Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wood burner ban...

495 replies

BusyGreySnail · 12/11/2026 16:16

Apparently there is a call for wood burners to be banned. They are bad for air quality, inside and out, and bad for the environment. I assume it's the same for fireplaces, but I don't know.

What about all this talk of black outs, and vulnerable critical infastructure and preparedness, should that factor in? If we really are at risk, people having an alternative source of heat is quite a good idea.

Do you have one?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
overhare · 12/11/2026 18:28

Tricksortreats · 12/11/2026 18:21

And woodburners are hugely more polluting than cars. Hugely. One woodburner equates to 60 lorries.

That's not the per hour figure.

It also ignores all the other pollutants produced by lorries.

tinyspiny · 12/11/2026 18:28

I have emphysema so I’m pretty anti wood burners but I think if you live rurally then that’s fine but they should be banned in built up areas as should bonfires and fire pits .

HRTtoHeart · 12/11/2026 18:27

Holeymoley28 · 12/11/2026 18:07

So the answer is we need less people 🙃👌🏻

Pretty much - to reach Norway's population density we'd need to kill 94.8% of the population of the U.K.

Tricksortreats · 12/11/2026 18:26

From the British Medical Journal:

An analysis by the charity Global Action Plan and Hertfordshire County Council estimated that admissions, hospital stays, outpatient care, and prescriptions treating asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), pneumonia, and cardiovascular events linked to domestic burning were costing the NHS £54m a year.[1] The report said that lives would be saved and the costs of treatment cut if there was no such domestic burning.

DoubleHellos · 12/11/2026 18:26

Tricksortreats · 12/11/2026 18:16

And are you comfortable with causing your neighbours' dementia and their children's cancer and infertility?
Presumably you've already made your peace with the risks you're causing to your own and your children's health.

Edited

Maybe people are balancing their children's need for heating and financial security?

I genuinely can't fork out the £800 oil would cost us and have gone for £180 for a tipper truck of seasoned logs instead.

I suppose I could work every evening in top of the second job I already do at the weekends to keep us going through the CoL crisis? But it would take me a long time to be able to pay for a tank of oil in one go and the government has done nothing to address support for those of us not on the mains gas.

That said, having smelt the outflow of our oil boiler I cannot imagine it is any good for my neighbours wither and god knows how unethical sourchignthe oil actually is? I find the sanctimonious line hear really hard to understand. I could spout the same about people driving, flying, wearing fast fashion, throwing things away at the tip.....

CelticTok · 12/11/2026 18:25

Tricksortreats · 12/11/2026 18:19

They're all very unhealthy. A wood fire inside would be more dangerous than a woodburner for the people in the house, but presumably the same as a woodburner for the neighbours.

Ok, that makes sense, cos I know fireplace fires can get a bit smokey inside.
I was just wondering whether the fact that fireplace fires use coal as well as wood makes a difference. (Off now to google how burning wood and burning coal compare, and wishing I had listened more in science at school!)

Tricksortreats · 12/11/2026 18:23

alcovecupboards · 12/11/2026 18:21

Oh do grow up. (She says with a roaring fire on!)

Being concerned by unnecessary and extremely serious pollution is being grown-up. How do you think the NHS is coping? The answer is - badly.

alcovecupboards · 12/11/2026 18:21

Tricksortreats · 12/11/2026 18:16

And are you comfortable with causing your neighbours' dementia and their children's cancer and infertility?
Presumably you've already made your peace with the risks you're causing to your own and your children's health.

Edited

Oh do grow up. (She says with a roaring fire on!)

Tricksortreats · 12/11/2026 18:21

Tricksortreats · 12/11/2026 18:16

And are you comfortable with causing your neighbours' dementia and their children's cancer and infertility?
Presumably you've already made your peace with the risks you're causing to your own and your children's health.

Edited

And woodburners are hugely more polluting than cars. Hugely. One woodburner equates to 60 lorries.

FOJN · 12/11/2026 18:21

Tricksortreats · 12/11/2026 18:08

I can tell you where the smoke ends up. It comes out of the chimney, cools down very quickly and sinks to the ground. The smoke from my neighbour's house very often gathers in the porch outside my front door, since that's the way the wind tends to blow.
Light your woodburner, go outside and walk round your house. You'll almost certainly smell the smoke from your woodburner.

