Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think "well, I wonder who they pissed off" when someone like Brand or Walliams face the music?

69 replies

DogBedPillow · 10/11/2026 13:28

First off, I'm no abuser apologist. The stuff being reported by women about these men is grim. Way outside what should be acceptable.

But also - the sort of thing being reported is beyond commonplace in areas (like show biz) full of high-status, powerful males. "Abuse of power" to attract minors just above the age of consent? Old as time. Grim, but almost universal across time and place for a sizeable subset of men.

And the system protects them. Savile, Rolf Harris, Stuart Hall, Gary Glitter, R Kelly, Weinstein. Cyril Smith. All the Epstein clients who remain seemingly untouchable. Andrew f-ing Windsor. Schofield. And that's just a tiny number of the famous ones off the top of my head. And it's mirrored all over the place - e.g., I've seen how a good proportion of rich bankers and "city" workers behave. Some senior male academics. The list goes on....

I guess that sometimes things just come out through chance factors. But generally speaking, I think there are so many instances where it seems powerful men are protected from consequence for so long that when someone do have to face the music (for what is clearly just commonplace), you have to wonder whether they've really pissed someone (even more powerful) off.

OP posts:
KnickerlessParsons · 10/11/2026 15:30

DogBedPillow · 10/11/2026 13:28

First off, I'm no abuser apologist. The stuff being reported by women about these men is grim. Way outside what should be acceptable.

But also - the sort of thing being reported is beyond commonplace in areas (like show biz) full of high-status, powerful males. "Abuse of power" to attract minors just above the age of consent? Old as time. Grim, but almost universal across time and place for a sizeable subset of men.

And the system protects them. Savile, Rolf Harris, Stuart Hall, Gary Glitter, R Kelly, Weinstein. Cyril Smith. All the Epstein clients who remain seemingly untouchable. Andrew f-ing Windsor. Schofield. And that's just a tiny number of the famous ones off the top of my head. And it's mirrored all over the place - e.g., I've seen how a good proportion of rich bankers and "city" workers behave. Some senior male academics. The list goes on....

I guess that sometimes things just come out through chance factors. But generally speaking, I think there are so many instances where it seems powerful men are protected from consequence for so long that when someone do have to face the music (for what is clearly just commonplace), you have to wonder whether they've really pissed someone (even more powerful) off.

you forgot the Harrods guy - Fayed.

RaggedRocks · 10/11/2026 15:39

KnickerlessParsons · 10/11/2026 15:30

you forgot the Harrods guy - Fayed.

and Bros

Tintarella · 10/11/2026 15:40

DogBedPillow · 10/11/2026 14:22

Absolutely not undermining journalists, etc. Some have done v impressive work.

The point is that there are thousands of men who have done similar, who (these or other) journalists could have focused on, no?

It takes HUGE amounts of time and resource and editorial backbone to get an investigation like this over the line. Note ITN and the Guardian worked together to join forces, and they are two of the largest media organisations in the country. Sure you're right and there are many other men who would face similar allegations if they were investigated fully, but sadly there aren't enough investigative journalists in the country to work at that scale!

HotGrapefruit · 10/11/2026 15:46

Totally agree with you OP.

I don't think there were ANY lecturers at my uni that were not sleeping with students. In the 1990s it was so normal, and if anyone tried to complain, they (the student) were asked to leave. This didn't change until the early 2000s IMO.

HotGrapefruit · 10/11/2026 15:46

(I sometimes google the worst of my uni and college lecturers to see if any cases were brought to light - none were, but there must have been hundreds of women well aware of it.)

DogBedPillow · 10/11/2026 15:55

Re journalists - yes, clearly tireless work went into it. Not detracting from that for a second.

However:

  1. there are MANY pieces of exceptional, tireless pieces of journalistic work which do not come to fruition because they're not supported, or shut down, or diverted, etc., by people with a lot of power and influence;
  2. there are MANY men about whom similar journalistic work could have been done, and wasn't.

So while it's an important point in general, it's far from a complete response to the central questions of the thread.

