Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to refuse to pay this or accommodate him anymore?

43 replies

confusedlady10 · 11/11/2026 22:15

(Sorry if this is a bit long winded). Background: My ex (M35) and I (F30) share a 7-year-old son who lives primarily with me and spends weekends (and 60/40 holidays) with him and his stepmother, who live 2 hours away. My ex is rather controlling (which our son’s first school has also documented) and has been actively trying to gain primary custody this year.

He requested we only communicate on a parenting app and then we went to mediation twice (and agreed to a holiday schedule and talked through any parenting concerns), but months later he called social services on me to gather evidence of bad parenting (after threatening to do so in front of our son over a disagreement). They closed the case the same day.

Anyway, our arrangement has always been that his contact time begins on Fridays at 3:20pm when school finishes (as his job was flexible), and I would collect our son from his on Sunday afternoons. However, he got a new job at the beginning of the year so said he couldn’t collect our son until 7pm.

I said in that case he must pay for Friday after-school clubs until 6pm (£60 a month) and I’d collect our son from school (an hour from my office, where I finish at 5pm), and then he collect him from my house at 7pm.

He initially disagreed but eventually conceded and has been paying the school directly all year alongside £400 in child maintenance. We had separate school accounts, as I also pay for weekday sessions while I work (and he refused to pay me directly).

Our son recently changed schools, but the new school only allows one parent to have a payment account, creating an issue with Friday sessions.

I’ve repeatedly contacted him through the app to resolve this and ask him to pay me directly (otherwise he must find his own childcare) whilst we wait to see if the school has an alternative, but he ignores me (as he does if it doesn’t benefit him). E.g ignored my enquires our son’s counselling, which he’s arranging privately (due to suspected ADHD). I’ve asked who the clinician is and for timescales, but received no response.

After warning him on the app (and getting nowhere) I emailed him confirming I would no longer book, or collect our son from Friday club unless he continued funding it and that I have informed the school that they should contact him regarding collection on those days and will reconfirm it to them in writing.

Only then did he respond on the app saying he is planning to collect our son for the next 2 Fridays and that he doesn’t see why he should pay for it anyway when he already pays child maintenance.

I don’t think I should automatically pay for childcare during his contact time, particularly due to our established arrangement. He earns £100k a year (3x more than me) and I cannot afford this extra expense to accommodate him and I run a strict budget due to my living costs.

Am I being unreasonable for putting my foot down? The school have said they will contact him for any issues on Fridays but I don’t want to call his bluff and possibly leave my son stranded/force the school to call me after the next 2 weeks either.

My sister lives local so she can collect my son in an emergency when I am in the office (if by then we still haven’t come to an agreement however).

OP posts:
confusedlady10 · 12/11/2026 17:55

Sartre · 12/11/2026 16:28

Difficult because if his school is anything like my DC’s, you won’t be able to book onto future sessions if you’re in arrears so if he doesn’t pay the Friday sessions, you won’t be able to use the club on your days. It’s his contact time though so his responsibility. I think you should inform school of the situation so they’re in the know and don’t think it’s ever you dodging the payment. They may put something in place where if he doesn’t pay, you can’t book Friday’s specifically until he does.

They can just call him because he will have to collect him going forward and I am not booking it. I have told them that it is his contact time so if he is not collected routinely on a Friday that is his issue to deal with them after school on Fridays so let’s see!

OP posts:
BadgerBadgerBear · 12/11/2026 17:57

I think you’ve already been asked this but why no weekends with you?

confusedlady10 · 12/11/2026 17:58

TurtleMcTurtle · 12/11/2026 09:32

Have you considered telling him that if he’s not prepared to pay for afterschool care then you can no longer afford to have DS this weekend and he will need to collect him on Friday and keep him all weekend?

Also, going forward I would stop all favours. Put in the app that you collecting on a Friday and having DS from 6-7pm was dependent on him paying for the afterschool session. As he is no longer committing to that, you will simply pick up DS from him on Sundays as usual, and childcare post-school on a Friday is now for him to arrange and pay for as it is his time.

You've given an inch, so now he wants to take a mile. Go back to the court order and stick with it to the letter. No extra hours, no extra weekends, just exactly what is on the court order.

Problem is I agreed to have our son in writing before all of this and if I went nuclear for this weekend he wouldn’t reply and my son would be stranded. Also, aside from the principle I want to have him for an extra weekend as I don’t get much fun time anyway. I will just have to pay for this weekend and then going forward no more favours or accommodating thanfully!

OP posts:
confusedlady10 · 12/11/2026 18:01

Easilyforgotten · 12/11/2026 09:28

Bearing in mind that you appear to work full time, collect your son at 6pm and have him only on occasional weekends, were SS not concerned by how little quality time you spend with him?
Not a dog as you seem to have been railroaded into an awful contact arrangement, but I can't see how the round trip every weekend benefits either you or your son.

Tbh no, and we went to mediation and I negotiated a lot more weekend time anyway which helps. My son is used to the round trip since he was a baby and usually sleep ls on the way home. It is what it is sadly.

OP posts:
CurlyhairedAssassin · 12/11/2026 18:44

confusedlady10 · 12/11/2026 17:52

It is strange. The school have said it directly to me and can only do it in exceptional circumstances and they are trying to find an alternative. The drive back and forth can’t be helped as our son lives with me 2 hours away since I moved out of the house I shared with my ex (when our son was a baby).

