Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wood burner ban...

495 replies

BusyGreySnail · 12/11/2026 16:16

Apparently there is a call for wood burners to be banned. They are bad for air quality, inside and out, and bad for the environment. I assume it's the same for fireplaces, but I don't know.

What about all this talk of black outs, and vulnerable critical infastructure and preparedness, should that factor in? If we really are at risk, people having an alternative source of heat is quite a good idea.

Do you have one?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
BusyGreySnail · 13/11/2026 08:18

HRTtoHeart · 12/11/2026 17:57

Because the population density here means we're all squished up against one another in big cities whereas in Norway it's a tiny population with vast expanses.

They have 14.6 people per square kilometre, we have roughly 280.

I mean yes, but they also have cities in Norway.

OP posts:
BusyGreySnail · 13/11/2026 08:17

JudgeJ · 12/11/2026 17:55

Lots of people are asthmatic but have never lived in a house with a wood burner, yet another erroneous example of cause and effect.

I mean, yes and no. It's a little like saying lots of people get lung cancer but have never smoked. Just because that's the case doesn't mean that smoking has no impact on lung cancer. I couldn't quote you the science, but I'm fairly sure I've seen over the years evidence presented that it can contribute to lung conditions such as asthma due to the air quality issues it causes.

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · 13/11/2026 08:15

Lots of the evidence mixes open fires - bonfires etc and coal burners with wood stoves.

I dont think it would be that difficult to study solely hones with woodburners so am a bit baffled why that hasn't been done.

BusyGreySnail · 13/11/2026 08:14

PrettyLittleRose · 12/11/2026 17:57

YABU to make this thread and not give any kind of link to this 'call for a wood burner ban.'

Where did you even see this @BusyGreySnail ?

It was just a headline I saw online. I think Daily express so probably not majorly reliable. Apparently Labour's environment plan has come up with calls to get burning of solid wood assessed. But it's come up now and again over the years.... Here's the link to the article I happened to see: https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/2265702/call-wood-burner-rule-change

Call for wood burner rule change with appliances ripped out of homes

A call has been made to rip wood burners out of homes and replace them.

https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/2265702/call-wood-burner-rule-change

OP posts:
C8H10N4O2 · 13/11/2026 08:09

DoubleHellos · 13/11/2026 07:44

Yes, it is not comparing like with like.

The deaths from RTA are confirmed from clinical coding.

The presumed deaths where air pollution was a factor are modelled and based on extrapolation and include wider deaths from co morbidities. It is all.completely hypothetical.

In terms of how many deaths could be wholly attributed to a wood burner, I imagine the answer would be in the single figures at most. There may have been one that exploded and killed someone outright in the blast or something.

This is true for most of the research linked here as "proof" that wood burners are mass murderers.

When you start digging into the numbers and the methodologies the wood burners are rarely broken down by type, the particles are not clearly distinguished and other forms of pollution are poorly controlled for.

And of course the reality for families depending on woodburners is that even if they have an older style wood burner which is less efficient at filtering the choice they face is wood burner vs freezing. More so than ever this last year.

DoubleHellos · 13/11/2026 07:52

ArabellaScott · 13/11/2026 07:42

Do you have a link?

I actually think it is really dangerous to state things like this.

Smoking is directly responsible for the early and avoidable deaths of millions of people and directly causes years of avoidably poor health prior to killing people.

Saying to smokers that anyone who who heats their home with a woodburner is doing as much damage to their health as a smoker, is very likely to reduce motivation to stop or cut down smoking. It is very likely to reduce efforts by smokers to stop smoking indoors around their children and during pregnancy etc.

Where is the evidence to say there is no point giving up smoking if you have a wood burner for eg?

Where is the evidence that considers the 24/7 365 day nature of smoking over the seasonal use of solid fuel? And weights the outcomes?

Or are you saying that the risk of neoplasms and respiratory and cardiovascular disease is the same in a household that heats using a wood burner as it is for a family living with a 20 a day smokers year round? The messaging here is impactful and bloody important. And will likely condemn more children to more cigarette smoke.

So please share that research.

DoubleHellos · 13/11/2026 07:44

AmnesiacDream · 13/11/2026 05:31

Not entirely clear on what medical coding you're referring too, but things like pollution are rarely directly attributed to an individual's outcomes, they're worked out on a population level.

