Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think cannabis should be legalized and alcohol made illegal at the same time?

218 replies

OonaStubbs · 10/11/2026 22:23

It would solve so many problems. The tax revenue lost by not being levied on alcohol sales could be levied on cannabis. It would massively reduce the violence and conflict caused by drunkenness and whilst increased cannabis use would undoubtedly cause some problems, it is far less destructive.

OP posts:
Portmore · 12/11/2026 20:43

OonaStubbs · 11/11/2026 21:19

The breweries will have to alter to produce cannabis drinks. The aisles of supermarkets will be full of cannabis related products. People and businesses are capable of adapting to changing needs.

Just how much of it are you smoking?

You will have puff the magic dragon as prime minister in the next chapter of your story!

( Actually might not be a bad idea .....)

Portmore · 12/11/2026 20:28

pinck · 12/11/2026 16:05

Where are you getting the claim that cannabis smokers have higher cancer rates than tobacco smokers? I’d lovto see the study. How much were people in each group smoking, and did it account for people who smoke both? A pack a day is twenty cigarettes. Most people I know who use weed don’t smoke anywhere near that. Some take a hit or two in the evening and don’t even get through a whole joint. Plenty of people use cannabis without smoking it at all, so why are you assuming legalization would reverse the decline in smoking?

And since you brought up CBD, I have MS. I’ve tried it, and it didn’t do shit for me. I’m glad if it helps someone else, but why should adults need a medical reason to use cannabis when nobody asks for a diagnosis at the liquor store?

The study was completed in Scotland around 2012 & published in a Respiratory medicine journal. The author gave a presentation to The Royal college of psychiatrists conference which I remember. I can probably dig out the reference you are comfortable reading scientific papers.

The precise reasons were not clear but it was thought that cannabis smokers inhale more deeply, tend to breath hold as they smoke & are less likely to use filters when they smoke which then increases the amount of cancer causing chemicals reaching the lungs. Burning cannabis (both natural & synthetic) is similar to burning tobacco & releases carcinogens. Cannabis & tobacco are often mixed & smoked together meaning more harmful carcinogens.

The overlap between severe mental illness & cannabis use is huge & also well studied.

There was not one person at that conference who thought legalizing cannabis was a good idea

Nospringchix · 12/11/2026 18:12

Nonewshoes · 11/11/2026 10:37

I think we have a pragmatic approach to drug taking in this country. All human societies have used some kind of psychoactive substance, I'm including caffeine as well. It's not going to go away so it needs to be made as safe as possible for people who are users. Professionally speaking, alcohol is by far the most destructive and dangerous drug, the amount of people who are alcohol dependant is off the scale. I am a HCP and would say at least 1 in 5 of the patients I deal with are alcohol dependent.

Yes, as an HCP I witnessed the damage alcohol can do. Working on liver ward wasn't always for the faint hearted at times.

Cattyisbatty · 12/11/2026 17:37

I choose booze and I don’t even drink at the moment.
i hate weed (I used to smoke it as a student), but now it’s ubiquitous and so much stronger and it stinks! My DCs smoked it as students - my eldest went through a big phase of smoking it and now it just causes paranoia.
i know alcohol can be dangerous too, but weed is a menace. Our old neighbour used to smoke it all the time and it drifted in to our house - grim.

FFSItsTooHot · 12/11/2026 17:17

Alcohol be made illegal? Are you having a laugh?i The sale of alcohol would go underground,which would cause more problems than it solves. There wouldn't just be drug dealers doing the rounds, there'd be alcohol dealers.

Mama2many73 · 12/11/2026 17:17

You drinking alcohol next to me does not impact me UNLESS you become emotional,aggressive, loud.
You smoking weed next to me 100% impacts me/my body. I hate normal cigarette smoke, weed is in a much worse category of its own! As a pp has said its a stench, a disgusting stench.

BusyGreySnail · 12/11/2026 17:16

I would not support legalising cannabis. All the places I have been where it's legal are unpleasant. It also absolutely stinks. I was recently in LA and it stank everywhere.
Also I am just not sure I believe it doesn't create social issues. All the users of cannabis (i.e. not just people who might have a joint socially and occassionally) I've ever known appear addicted and their lives are very impacted by the use.
I wouldn't legalise alcohol if it wasn't already illegal. I think it will be veyr difficult to make illegal.

