Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to pull DS out of music classes?

77 replies

MeerkatEyes · 10/11/2026 11:10

DS is 6. He started music ( tin whistle) classes at the end of Sept. There are 3 other boys in his class - two are 8, one is 6 or possibly 7.

DS is struggling a bit. He can’t get his fingers onto the whistle properly to cover the bottom holes. The other boys seem to be better than him.

We didn’t have class at Halloween so there was a 2 week break. We were away for a few days so he didn’t get to practice.

The teacher takes the boys into a small room and parents stay outside (but must stay on premises).

Last night DS left class really upset. I knew there was something wrong and he started crying as soon he got into car. He says that the teacher told him he might have to go to a different class if he doesn’t practice. Also at one point, he says, he played a squeaky note and the teacher said ‘are you deaf?’ to him loudly

I am furious. I don’t know whether to pull him out and ask for our money back. I think it’s unacceptable that she would say that to him without having discussed moving classes or being annoyed at the lack of practice to me.

Just to add - he doesn’t practice daily. We did 20 mins practice on Saturday and I lifted him early from after-school yesterday and he did another 20/25 mins practice.

Just to add, my initial reaction was to say that we’d practice every night and work on it together. However when my partner got home he mentioned quitting and finding another teacher, so that’s what DS now wants to do.

Just looking for views and advice really. Posting in AIBU for traffic! AIBU for pulling him out?

OP posts:
Natsku · 11/11/2026 05:53

Definitely good to take a break from the classes so he doesn't associate music lessons with getting upset and crying.

For daily practice, get up ten minutes earlier and do ten minutes straight after breakfast every day (or before breakfast, whichever works better). Me and my brothers always did our piano practice in the mornings that way, meant we weren't too tired for it and there wasn't an issue finding the time later in the day with extra curriculars and all.

Clydebuilt · 11/11/2026 05:57

MeerkatEyes · 10/11/2026 12:14

Thanks all.

I know we don’t practice enough. He’s in after-school until 5:30 every day, DP and I both work full-time (and I have a 3 hour commute) and we also have a 4 year old. Both DC have extra-curricular sports as well, and DS has stacks of homework. So life is hectic and we tend to do a couple of practice sessions at the weekend rather than the recommended 10 mins per day.

I have spoken to the teacher who says that DS kept saying last night ‘this is easy’ (I believe her about this). She says she’d asked him if he wanted to continue with the other boys or take some classes on his own.

She says she didn’t ask him if he was deaf (which I don’t believe as I don’t think he’d have made it up).

I think he was being a pain in the ass and she snapped. Which is still unacceptable in my opinion given that she made a child cry (albeit a very human and understandable reaction).

I don’t know what to do now!

Then he has no time for playing a musical instrument…

Doubleskunk · 11/11/2026 06:00

He’s six. This class isn’t for him. Stop the lessons and if he wants to learn an instrument when he’s older, then start afresh then. He shouldn’t feel pressurised at this age.

handybrandy · 11/11/2026 06:13

Doubleskunk · 11/11/2026 06:00

He’s six. This class isn’t for him. Stop the lessons and if he wants to learn an instrument when he’s older, then start afresh then. He shouldn’t feel pressurised at this age.

Yup

Leavemetonguetied · 11/11/2026 06:20

God, stop the lessons! I did all the grades in several instruments and what I learnt is that you should love the music. The grades and the formal learning suck out the fun. Get him a ukulele and help him learn some easy songs using YouTube/ a kids beginner book.

HalzTangz · 11/11/2026 06:20

I would actually speak to the teacher first and see if she did say what your son has told you. If she did, report her and find him a new class. If she didn't speak to your son about lying.
It could be she's told him to practice more, he's took offence at being told to do this (maybe because he wants to play guitar) and saw an opportunity to leave the class.
Kids don't always portray things accurately

queenceleste · 11/11/2026 06:21

this is so so wrong at this age.
my dd had nothing but love and patience and sweetness from her early music teachers.

NiaAndFar · 11/11/2026 06:29

You are being ridiculous.
It is a whistle class for 6 to 8 year old -hitting bum notes will happen all the time. I therefore believe the 'are you deaf' must have been in response to him not listening yo instructions rather than accidentally squeaking
Your child needs to listen and he needs to practise. I think moving him down to another class is a very valid thing to say.