Hertfordshire County Council commissioned a report that came up with 2200 deaths a year for woodburning stoves (copy of report here), road traffic deaths you can easily look up, but I went from memory that they are under 2000.

Yes, it is not comparing like with like.

The deaths from RTA are confirmed from clinical coding.

The presumed deaths where air pollution was a factor are modelled and based on extrapolation and include wider deaths from co morbidities. It is all.completely hypothetical.

In terms of how many deaths could be wholly attributed to a wood burner, I imagine the answer would be in the single figures at most. There may have been one that exploded and killed someone outright in the blast or something.

ArabellaScott · 13/11/2026 07:42

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 07:31

New research published today saying all wood burners are harmful to children's health in homes that have them.

They are known to be as harmful as smoking indoors.

If you already smoke cigarettes in your house with your kids around crack on. If you would be horrified at the idea of doing this consider finding an alternative to your log burner for the sake of your children.

Do you have a link?

Moonmelodies · 13/11/2026 07:39

Wait until they hear about people burning charcoal on their barbecues.

BeLemonMoose · 13/11/2026 07:31

New research published today saying all wood burners are harmful to children's health in homes that have them.

They are known to be as harmful as smoking indoors.

If you already smoke cigarettes in your house with your kids around crack on. If you would be horrified at the idea of doing this consider finding an alternative to your log burner for the sake of your children.

NoNonsense79 · 13/11/2026 06:39

montysmaw · 13/11/2026 00:37

So half filling my oil tank cost £900 last week.
That will last 8weeks with really stingy usage.

Should we freeze or use our free, seasoned logs on our log burner🤔. Let me think.....

Yep. We filled ours last week and it’s double the price of last year. I’ve not saved enough into the heating budget for it this year so it’s into main savings to heat our home. People not on oil or who have never experienced it don’t understand that level of stress. We both work from home so I’ll take it as a cost of doing business. But if prices don’t drop next year it could be cheaper to rent office space 🙈

AmnesiacDream · 13/11/2026 05:31

DoubleHellos · 12/11/2026 21:45

Where are you getting your statistics from please?

Having previously worked adjacent to medical coding I was never aware of any auditing of the domestic heat sources of any patients (lots of coding relating to accidents obviously)!

A camping stove isn't going to heat anyone ever btw.

Not entirely clear on what medical coding you're referring too, but things like pollution are rarely directly attributed to an individual's outcomes, they're worked out on a population level.

Hertfordshire County Council commissioned a report that came up with 2200 deaths a year for woodburning stoves (copy of report here), road traffic deaths you can easily look up, but I went from memory that they are under 2000.

https://www.actionforcleanair.org.uk/files/health_impacts_from_domestic_burning_in_the_uk.pdf

nevermind222 · 13/11/2026 04:28

Tricksortreats · 12/11/2026 23:33

@PleaseDontStepOnTheDaisies Seriously, you need to get your sense of smell checked out. Drive through any village on a winter evening, with your car window open, and it reeks of smoke. Because the particles fall down to the ground (you know, due to gravity).

I love that smell!

UltimateTravelList · 13/11/2026 03:54

Narniaisthatway · 12/11/2026 16:44

In many areas of Scotland you really need a source of heating/cooking that is viable in long power cuts, we get them a lot! If there was a ban it would have to be able to be by postcode or something.

Scotland needs to start building certified Passivhaus homes. They stay warm for up to a week in a power cut.

mumsntt · 13/11/2026 03:31

Countries likes Norway, Sweden and Denmark have more log burners per household than UK but also have better lung and general health rate than UK so how do the naysayers explain that???

I love my log burner

GrantMyWishes · 13/11/2026 02:29

Blackoutmaybe · 12/11/2026 16:45

They aren’t being banned though? The type of fuel you can burn in a Smoke Control Area must be approved and you must use a modern, defra approved appliance, which all are anyway since 2022. There are no plans to ban wood burners completely, anywhere, as far as I know.

This!

Talk of them being banned is wildly exaggerated, and it won't happen because of the risk of people being left without a heat source. Don't forget that many, many people in the country use oil for their heating, which has more than doubled in price during the last 12 months. We used to live in rural Wales where we had oil heating, and there's no way we could have continued to afford it at the price it is now. However, we did have a ready supply of trees and logs, and so the wood-burner would have become our only method of heating. It's all very well for those of us who live in towns and cities to say how bad they are for your health, but I'd sooner die from the effects of burning wood, than I would of hypothermia.

