Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want MIL staying over so often (or at all tbh)

416 replies

notanotherweekagain · 10/11/2026 22:58

2 months prior, we spent the last 3 years living 10 mins away from MIL. She's nice but very socially isolated and her only 'contacts' are essentially family members. FIL is the silent type and he was retired but has decided to start working again (even though they have enough for retirement).

I've tried multiple times to get her to join local groups or volunteer somewhere but she dismisses everything I say because 'why do I need to meet other people I have my family'.

My r/s with MIL is not easy. She would drop by unannounced all the time despite us telling her to please not to. Once she came over with cake. I was in the bedroom and texted her telling her I was in a meeting. She replied 'oh but I just wanted to have cake with you'. She then told DH that I didn't want her there and that she could stop but she was just trying to be nice.

She wants to join in on EVERYTHING. Sometimes in conversation she'll casually ask what our plans for the weekend were. We'd say we were going to do XYZ. The day before she'll text DH saying she coincidentally has to buy something from the area we were going so could she come along? If we say no she'll play the 'poor me' act and say that she doesn't drive, she's not going to be a bother, she just wants to see us etc.

The whole day then will be dominated by her. 'Just one more thing', 'let me pop into this store for a while', 'x family member said she liked clothes from this shop let's go have a look'. All DH and I's plans derailed because she won't go around without us.

Just a few examples off the top of my head.

Anyway DH and I moved 2+ hours away 2 months ago. We couldn't stand the 90 x 2 minute train commute anymore nor the boredom of a small town so bought a nice apartment centrally! It's a 1-bedroom apartment but as 2 people who don't need much space nor have kids/pets, it was perfect for us.

MIL wants to stay over 2-4 times a month for 1-2 nights each.

DH is sympathetic. He keeps saying that she's happy to sleep on the couch just to see us but that's not the point! I don't want her stuff to accumulate in our house (she's already left her toiletries on 1 out of 3 shelves in our bathroom amongst other things scattered around the house), I don't want her touching and rearranging my things, I don't want her dominating our evenings! DH thinks we should be accommodating as she's getting old and he knows how family is the only important thing to her.

AIBU? It's our home but now it's starting to feel like it's a home for the 3 of us.

OP posts:
Sweetandsours · 11/11/2026 21:39

arethereanyleftatall · 11/11/2026 18:45

your husband is not a nice guy op. He avoids conflict. That doesn’t make him nice, it means he doesn’t shout or get angry probably. All of this misery for you is caused by him avoiding conflict. I don’t think anyone can help you whilst you can’t accept the root. An actual nice guy would do what he can to keep both important people in his life happy.

So agree.
Selfish, weak men being called nice🙄.

They are not the least bit nice.
They only care about themselves.
That certainly doesn't make you a good man and husband.

JSovro · 11/11/2026 21:17

Tell your husband to grow some balls and talk to his dad about this- he should be spending time with his wife not you two

Umbrellasinthesunshine · 11/11/2026 19:56

Sounds dreadful. Who on earth wants their MIL sleeping on their sofa every month?! And for you to feel like you have to absent yourself to avoid her and then she’s essentially taking your place in your own home? I think you have to assert yourself with your DH. Might be time for an argument. She doesn’t need to stay that often and if DH wants to see her that much he can go there. It’s your weekend too, and hosting her is tiring for YOU! I’m afraid I’d be packing all her bits up in a box to send home with DH. One bed flats can’t spare their storage!

Therealjudgejudy · 11/11/2026 19:35

She sounds suffocating.

Also how could you respect any man who is such a wet blanket? Ick

Wildefish · 11/11/2026 19:28

thepariscrimefiles · 11/11/2026 18:15

How on earth have you worked out that OP's MIL will stay at OP's home 8 days max over a year?

OP has said:

'MIL wants to stay over 2-4 times a month for 1-2 nights each.'

At a minimum, if she stays twice a month that will be 4 days each month so 48 days a year and if she stays 4 times a month, that will be 8 days each month so 96 days a year. That is a ridiculous amount of time for OP's MIL to expect to stay in their tiny flat.

I thought it was 2-4 per year🤷‍♀️ skimmed reading as also cooking. yeah that’s completely different snd apologises to the OP that’s a lot.

Pinkrinse · 11/11/2026 19:26

notanotherweekagain · 11/11/2026 13:04

MIL is 68. I know she's lonely, she doesn't have any friends and never worked so her life is basically DH and FIL. DH is also a very 'nice' guy which means I have to make all the hard decisions and he has a tendency to placate when something goes wrong instead of backing me up.

It's quite sad sometimes tbh but it's suffocating. She's very rigid but not malicious; she just has very strict ideas on what should be done and gets extremely upset when we don't follow so DH just flows around her.

I do go out with friends some weekends but when I get home she just tells me that oh she came all the way she wished she could spend time with the both of us. DH did most of the hosting this past fortnight but that just means they sit on the sofa watching movies and then she cooks dinner for the two of them. Fine by me but I hate how we were looking forward to the move and now our personal space doesn't feel like our personal space anymore. Feels like I'm an outsider when she's there since everything in the house has to be catered to her.

That’s not old! I’m 67 so speaking from experience! I thought you were going to say 87! Thus is only going to get worse as she genuinely gets old.

you’re husband has to tell her this isn’t going to happen, snd if he doesn’t like it he should go and see her. It’s not your fault she’s unhappy not your problem to fix!

BeUmberMember · 11/11/2026 19:16

Stanstanstan · 10/11/2026 23:09

I kind of feel sorry for her.. has she got other children? Siblings? She’s obviously lonely. Can you alternate stays.. every other one DH goes to hers?

The mother in law is not a lonely, housebound old lady, she has a husband who has gone back to work, so is probably still quite young and just needs to get a life of her own instead of depending on her son and wife to meet her needs. Could her husband not drive her on shopping trips when he is not at work? Plus she should realise her son and his wife are both busy working and need quality time alone together on their days off. Perhaps a rescue dog or working in a charity shop or at a senior citizens luncheon club or foodbank would be an option for her.

IsawwhatIsaw · 11/11/2026 19:12

notanotherweekagain · 11/11/2026 13:04

MIL is 68. I know she's lonely, she doesn't have any friends and never worked so her life is basically DH and FIL. DH is also a very 'nice' guy which means I have to make all the hard decisions and he has a tendency to placate when something goes wrong instead of backing me up.

It's quite sad sometimes tbh but it's suffocating. She's very rigid but not malicious; she just has very strict ideas on what should be done and gets extremely upset when we don't follow so DH just flows around her.

I do go out with friends some weekends but when I get home she just tells me that oh she came all the way she wished she could spend time with the both of us. DH did most of the hosting this past fortnight but that just means they sit on the sofa watching movies and then she cooks dinner for the two of them. Fine by me but I hate how we were looking forward to the move and now our personal space doesn't feel like our personal space anymore. Feels like I'm an outsider when she's there since everything in the house has to be catered to her.

So MIL has never worked and has no friends.
A very narrow life then. This isn’t going to get better with age.
It’s sad really but your DH needs to talk to her about her demands and entitlement. This isn’t acceptable behaviour and it shouldn’t be you dealing with it

SpainToday · 11/11/2026 18:48

In these situations the husband is always choosing what they think is the easier path - easier to upset you than upset Mum

Definitely this. But her visiting plans are insane

Agapornis · 11/11/2026 18:48

If he wants to live with his mummy then he should go and do that. Elsewhere.

arethereanyleftatall · 11/11/2026 18:45

your husband is not a nice guy op. He avoids conflict. That doesn’t make him nice, it means he doesn’t shout or get angry probably. All of this misery for you is caused by him avoiding conflict. I don’t think anyone can help you whilst you can’t accept the root. An actual nice guy would do what he can to keep both important people in his life happy.

AMarkAMissionABrandAScar · 11/11/2026 18:26

There a lot of posts about lonely MiLs and giving them a pass for being a bit clingy, but they are usually widowed or divorced. I don't think I've read about any on here that are so bored by their husband that they want to spend their weekends away from him when he's not working. Especially when it's not about seeing grandchildren as there are none in this case.

thepariscrimefiles · 11/11/2026 18:20

notanotherweekagain · 11/11/2026 13:04

MIL is 68. I know she's lonely, she doesn't have any friends and never worked so her life is basically DH and FIL. DH is also a very 'nice' guy which means I have to make all the hard decisions and he has a tendency to placate when something goes wrong instead of backing me up.

It's quite sad sometimes tbh but it's suffocating. She's very rigid but not malicious; she just has very strict ideas on what should be done and gets extremely upset when we don't follow so DH just flows around her.

I do go out with friends some weekends but when I get home she just tells me that oh she came all the way she wished she could spend time with the both of us. DH did most of the hosting this past fortnight but that just means they sit on the sofa watching movies and then she cooks dinner for the two of them. Fine by me but I hate how we were looking forward to the move and now our personal space doesn't feel like our personal space anymore. Feels like I'm an outsider when she's there since everything in the house has to be catered to her.

Honestly, that would be marriage ending for me. I assume that she doesn't have any other children? Her life sounds so dull and narrow. What on earth does she have to talk about?

If you gave your DH an ultimatum that her visits must be drastically reduced or you will be moving out and ending your marriage, what would he do?

thepariscrimefiles · 11/11/2026 18:15

Wildefish · 11/11/2026 18:02

So at the most she wants to stay at the most 8 days over a year. Seriously, just suck it up.

How on earth have you worked out that OP's MIL will stay at OP's home 8 days max over a year?

OP has said:

'MIL wants to stay over 2-4 times a month for 1-2 nights each.'

At a minimum, if she stays twice a month that will be 4 days each month so 48 days a year and if she stays 4 times a month, that will be 8 days each month so 96 days a year. That is a ridiculous amount of time for OP's MIL to expect to stay in their tiny flat.

Brokeandold · 11/11/2026 18:07

That would drive me nuts! Why are people like this?
I could not tolerate my MIL staying at all! Not sure she would have wanted too either, shes the type of person that appears to be happy in company, scuttles home and immediately slags everyone off, think Catherine Tates Gran character!
Hope you can sort this out , dont feel guilty about having your boundaries, she is a grown woman after all!