NiaAndFar · 11/11/2026 06:43

i think he was being a pain in the ass and she snapped.
why do you think she "snapped" as opposed to speaking to him firmly about his behaviour? He is in a group class with students who WANT to learn and she has a duty to them.
Furthermore what was even the point in speaking to the teacher if you are not going to believe what she says?

SoftIce · 11/11/2026 08:41

I agree with PPs who suggested ukulele lessons.

ExtraOnions · 11/11/2026 08:52

Back in the 80s we all learned an instrument in primary school, mostly recorder. We had a music room full of instruments, and all learned to read music.
I think it one of the most valuable life skills I learned at primary. I can now bash out a tune on most things, as I understand the order of the notes (I will win no prizes)
I also played the Glockenspiel, Tenor Recorder, Treble Recorder, Violin etc.

This wasn’t some sort of posh school, a regular Catholic primary.

I think it’s a shame that music isn’t taught as much anymore, gave some people the chance to shine that they didn’t in other topics, plus it was all free so everyone got a chance.

In this instance, have instruments around the house, they don’t need to be expensive. Let him play with them, make his own kind of music, and when you & him are clearer about what he wants move into formal lessons. If he has a natural love for music, it will come through. A keyboard is a good one to have around, and you can pick up cheap stuff on Marketplace (invest in a tuner)

Mcdhotchoc · 12/11/2026 08:14

If he is 2 years younger, maybe he just doesn't have the dexterity/understand the link between practice and success or other things needed at this point in time.
I had a bit of a rule that my kids didn't give up after a bad week/lesson. But equally if something wasn't for them after giving it a decent go, that was ok.
I'd just give it a rest for the moment. Say you'll revisit it next September. Have a proper break.

Mcdhotchoc · 12/11/2026 08:15

Also agree with pp above. Have some cheap musical instruments about

Prekoc2 · 12/11/2026 08:25

We didn’t have class at Halloween so there was a 2 week break. We were away for a few days so he didn’t get to practice.

That's pathetic, I'm afraid. It's the sort of excuse a child would give. What about the other ten or so days?

I highly doubt the teacher asked him if he was deaf. Obviously unacceptable if she did, but I think it's unlikely.

Natsku · 12/11/2026 08:39

ExtraOnions · 11/11/2026 08:52

Back in the 80s we all learned an instrument in primary school, mostly recorder. We had a music room full of instruments, and all learned to read music.
I think it one of the most valuable life skills I learned at primary. I can now bash out a tune on most things, as I understand the order of the notes (I will win no prizes)
I also played the Glockenspiel, Tenor Recorder, Treble Recorder, Violin etc.

This wasn’t some sort of posh school, a regular Catholic primary.

I think it’s a shame that music isn’t taught as much anymore, gave some people the chance to shine that they didn’t in other topics, plus it was all free so everyone got a chance.

In this instance, have instruments around the house, they don’t need to be expensive. Let him play with them, make his own kind of music, and when you & him are clearer about what he wants move into formal lessons. If he has a natural love for music, it will come through. A keyboard is a good one to have around, and you can pick up cheap stuff on Marketplace (invest in a tuner)

I love that the music curriculum in my country has an emphasis on playing instruments, my DD has learnt the basics of several different instruments like piano, drums, guitar, kantele, probably recorder too, as well as a lot of time on singing.

Fortuity · 12/11/2026 09:09

Can he practise at after school club? The great thing about a tin whistle is that it's really portable.

Saturdaysfairies · 12/11/2026 09:22

If you don't practise your instrument don't do classes. It's a waste of time. Mostly the teacher's and other pupils' time if your son is faffing around.

Sounds like it's not a right fit for your son anyway.

Saturdaysfairies · 12/11/2026 09:24

Fortuity · 12/11/2026 09:09

Can he practise at after school club? The great thing about a tin whistle is that it's really portable.

Most after school clubs don't have room for this.

MeerkatEyes · 12/11/2026 09:32

Thank you to everyone for your comments and advice.

To add - he will learn tin whistle in school in 3/4 years as well.

I am disappointed in how it’s worked out but obviously there’s no alternative now except to stop lessons. I will keep practicing with him at home to try to learn the few tunes he has, just to give him the basics. And maybe in the New Year we’ll look again at formal lessons in something, if he really wants to. And we’ve learned our lesson re daily practice.

