Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not pay out, and let them take me to court?

244 replies

peeved123 · 10/11/2026 11:04

Not sure if I am just being stubborn, or if I should just let it go and move on.

Long story short; I used Lookiero (an online personal shopper service) who send out several items at an agreed interval and you can pay for what you want to keep and send the rest back.

I chose to keep 3 out of 8 items and paid for them. the return label provided was an Evri drop off one, and unfortunately I don't have a drop off point within 3 hours of me (yes, really). I emailed them 3 times asking what I should do and if they could provide and alternative return option. They initially ignored my emails and then I got one saying I had to return by the following day or I would be charge for the full amount (nearly £300!!). I decided I would have to just fork out on a Royal Mail tracked service and posted it the next day.

I have Royal Mail proof it was delivered, and even got an email from Lookiero to say they had received it.

Not long after, however, they said my return was invalid as I didn't use Evri, and that they hadn't receive the parcel. They have been trying to charge my account £278 every week for the last few months despite my attempts at trying to speak to someone to discuss the problem (I've only had generic AI responses). I have blocked the payments through my bank account.

Lookiero have since escalated it to a debt collector. I have gathered all my evidence, which took a long time, and sent it to them. They are continuing to say I owe Lookiero £278 and have added on a £25 fee taking it to over £300. My latest email from the debt collector has said Lookiero will now be starting formal court proceedings because I have not paid. This has been going on since the end of June.

I'm at the point now I just want it to go away, it's really stressing me out and I don't want to go through the court or have it affect my credit score. On the other hand, £300 is a huge amount to me and at this time of year will have a big impact.

What would you do?

YABU - just pay the £300 and consider it a lesson learned
YANBU - keep fighting them and don't let them get away with it

I have already contacted Citizen's advice, Resolver UK and Watchdog.

Sorry that ended up long after me saying I would keep it short.

OP posts:
nevernotmaybe · 10/11/2026 23:47

prh47bridge · 10/11/2026 23:36

If the retailer pays the cost of carriage, they can choose the carrier. If, as here, the consumer pays the cost of carriage, the consumer can choose the carrier. The retailer cannot require a specific carrier. And what do you think will happen if this gets to court? Do you really believe the judge is going to say that the retailer has acknowledged getting the goods back but OP must still pay for the goods she returned just because the retailer wanted her to use a different carrier? If you believe that, you are wrong.

Did You read? For statutory rights this is true.

Anything else, you don't have a right to send it back at all by default. And they can put any restriction they want on this extra you has no right to, that got with a private contract.

nevernotmaybe · 10/11/2026 23:43

Realitybitesyerbum · 10/11/2026 22:21

I have an ongoing situation with Paypal. They paid an annual sum to Domestika for a subscription I didn't know I had (something I now know Domestika are renowned for - giving you a second level of subscription you didn't ask for). I spotted it before they took the money from my bank account, and stopped Paypal from taking anything from me.

I went through the Domestika complaints procedure (which they ignored), then the Paypal complaints procedure and they sided with Domestika. Paypal sent it to a debt collection agency - I told them I wasn't paying up. They sent it back to Paypal, who wouldn't budge, and neither would I.

They sent it back to the debt collectors and i told them not to contact me unless it's a court summons. I also told them that when I do get one I'll be requesting a change of court to my local one, and also will be asking for witnesses from Paypal for my face to face hearing so I can question them.

That was a year ago and I haven't heard anything since. I've kept everything to prove I'd cancelled the actual subscription, and the internet is awash with tales of horror regarding Domestika's flaky processes. If it had been taken by Domestika directly from my account I would have been refunded.

Stick to your ground @peeved123 . Tell them to do one unless they want to issue proceedings and that you're really looking forward to your day in court. My minor inconvenience is no more Paypal, but I wouldn't want to use them again after this.

When the amount is relatively low, they often don't get around to it for a while (multiple years), and on a semi regular basis do let that kind of thing go past 6 years without bothering. But they have 6 years to start it.

