My husband, brother, and I live together in a house that costs $2,550 per month in rent. My husband and I pay $1,700 (two-thirds), and my brother pays $850 (one-third). The bedrooms are roughly the same size. My husband and I share the primary bedroom and an office. My brother has his own bedroom AND his own separate office. The bigger issue is the common areas. My brother’s belongings take up a substantial amount of the living room and family room, and he occupies more than half of the garage. My husband opted to park on the driveway so we can use his garage spot as a home gym, which my brother uses as well. My husband and I bought around 75% of the gym equipment. My brother also uses the entire storage unit that spans the length of a two car garage. My husband and I have maybe 5 feet of space above the cars and he has the remaining shelf. In practice, my husband and I feel like we have our bedroom and shared office, while my brother has his bedroom, office, and most of the remaining usable space in the house. We originally fell into this agreement after my husband moved in when it was just me and my brother who were living here and then my brother and I split rent equally. I will add that when I was working part time and in school, I paid less than he did and my parents picked up my slack. But at this point, that was around 4 years ago. We’ve increasingly felt that the arrangement is unfair, especially considering we’re paying twice as much rent while sharing our private spaces. We’ve considered proposing a 55/45 rent split, with my husband and me paying $1,402.50 and my brother paying $1,147.50. We’d also like to establish clearer boundaries around shared spaces and garage storage. The difficult part is that our family tends to side with my brother, so we’re worried that even bringing this up will make us look selfish or unreasonable and make an uncomfortable living situation worse. Despite living together, we haven’t spoken to my brother in almost a year besides his occasional passive aggressive texts. We would move out if it was an option but unfortunately it isn’t. *I’d genuinely like outside perspectives:* - Is our current rent split fair? - Should having an additional private office and substantially more storage affect someone’s rent contribution? - Is 55/45 reasonable, or are we overlooking something? - Are we being unreasonable for wanting more access to the common areas of the house? I’m looking for honest opinions, even if you disagree with us