Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want MIL staying over so often (or at all tbh)

416 replies

notanotherweekagain · 10/11/2026 22:58

2 months prior, we spent the last 3 years living 10 mins away from MIL. She's nice but very socially isolated and her only 'contacts' are essentially family members. FIL is the silent type and he was retired but has decided to start working again (even though they have enough for retirement).

I've tried multiple times to get her to join local groups or volunteer somewhere but she dismisses everything I say because 'why do I need to meet other people I have my family'.

My r/s with MIL is not easy. She would drop by unannounced all the time despite us telling her to please not to. Once she came over with cake. I was in the bedroom and texted her telling her I was in a meeting. She replied 'oh but I just wanted to have cake with you'. She then told DH that I didn't want her there and that she could stop but she was just trying to be nice.

She wants to join in on EVERYTHING. Sometimes in conversation she'll casually ask what our plans for the weekend were. We'd say we were going to do XYZ. The day before she'll text DH saying she coincidentally has to buy something from the area we were going so could she come along? If we say no she'll play the 'poor me' act and say that she doesn't drive, she's not going to be a bother, she just wants to see us etc.

The whole day then will be dominated by her. 'Just one more thing', 'let me pop into this store for a while', 'x family member said she liked clothes from this shop let's go have a look'. All DH and I's plans derailed because she won't go around without us.

Just a few examples off the top of my head.

Anyway DH and I moved 2+ hours away 2 months ago. We couldn't stand the 90 x 2 minute train commute anymore nor the boredom of a small town so bought a nice apartment centrally! It's a 1-bedroom apartment but as 2 people who don't need much space nor have kids/pets, it was perfect for us.

MIL wants to stay over 2-4 times a month for 1-2 nights each.

DH is sympathetic. He keeps saying that she's happy to sleep on the couch just to see us but that's not the point! I don't want her stuff to accumulate in our house (she's already left her toiletries on 1 out of 3 shelves in our bathroom amongst other things scattered around the house), I don't want her touching and rearranging my things, I don't want her dominating our evenings! DH thinks we should be accommodating as she's getting old and he knows how family is the only important thing to her.

AIBU? It's our home but now it's starting to feel like it's a home for the 3 of us.

OP posts:
nomas · 11/11/2026 11:32

Once she came over with cake. I was in the bedroom and texted her telling her I was in a meeting. She replied 'oh but I just wanted to have cake with you'. She then told DH that I didn't want her there and that she could stop but she was just trying to be nice.

YANBU. My MIL comes to stay once a year and that's enough, I enjoy it.

Your MIL is enmeshed.

It sounds like the heavy lifting falls to you.

Why is she bothering you and not her son? Does your H cook for her, sit with her? Or is it expected of you?

nomas · 11/11/2026 11:33

wildnwilde · 11/11/2026 11:27

Dropping in with cake HOW AWFUL 😱😱 thoughts and prayers 🙏

What kind of job do you have where you can abandon your meetings and colleagues and have cake with your MIL instead?

sittingonabeach · 11/11/2026 11:34

Netcurtainnelly · 11/11/2026 10:58

OP is forgetting she might be a mil one day.

Maybe she can be a better MIL

sittingonabeach · 11/11/2026 11:36

wildnwilde · 11/11/2026 11:27

Dropping in with cake HOW AWFUL 😱😱 thoughts and prayers 🙏

I see you conveniently missed the bit where OP was in a work meeting and the MIL complained that OP didn't join the MIL to eat the cake

rainbowstardrops · 11/11/2026 11:37

Two to four times a month is way too often, especially as you’re in a small apartment now. I know you said your husband is too tired to visit them (🙄) but that’s what he needs to do. Can’t he get a train or a coach or something?
Could your husband FaceTime her?
I think the fact your FIL has gone back to work from being retired speaks volumes.
I’d be nipping this in the bud now and telling your DH that it’s not feasible.

nomas · 11/11/2026 11:38

Netcurtainnelly · 11/11/2026 10:58

OP is forgetting she might be a mil one day.

My MIL has the common sense to understand I can't abandon my work meeting and sit and have cake with her.

And she wouldn't come to stay up to 4 weekends per month.

How often does your MIL come to stay?

