ideally, I assume the OP and her neighbours would rather be in their own houses, but can't afford those, so they have to live cheek by jowl in a block of flats.

The signs don't work, I've given birth at two different hospitals and both of them had issues with people smoking directly next to the doors to the maternity units. One of them the building was both the maternity ward AND children's ward. Doesn't stop them.

riceuten · 13/11/2026 18:09

I'm not "slaughtering" you, but I suspect - like many on MN - you came here to get supportive comments, and pretty much don't care what people think - MNers or your fellow residents. Not really sure why people post stuff like this, tbh

Icecreammonster · 13/11/2026 18:07

I sympathise as nicotine is the worst addiction, and as an ex smoker I can't judge you for smoking. I now vape and am weaning myself off, but I don't have one of those which pumps out big clouds, I have a pod system which is more like a crutch for me now. I would suggest looking into this as I don't crave cigarettes at all now, in fact, I hate the smell, and it would solve your dilemma. I do think you should refrain from smoking in a flat though, I can completely imagine how it would permeate through the building. I still cringe at the days when I smoked indoors in a flat share, as the only smoker. It was 1995 but still I can't believe I was so selfish. To those who don't smoke and hate it, I agree but I can cut anything else (including alcohol) but it is the hardest habit to kick, especially if you have to deal with a lot of stress. And I tried every method going, including the actual Alan Carr course (twice). It was vapes which worked eventually and I guess many would judge that but it's bloody hard.

Notimeforaname · 13/11/2026 18:06

Of course you can do what you like in your own home.

You are not breaking the law. Carry on living your life as you wish and ignore the neighbour.

Pepperlee · 13/11/2026 17:59

RafaFan · 13/11/2026 13:59

You don't have to put up with council workmen smoking in your home - it's actually illegal. Report them to the council.

I'll bet they don't.

Single50something · 13/11/2026 17:58

Smells go through from house to house.Our neighbours cook the most amazing Thai food and our house smells pretty good from.it. used to have smokers 2 doors up and it would get into our house :(

Megifer · 13/11/2026 17:57

Smoke if you want op.

I'll agree with the hand wringing about how much smokers cost the NHS when the same things are said about how much overweight (due to diet) people cost.

WitchesBritches · 13/11/2026 17:52

DiligentDandelion · 13/11/2026 17:47

My comparison to weight loss drugs was to vaping, not smoking, which releases flavoured water vapour and doesn’t carry the risks second hand smoke does. People don’t want people to smoke, but they also don’t want people to use a method to give up smoking that actually works. They are however fully supportive of weight loss drugs and don’t regularly shame people with ignorant ‘just stop eating so much’ posts in the way they tell to people to just give up nicotine, like it’s that easy.

The neighbour who has complained is 2 floors up. The flat above isn’t bothered by the smoke at all. It’s unlikely they can smell much of anything 2 floors up.

Edited

Not that diligent.

The person the smoke is affecting is not two floors up.

But even if they were, so what?, They're still being affected by the OP's anti social behaviour.

DraigCymraeg · 13/11/2026 17:52

Skippythemagnificent · 12/11/2026 22:21

Just stop smoking in a building other people also live in. Go outside. Or stop smoking altogether. Unless you’re very old, there is no reason for you to have started smoking in the first place.

It is none of your business.

MalateOxaloacetate · 13/11/2026 17:49

DiligentDandelion · 13/11/2026 17:47

My comparison to weight loss drugs was to vaping, not smoking, which releases flavoured water vapour and doesn’t carry the risks second hand smoke does. People don’t want people to smoke, but they also don’t want people to use a method to give up smoking that actually works. They are however fully supportive of weight loss drugs and don’t regularly shame people with ignorant ‘just stop eating so much’ posts in the way they tell to people to just give up nicotine, like it’s that easy.

The neighbour who has complained is 2 floors up. The flat above isn’t bothered by the smoke at all. It’s unlikely they can smell much of anything 2 floors up.

Edited

Vape smoke is associated with COPD

MalateOxaloacetate · 13/11/2026 17:49

Gross. You’re basically sending second hand smoke up into their home. I think it should be illegal in flats… you own your flat not the whole building.

Smokers can rarely smell their own smoke. It will also drastically reduce the value of your flat should you choose to re sell. And it will eliminate a lot of families from being willing to buy.

DiligentDandelion · 13/11/2026 17:47

ProcrastinatorsAnonymous · 13/11/2026 14:53

That comparison to food addiction makes no sense, as that doesn't impact the quality of life of those around you.

From the sound of it, the neighbours simply don't want their own homes impacted with the smell. There's no suggestion they give a damn whether or not OP smokes - just as long as it doesn't ruin their home (which it inevitably does if you live in a shared building with imperfectly sealed doors, windows next to each other, connected extractor fans etc). I don't think this is a thread about smoking per se. It's about impact on others.

My comparison to weight loss drugs was to vaping, not smoking, which releases flavoured water vapour and doesn’t carry the risks second hand smoke does. People don’t want people to smoke, but they also don’t want people to use a method to give up smoking that actually works. They are however fully supportive of weight loss drugs and don’t regularly shame people with ignorant ‘just stop eating so much’ posts in the way they tell to people to just give up nicotine, like it’s that easy.

The neighbour who has complained is 2 floors up. The flat above isn’t bothered by the smoke at all. It’s unlikely they can smell much of anything 2 floors up.

Tryagain26 · 13/11/2026 16:10

LouisFuton · 13/11/2026 10:00

What if you were cooking curry everyday?What if you were burning incense every day? What if what if what if what if

Curry and incense are not unpleasant smells and not injurious to health