I do, regularly, and I'm surprised that most of the time all I can see is a heat haze at the top of my chimney. I do it to check that the kiln dried wood I buy is worth the money I pay for it, a clean burn means it has a low moisture content.

I do understand what you are saying though, one of my neighbours burns any old shit in theirs and I can smell it as soon as it's lit. Several of my other neighbours have wood burners or open fires and I can rarely tell when they are going because they use dry wood.

Tricksortreats · 12/11/2026 18:19

CelticTok · 12/11/2026 18:14

Can someone explain to me (sorry I don't know the science).... is a fireplace fire (with coal and wood) equally bad as a woodburner, in terms of pollution/health?

And does this mean that open fires outside, like small bonfires and firepit fires are also unhealthy? If so then it seems ironic that 'forest school' activities are seen as the most wholesome things to make our children do!

And what about BBQs?! I hate the smell when DH cranks that up - he seems to use stinky chemical firelighters as well as the coals.

They're all very unhealthy. A wood fire inside would be more dangerous than a woodburner for the people in the house, but presumably the same as a woodburner for the neighbours.

Tricksortreats · 12/11/2026 18:16

PonkyPonky · 12/11/2026 18:09

People in nice warm well insulated houses are clueless about wood burners. Some of us need them to get our houses to a bearable temperature in the winter. If you burn the right stuff there is barely any smoke. If you get your wood from a sustainable source and it means you’re using less fossil fuels because of it then you’re not doing a bad thing. Go and drive your electric cars that have been charged with the electricity we generate by burning coal still! The hypocrisy of it all whilst having zero consideration for people who might not want to sit in a freezing cold house!

And are you comfortable with causing your neighbours' dementia and their children's cancer and infertility?
Presumably you've already made your peace with the risks you're causing to your own and your children's health.

CelticTok · 12/11/2026 18:14

Can someone explain to me (sorry I don't know the science).... is a fireplace fire (with coal and wood) equally bad as a woodburner, in terms of pollution/health?

And does this mean that open fires outside, like small bonfires and firepit fires are also unhealthy? If so then it seems ironic that 'forest school' activities are seen as the most wholesome things to make our children do!

And what about BBQs?! I hate the smell when DH cranks that up - he seems to use stinky chemical firelighters as well as the coals.

Farmwifefarmlife · 12/11/2026 18:13

We live rural and have a solid fuel Rayburn that I cook on & it heats the water so we’d be pretty screwed without it. We have a log burner in the living room 24/7 now , we’ve not had any heating on in the house yet either. It’s just another thing the government are trying to control. My husband also processes & sells timber & logs it’s is his main income at the moment so again we’d be pretty badly off without all of the above!

TheYorkshirePudding · 12/11/2026 18:13

How can they ban them? Trot around to everyone’s house with a policy and tell us to take it out? They’re so heavy, the flue would need capping off…. Stop being silly. It’s not getting banned. Nobody will comply…unless they give us free heating?

Holeymoley28 · 12/11/2026 18:10

Tricksortreats · 12/11/2026 18:08

I can tell you where the smoke ends up. It comes out of the chimney, cools down very quickly and sinks to the ground. The smoke from my neighbour's house very often gathers in the porch outside my front door, since that's the way the wind tends to blow.
Light your woodburner, go outside and walk round your house. You'll almost certainly smell the smoke from your woodburner.

Can’t smell anything from our neighbours inside their house or when walking by. I only know it’s lit because you can see it from their chimney.

But they use good wood and store it properly I think they are still on the year before lasts delivery.

PonkyPonky · 12/11/2026 18:09

People in nice warm well insulated houses are clueless about wood burners. Some of us need them to get our houses to a bearable temperature in the winter. If you burn the right stuff there is barely any smoke. If you get your wood from a sustainable source and it means you’re using less fossil fuels because of it then you’re not doing a bad thing. Go and drive your electric cars that have been charged with the electricity we generate by burning coal still! The hypocrisy of it all whilst having zero consideration for people who might not want to sit in a freezing cold house!

Tricksortreats · 12/11/2026 18:08

Topofthecliffs · 12/11/2026 18:04

That’s not a reasonable cost estimate. It’s like comparing buying one slice of cake in a cafe instead of a whole cake in a bakery. We buy a load of dried logs for about £120 and there are at least 300 chunks of wood in the pile. Bulk purchase is always going to be the cheapest.