It will have nothing to do with anything you said. And a court probably wouldn't be happy with you wasting time trying to call witnesses in a basic case like this. Even if you are in the right you shouldn't push your luck and act unreasonable because you think it will inconvenience the other party, courts take a very dim view of all that nonsense regardless of who is right.

prh47bridge · 10/11/2026 23:36

nevernotmaybe · 10/11/2026 21:29

For statutory rights that is true. It isn't just a general right outside of that, they could then require a specific courier.

If the retailer pays the cost of carriage, they can choose the carrier. If, as here, the consumer pays the cost of carriage, the consumer can choose the carrier. The retailer cannot require a specific carrier. And what do you think will happen if this gets to court? Do you really believe the judge is going to say that the retailer has acknowledged getting the goods back but OP must still pay for the goods she returned just because the retailer wanted her to use a different carrier? If you believe that, you are wrong.

peeved123 · 10/11/2026 22:48

nevernotmaybe · 10/11/2026 20:17

How long past the point you generated the returns label, did you then send it back? If it was within 14 days from that point, in court you can argue you informed them you were returning them, then returned them, and this will fall within the remit of statutory rights. And they can't make a demand you only one specific way for that. You will win.

If it was after 14 days, you are covered by the contract you signed with them. Even so, charging you for the items won't win in court if you don't have them. But if they at least offer the service to get them back to you, whether you take them or not, they will probably win and you do owe the money.

And what island do you live on to not be near any Evri drop off point within 3 hours?

The return label comes with the delivery so it doesn’t need it be generated. I paid for the goods I was keeping the day after they arrived and contacted them about alternative return options a few days after that.

I don’t live in an Island

OP posts:
Realitybitesyerbum · 10/11/2026 22:21

I have an ongoing situation with Paypal. They paid an annual sum to Domestika for a subscription I didn't know I had (something I now know Domestika are renowned for - giving you a second level of subscription you didn't ask for). I spotted it before they took the money from my bank account, and stopped Paypal from taking anything from me.

I went through the Domestika complaints procedure (which they ignored), then the Paypal complaints procedure and they sided with Domestika. Paypal sent it to a debt collection agency - I told them I wasn't paying up. They sent it back to Paypal, who wouldn't budge, and neither would I.

They sent it back to the debt collectors and i told them not to contact me unless it's a court summons. I also told them that when I do get one I'll be requesting a change of court to my local one, and also will be asking for witnesses from Paypal for my face to face hearing so I can question them.

That was a year ago and I haven't heard anything since. I've kept everything to prove I'd cancelled the actual subscription, and the internet is awash with tales of horror regarding Domestika's flaky processes. If it had been taken by Domestika directly from my account I would have been refunded.

Stick to your ground @peeved123 . Tell them to do one unless they want to issue proceedings and that you're really looking forward to your day in court. My minor inconvenience is no more Paypal, but I wouldn't want to use them again after this.

nevernotmaybe · 10/11/2026 21:29

prh47bridge · 10/11/2026 20:58

Their terms cannot override the law. A seller cannot legally insist that you use one specific carrier. They can recommend or prefer a specific service, but imposing it as a restriction is considered an unreasonable requirement.

For statutory rights that is true. It isn't just a general right outside of that, they could then require a specific courier.

prh47bridge · 10/11/2026 20:58

latetothefisting · 10/11/2026 20:22

their website is completely clear that returns must be sent via evri though
Our returns step by step – Lookiero. It took me less than 30 seconds to check that. I always check what the returns process is before buying, if you don't bother, that's on you. Even more so if you know you live somewhere where delivery/return options are more restricted than 99.99% of the country!

From their perspective, if you buy from them, you're agreeing to abide by their t&c. If their t&c are you only get a refund if you use their specified returns service, then you're the one who hasn't fulfilled your side of the agreement.

Again, I think they are being disproportionate in their actions. I just don't agree it's a slam dunk they're completely wrong and you're completely right.

Edited

Their terms cannot override the law. A seller cannot legally insist that you use one specific carrier. They can recommend or prefer a specific service, but imposing it as a restriction is considered an unreasonable requirement.

DelilahBucket · 10/11/2026 20:43

I haven't read the full thread so apologies if I'm repeating, but under the Consumer Contract Regulations, I believe a retailer cannot insist on the use of a set courier service for returns if you are paying the cost. Regardless of their terms and conditions, the law supercedes them. Let them take you to court. Counter claim for time wasted dealing with them.

TY78910 · 10/11/2026 20:37

Sladuf1 · 10/11/2026 12:57

Another point I thought worth asking about was how long did you have the clothes for before you contacted them to say you wanted to return them?

I’d argue your rights under the Consumer Contracts Regulations 2013 could apply. It clearly sounds like a distance selling scenario and under those Regulations, which were passed to bring an EU Directive into law, you have rights to reject goods. I mention this because from what I could see Lookiero is a Spanish outfit?

With distance selling situations, the consumer has a 14 day window (cooling off period) to reject the goods because they’ve changed their mind. There’s a longer window if the goods are faulty or don’t match description.
The 14 day cooling off/changed your mind period starts the day after the consumer takes physical possession of the goods.
I’ve had experience of reminding a company about this before. If you’ve rejected the goods within the 14 days i.e. contacted the seller and said you don’t want the goods, the seller is obliged to refund them.

It sounds like you have a good trail of contacting them to try and arrange an alternative way to return. I don’t think it would be reasonable for them to hold you to “you can only return via Evri” if there were no drop-offs near you.
They haven’t acted reasonably.

Edited

I don’t think this is the issue here - they aren’t disputing the return because of it being made outside of the timeframe, or refusing a remorse period, they’re trying to dispute that they can’t give money back due to not receiving the items back. You can’t issue a refund if the customer doesn’t bring back the product.

Now, the company is trying to say that they didn’t receive the items and that the acknowledgment email is automated (yes, it is. Once someone scans the item in at the warehouse). So somebody has handled it. I wonder if there was a CF employee that didn’t know what the package was as it didn’t come in an Evri van, scanned it to see what it was, then thought oh well it was just a parcel so let me take these home as technically they’re unaccounted for.

Regardless, I’d speak to citizens advice - they will point you in the right direction.

Someone upthread mentioned Retail ADR - only participating retailers will engage in the dispute service and I doubt they do.

latetothefisting · 10/11/2026 20:22

their website is completely clear that returns must be sent via evri though
Our returns step by step – Lookiero. It took me less than 30 seconds to check that. I always check what the returns process is before buying, if you don't bother, that's on you. Even more so if you know you live somewhere where delivery/return options are more restricted than 99.99% of the country!

From their perspective, if you buy from them, you're agreeing to abide by their t&c. If their t&c are you only get a refund if you use their specified returns service, then you're the one who hasn't fulfilled your side of the agreement.

Again, I think they are being disproportionate in their actions. I just don't agree it's a slam dunk they're completely wrong and you're completely right.

CypressGrove · 10/11/2026 20:21

peeved123 · 10/11/2026 11:36

It does say on their website that returns are only accepted through Evri. However it also says that you receive an email when the return has been processed (which I did) suggesting they did receive it and process it.

Why did you sign up with them knowing you wouldn't be able to organise returns? Surely that would have been something you planned for before starting?

BooksnChocolate · 10/11/2026 20:20

Is it also worth posting on social media and tagging them? X, linked in, blue sky. Whatever you can do easily. They might back down to stop the bad publicity. And agree with PP - don't back down. Engage politely but firmly with any communications. You have proof that you did nothing wrong. Stand your ground!

nevernotmaybe · 10/11/2026 20:17

How long past the point you generated the returns label, did you then send it back? If it was within 14 days from that point, in court you can argue you informed them you were returning them, then returned them, and this will fall within the remit of statutory rights. And they can't make a demand you only one specific way for that. You will win.

If it was after 14 days, you are covered by the contract you signed with them. Even so, charging you for the items won't win in court if you don't have them. But if they at least offer the service to get them back to you, whether you take them or not, they will probably win and you do owe the money.