Firesidechatter · 12/11/2026 17:13

littlemousebigcheese · 12/11/2026 17:12

Ban both

We know that doesn’t work with booze so a bit silly

littlemousebigcheese · 12/11/2026 17:12

Ban both

Oxaloacetate · 12/11/2026 16:29

You say this but lots of people react to cannabis with paranoia and worsened mental health. It’s not some healthy Panacea

AmnesiacDream · 12/11/2026 16:29

pinck · 12/11/2026 16:21

And once again, not everyone lives in the UK. I’m in the US, where thousands of people die in drunk-driving crashes every year. Either way, the point remains the same. If the risk of impaired driving is enough reason to keep cannabis illegal, why doesn’t that same argument apply to alcohol?

Not trying to dilute the point that drugged driving, whether alcohol, cannabis, or any other, has a devastating impact on others, but since this is a predominantly UK forum, don't want people thinking our roads are as crazy dangerous as that.

pinck · 12/11/2026 16:21

AmnesiacDream · 12/11/2026 16:16

Without wanting to minimize the devastation even one death causes, deaths in traffic accidents where at least one of the drivers was over the limit are in the 2 - 300 range, not the thousands.

And once again, not everyone lives in the UK. I’m in the US, where thousands of people die in drunk-driving crashes every year. Either way, the point remains the same. If the risk of impaired driving is enough reason to keep cannabis illegal, why doesn’t that same argument apply to alcohol?

Sartre · 12/11/2026 16:17

The prohibition era in the US worked out so well, we should definitely try to replicate it. I can definitely also imagine the middle class parents who like to share a bottle of red taking up smoking pot instead.

Most alcohol drinkers are not destructive, nor are they raging alcoholics. Banning something millions of people enjoy to appease the minority who happen to become addicted or act like utter bellends when drunk isn’t the answer. Also, cannabis STINKS and I’ve met incredibly paranoid and abusive potheads. Also met really boring dead brain potheads, like the drug has zapped any intellect.

GingerBeverage · 12/11/2026 16:16

TwilightSkies · 12/11/2026 15:40

A lot of the comments on here are funny. All this hysteria about psychosis and memory loss. The same people never mention about how alcohol effects mental health and cognition.
Stoned people are completely harmless. They sit quietly in the house and eat snacks.

And no one has EVER died from cannabis. Millions and millions have died from alcohol.

What, like this?

To think cannabis should be legalized and alcohol made illegal at the same time?
AmnesiacDream · 12/11/2026 16:16

pinck · 12/11/2026 14:24

Were you drunk when you wrote this post? 😂 Because the logic here is genuinely baffling. You're presumably fine with alcohol being legal despite the thousands of fatal accidents caused by drunk drivers every year, but somehow cannabis is where you draw the line? Nobody is suggesting that driving while high should be legal. We already have laws against impaired driving, and legalizing cannabis doesn't mean giving people permission to get behind the wheel stoned. You can support legalization AND strict penalties for impaired driving. Funny how that works, isn't it? 💀

Without wanting to minimize the devastation even one death causes, deaths in traffic accidents where at least one of the drivers was over the limit are in the 2 - 300 range, not the thousands.

Firesidechatter · 12/11/2026 16:13

This is a terrible idea for many reasons, I am still surprised people don’t understand rhe impacts of cannabis,

it causes anxiety and paranoia, I’ve two friends who use it, one can’t drive any more, due to anxiety, the other can onky go short distances due to it, it’s terrifying to see once confident people and the slow degradation of their personalities,

in addition alcohol is a social substance, it eases social situations, cannabis users end up in their own little bubble laughing at random inate shite,

itstoolateforsnacks · 12/11/2026 16:10

They are both potentially harmful drugs, and both not a big deal if used responsibly. I do think they belong in a similar category. But I do take your point op that stoned people are way less of a risk to others than drunk people.

pinck · 12/11/2026 16:05

Portmore · 12/11/2026 15:51

The rate of cancer is higher in cannabis smokers than in tobacco smokers.

Smoking rates have been steadily decreasing. Legalizing cannabis will likely reverse that & increase cancer.

The vaping rules were deliberately lenient to cut smoking rates but now we have a generation of young people hooked on vaping nicotine. At the time people made the same arguments - it's harmless , hugely better than smoking or drinking etc

Cannabis can also cause devastating psychosis in young people that remain affected for life.

There is definitely a case for medical cannabis & promising clinical studies for CBD.

We don't need any more recreational drugs.