Happyjoe · 11/11/2026 11:40

notanotherweekagain · 10/11/2026 23:20

He apparently is tired and doesn't want to make the drive up as weekends are for relaxation! He's neutral about MIL visiting (don't think he cares if she comes or doesn't come) but since she wants to come he goes with the bloody flow.

The thing is while he doesn't care, he should care about what YOU want. If he won't take your feelings and needs into account then you've very much a husband issue.

NotAtMyAge · 11/11/2026 11:44

Theextraordinaryisintheordinary · 11/11/2026 07:05

You will be where she is one day.

I very much doubt it. She sounds extraordinarily needy and demanding and I would hope you and most other people commenting are not like that. I certainly am not. Thankfully DH & I lived so far away from parents and parents-in-law that visits were always planned well ahead, regular but infrequent and much enjoyed on both sides. The same is true now we're the older generation and our children and grandchildren live at a distance too. No point in bringing up your children to be independent if you then depend on them all the time.

Paganpentacle · 11/11/2026 11:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Oh do fuck off. Have you actually read the post?
This woman is taking over and dictating OPs life.
I wouldn't want her around at all either. She sounds horribly manipulative.

NotAtMyAge · 11/11/2026 11:54

Familymanhero · 11/11/2026 07:58

You are cold hearted. Your MIL is family and you are treating her like a nuisance.

Which she certainly is. It's outrageous behaviour to expect to visit your adult child and stay over multiple times a year, especially when said child is married and lives in a one-bedroom apartment. MIL needs to grow up and learn to entertain herself, not expect the rest of the world to entertain her.

arethereanyleftatall · 11/11/2026 12:02

Husband problem. How dare he be so fundamentally selfish that he’d rather you be unhappy in your own home than he have a difficult conversation. Can’t stand these ‘nice guys’ who are anything but nice because they expect their wives to deal with shit so that they can retain their nice guy status. Of course Yanbu to not want this frequent intrusion.

nomas · 11/11/2026 12:06

Familymanhero · 11/11/2026 07:58

You are cold hearted. Your MIL is family and you are treating her like a nuisance.

If you're such a family man hero, how often does your wife's mum come and stay? Does she stay with you up to 4 times per month?

Do you leave your job to go and and sit and have cake with your wife's mum?

CreativeGreen · 11/11/2026 12:06

A small but vocal contingent on here will always tell you that they feel sorry for any and all MILs, and that you'll be one one day and then YOU'LL BE SORRY etc. You could say she came round and threw all your stuff in a skip and you'd get 'wow, how ungrateful, all she wanted to do was help you declutter and out of interest, is your house quite messy? Poor old lady only wanted to help. You sound very ungrateful.'

But this woman is being annoying and intrusive and asking much too much of you, as the DIL - and your husband needs to back you up and help out.

Eightfor15 · 11/11/2026 12:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ByLilacMember · 11/11/2026 12:11

I'd accept pre arranged visits during day but no sleep overs

Thehop · 11/11/2026 12:15

You'll have to start weaning her down

"no sorry can't do this weekend we'll see you next weekend" and gradually extend the gaps.

id also make sure she takes everything with her when she goes or throw it away.

be busy when she comes: stay out yourself. This would drive me mad.

BlueFlyCheetah · 11/11/2026 12:21

notanotherweekagain · 10/11/2026 23:29

Sorry I'm just very frustrated. It's a small apartment and I wanted to put some bags and duffels away so they aren't on the floor but her stuff is in one of our 3 living room cabinets so that's 1/3 of the space gone.

Bag it all up and give it to her next time she comes “oh MIL I found these bits you forgot to take home last time you came, I’ve popped them in a bag for you so you don’t forget them again”.

andthat · 11/11/2026 12:25

Give over @Greenmouldycheese, @notanotherweekagain is accommodating her weekly for a couple of nights a week.

Shes being far from horrible…I wouldn’t want to host someone twice a week either, no matter how much I liked them!

phoenixrosehere · 11/11/2026 12:26

Netcurtainnelly · 11/11/2026 10:58

OP is forgetting she might be a mil one day.

Why is this always a comment?