I work in a school and am very familiar with your problem. My own school's payment system allows a secondary parent to make payments, but there is only one "pot" - the credit is tied to the child's profile and not to individual parent accounts. It's just not the way it works. Therefore it's impossible to divide credit balances between parents and it's up to the parents to make the payments for their days.

I realise it must be frustrating if your ex is being difficult and not paying their share and that it puts you in a difficult position but that isn't the fault of the school.

Perhaps the answer would be to ask the school if you and your son's dad can EACH have a contract with your own days on, clearly showing the dates you need for that booking period. Perhaps arrange a new one for each half term, and each sign as being financially responsible for their own dates, with an agreement to each make a payment IN ADVANCE so that the school has received payment before deadline so that your son is booked onto the afterschool club register for that month/half term only on the dates that are already fully paid for.

I mean, all that is extra faff for everyone and added work for the school so only to be used in case of a payment dispute beween parents but it might be the only way to resolve it.

If your ex didn't pay for the days he needed then the school would withdraw his place on that day, and I guess that's the point that you'd need to look at your contact arrangements and go back to the family court if your ex was not picking up his son in lieu of paying for an afterschool club place on the days he is due to have him.

confusedlady10 · 12/11/2026 23:47

BadgerBadgerBear · 12/11/2026 17:57

I think you’ve already been asked this but why no weekends with you?

We’ve always had it that way for some reason (apart from the odd time I would have our son for a weekend if my ex needed me to in advice) and I just accepted it. But we went to mediation a few months ago and I negotiated some weekends during school time and half terms which helps!

OP posts:
confusedlady10 · 12/11/2026 23:55

CurlyhairedAssassin · 12/11/2026 18:44

I work in a school and am very familiar with your problem. My own school's payment system allows a secondary parent to make payments, but there is only one "pot" - the credit is tied to the child's profile and not to individual parent accounts. It's just not the way it works. Therefore it's impossible to divide credit balances between parents and it's up to the parents to make the payments for their days.

I realise it must be frustrating if your ex is being difficult and not paying their share and that it puts you in a difficult position but that isn't the fault of the school.

Perhaps the answer would be to ask the school if you and your son's dad can EACH have a contract with your own days on, clearly showing the dates you need for that booking period. Perhaps arrange a new one for each half term, and each sign as being financially responsible for their own dates, with an agreement to each make a payment IN ADVANCE so that the school has received payment before deadline so that your son is booked onto the afterschool club register for that month/half term only on the dates that are already fully paid for.

I mean, all that is extra faff for everyone and added work for the school so only to be used in case of a payment dispute beween parents but it might be the only way to resolve it.

If your ex didn't pay for the days he needed then the school would withdraw his place on that day, and I guess that's the point that you'd need to look at your contact arrangements and go back to the family court if your ex was not picking up his son in lieu of paying for an afterschool club place on the days he is due to have him.

Thank you. I don’t think that would be possible as my ex chops and changes when he collects him from school or my house so I don’t think he would be able to agree in advance to anything. We went to mediation and I cannot afford court sadly. Scared of calling his bluff and leaving our son stranded but he can’t say I didn’t give him advanced warning.

OP posts:
99bottlesofkombucha · 12/11/2026 23:58

If he leaves him stranded I would say ‘if you abandon our son again I will have to apply for reducing your weekends, as forgetting to pick them up or make any arrangements is not parenting, it is stressful for children to be abandoned, and courts will recognise that.’

CombatBarbie · 13/11/2026 00:21

Why on earth did you bow down to every weekend? EOW is the absolute norm.

But back to your actual post. As PPs have said send 1 final message on the app, not email etc, the app is what is used in court stating his time starts at 3.20pm. School have been informed he is the 1st contact etc etc. Its bloody awful that your son has to be put in that situation but ex needs to see you arent there to do his parenting.

DoubleBusy2026 · 13/11/2026 01:12

Your poor son :( I also feel for you, rarely getting any downtime with him. I just can’t imagine..

My only advice is, as you say, to not call his bluff this weekend as your son will be unlikely to ever forget it and may be quite upset, I know my DD would be.

nevernotmaybe · 13/11/2026 02:52

When you say established arrangement, you mean from a court etc?

Granville82 · 13/11/2026 04:25

He knows you care and wouldn't leave your son

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · 13/11/2026 06:24

confusedlady10 · 12/11/2026 09:06

Only proof is from what CMS told me they were awarding me based on how much he earns. He’s not self employed, he works in IT for a company. I should ask them to recalculated I guess! Technically it’s £400 and some change.

Recalculate I bet he did some crazy bullshit like pay £60k into his pension when he knew you were claiming.

I pity the new wife.
He sounds like a nightmare.

confusedlady10 · 14/11/2026 19:45

nevernotmaybe · 13/11/2026 02:52

When you say established arrangement, you mean from a court etc?

Unofficial and then we made it “official” in meditation (and I negotiated some weekends).

OP posts:
caringcarer · 14/11/2026 22:10

trapdooragain · 11/11/2026 22:17

His time his problem

First reply nailed it.

caringcarer · 14/11/2026 22:11

99bottlesofkombucha · 12/11/2026 23:58

If he leaves him stranded I would say ‘if you abandon our son again I will have to apply for reducing your weekends, as forgetting to pick them up or make any arrangements is not parenting, it is stressful for children to be abandoned, and courts will recognise that.’

Yes this is good.

Ophy83 · 14/11/2026 22:18

Child maintenance isn't there to cover childcare during his contact time. He is being unreasonable, I think a court would see this

CombatBarbie · Yesterday 12:35

What happened on Friday?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread