Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think cannabis should be legalized and alcohol made illegal at the same time?

218 replies

OonaStubbs · 10/11/2026 22:23

It would solve so many problems. The tax revenue lost by not being levied on alcohol sales could be levied on cannabis. It would massively reduce the violence and conflict caused by drunkenness and whilst increased cannabis use would undoubtedly cause some problems, it is far less destructive.

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock000 · 11/11/2026 21:39

OonaStubbs · 11/11/2026 21:35

No research needed, people on cannabis are much more peaceful than violent drunkards.

What about people who just enjoy a calmly couple of drinks?
Or the people whose mind gets warped and paranoid when they smoke weed and harass their partners? There are outliners on both sides of the coin.
My friend’s husband got so paranoid he installed secret cameras.

XenoBitch · 11/11/2026 21:38

OonaStubbs · 11/11/2026 21:35

No research needed, people on cannabis are much more peaceful than violent drunkards.

Are they? I will tell my friend that then who has her son and his GF living with her. Both hooked on weed, and both in and out the courts due to violence. Her son is under the Psychosis team, and his GF is causing issues with the neighbours to the point any relationship my friend had with them is now ruined.
She wont see her son or his GF out on the streets though.

I have gone out with people who smoke weed, and they are boring as fuck. I don't know any stoners who have jobs as they just smoke, game, sleep, and melt into the sofa.

OonaStubbs · 11/11/2026 21:35

No research needed, people on cannabis are much more peaceful than violent drunkards.

OP posts:
EmeraldShamrock000 · 11/11/2026 21:34

OonaStubbs · 11/11/2026 21:19

The breweries will have to alter to produce cannabis drinks. The aisles of supermarkets will be full of cannabis related products. People and businesses are capable of adapting to changing needs.

People and businesses are capable of adapting to changing needs.
So you want to change the entire industry because approximately 8% of users are predisposed to addiction and some users act violently when they consume alcohol. The ones who become addicted will find another vice, cannibas as you suggested or food. The people who act violently when they use alcohol will still be violent people if they’re using weed.
Do you think they’ll suddenly become a rational calm person without alcohol? A thug is a thug, sober, drunk or stoned.,

XenoBitch · 11/11/2026 21:22

OonaStubbs · 11/11/2026 21:19

The breweries will have to alter to produce cannabis drinks. The aisles of supermarkets will be full of cannabis related products. People and businesses are capable of adapting to changing needs.

I really do not think it would.
Is this idea plucked out of your ass, or have you done any actual research into it?

XenoBitch · 11/11/2026 21:21

Secretseverywhere · 11/11/2026 21:16

It’s not a harmless drug, in people who are genetically predisposed it’s often a trigger for severe psychiatric illness such as schizophrenia.

If there is a history in your family you should give it a wide berth. It is difficult as not everyone reacts the same way to substances, currently legal or not.

I’m a happy drinker, I’ve never caused damage beyond a broken wine stem. I’m not violent or aggressive. I’ve two members of my immediate family who were sectioned after smoking cannabis regularly. In my case booze is probably better all round.

Im sure there are people who get on much better with cannabis though. I wonder in future if we will all be genetically profiled so we understand our individual risk levels

Yep, I have been in hospital alongside others who have been there for drug-induced psychosis. And they will go home, and start smoking again as they seem to think it actually helps them. I have never met a single MH professional who would say cannabis should be legalised. They see the damage it can cause.
My ex avoided it. If he had a few tokes on a joint, he ended up scared to death that something awful was going to happen. I can't imagine how he would be if he took it up as a habit. Meanwhile, he was into craft beers and going to different pubs to try them out.

OonaStubbs · 11/11/2026 21:19

XenoBitch · 11/11/2026 21:07

I really doubt it will.

Think of all the breweries out there, and all the staff. The multiple alcohol aisles in supermarkets. Bars and pubs. Cannabis will never replace all that. I like the occasoinal glass of wine, or a nice craft beer in a pub. I have no interest at all in taking weed in whatever form it comes in.

The breweries will have to alter to produce cannabis drinks. The aisles of supermarkets will be full of cannabis related products. People and businesses are capable of adapting to changing needs.

OP posts:
Secretseverywhere · 11/11/2026 21:16

It’s not a harmless drug, in people who are genetically predisposed it’s often a trigger for severe psychiatric illness such as schizophrenia.

If there is a history in your family you should give it a wide berth. It is difficult as not everyone reacts the same way to substances, currently legal or not.

I’m a happy drinker, I’ve never caused damage beyond a broken wine stem. I’m not violent or aggressive. I’ve two members of my immediate family who were sectioned after smoking cannabis regularly. In my case booze is probably better all round.

Im sure there are people who get on much better with cannabis though. I wonder in future if we will all be genetically profiled so we understand our individual risk levels

EmeraldShamrock000 · 11/11/2026 21:09

OonaStubbs · 11/11/2026 21:04

Cannabis would be taxed and that would replace the revenue brought from alcohol taxation. It is literally a win/win situation.

It really isn’t a win win.
It is not going to happen. Don’t think customers will fill their trolley with weed over Christmas?
My great aunt might prefer a blunt over a sweet sherry.
If alcohol was discovered in this era it would be illegal. It’ll never be illegal. Banning it for weed is ridiculous.
Maybe get rid of cocaine and keep heroin, as heroin users are much calmer than cocaine users, sounds silly doesn’t it.

XenoBitch · 11/11/2026 21:07

OonaStubbs · 11/11/2026 21:04

Cannabis would be taxed and that would replace the revenue brought from alcohol taxation. It is literally a win/win situation.

I really doubt it will.

Think of all the breweries out there, and all the staff. The multiple alcohol aisles in supermarkets. Bars and pubs. Cannabis will never replace all that. I like the occasoinal glass of wine, or a nice craft beer in a pub. I have no interest at all in taking weed in whatever form it comes in.

OonaStubbs · 11/11/2026 21:04

XenoBitch · 11/11/2026 21:01

Alcohol brings about £12billion in taxes to the coffers each year. I can't see the gov wanting to change that.

Cannabis would be taxed and that would replace the revenue brought from alcohol taxation. It is literally a win/win situation.

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 11/11/2026 21:01

Alcohol brings about £12billion in taxes to the coffers each year. I can't see the gov wanting to change that.

Savenny · 11/11/2026 21:01

pinck · 11/11/2026 18:00

Girl, you went from London where recreational weed is illegal to New York where it’s legal and smelling it was a “real eye-opener”? Also, I doubt use has gone up as dramatically as your friend thinks, people are probably just more open about it because,l once again, it’s legal now. Come on now, use your head.

Yes, it’s gone up because it’s legal. Don’t ‘girl’ me thanks.

bababamama · 11/11/2026 19:54

Why, I hate smoking but like wine … I’ve never been violent in my life! Honestly some people

Surroundedbyfools · 11/11/2026 19:10

I work in mental health services and I absolutely do not think cannabis should be legalised. Alcohol is also a massive problem but it’ll never be banned. Educating people is probably the best we can do but you can’t always change peoples minds

pinck · 11/11/2026 19:07

EdgyNewt · 11/11/2026 17:09

^This!

Cannabis is one of the most antisocial drugs.

It absolutely stinks. It should absolutely NOT be smoked in a household with children, but it also smells really bad when smoked outside. Perhaps climb inside a wheely bin with the lid shut and smoke it if you're that desperate??

My SIL uses it and has such bad paranoia due to prolonged use.

And it turns most users into the most dull and boring zombies! Except they seem to think they're the most interesting people...

Lol, what an absolutely insane and wildly inaccurate take. Not liking the smell of cannabis is perfectly reasonable, but declaring it one of the most antisocial drugs and claiming it turns most users into dull, boring zombies is just laughable. I know a ton of people who smoke weed and are incredibly successful, intelligent, productive, and perfectly sociable. They're raising families, running businesses, working demanding jobs, and generally functioning just fine. Your SIL having a bad experience doesn't somehow make her representative of everyone who uses cannabis. Paranoia can certainly be a side effect, but your entire argument is lazy as hell, relying on tired stereotypes and one personal anecdote instead of anything resembling actual evidence. And frankly, considering you're suggesting people climb inside wheelie bins to smoke, you're the one who sounds paranoid. The irony of calling other people dull, boring, and convinced they're fascinating while delivering this spectacularly self-important rant is clearly lost on you. I promise you, being stuck in a room full of stoners sounds infinitely more entertaining than spending five minutes listening to you lecture everyone about them.

Cuttertheduck · 11/11/2026 18:28

HRTQueen · 11/11/2026 17:30

Far less people are smoking cannabis regularly than drinking alcohol regularly so the points you make are not so clear cut

paranoia is very often a side effect of smoking cannabis paranoia often leads to an increase in violent behaviour

far more young people are being admitted to psychiatric wards due to cannabis use than any other substance and people with ongoing mh issues life expectancy is lower

Even if you look at usage per user alcol still does more harm to society and individual users. Alcolism is twice as harmful to users and 5 times more harm to other people.
Alcohol also has a higher number of road accidents per user than cannabis consumption.
While cannabis leads to more cases of psychosis alcohol consumption leads to more cases of depression and anxiety.
Confound that with the higher rate of alcohol addiction vs.cannabis addiction and the higher number of physical risks I don't thing cannabis is more harmful
However alcohol consumption will never be prohibited, the question would be if cannabis should be different.

pinck · 11/11/2026 18:00

Savenny · 11/11/2026 14:00

We went to New York last year. I was really struck by the strong smell of cannabis everywhere. I live and work in London and I’m not hit by the smell of cannabis everywhere in the centre. It was a real eye-opener.

And my NY friend said the use of cannabis there had gone up hugely and she commented on it too.

Edited

Girl, you went from London where recreational weed is illegal to New York where it’s legal and smelling it was a “real eye-opener”? Also, I doubt use has gone up as dramatically as your friend thinks, people are probably just more open about it because,l once again, it’s legal now. Come on now, use your head.

