Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the age of consent needs to be increased to protect children from predators? (title edited by MNHQ at request of OP)

179 replies

Sweepingthetide · 10/11/2026 13:15

In a week of news around celebrity predators, I am sick of hearing about men sleeping with or waiting until girls turn 16 to have sex with them.

16 and 17 year olds are not adults. They must stay in education. They cannot drink. I totally understand 16 and 17 year olds wanting to have sex with people their own age. But surely the law could be changed in a way that tries to protect them from adults?

OP posts:
DarkAngel23 · 11/11/2026 16:39

TempestTost · 11/11/2026 16:16

The thing is that the fact that there are predatory men who will try and skirt the edges of the law does not necessarily mean that the marginal activity should be restricted.

You see this in a lot of different scenarios. At my work, we have a public service that is being looked at constantly because of a minority of people abusing it. We've tried tightening up the requirements and rules. We've tried to change the processes in the back systems to make it less easy for people to do it - which means more work for us and some annoyance for people using it properly.

They are now considering stopping the service because of this minority of jerks who abuse staff what they don't get what they want.

The thing is - the service is fine in itself. People like it. But these assholes who don't care about other people have meant we tighten up the rules so the service isn't as good and maybe will disappear.

My point being, the fact that there are abusive people does not mean that non-abusive people should be stopped from doing something to try and deter the jerks.

What DW was doing was not just dating someone of barely legal age. It frankly doesn't even come close. What he was doing was already totally and entirely illegal and he may well go to prison for it. Almost everyone thinks he should go to prison. Clearly that possibility didn't deter him and it didn't help the girls he targeted.

Is there really a good reason though for the current age of consent law staying as it is? Who is it benefiting (mainly creepy older men). I think the majority of sensible people can agree that the ‘marginal’ activity (dating a barely legal teen) is morally wrong in 2026.

Its not a work process, we are talking about protecting minors here.

DarkAngel23 · 11/11/2026 16:21

TempestTost · 11/11/2026 16:04

So here is my question about this:

Do you think that a 16 year old is capable of making responsible decisions about who she has sex with? That doesn't mean she will always choose correctly, just as older women don't. But that she has capacity.

If she is, why would you impose an arbitrary cutoff on who she can decide to have sex with?

If she isn't, why is she allowed to make a decision to have sex with other teens? They are just as likely to be predatory twats as older men.

There is a big difference in maturity between a 16yr old and someone 20 plus. Id argue there is significant difference in maturity between 16 and 18/19 yr olds too.

Yes we know 16 yr old want to explore sex, and yes we know they need to make mistakes but they dont need to make ‘mistakes’ with creepy older men. 16/17 yr olds are much easier to control and manipulate thats why these men pursue them. In 2026 we know that more often or not these ‘relationships’ cause harm to the young person. Social norms change and our consent laws should reflect this.

Yes sadly a change in law wont stop peer to peer abuse, but we can and should easily give 16/17 yr old minors protection from predatory adults.

I cannot understand why it is so difficult for some people to grasp this.

Crunchymum · 11/11/2026 16:17

Thundertoast · 10/11/2026 14:15

Cant wait for all the people who met their husband when they were 17 and he was 28 and actually 'i was very mature for my age' and 'im actually the one who wears the trousers' and they've been happily married for 40 years with three kids and so that makes it TOTALLY FINE that their husband was a fully grown adult man chasing a teenage girl and its NOT CREEPY and nothing bad ever happened to them come onto the thread.
Bonus points for if they wouldnt let their own teenagers date a man of that age because 'it was different back then, I was more mature, it was normal'.

Head over to the thread/s about JR and you'll see pages full of this!

TempestTost · 11/11/2026 16:17

displayedg · 11/11/2026 16:07

There already is an arbitrary cutoff.

I am asking you, if 16 is too young for sex, why allow 16 year olds to make the decision to have sex with anyone at all.

TempestTost · 11/11/2026 16:16

DarkAngel23 · 11/11/2026 15:56

Id say keep it simple. 3-4 year gap max for all 16/17 yr olds. For me 16/19 is acceptable.

Would I want to see an 18/19 yr old with a 30 yr old, no, but I think given 18 is legally an adult, it would be a harder change to get public support for and through parliament to restrict consent ages for 18 plus. All you have to do is look at the comments online around this to see how much resistance there still is. When faced with losing their ‘legal right’ to have sex with a schoolgirl, disgusting men using the arguments that ‘16/17 yr olds are not innocent/teases’ or ‘girls mature faster’.

I do think there should be some safeguards though if a much older person starts the ‘grooming’ process prior to that person turning 18 though. We can see that DW used that tactic so he could argue he did nothing illegal. I do hope police look into it and he is prosecuted for the sexual assault against the 15 yr old. I imagine he justified it being ok to himself as not being ‘full sex’. I had someone do similar to me.

