Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say no to son’s girlfriend coming for Christmas.

558 replies

5littleducksallinarow · 10/11/2026 10:42

We don’t have the biggest house and our very small dining table is in an alcove in the lounge, we pull it out for meals but there is 6 of us squeezed around this 4 seater table with 2 extra chairs.
Last year we decided to do a cold meat buffet instead and just have our plates on the sofa and it worked so we’ve decided to do the same again.
This year ds has a girlfriend and has asked if she can come for Christmas and I explained it will only be buffet but he’s unimpressed and says she’s from a posh family and would expect a traditional roast dinner.

Aibu to say we can’t cater for anyone else? We don’t mind if she wants to come for a while or even for some of the buffet but I will not be cooking a Christmas dinner.
Ds is concerned about her reaction to a non traditional roast.
We have met her once and I did put on a similar cold meats buffet back in the summer but she didn’t eat anything.

OP posts:
thisismeithinkorisit · 11/11/2026 00:17

he goes to hers then surely

WhistPie · 11/11/2026 00:23

If they have a son in his late 30s, their 2 surviving parents would, I imagine, be quite elderly.

It's one thing for everyone to squash into a small space when they're students, but quite another when you have to consider a couple of 80 odd year olds, who will be wanting easy access to the WC!

PrincessFiorimonde · 11/11/2026 00:27

ADragonFlyCharm · 10/11/2026 20:44

This.

It would be no trouble at all.

If you did want to show that you had gone to a bit of effort for the sake of your future relationship with your future daughter-in-law, would you consider building an extension or a lovely conservatory that will solve this problem, enhance your home and make it more valuable. Win, win, win.

I know that may not be easy and there isn't masses of time, so it might not be possible and if that proves to be the case, how about a summer house.

Our lovely local garden centre can erect one of these pretty quickly at reasonable cost and it would look absolutely gorgeous and welcoming, twinkling with Christmas Fairy Lights.

We love ours and it has the added advantage that anyone who has over indulged in the plum pudding can just walk out of the door straight into the garden for a quick breath of fresh air before the cheese.

Do consider it at least! x

Edited

🤣🤣

thisismeithinkorisit · 11/11/2026 00:31

5littleducksallinarow · 10/11/2026 15:50

I don’t think he thinks he needs an invitation so if I ask him on Saturday if he wants to come for dinner on Sunday, he will say “I might do” and leave it at that.
If he decides not to we won’t hear a thing and if he decides to turn up he will.

It is annoying as we don’t know what we’re doing and can’t make any plans because we’ve invited him and don’t know if he’ll come or not, so if I suggest would he like to come for a roast tomorrow I have to keep tomorrow free and I’m then obliged to cook it because I invited him when really if he wasn’t coming we’d probably have eaten out or had something else.

but he texted you like that you let him. does the other child treat you as a restaurant similarly?

Jack, are you coming for Sunday lunch?
oh I don't know Mom, who knows which way the wind will blow??
Well I need to know by 10 am else Dad bad I are off to the pub / having a sandwich / having 2pm sofa sex / etc.
oh but I don't know Mom, I can't be expected to make a decision with only 24 hours notice
that's fine darling, maybe we'll see you next week, or your welcome to turn up at The Old Dog and Kennel at 2.

Itsthewoluff · 11/11/2026 00:41

It may not be he’s being demanding as such.

It could be he just wants to spend time with his gf but doesn’t want to miss out on Xmas at yours. He’d rather be at yours than at theirs. But he knows her family goes all out. It’s likely that she won’t want to come and will try to persuade him to go to hers if you aren’t doing a “traditional” Xmas. Most people prefer their own traditions anyway. I think he’s just trying to increase his chances of persuading her to come to yours as he’d prefer it at yours rather than hers. It’s actually a complement he’s paying you that your relationship is so good he wants to stay at home. If he wasn’t bothered he would just go to hers.

Onthemaintrunkline · 11/11/2026 00:55

Your son comes across as rude and bordering on arrogant….he might come, he might not. The Christmas you are happy pay for and host, isn’t quite going to suit him, and according to him probably won’t suit his GF. Your house somehow doesn’t match the GF’s parents place.!! I mean what the heck!

How dare he turn his nose up at your hospitality, what is he able to host and where? And this not letting you know if he’ll be there or not 🤷🏻‍♀️ - it’s just rude!

Despite it being Christmas, go ahead with your plans, don’t change a thing, he either comes or he doesn’t, (and lets you know in good time), but don’t for heaven sake pander to his nonsense.