Do all MIL decide their adult children and spouses should drop everything and entertain even when they’re working and ignore when they’ve been told not to come by unannounced?

Pretty sure many of us who may be MIL someday wouldn’t pull this nonsense and refuse to be independent.

She has a husband at home. Her own son rather his mother come to him than go to her. Why is this on OP and not them and why should OP allow her nonsense when she doesn’t respect OP or her son when they said repeatedly not to come to their home unannounced which is not a hard ask. She has a phone and the time to moan about how her DIL wouldn’t leave a work meeting to have cake with her but can’t use the same phone to ask if their available on xyz at a certain time?

Kirschcherries · 11/11/2026 12:26

notanotherweekagain · 10/11/2026 23:29

Sorry I'm just very frustrated. It's a small apartment and I wanted to put some bags and duffels away so they aren't on the floor but her stuff is in one of our 3 living room cabinets so that's 1/3 of the space gone.

Pack up MiLs things, including the bathroom shelf, and take them
back to her when you next visit.

Simply explain you are living in a one bed place and only just have enough space for your belongings.

You would appreciate her respecting that you have chosen to live minimally and to store her belongings in her own home.

WRT staying regularly, once every 2 months and find a cheap Premier Inn for her to stay in. At some point the sofa will be unsuitable for her and you and DH will suddenly find you are on the sofa and she has a double bed.

BusyGreySnail · 11/11/2026 12:29

I was on the fence till i realised you don't have children. This amount of involvement is insane. Hard no to the weekly sleepovers, that's just odd and inappropriate.

I do feel sorry for her, she sounds very lonely, but the fix isn't to be the third person in your relationship. I would probably want to be kind to her and welcome her on a much less frequent basis, and encourage DH to go spend time with her on his own, but there is no way i would have a family member on my sofa that often.

Firefly100 · 11/11/2026 12:31

Well YANBU for sure. Interesting that people with this issue are often told to move away - you did that and it still hasn't solved it. Obviously your main issue is a DH problem. I'd start by absenting myself when MiL comes to stay - leaving 100% of the hosting to your DH. Girls weekend away, event you have to attend, a shopping trip you simply MUST do alone...whatever will work that she cannot join. Don't make up a sofa bed for her, don't cook, don't buy in food for her, make him clean if the place needs tidying before she arrives. I suspect that will solve the issue. If it still doesn't resolve it, I would then move to plan B and state 1 x month is the max you will accept and proactively offer it to her rather than wait for her to invite herself and tell DH to go to see his mum if he thinks she should be allowed to come in between times. I would also put all her stuff in a suitcase and stow it out of the way somewhere and tell DH to get it out and leave it next to the sofa when she comes.

MissSacharissaCripslock · 11/11/2026 12:33

notanotherweekagain · 10/11/2026 23:20

He apparently is tired and doesn't want to make the drive up as weekends are for relaxation! He's neutral about MIL visiting (don't think he cares if she comes or doesn't come) but since she wants to come he goes with the bloody flow.

Yet at the same time he said he wants to be accommodating as she is old and family is important? Sounds like he needs to put the effort in then as it’s his mum and you are finding it difficult. I know my DH can only take my mum in small doses so I make the effort to take the kids and visit her on a fairly regular basis while he stays at home. She’s a couple of hours away. You have a DH problem.

HeyUpDuckie · 11/11/2026 12:34

Tell her no, you're to busy for overnight stays but dh will come and stay with her instead.

arethereanyleftatall · 11/11/2026 12:37

I think people on this thread who think the op should just ‘be kind’ are the type who never get put in these situations themselves.
the husband could have a difficult conversation with his mum, visit his mum or take his mum out when she visits, but he can’t be arsed.
so instead he gaslights the op in to thinking it is her with the problem.
he goes through life with his ‘nice guy’ status when the actual nice people, the real ones (ie not the ones who just avoid conflict) would never actually do this to someone they loved.
can you imagine it op? Eg say you have a sister that is a bit of a pita. Would you say it’s fine to come over whenever you like even if you’re not in. Would your husband make up her bed and host her. Would he entertain her if she came to his work with cake?
no, no, no and no.
you wouldn’t do that to him, because you’d consider him when helping your sister. He doesn’t give a shiny shit about helping you though.