OP posts:
Laurmolonlabe · 10/11/2026 16:51

I often think it's a balance between the weight of the abused and the earning power/ celebrity of the accused. These people are usually in the dock when the best of their career is in the rear view mirror.

essexmam89 · 10/11/2026 19:21

It’s no secret what’s went on for decades , yet people turn a blind eye when it suits them , elvis , Bowie , to name a couple all slept with underage groupies

i worked the circuit in the 90 s and can think of at least 20 pop stars who should be in prison with brand , he became more of a inconvenience to the them when he jumped ship and started going against the narrative

weirdly enough where’s the uproar of the great queen paying over 12 million to Andrew’s victims and why isn’t he in prison ? Same with the espetein list , over 100 a list celebs on it and no one bats an eyelid

then a total different prospective I know couples from the 50s/60s who married grown men when they had been in relationships from some as young as 12

Iroll · 10/11/2026 19:32

It's sad but it's not only just rich powerful men, or celebrities. It's prolific even in schools, colleges and universities. It's just men. I told my husband it's coercion to keep badgering a woman for sex, I said men feel entitled to sex and women's bodies...he is so supportive of feminism etc and he blinked a couple of times and said...but I badger you for sex... I said yes you do and he suddenly registered that he uses "tactics". I said this is why men accuse women of "regretting" and encounter and accusing them of rape....it doesn't even register in a man's head that they use many tactics for sex, I think they view it as something violent but their "tactics" such as emotional blackmail, or wearing them down to say "yes". Is not consent.

LastChristmasI · 10/11/2026 19:37

I agree.
The issues have been an open secret for so long but countless people must have known and still given them work and publicity.
What made them turn a blind eye for so long?

Accountability needs to reach far beyond these individuals

justasking111 · 10/11/2026 19:53

I had three bosses sexually assault me. The first one I reported and was sacked. I didn't report the second or third because by then I was married, we needed my earnings.

AmnesiacDream · 10/11/2026 20:00

DogBedPillow · 10/11/2026 15:55

Re journalists - yes, clearly tireless work went into it. Not detracting from that for a second.

However:

  1. there are MANY pieces of exceptional, tireless pieces of journalistic work which do not come to fruition because they're not supported, or shut down, or diverted, etc., by people with a lot of power and influence;
  2. there are MANY men about whom similar journalistic work could have been done, and wasn't.

So while it's an important point in general, it's far from a complete response to the central questions of the thread.

I very much agree with point 1.

I think point 2 is messier. When we rely on journalism to pave the way for prosecution of powerful men (and I think we do) we are implicitly limiting the number of men who can be prosecuted because there is a limit to how many stories the public is interested in reading bout and so a limit to how many press leadership is prepared to publish.

What we need is a more accessible/palatable way for women to report assault and for that to lead to investigation. Women don't go to the police because they are shit. If women felt able to report without it becoming as traumatising as the assault itself with no likelihood of it even being prosecuted let alone succeeding and they did so routinely then we would have the data to build cases against prolific predators even if it didn't help much with one off and individual cases.

MiniCoopers · 10/11/2026 20:03

Has anyone who have worked with Williams said anything? He worked on a lot of big talent shows

Goatsarebest · 10/11/2026 20:07

Most of the time we don't hear of how quick they are to use legal powers to close down anyone complaining about them. The Courts were quick enough to grant 'super injunctions' where it couldn't even be reported there was an injunction and the complainant wasn't even permitted to talk about it, even when it was true, because of how it might affect the celebrity. Ryan Giggs, Jeremy Clarkson, Andrew Marr and John Terry all used them to prevent publication of the truth. They weren't criminal alegations in their cases, just the truth about their behaviour. But tge Courts still said nobody shoukd know about them. Fortunately, Walliams didn't get his. We don't know how many are granted because you can't even say one has been granted.

Goatsarebest · 10/11/2026 20:13

Jermy Clarkson tried to get an injunction to stop it being printed he was having sex with his wife😂
He had left her for his affair partner but a couple of years later he decided that the grass isn't always greener and started seeing his wife again whilst still with his new partner. Tabloids found out and he stopped them publishing, until it was published in Scotland and everyone knew. He gave up and said it's a waste of money with the Internet trying to stop people finding out.

TeethAreImportant · 10/11/2026 20:36

DogBedPillow · 10/11/2026 13:28

First off, I'm no abuser apologist. The stuff being reported by women about these men is grim. Way outside what should be acceptable.

But also - the sort of thing being reported is beyond commonplace in areas (like show biz) full of high-status, powerful males. "Abuse of power" to attract minors just above the age of consent? Old as time. Grim, but almost universal across time and place for a sizeable subset of men.

And the system protects them. Savile, Rolf Harris, Stuart Hall, Gary Glitter, R Kelly, Weinstein. Cyril Smith. All the Epstein clients who remain seemingly untouchable. Andrew f-ing Windsor. Schofield. And that's just a tiny number of the famous ones off the top of my head. And it's mirrored all over the place - e.g., I've seen how a good proportion of rich bankers and "city" workers behave. Some senior male academics. The list goes on....

