Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want MIL staying over so often (or at all tbh)

416 replies

notanotherweekagain · 10/11/2026 22:58

2 months prior, we spent the last 3 years living 10 mins away from MIL. She's nice but very socially isolated and her only 'contacts' are essentially family members. FIL is the silent type and he was retired but has decided to start working again (even though they have enough for retirement).

I've tried multiple times to get her to join local groups or volunteer somewhere but she dismisses everything I say because 'why do I need to meet other people I have my family'.

My r/s with MIL is not easy. She would drop by unannounced all the time despite us telling her to please not to. Once she came over with cake. I was in the bedroom and texted her telling her I was in a meeting. She replied 'oh but I just wanted to have cake with you'. She then told DH that I didn't want her there and that she could stop but she was just trying to be nice.

She wants to join in on EVERYTHING. Sometimes in conversation she'll casually ask what our plans for the weekend were. We'd say we were going to do XYZ. The day before she'll text DH saying she coincidentally has to buy something from the area we were going so could she come along? If we say no she'll play the 'poor me' act and say that she doesn't drive, she's not going to be a bother, she just wants to see us etc.

The whole day then will be dominated by her. 'Just one more thing', 'let me pop into this store for a while', 'x family member said she liked clothes from this shop let's go have a look'. All DH and I's plans derailed because she won't go around without us.

Just a few examples off the top of my head.

Anyway DH and I moved 2+ hours away 2 months ago. We couldn't stand the 90 x 2 minute train commute anymore nor the boredom of a small town so bought a nice apartment centrally! It's a 1-bedroom apartment but as 2 people who don't need much space nor have kids/pets, it was perfect for us.

MIL wants to stay over 2-4 times a month for 1-2 nights each.

DH is sympathetic. He keeps saying that she's happy to sleep on the couch just to see us but that's not the point! I don't want her stuff to accumulate in our house (she's already left her toiletries on 1 out of 3 shelves in our bathroom amongst other things scattered around the house), I don't want her touching and rearranging my things, I don't want her dominating our evenings! DH thinks we should be accommodating as she's getting old and he knows how family is the only important thing to her.

AIBU? It's our home but now it's starting to feel like it's a home for the 3 of us.

OP posts:
99bottlesofkombucha · 11/11/2026 09:23

Kick him out the door Friday night to his mums. If he won’t talk to her then he needs to go to her before she turns up, every week is not ok. If you make it harder for him he will discover the path of least resistance is actually not to be found in making you miserable.

Meadowfinch · 11/11/2026 09:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

No, the OP just wants to have the privacy of her own home. That is not unreasonable, and a one bed flat does not offer enough space to get away from someone.

Well done for moving so far away OP. Your MIL is being selfish and completely unfair on you both. You need to get this under control or eventually she will destroy your marriage. You are not an unpaid companion and you have your own life.

I'd agree to a visit every couple of months where you put her first, plus your DH visiting his mum as often as he wants.

boredandgrand · 11/11/2026 09:29

I wouldn't be happy with this in a larger property but in a one bed apartment, it's insane. Tell your DH to go and visit.

CloveRinse · 11/11/2026 09:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Your posts always amaze me. Do you read the OP's posts?

MIL arrived announced and is talking about cake etc.

If that was me - I'd be in back to back work calls and in meetings with management responsibilities - I can't just drop things to have tea and cake with someone without prior arrangement.

OP is not horrible at all.

She is not responsible for being MIL's entertainment centre. Also - this is really DH's responsibility as well if his mother is lonely. What is he doing about it? Why do these tasks always default to women?

AlwaysExtraHot · 11/11/2026 09:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What if the OP was in a meeting room in an office with several colleagues and the MIL 'dropped in with cake'?
Should she be allowed to 'pop in' in this scenario?

IsawwhatIsaw · 11/11/2026 09:34

It was your MIL choice to decide nobody was important but her family, and then rely on them for everything.
It now sounds like your FIL is trying to avoid spending time with her. Her neediness and loneliness should not be your problem.
So this is for your DH to deal with. And if he doesn’t listen to you, that’s a bigger problem.

AbouttimeIhadanewusername · 11/11/2026 09:41

You need to speak up for yourself more. Take MILs stuff out of the cupboards and give it back to her to take home. Just tell her it is a small flat and you haven’t got room.

Coconutter24 · 11/11/2026 09:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Would you find it acceptable for your MIL to drop in to your place of work whilst you’re in a meeting with cake?

TurtleMcTurtle · 11/11/2026 09:48

Theextraordinaryisintheordinary · 11/11/2026 07:05

You will be where she is one day.

Don’t be ridiculous.

The MIL in this scenario has no job, no hobbies and no friends to spend her time with, and doesn’t seem to enjoy spending time with her DH.

I’m on the verge of being an empty nester, but between work, friends, hobbies, exercise etc I simply wouldn’t have the time to visit any of my DC 1-2 nights a week every week. Why would you imagine that OP would set herself up with a boring, lonely life when she’s been actively trying to help MIL find friends and activities?

Life is what you make of it, and the MIL here has made her life very small and her sole entertainment her DS; that’s not fair on him or the OP.

Nomura · 11/11/2026 09:52

FIL is the silent type and he was retired but has decided to start working again (even though they have enough for retirement).

Damed if you do, damned if you don't. Why is it any of your business if fil decides to take up work again and how are you in a position to know whether they have 'enough' for retirement or not? keep your beak out of your parents in law's, private business.