At the minute he is happy to quit (he doesn’t have much choice now anyway!) and I think is happy that I stood up for him.

I am still angry and disappointed in the teacher for how she handled it. Her behaviour was wholly inappropriate. I’m probably not going to formally complain but will respond to her text message letting her know that he is hurt and I am disappointed.

OP posts:
LoveSkaMusic · 12/11/2026 09:45

I think the teacher was unnecessarily harsh on your tiny child.

However, manual dexterity is a skill that needs to be learnt, so what I'd suggest is that you do lots of fun activities like Lego, those kids sewing toys with the big plastic needle, etc to improve fine motor control. This is also good for helping with handwriting, using cutlery etc. In fact, I cant think of any drawbacks!

Awlier · 12/11/2026 10:02

Yes dumping a 6 year old like that sounds extremely unprofessional, but she didn't want to teach him so getting him out of there was the best thing for him.

I wouldn't bother emailing her to explain your son's feelings on the subject. She is not that interested in his feelings or she wouldn't have just dumped him. Much stronger I think to express your own feelings that the punishment was disproportional to the crime especially for such a young child.

Bitsostuff · 12/11/2026 10:06

MeerkatEyes · 10/11/2026 11:33

He originally wanted to play guitar as he wants to be a rock star. I persuaded him to start with the whistle because it’s easier (and much cheaper).

We’re in Ireland and tin whistle would be the ‘normal’ starter instrument.

The thing is though I’m not sure that there is a lower class as they only take children when they’re 6. DS turned 6 in June so he’s the youngest in the class.

I do have a bit of sympathy in her frustration at her lack of progress but surely she needed to talk to me directly then, rather than speaking to him in that way, especially in front of the other boys?

Edited

If hes old enough to learn an instrument then he's old enough to be told that he needs to practice to get better. You should know that without bring told.* *

You can try a new teacher (hes likely to progress better if he likes his teacher) but that won't negate the practice issue.

Coconutcreamz · 12/11/2026 10:41

OP, 6 is a bit young for the tin whistle in my opinion, there is dexterity involved.
He will be well able for it at 9 and 10, when they usually learn.
Don't stress yourself about it.
Mine all did piano from 6 and it is a huge waste of money if daily practice isn't adhered to.
It's quite the dose commitment wise.

user1476613140 · 15/11/2026 07:41

Awlier · 12/11/2026 10:02

Yes dumping a 6 year old like that sounds extremely unprofessional, but she didn't want to teach him so getting him out of there was the best thing for him.

I wouldn't bother emailing her to explain your son's feelings on the subject. She is not that interested in his feelings or she wouldn't have just dumped him. Much stronger I think to express your own feelings that the punishment was disproportional to the crime especially for such a young child.

My DS was treated similarly too, by a tin whistle teacher (male). Just told that it wasn't working out. DS wasn't listening but I think because he's small for his age, the tutor wasn't wrong, really...DS can try again at a later date.

OP will need to get used to stuff like this happening depending on the instrument. Sometimes it can take several attempts trying with different ones to get the right fit.

Sannabay · 15/11/2026 07:55

MeerkatEyes · 10/11/2026 12:14

Thanks all.

I know we don’t practice enough. He’s in after-school until 5:30 every day, DP and I both work full-time (and I have a 3 hour commute) and we also have a 4 year old. Both DC have extra-curricular sports as well, and DS has stacks of homework. So life is hectic and we tend to do a couple of practice sessions at the weekend rather than the recommended 10 mins per day.

I have spoken to the teacher who says that DS kept saying last night ‘this is easy’ (I believe her about this). She says she’d asked him if he wanted to continue with the other boys or take some classes on his own.

She says she didn’t ask him if he was deaf (which I don’t believe as I don’t think he’d have made it up).

I think he was being a pain in the ass and she snapped. Which is still unacceptable in my opinion given that she made a child cry (albeit a very human and understandable reaction).

I don’t know what to do now!

Just a word.

I once 'made' a child cry whilst teaching.

It was unintentionally done. I wasn't expecting it at all and my tone was just firm.

Just saying.

Year 7 child this was. Saying are you deaf though is bizarre. I can't see that myself. But you know your child.