I have an electric air filter in my living room since Covid, and it flares up when I light the burner but settles very quickly once the chimney is drawing. Indoor pollution is minimal but I do wonder where the smoke ends up.

I can tell you where the smoke ends up. It comes out of the chimney, cools down very quickly and sinks to the ground. The smoke from my neighbour's house very often gathers in the porch outside my front door, since that's the way the wind tends to blow.
Light your woodburner, go outside and walk round your house. You'll almost certainly smell the smoke from your woodburner.

Tortephant · 12/11/2026 18:08

They are essential in some homes.

DoubleHellos · 12/11/2026 18:08

Blackoutmaybe · 12/11/2026 16:35

Yes. And I love it. But I live in the middle of nowhere with no neighbours for miles and I am on oil fired heating. I can afford to fill my tank but many people can’t, so for them, a burner is the only/most affordable form of heat.

We only have oil and it is currently 3x the price it was when we last bought it! So we are not buying it and haven't turned the heating on.

We are managing with electric blankets and heaters, hot water bottles and the log burner.

We would be absolutely up a gum tree without our log burner and open fire!

We don't qualify for the fuel bill assistance as a detached house it is a high council tax band (but not remotely fancy, purchased for £350k a few years ago!) and changes to gas billing are irrelevant to those of us not near mains gas!

Whilst I appreciate everyone thinks log burners are awful they are a very valid source of heat!

Holeymoley28 · 12/11/2026 18:07

HRTtoHeart · 12/11/2026 17:57

Because the population density here means we're all squished up against one another in big cities whereas in Norway it's a tiny population with vast expanses.

They have 14.6 people per square kilometre, we have roughly 280.

So the answer is we need less people 🙃👌🏻

Lugol · 12/11/2026 18:06

Anyahyacinth · 12/11/2026 17:58

They are connected to additional unnecessary deaths and a real backwards step..not chic and an ugly choice.

www.theguardian.com/environment/2025/oct/23/wood-burners-linked-to-2500-deaths-a-year-in-the-uk-analysis-finds

Far too broad to say their deaths were caused by log burners. I'd like to see a breakdown of whether they smoked, vaped, used scented candles, what jobs they did, existing health issues.
Too many variables.

Out of 650,000 that die every year in the UK, 2500 is fuck all.

10,000 people die every year in the UK from drinking alcohol and nobody is talking about banning about that. 🙄

Tricksortreats · 12/11/2026 18:05

Lugol · 12/11/2026 18:01

Posters on MN always go on about log burners and the climate etc but if you're using AI or you travel by plane for your holidays you're a hypocrite.

Those fuck-awful Yankie candles have been proven to cause lung cancer but loads of MN posters love those!

Are you getting mixed up? Wood burners are presumably better for the climate than using electricity produced by coal, for example.
We're not talking about the climate here, we're talking about air pollution and its effect on health.
I agree with you that burning candles is a bad idea. It's seen as a real health problem in Denmark, where they burn loads of them.

Topofthecliffs · 12/11/2026 18:04

LiberteLynx · 12/11/2026 16:58

Loads of people can't afford heating and you want to ban the one thing people can do to heat their house on their own.

Wood is not free unless you are rich enough to own a forest and can cut down trees yourself.

A small net bag of firewood that would last maybe two hours to heat 1 room is selling for £6 at my local co-op last I looked.

£3/hr for heat is not very affordable.

That’s not a reasonable cost estimate. It’s like comparing buying one slice of cake in a cafe instead of a whole cake in a bakery. We buy a load of dried logs for about £120 and there are at least 300 chunks of wood in the pile. Bulk purchase is always going to be the cheapest.

I have an electric air filter in my living room since Covid, and it flares up when I light the burner but settles very quickly once the chimney is drawing. Indoor pollution is minimal but I do wonder where the smoke ends up.

chroniciconic · 12/11/2026 18:03

I discovered last winter that wood-burners trigger my allergies horribly- I stayed for a week in a family member's rural house with a lovely log-burner, and by the third day I had constant rhinitis and allergic conjunctivitis, I could hardly breathe or open my eyes. It was our only source of heat in the depths of January, so I had to suck it up, but it triggered a flare in my symptoms that lasted for four months- even fexofenadine barely touched it. It's such a shame that I likely won't be able to visit the house again in the wintertime.

I haven't noticed a huge impact from other people's wood-burners, but I have to admit I'm wary of going near them now.

Swipe left for the next trending thread