Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to pull DS out of music classes?

77 replies

MeerkatEyes · 10/11/2026 11:10

DS is 6. He started music ( tin whistle) classes at the end of Sept. There are 3 other boys in his class - two are 8, one is 6 or possibly 7.

DS is struggling a bit. He can’t get his fingers onto the whistle properly to cover the bottom holes. The other boys seem to be better than him.

We didn’t have class at Halloween so there was a 2 week break. We were away for a few days so he didn’t get to practice.

The teacher takes the boys into a small room and parents stay outside (but must stay on premises).

Last night DS left class really upset. I knew there was something wrong and he started crying as soon he got into car. He says that the teacher told him he might have to go to a different class if he doesn’t practice. Also at one point, he says, he played a squeaky note and the teacher said ‘are you deaf?’ to him loudly

I am furious. I don’t know whether to pull him out and ask for our money back. I think it’s unacceptable that she would say that to him without having discussed moving classes or being annoyed at the lack of practice to me.

Just to add - he doesn’t practice daily. We did 20 mins practice on Saturday and I lifted him early from after-school yesterday and he did another 20/25 mins practice.

Just to add, my initial reaction was to say that we’d practice every night and work on it together. However when my partner got home he mentioned quitting and finding another teacher, so that’s what DS now wants to do.

Just looking for views and advice really. Posting in AIBU for traffic! AIBU for pulling him out?

OP posts:
Balloonhearts · 10/11/2026 11:26

Well if he isn't practicing, then he won't be progressing. I have sympathy for the teacher having to try and teach a class where one child doesn't practice, what should she do? Hold everyone back for the sake of one child? Or tell him that he needs to practice or he will have to move to a lower class?

takealettermsjones · 10/11/2026 11:20

I wouldn't be continuing with a teacher who made my 6yo cry. The teacher doesn't sound very encouraging. The tin whistle is an interesting choice - does he want to play that specifically? He might get on better with a different instrument.

Swipe left for the next trending thread