LAMPS1 · 11/11/2026 00:58

I would want to really welcome her for the Christmas meal and would do everything in my power to make it a hot traditional meal.
But after reading all your posts it really does sound pretty much impossible in your small space. And actually, your cold buffet food sounds really lovely…Christmassy and appetising. I would possibly offer a hot soup to start, also served help yourself style and maybe in mugs to avoid spillage.
As long as it feels festive and is all well presented, I think you have made the right decision.

It’s obvious you are doing your very best on the off chance that they might turn up.
Could you have a quiet and gentle word with your son about the difficulty of a sit down traditional meal in the small space available so that he completely understands and accepts your decision.
I suggest you also speak to him about his awful cavalier attitude towards invitations. He sounds as if he needs to grow up a bit more yet and learn some manners. It’s not all about him and impressing his gf, it’s about the 7 of you spending time and feasting together at Christmas.
Good luck OP.

OneRedFinch · 11/11/2026 02:12

All sounds a bit grim really - what's the point if all you're going to do is sit on the sofa with a plate of cold food.

ItsNotMeEither · 11/11/2026 02:45

I’m a mother to four adult sons, I’d put money on this being more him than her. He’s still in the stages of wanting to impress her and he’s the one worried about comparisons to her family. She may not care about these things in the slightest!

I wouldn’t change anything you were planning, just reiterate that she’s more than welcome to come over any time, but you won’t be changing your own plans. If you did wish to offer an alternative, what do you do Christmas Eve? Would yummy Christmas foods and playing a board game with a few drinks and carols on be an easy alternative?

Either way, you never know, she could be part of your family long term and these communication issues are on him, so I wouldn’t change proceed on that basis.

You're fast approaching the time now where you won’t even see him every Christmas. Whether it’s this girl or another, Christmas will be shared with family on both sides and becomes even more of a juggle once children come along. So, enjoy what you can of the time you will spend together before he rushes off to her family, but that doesn’t have to involve a hot dinner.

Goatinthegarden · 11/11/2026 03:17

What gets me is the number of people who cannot understand that different people like and prioritise different things. A traditional Christmas dinner is just one way of celebrating a day that may mean different things to different people. Op is doing what suits her household at Christmas, her adult child can join or not join. He’s old enough to find a solution to hosting everyone if he wants to. OP has planned to have a buffet of lovely food that suits her and her other guests. She should get to enjoy the day too.

I teach children in an inner city school. Some people here would collapse when they hear about how many family members share a very tiny space - and hear about the very different ways in which they all celebrate, or don’t celebrate, Christmas. Even amongst practicing Christian children, there are huge differences as to which day they have food (and what food they have) and presents depending upon where their families are from. And any kind of special food, happy family, festive anctivities and presents are things that many of my pupils won’t get to experience at all.

DH and I don’t have children and we choose to go on holiday over Christmas to avoid all the over excited nieces and nephews and stressed out relatives trying to provide the ‘perfect’ day. I had lovely Christmases as a child, but I don’t like the day much as an adult. Rather than spread our Grinchiness, we take ourselves off to do something we enjoy and we like to see family once the chaos of Christmas is over.

Petlover9 · 11/11/2026 04:32

AMillionTomorrows · 10/11/2026 10:47

You haven’t said no - that’s up to them!
(Btw your son is cheeky)

OP could you suggest your son spends lunchtime at Christmas with her 'posh' family? Has she not noticed that you are short of space, we can't all live in mansions.

Petlover9 · 11/11/2026 04:41

Thegirlwhowent · 10/11/2026 23:07

It's unbelievable, isn't it? Do they realize that some people don't have an ensuite, let alone an extra staircase for the servants?

Just what I was thinking !! With the price of houses I don't know how people afford anything now; it is all out of proportion to 'ordinary' earnings.

keepswimming38 · 11/11/2026 05:44

The poshest houses I went to at Christmas all veered away from a traditional roast. It’s a bit Royle family isn’t it? Your way or the highway op I think.

AlertCat · 11/11/2026 06:05

Freshrain · 10/11/2026 23:44

Thank you.

@CloveRinse and @The girl who went.

I can only go on my experience of all the homes me, and my adult dc and my nieces and nephews and siblings and parents and grandparents have lived in.

2 bed terraces. Homes in terraced rows opening out directly on to the street. Miners cottages. Streets of houses built for factory workers. Terrace homes let to students. One of my siblings lived in several different parts of the country, and both siblings, dc and dn have all lived in student houses.
All either have a living room similar in size to the OP's and a kitchen big enough to eat in (the EAs would call it a 'dining kitchen') or, a galley type kitchen and either 2 small living rooms or one larger living room.

I'm not talking about 3 bed semis, or even larger homes. My dd is currently subletting a room in a 2 bed terrace which opens out onto the pavement, small backyard, but there are 2 living rooms and a galley kitchen. The other dd has one living room, but the kitchen is big enough for a table. It isn't a "rich MN thing"

It seems incredibly unusual to have one living room that isn't big enough for a table + a settee, without having a kitchen that is big enough to include a table.

My ex’s parents live in a 1970s house with 3 bedrooms. One bedroom has the rise of the staircase stealing floor space (if you can picture that, it is a sloping surface coming from the wall down to the floor about a metre in). So it’s not a big room.

Downstairs they have a kitchen which is basically a galley with a serving hatch. In here they could fit a tiny table and a stool.
The other downstairs room is the lounge. They have a square table which four could eat at, if they didn’t have dishes in the middle. Then they’ve the sofa facing the fireplace. They have a conservatory but it isn’t insulated and doesn’t have a table in it.

Their house has a garage, it’s sort of another room inside the house’s footprint, and they use it for storage rather than the car.

When I spent Christmas there, we were about 10 people. Three ate at the table. Four ate sitting on the sofa (it’s a big sofa). My MiL ate in the kitchen. The others stood or perched in the conservatory. We had a lovely roast dinner and everyone enjoyed each other’s company, but I wouldn’t pretend it was conventional or comfortable for some. A buffet might have been easier given the house set up.

I also lived in a tiny terrace as a student which had a galley kitchen and a front room, a tiny windowless bedroom downstairs which may once have been a cupboard, and another two upstairs (one of which had the bathroom door in it). My own first house had two bedrooms and a downstairs bathroom, so there was just a small kitchen with no space for a table, and a living room with no space for a table if you had other furniture in it like sofas etc.

While lots of smaller houses have been extended to create eat-in kitchens or extra rooms, not all have. And some newer houses also are built very small. It’s a bit of a luxury to consider high days and holiday when money is tight and you need to think about how you manage for the other 363 or 364 days of the year.

AlertCat · 11/11/2026 06:19

Sotiredimightreallydie · 10/11/2026 23:27

I get the point though. I said that it must be a very tiny lounge earlier and was told that it was a very normal size for a terraced home. I've lived in a few myself and that didn't seem right. So in had a look on Rightmove and it's actually really challenging to find a home with only a kitchen that's too small to eat in plus a 12x12 lounge.

Almost all either have 2 rooms, a kitchen diner or a lounge diner. These are small old 2 bedroom terraces where the lounge opens into the lounge btw, not large homes.

Unless it's a 1 bedroom house, which is viable if it's just for the op and husband I guess. There can't be many of those around though

So I'm also a bit curious too.

Posted twice, can’t see how to remove the quote

Iocanepowder · 11/11/2026 06:22

5littleducksallinarow · 10/11/2026 20:39

I don’t think I’m much of a Christmas person.

I loved it at my own parents all sitting together eating in the dining room with Christmas crackers set out and food in the middle to help yourselves but they had the room and a huge table all nicely decorated and inviting with wine glasses set out, of course I would love a Christmas dinner in those circumstances.

It’s not the same when there’s no space and it’s all stress and make do, nobody can move once seated without everyone else getting up first because some people are trapped against the wall, others can’t move their chair back because of the sofa and nobody can get to the kitchen for anything once we’re seated because the kitchen door is blocked by table and chairs and nobody can put their plate down until everybody has finished dishing up because there’s no space on the table until the serving plates are removed meaning second helpings are a pain and it’s just an obstacle course.

At least if I set the food out on the table I can leave it in the alcove and people can pull a chair out and sit comfortably on a dining chair or the sofa or wander into the kitchen and grab another drink.
I’m just trying to make the best of what we’ve got, we can’t even fit a Christmas tree but I’m glad we’ve got a table at all as some people don’t.

When it’s just Dh and I we don’t need to pull the table out and can eat fine.
Christmas is meant to be fun, a time to get together and celebrate and enjoy the day, if the roast dinner is the cause of all stress then I’d rather have a buffet and done with.
As long as I get some pigs in blankets and some wine.

Ignore those posts op. People are talking as though Christmas can’t be enjoyed unless someone spends most of it in the kitchen.