I guess that sometimes things just come out through chance factors. But generally speaking, I think there are so many instances where it seems powerful men are protected from consequence for so long that when someone do have to face the music (for what is clearly just commonplace), you have to wonder whether they've really pissed someone (even more powerful) off.

From just what I've seen on tv and read over the years, it could be any one of thousands of people. Something that stood out about both Russell Brand and David Walliams, is that they always came across as being cruel for cruels sake. Mean, when there was no real need to be, so probably they just enjoyed it, the power. Now imagine how many people over the years, they've humiliated, belittled or just been downright mean to. Now it's all coming home to roost.

Trottersup · 10/11/2026 20:36

Let them all rot in jail. And the women who support them or question their guilt - utter scum.

Trottersup · 10/11/2026 20:38

justasking111 · 10/11/2026 19:53

I had three bosses sexually assault me. The first one I reported and was sacked. I didn't report the second or third because by then I was married, we needed my earnings.

You showed them they could get away with it, so they probably carried on and did it to other women. I couldn't have done that.

Headtorch · 10/11/2026 20:39

I agree, there seem to be so many possible targets, I wonder how journalists decide which cases to persue. Whether some people are untouchable or others have upset someone enough to come to the top of the list.

HoppityBun · 10/11/2026 20:42

Irridescence · 10/11/2026 15:26

Shappi K says there are at least 15 other comics on the circuit who act in a similar vein to Brand, except they aren’t as well known.

There’s apparently an elderly male national treasure about whom stuff is going to be printed when they die. Don’t name any names, but there are at least 3 men who I’m so very much hoping aren’t the one.

NigellaAwesome · 10/11/2026 20:46

I was recently in the BBC giving a media interview. Afterwards there was some general discussion and the presenter said they can only report on about 10% of what they are aware of as they have to be so sure of their sources being watertight.
I am aware of a senior police officer who was using brothels and left operational material in one. It is an open secret, and rock solid sources, but he obtained some sort of injunction so although the world and his wife know about it, it can’t be reported on.

spottybluetie · 10/11/2026 20:53

Trottersup · 10/11/2026 20:38

You showed them they could get away with it, so they probably carried on and did it to other women. I couldn't have done that.

No. She is not responsible for their actions.

LastChristmasI · 10/11/2026 21:02

NigellaAwesome · 10/11/2026 20:46

I was recently in the BBC giving a media interview. Afterwards there was some general discussion and the presenter said they can only report on about 10% of what they are aware of as they have to be so sure of their sources being watertight.
I am aware of a senior police officer who was using brothels and left operational material in one. It is an open secret, and rock solid sources, but he obtained some sort of injunction so although the world and his wife know about it, it can’t be reported on.

The press also often very much make a decision to not publish certain things. I have a family member who has been trying to persuade the press to report on a cluster of actual convictions that would be hugely newsworthy if published. But for some reason the press refuse (well, we can guess at the reasons - powerful interests)

LizzieSiddal · 10/11/2026 21:17

DogBedPillow · 10/11/2026 14:22

Absolutely not undermining journalists, etc. Some have done v impressive work.

The point is that there are thousands of men who have done similar, who (these or other) journalists could have focused on, no?

How many journalists do you think there are? Like every other industry, the number of journalists has been decimated in the last few decades. It would have cost hundreds of thousands to investigate Brand and Walliams, so the men they do choose to investigate have to be well known because if they chose to investigate Mr X who works in an office in Swindon, only a very few people would know him, so not many would be intested in reading about him.

I do think we need to change the way these crimes are dealt with. Women do not want to go t the police so we need to come up with something else.

fivepastmidnight · 10/11/2026 21:18

I think the people in charge who allowed it to continue made financial decisons - Brand attracted audiences and money and Walliams too as well 40% of the revenue of the publishing company. When they became less financially attractive they were open to prosecution. They can do all the hand wringing they want now but it is bullshit . They do not care about women then or now. They will be currently covering for others making them money.

Reading Walliams story today I didn't realise how long the investigation had been going on. I know they claim a change of leadership re the publishers but I suspect it is more they got wind of the investigation - heard it was by ITN and the Guardian - and didn't want to be on the wrong side if and when it came out.

There was a lot of why did they not come forward sooner in some places but it seems many did and were ignored. Kathryn Ryan is top of her game at the moment - re the amount of programmes she is on and touring etc. I suspect if she was not a money maker her comments would have been ignored and she would be dropped.