And what island do you live on to not be near any Evri drop off point within 3 hours?

herbetta · 10/11/2026 20:16

peeved123 · 10/11/2026 12:24

I genuinely didn't know I could arrange an Evri collection, a local courier is sub contracted to deliver for Evri here but I didn't know I could use them for uplift too. Total oversight on my part. However, it was never suggested to me as an option when I tried to contact them about my predicament.

But is it an option though? I know they say it is, but they've said a lot of things aren't correct. Do you know anyone who's actually had an Evri Collect from your location?

CathyCatnip · 10/11/2026 20:13

prh47bridge · 10/11/2026 20:03

The police would say this is a civil matter and refuse to get involved.

The police would be able to put op in touch with the Action Fraud: National Fraud and Cyber Crime Reporting Centre for advice. They were really helpful when I had an issue.

prh47bridge · 10/11/2026 20:06

anyolddinosaur · 10/11/2026 19:39

Have you mentioned the Unfair Contracts Term Act of 1977 in your correspondence with them. If not you will need to do so in court, pointing out that this is not a reasonable requirement in your location. If this was not brought prominently to your attention before you ordered you should say that too. Check any insurance you have in case you have a free legal advice line.

The outcome will depend on whether the judge thinks you were being reasonable, I dont think the company will win but it's not certain.

I wouldn't bother with the Unfair Contract Terms Act. OP certainly doesn't need to mention it in court. This will be a small claim, so OP doesn't need a lawyer and the court won't expect her to be able to quote chapter and verse on the law. All that matters is that Lookiero have acknowledged return of the goods but are still trying to collect payment for them.

prh47bridge · 10/11/2026 20:03

CathyCatnip · 10/11/2026 18:32

I would advise calling the Police Fraud Department for advice as they sound as if they are trying it on especially when it's clear you have returned the items.

The police would say this is a civil matter and refuse to get involved.

anyolddinosaur · 10/11/2026 19:39

Have you mentioned the Unfair Contracts Term Act of 1977 in your correspondence with them. If not you will need to do so in court, pointing out that this is not a reasonable requirement in your location. If this was not brought prominently to your attention before you ordered you should say that too. Check any insurance you have in case you have a free legal advice line.

The outcome will depend on whether the judge thinks you were being reasonable, I dont think the company will win but it's not certain.

CathyCatnip · 10/11/2026 18:32

I would advise calling the Police Fraud Department for advice as they sound as if they are trying it on especially when it's clear you have returned the items.

Truinio · 10/11/2026 17:53

You returned the goods and you have an email confirming receipt. They don’t have a leg to stand on. They are just trying to intimidate you into paying up and highly unlikely this will go to court.

peeved123 · 10/11/2026 17:52

@Error404FucksNotFoundI’m not sure why some people just go out of their way to be combative and irrational. Perhaps they struggle in real life and this is an outlet for them 🤷🏼‍♀️.

There’s a respectful way to say things, but through computer/phone screens a lot of people lose basic human manners.

Anyway, the vast majority have been extremely helpful and supportive so thank you.

I hope the others get a good night sleep and have a better day tomorrow.

OP posts:
CatherinedeBourgh · 10/11/2026 17:49

We've had a couple of things where we were charged for things we shouldn't have been/they didn't take payment on our card when they were meant to. We were threatened all sorts by debt collectors. We told them to prove we owed the money (we didn't) or we would ignore them, they said they would take us to court. They have carried on sending AI generated emails for a year.

It will never go to court, they know they can't win and are trying to wear you down or frighten you. If you ignore them (just keep resending the email where you explain why you don't owe them anything), they will eventually go away.

Error404FucksNotFound · 10/11/2026 17:46

I don't know why people are insisting you are this martin bloke.
There's more than one page of one star reviews and the one i think is probably yours was left a while back.

Dripnoz · 10/11/2026 17:46

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

PrettyPickle · 10/11/2026 17:43

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

No, the fact is that they have had the goods back, they have acknowledged it, perhaps an advisory note saying she could have arranged an Evri collection from home for future information....but a debt collector???

They haven't suffered a loss, how can they take her to court?

The world has gone mad.