As horrible as the RB/DW cases are, I do really hope this prompts some form of national conversation around consent.

The thing is that the fact that there are predatory men who will try and skirt the edges of the law does not necessarily mean that the marginal activity should be restricted.

You see this in a lot of different scenarios. At my work, we have a public service that is being looked at constantly because of a minority of people abusing it. We've tried tightening up the requirements and rules. We've tried to change the processes in the back systems to make it less easy for people to do it - which means more work for us and some annoyance for people using it properly.

They are now considering stopping the service because of this minority of jerks who abuse staff what they don't get what they want.

The thing is - the service is fine in itself. People like it. But these assholes who don't care about other people have meant we tighten up the rules so the service isn't as good and maybe will disappear.

My point being, the fact that there are abusive people does not mean that non-abusive people should be stopped from doing something to try and deter the jerks.

What DW was doing was not just dating someone of barely legal age. It frankly doesn't even come close. What he was doing was already totally and entirely illegal and he may well go to prison for it. Almost everyone thinks he should go to prison. Clearly that possibility didn't deter him and it didn't help the girls he targeted.

Sweepingthetide · 11/11/2026 16:07

TempestTost · 11/11/2026 16:01

Here is the thing OP.

People struggle to stop 15 and 16 yo's who want to have sex from doing so now.

A 16 year old can leave home, leave school and work. Is it really practical to tell them it's illegal for them to have sex? Are you going to prosecute them or their partners?

As I've said this isn't about preventing 16 YOs from having sex. It is about preventing much older men from having sex with under 18s. The suggestions PPs have laid out make perfect sense to me.

OP posts:
displayedg · 11/11/2026 16:07

TempestTost · 11/11/2026 16:04

So here is my question about this:

Do you think that a 16 year old is capable of making responsible decisions about who she has sex with? That doesn't mean she will always choose correctly, just as older women don't. But that she has capacity.

If she is, why would you impose an arbitrary cutoff on who she can decide to have sex with?

If she isn't, why is she allowed to make a decision to have sex with other teens? They are just as likely to be predatory twats as older men.

There already is an arbitrary cutoff.

TempestTost · 11/11/2026 16:04

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 10/11/2026 13:29

I agree that it’s about the age gap, rather than 16 being too young for two consenting 16 year olds to be together. I think a change in the law could actually help bring about the cultural shift we need - so that creepy older men coming on to young girls is no longer seen as socially acceptable.

So here is my question about this:

Do you think that a 16 year old is capable of making responsible decisions about who she has sex with? That doesn't mean she will always choose correctly, just as older women don't. But that she has capacity.

If she is, why would you impose an arbitrary cutoff on who she can decide to have sex with?

If she isn't, why is she allowed to make a decision to have sex with other teens? They are just as likely to be predatory twats as older men.

TempestTost · 11/11/2026 16:01

Here is the thing OP.

People struggle to stop 15 and 16 yo's who want to have sex from doing so now.

A 16 year old can leave home, leave school and work. Is it really practical to tell them it's illegal for them to have sex? Are you going to prosecute them or their partners?

displayedg · 11/11/2026 15:59

user293948849167 · 11/11/2026 15:35

Of course we wouldn’t prosecute a pregnant under 18 year old, we don’t prosecute pregnant under 16 year olds now do we!

But I do get your point about what happens when they turn 19, an age gap rule may be better then - so 16-18 is ok with an age gap under 3 years, for example

This is daft . An 18 year old is an adult and she can go out with and sleep with a 22 year old if she chooses.

DarkAngel23 · 11/11/2026 15:56

Id say keep it simple. 3-4 year gap max for all 16/17 yr olds. For me 16/19 is acceptable.

Would I want to see an 18/19 yr old with a 30 yr old, no, but I think given 18 is legally an adult, it would be a harder change to get public support for and through parliament to restrict consent ages for 18 plus. All you have to do is look at the comments online around this to see how much resistance there still is. When faced with losing their ‘legal right’ to have sex with a schoolgirl, disgusting men using the arguments that ‘16/17 yr olds are not innocent/teases’ or ‘girls mature faster’.

I do think there should be some safeguards though if a much older person starts the ‘grooming’ process prior to that person turning 18 though. We can see that DW used that tactic so he could argue he did nothing illegal. I do hope police look into it and he is prosecuted for the sexual assault against the 15 yr old. I imagine he justified it being ok to himself as not being ‘full sex’. I had someone do similar to me.

As horrible as the RB/DW cases are, I do really hope this prompts some form of national conversation around consent.

BertieBotts · 11/11/2026 15:53

Arbourimage · 11/11/2026 07:48

Literally none of these laws sound weird at all.