Wopple · 11/11/2026 17:32

Cuttertheduck · 11/11/2026 17:16

Alcohol leads to more domestic violence, road accidents and premature deaths.
I think I take the smell over those effects.

If everyone swapped alcohol to cannabis I don’t think that would eradicate drug induced violence or car accidents. Someone who is going to drink drive will likely drug drive.

HRTQueen · 11/11/2026 17:30

Cuttertheduck · 11/11/2026 17:16

Alcohol leads to more domestic violence, road accidents and premature deaths.
I think I take the smell over those effects.

Far less people are smoking cannabis regularly than drinking alcohol regularly so the points you make are not so clear cut

paranoia is very often a side effect of smoking cannabis paranoia often leads to an increase in violent behaviour

far more young people are being admitted to psychiatric wards due to cannabis use than any other substance and people with ongoing mh issues life expectancy is lower

pointythings · 11/11/2026 17:20

EdgyNewt · 11/11/2026 17:09

^This!

Cannabis is one of the most antisocial drugs.

It absolutely stinks. It should absolutely NOT be smoked in a household with children, but it also smells really bad when smoked outside. Perhaps climb inside a wheely bin with the lid shut and smoke it if you're that desperate??

My SIL uses it and has such bad paranoia due to prolonged use.

And it turns most users into the most dull and boring zombies! Except they seem to think they're the most interesting people...

You don't have to smoke it. Edibles do not smell at all.

pointythings · 11/11/2026 17:19

mcmuffin22 · 11/11/2026 17:03

Could you not say that about every substance legal or illegal?

I can absolutely guarantee you that cannabis does not chill this guy out. It makes him paranoid and makes him verbally and physically abusive towards his mum who has to leave her own house when he is having a psychotic episode.

You could, but it's difficult to separate cause and effect. Alcohol killed my husband and my mum. When I started opening up about my husband's alcohol addiction, it was shocking how many people I spoke to knew at least one person who was also an alcoholic.

And of course prohibiting something doesn't stop people from using it - it just enriches criminals and means that what you buy isn't subject to quality control. If you look at countries that pursue policies of regulation, harm reduction and treating addiction as a medical issue rather than a criminal one, they tend go have better outcomes.

Lastly, I have a DS who suffers from chronic pain. When we were in Canada a few weeks ago, he used edibles on both nights that he had the opportunity. Result: a pain free night's sleep. He could get that here, but he would have to leap through so many hoops, and the cost would be prohibitive. We need to find a better balance.

Cuttertheduck · 11/11/2026 17:16

EdgyNewt · 11/11/2026 17:09

^This!

Cannabis is one of the most antisocial drugs.

It absolutely stinks. It should absolutely NOT be smoked in a household with children, but it also smells really bad when smoked outside. Perhaps climb inside a wheely bin with the lid shut and smoke it if you're that desperate??

My SIL uses it and has such bad paranoia due to prolonged use.

And it turns most users into the most dull and boring zombies! Except they seem to think they're the most interesting people...

Alcohol leads to more domestic violence, road accidents and premature deaths.
I think I take the smell over those effects.

Cuttertheduck · 11/11/2026 17:11

EmeraldShamrock000 · 11/11/2026 08:19

I disagree. Regular popular cannibas use is a new thing. It wasn’t as accessible twenty or forty years ago. How many families twenty or forty years ago had an alcoholic or three within the wider family.
Anything done to excess food, alcohol and drugs have to potential to be an all consuming addiction.
8% of users approx will suffer from weed addiction disorder. Likewise there will always be people who enjoy a drink occasionally and others who knocks one back in the morning.
It has a lot to do with personality types.

It is 23% for alcoholism. Korsakoff syndrome via constant alcohol consumption can cause long term brain damage .
Also alcohol withdrawal or poisoning can lead to hallucinations, black outs and death.
Cannabis addiction can be seriously damaging, but it has a much lower direct fatality risk than alcohol addiction.

EdgyNewt · 11/11/2026 17:09

schnubbins · 11/11/2026 16:28

Cannabis is antisocial and stinks like cat-piss .Cant believe we used to think cigarette smoke stank .It does but cannabis permeates everything and makes me feel ill.
It is destroying the mental health of many young people especially boys and I know through seeing it in many of my two young adult son's peers who are now dealing with psychosis , depression and in one case Schizophrenia.All leading back to cannabis use in their teenage years .My own son's say that going to some party now is a waste of time as so many are stoned out of their minds and completely boring. I have heard many of their peers saying the same
The effect on the aging brain should also be noted ,memory loss with some folk only having up to ten clear memories of their lifetime (heavy users )

^This!

Cannabis is one of the most antisocial drugs.

It absolutely stinks. It should absolutely NOT be smoked in a household with children, but it also smells really bad when smoked outside. Perhaps climb inside a wheely bin with the lid shut and smoke it if you're that desperate??

My SIL uses it and has such bad paranoia due to prolonged use.

And it turns most users into the most dull and boring zombies! Except they seem to think they're the most interesting people...

Swipe left for the next trending thread