Where are you getting the claim that cannabis smokers have higher cancer rates than tobacco smokers? I’d lovto see the study. How much were people in each group smoking, and did it account for people who smoke both? A pack a day is twenty cigarettes. Most people I know who use weed don’t smoke anywhere near that. Some take a hit or two in the evening and don’t even get through a whole joint. Plenty of people use cannabis without smoking it at all, so why are you assuming legalization would reverse the decline in smoking?

And since you brought up CBD, I have MS. I’ve tried it, and it didn’t do shit for me. I’m glad if it helps someone else, but why should adults need a medical reason to use cannabis when nobody asks for a diagnosis at the liquor store?

Portmore · 12/11/2026 15:51

The rate of cancer is higher in cannabis smokers than in tobacco smokers.

Smoking rates have been steadily decreasing. Legalizing cannabis will likely reverse that & increase cancer.

The vaping rules were deliberately lenient to cut smoking rates but now we have a generation of young people hooked on vaping nicotine. At the time people made the same arguments - it's harmless , hugely better than smoking or drinking etc

Cannabis can also cause devastating psychosis in young people that remain affected for life.

There is definitely a case for medical cannabis & promising clinical studies for CBD.

We don't need any more recreational drugs.

pinck · 12/11/2026 15:49

SuddenDaredJelly · 12/11/2026 15:41

But what if most of us dont want it?

There are plenty of western countries where cannabis is legal, and it has not even remotely out competed alcohol. You might be a dedicated pot head but it doesnt mean everyone is desperate for a joint & just waiting for it to be legalised. Its not hard to get hold of now!

Our local liquor store started selling THC drinks a over th summer and and they’re already about to pull them. From what I understand, we’ll probably only be able to buy them at dispensaries going forward. So much for supermarkets surrendering an entire aisle to weed. And if most people don’t want THC drinks, they can do exactly what I do when I walk past the wine aisle. Keep walking.

Wopple · 12/11/2026 15:47

TwilightSkies · 12/11/2026 15:40

A lot of the comments on here are funny. All this hysteria about psychosis and memory loss. The same people never mention about how alcohol effects mental health and cognition.
Stoned people are completely harmless. They sit quietly in the house and eat snacks.

And no one has EVER died from cannabis. Millions and millions have died from alcohol.

But would lung cancer or lung disease rates increase if more people started smoking it? Would it count if someone died in a car accident because they were impaired? While cannabis itself may not directly cause death by overdose, of course it can cause deaths indirectly. The actual act of smoking a cigarette does not kill you (unless you seriously overdose) it’s mainly the long term effects that kills.

pinck · 12/11/2026 15:45

SuddenDaredJelly · 12/11/2026 15:36

Oh and "thousands of fatalities caused by drunk drivers each year" is a bit of a sensationalist statement.

There were just over 1,500 fatalities in road collisions in great britain in 2025, in total. For the most recently reported years there were only around ~200 involving at least one driver over the legal limit.

Older drivers are involved in more fatal collisions than drunk drivers.

Shocking as this may be, not everyone on Mumsnet lives in the UK. I’m American. I was talking about the US so citing Great Britain’s figures and calling mine “sensationalist” is a bit premature. Also, what exactly are older drivers supposed to have to do with whether adults should be allowed to buy weed?

SuddenDaredJelly · 12/11/2026 15:41

OonaStubbs · 11/11/2026 21:19

The breweries will have to alter to produce cannabis drinks. The aisles of supermarkets will be full of cannabis related products. People and businesses are capable of adapting to changing needs.

But what if most of us dont want it?

There are plenty of western countries where cannabis is legal, and it has not even remotely out competed alcohol. You might be a dedicated pot head but it doesnt mean everyone is desperate for a joint & just waiting for it to be legalised. Its not hard to get hold of now!

TwilightSkies · 12/11/2026 15:40

A lot of the comments on here are funny. All this hysteria about psychosis and memory loss. The same people never mention about how alcohol effects mental health and cognition.
Stoned people are completely harmless. They sit quietly in the house and eat snacks.

And no one has EVER died from cannabis. Millions and millions have died from alcohol.

SuddenDaredJelly · 12/11/2026 15:36

Oh and "thousands of fatalities caused by drunk drivers each year" is a bit of a sensationalist statement.

There were just over 1,500 fatalities in road collisions in great britain in 2025, in total. For the most recently reported years there were only around ~200 involving at least one driver over the legal limit.

Older drivers are involved in more fatal collisions than drunk drivers.