SnowflakesandSlippers · 13/11/2026 02:00

BeLemonMoose · 12/11/2026 21:50

Not true.

  • Research from the University of Sheffield showed that regular four-hour stove use tripled indoor harmful particle levels, with massive surges occurring every time the door was opened to refuel.
  • More toxic chemical makeup. Wood smoke contains carcinogenic polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), carbon monoxide, benzene, and heavy metals (especially if treated or waste wood is burned). Toast particles are mostly organic carbon and ethanol from baking yeast.
  • Severe public health impact. Domestic wood burning is one of the largest sources of fine particle pollution in the UK. Public health data links residential wood and coal burning in the UK to roughly 2,500 deaths, 3,700 new diabetes cases, and 1,500 new asthma cases annually.

Not sure a study based on 20 households counts for anything at all.

montysmaw · 13/11/2026 00:37

So half filling my oil tank cost £900 last week.
That will last 8weeks with really stingy usage.

Should we freeze or use our free, seasoned logs on our log burner🤔. Let me think.....

NorthernJim · 13/11/2026 00:30

BeLemonMoose · 12/11/2026 21:26

Wood burning stoves are the main producer of small particle air pollution in the UK. It's the most dangerous type of air pollution for humans.

But open fires produce vastly higher amounts of small particulate matter. So why not ban them, it'd have a far greater effect on hazardous pollution. The only difference is that wood burners are considered a fashionable, posh accessory, and labour can't bear anything that's associated with private wealth.

Tricksortreats · 12/11/2026 23:33

@PleaseDontStepOnTheDaisies Seriously, you need to get your sense of smell checked out. Drive through any village on a winter evening, with your car window open, and it reeks of smoke. Because the particles fall down to the ground (you know, due to gravity).

AmnesiacDream · 12/11/2026 23:26

FOJN · 12/11/2026 21:56

Unless a camping stove specifically states it is designed for indoor use you should NEVER use one indoors. If it states it's for indoor use you should always have a carbon monoxide monitor to hand. You should not leave a gas canister inside a stove you are not using, remove after each use. People die from carbon monoxide poisoning caused by using heating or cooking appliances indoors when they were never designed for it.

You're absolutely right, FOJN. It was stupid of me to suggest. Thank you pointing out the danger.

Cobol · 12/11/2026 23:14

PleaseDontStepOnTheDaisies · 12/11/2026 20:40

Oh that's awful - I really think a flue should not legally be allowed to be by a neighbour's window!
No need to ban all woodburners though - where I live, the smoke just puffs through chimneys on top of the houses, and you can't ever smell it.

I was surprised by how short the minimum distance they need to be sited from an opening window actually is. They had it installed in a single storey extension and it must affect them too but they chose that, we didn't. FWIW I don't think people who already have them should be stopped from using them but I do think new installations in urban areas shouldn't be allowed. Wood burners may be better than oil or coal in remote areas but they aren't better than gas boilers or renewables in urban areas. They feel like a step backwards when we have less polluting alternatives.

Clafoutie · 12/11/2026 22:59

GasPanic · 12/11/2026 17:42

Not just.

Multiple Holidays.

Pets.

Halloween tat etc.

People are generally climate conscious until it means actually giving up something they like.

Then it tends to be "well all the billionaires are doing it so why shouldn't I?".

This is very true

Greenismyfavouritecolournow · 12/11/2026 22:53

We have two working open fires. I would never give them up. We live rurally and grow our own wood. We use coal too. I’d rather be warm and die at 75 than freezing and live to 80. The government encouraged /forced people to give up their fires and don’t ensure gas , oil , electric is an affordable alternative? So now we will die of hypothermia instead of asthma?

iloveanearlynight · 12/11/2026 22:41

TheOlderIGetTheStayerIHome · 12/11/2026 16:26

They are awful. The fine particulate matter damages lungs, and even goes through lung tissue and enters the blood stream.

I wish they were banned. My bathroom and kitchen fill up with the stinking smoke from the neighbours log burner if I ever open my windows, but the smell (and presumably the particles) still manage to get in my home with the windows shut. My choices are to have a bathroom & kitchen full of condensation, or the selfish neighbours stinking smoke. 😡

Try an extractor fan or dehumidifier perhaps?

Swipe left for the next trending thread