Yeah it probably didn't help that I wrote about the bits I found weird and then deleted them but left in the last sentence.

There are other reasons Germany is weird about sex. They are not especially relevant on this thread.

user293948849167 · 11/11/2026 15:35

mummymeister · 11/11/2026 15:00

But you see the minute you start saying that 16,17 and 18 year olds can have sex with each other then the classic thing happens. 16 and 18 year old go out together. have a sexual relationship. older person turns 19 and what then? they have to stop having sex until the younger one reaches 18. that is a completely unworkable rule. and do we prosecute under 18 when they are pregnant?

Of course we wouldn’t prosecute a pregnant under 18 year old, we don’t prosecute pregnant under 16 year olds now do we!

But I do get your point about what happens when they turn 19, an age gap rule may be better then - so 16-18 is ok with an age gap under 3 years, for example

hourglass2 · 11/11/2026 15:31

StarlightLady · 11/11/2026 14:46

Apologies. I forgot a out the voting age change.

No problem

Wemustbetherebynow · 11/11/2026 15:02

user293948849167 · 11/11/2026 14:55

Legal age for marriage should be 18 across the whole of the UK, not allowed at 16 with parental consent either.
Likewise joining the forces at 16, ok - but actually be sent to “die for your country” shouldn’t be allowed until 18.

The difference in maturity between 16 and 18 is huge too, the age of consent rising to 18 means the young person being more likely to recognise grooming and coercion.

I wouldn’t want to see an 18 year old prosecuted for having sex with a 16 year old, but some kind of regulation where 16,17 & 18 having sex with eachother is ok but 19+ having sex with a minor (under 18) is not (and why would they want to really?).

Edited

young people joining the forces in the U.K. are not supposed to go into combat until 18, and do actually retain a right to leave immediately if they choose, which is what made the abuse of these young people even more awful. however there are lots of other issues to my mind with 16 and 17 year olds in the forces, though I recognise that some of them are using it to escape intolerable situations at home. (I feel there should be some sort of guardian/advocate located on each site for military personnel under 18)

mummymeister · 11/11/2026 15:00

user293948849167 · 11/11/2026 14:55

Legal age for marriage should be 18 across the whole of the UK, not allowed at 16 with parental consent either.
Likewise joining the forces at 16, ok - but actually be sent to “die for your country” shouldn’t be allowed until 18.

The difference in maturity between 16 and 18 is huge too, the age of consent rising to 18 means the young person being more likely to recognise grooming and coercion.

I wouldn’t want to see an 18 year old prosecuted for having sex with a 16 year old, but some kind of regulation where 16,17 & 18 having sex with eachother is ok but 19+ having sex with a minor (under 18) is not (and why would they want to really?).

Edited

But you see the minute you start saying that 16,17 and 18 year olds can have sex with each other then the classic thing happens. 16 and 18 year old go out together. have a sexual relationship. older person turns 19 and what then? they have to stop having sex until the younger one reaches 18. that is a completely unworkable rule. and do we prosecute under 18 when they are pregnant?

user293948849167 · 11/11/2026 14:55

mummymeister · 11/11/2026 12:55

So we move it to 18 and these people groom until that deadline is met? or 21 or 25 or whatever. Moving the age of consent now is going to be a massive can of worms. so you can get married at 17 but not have sex until you are 18? or you can join the army and die for your country at 16 or 17 but not have sex?

The issue here is 100% not underage sex or age gaps or anything else. Its grooming. Its power and the exercising of it over other people. Its the culture, its the expected norms the not speaking out the turning a blind eye because this or that person is deemed to be talent and therefore their every whim is catered for.

We the public and those in the industry have known about this for years and yet still they perpetuate it.

The whole age gap thing is an absolute nonsense. you cant dictate to people who are of legal age of consent who they can and cannot marry. however much one cant understand the attraction between a 20 year old and a 40 or 50 year old it happens and people remain happily married for years. But honestly thats not what we should be talking about here. we should be talking about coercion and power and the entertainment industry where nepotism and favour is rife.

Legal age for marriage should be 18 across the whole of the UK, not allowed at 16 with parental consent either.
Likewise joining the forces at 16, ok - but actually be sent to “die for your country” shouldn’t be allowed until 18.

The difference in maturity between 16 and 18 is huge too, the age of consent rising to 18 means the young person being more likely to recognise grooming and coercion.

I wouldn’t want to see an 18 year old prosecuted for having sex with a 16 year old, but some kind of regulation where 16,17 & 18 having sex with eachother is ok but 19+ having sex with a minor (under 18) is not (and why would they want to really?).