Most years I work up until Christmas eve and in previous jobs I also worked Boxing Day. Like fuck am I going to spend Christmas day stressing about feeding loads of people.

importantupdate · 11/11/2026 06:24

If he has his own place why isn’t he either cooking Christmas dinner for his gf, or inviting you all along to his? I think you’ve offered enough tbh, you shouldn’t have to change plans to accommodate her expectations.

BusyMum47 · 11/11/2026 07:01

Holeymoley28 · 10/11/2026 10:58

I’m torn. Because I wouldn’t do a cold buffet on the sofa for Christmas dinner full stop. But I wouldn’t want to be dictated to either.

If you say she has been to one of your buffet style spreads and didn’t eat anything then odds are she wouldn’t eat it at your Christmas either.

Just expect that he will spend more time at hers where she is comfortable and don’t moan that he is never home when that happens.

This ⬆️🤷🏼‍♀️

Lurker85 · 11/11/2026 07:08

There are some real Ebeneezer arseholes on this thread. Judging someone else’s Christmas and declaring it shit just because they do something differently to you because they don’t have your big houses. Vile. Sounds lovely OP, ignore the misers.

Lurker85 · 11/11/2026 07:14

AskAggie · 11/11/2026 00:15

No that’s not quite it. I suspect that it’s about far more than not cooking Christmas Dinner. Just depressing. Joy lacking all round and little sense of enjoyment in relationships.

So because they have a small house, they have no joy in their relationships?

Newvember · 11/11/2026 07:33

I initially thought it sounds a bit 'royle family".

However having read all your posts, your Christmas sounds lovely. You and DH sound very accommodating. Ds sounds like a pain, not committing leaving you unable to make plans.

Yanbu

Stephaneey · 11/11/2026 07:54

Wow how snobby are people being about the cold meats!
Everyone does Christmas differently, my family has a later dinner and people have said to me ‘oh you don’t have dinner at 12?!’
It’s who’s around the tree not what’s under it!!

Thegirlwhowent · 11/11/2026 08:02

Freshrain · 10/11/2026 23:44

Thank you.

@CloveRinse and @The girl who went.

I can only go on my experience of all the homes me, and my adult dc and my nieces and nephews and siblings and parents and grandparents have lived in.

2 bed terraces. Homes in terraced rows opening out directly on to the street. Miners cottages. Streets of houses built for factory workers. Terrace homes let to students. One of my siblings lived in several different parts of the country, and both siblings, dc and dn have all lived in student houses.
All either have a living room similar in size to the OP's and a kitchen big enough to eat in (the EAs would call it a 'dining kitchen') or, a galley type kitchen and either 2 small living rooms or one larger living room.

I'm not talking about 3 bed semis, or even larger homes. My dd is currently subletting a room in a 2 bed terrace which opens out onto the pavement, small backyard, but there are 2 living rooms and a galley kitchen. The other dd has one living room, but the kitchen is big enough for a table. It isn't a "rich MN thing"

It seems incredibly unusual to have one living room that isn't big enough for a table + a settee, without having a kitchen that is big enough to include a table.

Going by your own experience isn't helpful. There are thousands of sorts of homes. If you look at many new builds, it's fairly common to have a small lounge and no space for a table in the kitchen either. Times change and family meals are not as common as they were. (I wish they were though.)

5littleducksallinarow · 11/11/2026 08:02

Sotiredimightreallydie · 10/11/2026 23:27

I get the point though. I said that it must be a very tiny lounge earlier and was told that it was a very normal size for a terraced home. I've lived in a few myself and that didn't seem right. So in had a look on Rightmove and it's actually really challenging to find a home with only a kitchen that's too small to eat in plus a 12x12 lounge.

Almost all either have 2 rooms, a kitchen diner or a lounge diner. These are small old 2 bedroom terraces where the lounge opens into the lounge btw, not large homes.

Unless it's a 1 bedroom house, which is viable if it's just for the op and husband I guess. There can't be many of those around though

So I'm also a bit curious too.

It’s a housing association property.

OP posts:
Goinggreymammy · 11/11/2026 08:19

Inertia · 10/11/2026 10:55

If she’s so traditional, why can’t she eat Christmas dinner with her own family who will provide the traditional arrangements she’s used to? She can come to you on Boxing Day.

This.
Its a relationship of less than a year, according to OP. Why does she need to come to her boyfriend's for Christmas? Stay home with her posh family.