IsItSnowing · 11/11/2026 09:52

I would probably still let her come but I'd set some boundaries mainly about her stuff. I'd just say, look it's a small apartment and you're only here 1-2 nights, please take all your stuff with you and bring what you need for each visit. I wouldn't put up with losing valuable storage space.
Now you're living further away, maybe she will gradually make a few friends near her home or find something else to do. Of course she may just look to move closer.

Petr748bkhj · 11/11/2026 09:54

Sounds horrific, no chance I would let her stay that often. Maybe once every 6 months for a couple of nights at a push.

Noshowlomo · 11/11/2026 09:57

God this would piss me right off, and then have her stuff as yours taking up space! Nope! Bag it up, your husband can visit her.: when she next suggests it, ooops you’ve got friends over that week, and then having some work done so no visitors for a bit. She needs to get a hobby

Boopsi · 11/11/2026 09:59

2 days and nights, 4 days a month might be a little much, but I couldn’t be as dismissive of my mil as you are and twice a month isn’t that much and you could agree a pattern to ensure consistency and plan around it. She’s an older, lonely, woman and she needs her family. Not everyone finds it easy to make new friends as they get older, and you are trying to force her to build a network that she may not feel able to build.

My mil comes round once or twice a week, and we spend approx 5 days with her every 6-8 weeks. Is it sometimes a bit much? Yes. But not often, and I couldn’t bear to think of her lonely and unhappy. And perhaps this is old fashioned, but I think people have a duty towards their families. As a society we decry the loneliness epidemic, yet can’t even put ourselves out to help our own parents?

MargoisanA1arsehole · 11/11/2026 10:03

What are you going to do, OP?
I think MIL is being massively unreasonable. Get her stuff out, pronto! She doesn’t need to store stuff at yours!! She’s moving in by stealth!

Spaniels4Eva · 11/11/2026 10:06

She does sound lonely though, and I wonder if you both need to give up one weekend a month and go stay with her. You can at least be in control of the situation then - arrive saturday morning and leave after sunday lunch sort of thing. It will give her something to look forward to, and you can book the next visit with her before you leave.

cantthinkofagoodusername2026 · 11/11/2026 10:06

notanotherweekagain · 10/11/2026 23:20

He apparently is tired and doesn't want to make the drive up as weekends are for relaxation! He's neutral about MIL visiting (don't think he cares if she comes or doesn't come) but since she wants to come he goes with the bloody flow.

Oh God not another man who just ‘goes with the flow’. In other words he expects everyone around him to make life happen. He will never stand up to his mother. Unfortunately you are going to be the bad guy here, no matter how you handle this. YANBU in the slightest.

Petr748bkhj · 11/11/2026 10:09

Spaniels4Eva · 11/11/2026 10:06

She does sound lonely though, and I wonder if you both need to give up one weekend a month and go stay with her. You can at least be in control of the situation then - arrive saturday morning and leave after sunday lunch sort of thing. It will give her something to look forward to, and you can book the next visit with her before you leave.

Why should they have to give up one weekend a month because the MIL doesn't want to go and find some friends?

Jonasate · 11/11/2026 10:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

No, she’s not horrible. She’s fed up of having her personal space constantly invaded after asking MIL to take a step back multiple times. Everyone deserves peace and privacy in THEIR OWN home. MIL sounds very selfish and thinking about only what she wants, not her son and DIL. She cannot rely on children to be her social circle. This is what causes rifts when it becomes overbearing for the children. She needs to get her own life outside of her family.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 11/11/2026 10:13

Can you ask him how he’d feel if your parents took over the living room for two weekends a month? Why does she need to sleep over?

Jonasate · 11/11/2026 10:15

OP, sounds like your DH has no backbone. You need to take the lead on this to protect your sanity. You and DH aren’t little children that she has control over and can tell you what to do, so don’t let her. Tell MIL that 3/4 times a month is too frequent. You and DH want to spend the majority of your time together as a couple. You are willing to compromise and that MIL is welcome to visit for two nights, once a month, for example. Please don’t let this woman rule your life. It’s a difficult conversation but it needs to be had. If she gets upset, that’s unfortunate but that is her issue, not yours. If DH isn’t willing to have the conversation himself, he can’t be shitty with you for standing up to her yourself.

anterenea · 11/11/2026 10:16

Your new place is too small to accommodate another guest on a regular basis + your MIL has her own husband and family!

Petr748bkhj · 11/11/2026 10:18

Boopsi · 11/11/2026 09:59

2 days and nights, 4 days a month might be a little much, but I couldn’t be as dismissive of my mil as you are and twice a month isn’t that much and you could agree a pattern to ensure consistency and plan around it. She’s an older, lonely, woman and she needs her family. Not everyone finds it easy to make new friends as they get older, and you are trying to force her to build a network that she may not feel able to build.

My mil comes round once or twice a week, and we spend approx 5 days with her every 6-8 weeks. Is it sometimes a bit much? Yes. But not often, and I couldn’t bear to think of her lonely and unhappy. And perhaps this is old fashioned, but I think people have a duty towards their families. As a society we decry the loneliness epidemic, yet can’t even put ourselves out to help our own parents?

Twice a month is a lot though when you work full time, have friends to see and a life to live as a couple.
She hasn't even tried to make friends and fulfil her life another way.

Popping around for an hour for a cup of tea is totally different to staying around 1-2 nights 2-4 times a month. Its way to much.
MIL is responsible for her own happiness and needs to find something to do.

SylvanMoon · 11/11/2026 10:22

How old is your MiL?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 11/11/2026 10:22

OP hasn't been back since last night, but I don't think there's been any mention of how old MIL is?

She might of course be fairly young, but anyway it's worth remembering that this isn't going to get any better with age, and if DH is still determined not to visit himself she'll probably hope to move in