StarlightLady · 11/11/2026 14:46

hourglass2 · 11/11/2026 14:21

Voting age depends on where you are, it's 18 for now but it will be lowered to 16 at the next GE, and as for medical procedures it depends on the child and what they want, they're not all super confident, I know mine isn't..

Apologies. I forgot a out the voting age change.

BestZebbie · 11/11/2026 14:33

DarkAngel23 · 10/11/2026 20:29

I support staggered age of consent laws for 16/17 yrs who are still legally minors and have been very vocal about it. It’s surprising how so many people are against it though and use ‘the past’ or ‘maturity’ to justify sex with someone that age.

Even those who support it though disagree on what age gap is acceptable. Im in favour of a 3 year gap for 16 year olds, maybe 4 for 17 year olds. I think 5 years is too large. I think my fear is that it would create a legal loophole for a 20/21 to avoid being criminalised with having sex with someone ‘nearly 16’ or sexual abuse within a relationship just because they are now classed as ‘young adult’. But this is specifically based on my own personal life experiences so I tend to ‘see red’ around this particular age gap. Someone who had a more positive life experience will see things differently

It wouldn’t be perfect but if we can protect 16/17 yr olds from exploitative relationships either much older adults then we should.

How about "persons aged between 16 and 21 may consent to sexual activity with persons who are also over the age of 16 but no more than 4 years older or younger. e.g.: 16-20, 17-21, 18-22, 19-23, 20-24."

user293948849167 · 11/11/2026 14:28

Agreed. Some sort of protection so that the age of consent rises to 18 but that 16-18 year olds having sex with eachother would not be a crime.
They manage this in many US states so it is possible

hourglass2 · 11/11/2026 14:21

StarlightLady · 11/11/2026 09:08

But as PP said, there is a power imbalance. That imbalance is still there with an 18 year old woman (or man come to that) and a 30/40 year old other party. So raising the age alone is just kicking the can down the road.

At 15 (40s now) my hormones were bubbling.

Easier said than done but l think better education is needed about consent and identifying grooming. This is not solved by a magic birthday.

Would it be right for a 16 year old not to be able to consent to a medical procedure?

The voting age is 18, not 16.

Voting age depends on where you are, it's 18 for now but it will be lowered to 16 at the next GE, and as for medical procedures it depends on the child and what they want, they're not all super confident, I know mine isn't..

Minasama · 11/11/2026 13:29

MJagain · 11/11/2026 08:19

Not very helpful now though is it.

millions of young people grow up without a father figure. Even if dad is in the house, a quick look on these forums tellls you they often don’t care enough to parent a teenager appropriately

It’s so sad and so negative overall for society. This is just one example of where a child can really benefit from a good father.

mummymeister · 11/11/2026 12:55

So we move it to 18 and these people groom until that deadline is met? or 21 or 25 or whatever. Moving the age of consent now is going to be a massive can of worms. so you can get married at 17 but not have sex until you are 18? or you can join the army and die for your country at 16 or 17 but not have sex?

The issue here is 100% not underage sex or age gaps or anything else. Its grooming. Its power and the exercising of it over other people. Its the culture, its the expected norms the not speaking out the turning a blind eye because this or that person is deemed to be talent and therefore their every whim is catered for.

We the public and those in the industry have known about this for years and yet still they perpetuate it.

The whole age gap thing is an absolute nonsense. you cant dictate to people who are of legal age of consent who they can and cannot marry. however much one cant understand the attraction between a 20 year old and a 40 or 50 year old it happens and people remain happily married for years. But honestly thats not what we should be talking about here. we should be talking about coercion and power and the entertainment industry where nepotism and favour is rife.

displayedg · 11/11/2026 12:49

Where is the line drawn though? 16 and 46 is clearly wrong. Are we then saying 18 and 48 is okay? It isn’t, surely? But then by 28 and 58? That is surely their choice. It’s just such a grey area for legislation.

StillCreatingAName · 11/11/2026 12:37

But you can’t treat them like a 10 year old nor can you lock them in their rooms until they are adults, and you can only know what they tell you.

The irony of how much worse it can be when they are kept in their rooms, just freestyling on their smartphones. They’re actually ‘safer’ to be with real friends walking the dark streets at night- but would you let a 13yo walk alone late at night? Huge numbers of children under 16 are free to engage in chat at any time of the day, they freestyle with sharing pics and go to meet ups organised via groups and social media- all without, legally enforced age restrictions.

Who shall we blame when our children have been groomed online or via WhatsApp and other private messages? When the boys have been influenced by porn and normalise choking, when they’re confused about consent because of what they’ve seen online in unregulated content.

If you’re concerned about the age of consent and angry at celebrity males you really shouldn’t be allowing any under 16 to be anywhere near social media or have a smartphone, before they’re ready- especially emotionally- to handle the situations they can end up in 🤷‍♀️