PetulaGordeno · 11/11/2026 18:04

Wildefish · 11/11/2026 18:02

So at the most she wants to stay at the most 8 days over a year. Seriously, just suck it up.

4 days a month x 12 months is 48 days and that’s the very least.

Wildefish · 11/11/2026 18:02

So at the most she wants to stay at the most 8 days over a year. Seriously, just suck it up.

NotAtMyAge · 11/11/2026 16:44

AlwaysExtraHot · 11/11/2026 16:37

Twice a month is every other weekend!
And she's only 68, for Christ's sake, she's not a dodderer.

I'm 80 and I'm not a dodderer! 😁 DH and I see our DS and DD and their families probably 4 times a year at the most, but always for proper visits when it's convenient to them in their very busy working lives. The 3 grandsons are in their early 20s and the two older and DS work in London and the youngest in Bristol, while DD is in Yorkshire and we're in Mid-Wales. We don't love them any less than we always have, but they have their own lives to live as DH and I have lived ours.

givemesteel · 11/11/2026 16:37

BeenWatching · 11/11/2026 08:19

Goodness me!

Ring her and say that your circumstances have changed (eg more busy at work) and she is no longer to come to your house anymore. If she still turns up answer the door and say she is not coming in

Do you really treat others like that? Would you say the same to your mum?

100% I would if she turned up unannounced, made a nuisance of herself whilst I was on work calls, left all her stuff around my flat and then wanted to stay over on weekends 2-3 days a month. It's ridiculous, I wouldn't put up with that from any of my family.

AlwaysExtraHot · 11/11/2026 16:37

Boopsi · 11/11/2026 09:59

2 days and nights, 4 days a month might be a little much, but I couldn’t be as dismissive of my mil as you are and twice a month isn’t that much and you could agree a pattern to ensure consistency and plan around it. She’s an older, lonely, woman and she needs her family. Not everyone finds it easy to make new friends as they get older, and you are trying to force her to build a network that she may not feel able to build.

My mil comes round once or twice a week, and we spend approx 5 days with her every 6-8 weeks. Is it sometimes a bit much? Yes. But not often, and I couldn’t bear to think of her lonely and unhappy. And perhaps this is old fashioned, but I think people have a duty towards their families. As a society we decry the loneliness epidemic, yet can’t even put ourselves out to help our own parents?

Twice a month is every other weekend!
And she's only 68, for Christ's sake, she's not a dodderer.

Kokonimater · 11/11/2026 16:36

Sadly she is being manipulative. She needs very strong boundaries. Start putting your foot down. Be busy and unavailable. Tell your husband he needs to listen to you.

Somerford · 11/11/2026 16:00

I didn't enjoy reading this one bit. Having someone sleep on the sofa so often in a one bed flat sounds awful, having that person also fill your cupboard space and leave toiletries sounds worse still.

It sounds very suffocating and you must feel like your home and your free time are never truly your own. It's horrible of the pair of them to make you feel that way. There probably isn't a way of dealing with this without hurting anybody's feelings or putting noses out of joint, but currently they don't seem to care much about imposing on you or how you feel about it.

Firefly100 · 11/11/2026 15:35

So unfortunately being away will not be likely to stop her coming based on your last update. Time for plan B then - NO. 1x month max (and personally that would be too much for me). Agree which weekend it will be eg. first or last weekend of the month, put it in the diary and that's that. If she wants to come at other times, tell DH NO and if he has an issue with that HE must go to see HER. Not your parent, not your problem but it is YOUR life and YOUR sofa you want to sit in 3 weekends out of 4. I would be incredibly blunt with DH. So far he is far more willing to upset you than to upset MiL. Change the dynamic. MiL comes and SHE cooks? Damn your DH sounds lazy. Tell him for every day MiL comes more than 1x weekend/month, for the 1 week after you will cook for yourself only as you lost so much free time. Any washing of his you can reject to 'reclaim your free time'? Any cleaning? Make it more uncomfortable to give in to his mum than to give in to you.

Overwhelmedandtired · 11/11/2026 15:30

I really feel for you. It sounds so difficult. You definitely need your DH to step up and have a word. You both need your space. You need a hard limit on the amount she visits you and stays with you (I'm thinking 2-3 times a year!).

Next time she comes, I would have all the stuff she has left at yours packed in a bag and say you are very limited on storage so are unable to keep her belongings in your flat as a start.

Good luck!

AMarkAMissionABrandAScar · 11/11/2026 15:07

Oooft, no. When we had DS we donated our spare bed and turned the spare room into a playroom, which was enough of a signal to everyone that we would no longer be having pairs of guests/families to stay (we have room for a single air mattress which has served well for things like DH's sister staying overnight to break up a drive to Cornwall for work, or a friend staying over after a gig). I feel like you moving into a one bed apartment should signal the same! A regular sofa sleeper is not convenient.

This would be enough for me to have it out with DH properly over you being comfortable in your own home. He doesn't get to keep his mum happy by making you miserable.