Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it ever ok to send one to private and one to state?

239 replies

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 10/11/2026 09:03

Just that really. I would have always said you can never give children such unequal opportunities within a family but I'm looking at my two and they're such different children I'm sort of considering it. I have two primary aged children. My boy (older) is very sweet, impressionable and cautious. He's also insanely bright. He could read well from early 4, was doing Lego for 11+ at 3, he asks me to throw maths questions at him while in the bath. I think he would really thrive in an academic private whereas I worry he won't be stretched enough as he gets older in state and potentially would start coasting and lose interest. This rings true because exactly the same happened to his dad (who was then moved to private), whereas I was private all the way through and left with 5 A levels, top university degree, postgrad quals and now a great career. For these reasons I'm trying to work out finances to allow him to go to a great prep from 8.

The problem is, I can't afford it for two. My daughter (5) is a wholly different character. She's utterly brilliant, so confident, sporty (unlike her brother), she does dance and drama, gymnastics already and loves it all. Academically she's fine, she's thriving at their lovely village primary and she knows her own mind enough to not get distracted. I have no doubt she will thrive anywhere and suspect that she will throw her weight into sports and other extra curriculars rather than being exceptionally academic. I could afford to send DS to private for academic rigour while supporting DD's interests outside of school (and getting tuition for the one girls grammar nearby). But I couldn't afford two in private at the stage and obviously costs go up in secondary.

Am I unreasonable to even consider this? I've gone back and forth so many times my head is now mush.

Thank you for reading!

OP posts:
BlueJaffa · 10/11/2026 20:17

Speaking from personal experience, my older sibling was sent to a private school as my parents struggled to manage his ADHD and for many years I found it very upsetting that all these private schools "wanted" him and I could only get into the local comp.

It felt like he was being rewarded for behaving badly. Obviously now I can view it from my parent's perspective (and have more understanding about sufferers of adhd) but certainly I think a better job could have been done of explaining this to me at the time (despite my young age).

What I'm saying is, tred carefully, if you go down this road. If it's the case that there is this fabulous girls grammar nearby which you are confident she will get into then great. It's a simple case of a boy's option being too far. But if she fails to get into the grammar you want to ensure you have the resources available to best support her future as you have done for your son.

dancehysterical22 · 10/11/2026 16:33

No, you can’t do that

seahorsessky · 10/11/2026 16:21

I was going to say if one child has SEND, yes. If you had one kid who was ill, and the NHS wasn't helping them, you'd spend what you could to make their life better, no?
In your case, there isn't such a clear-cut difference, I know. FWIW, with my very limited experience so far, our state schools seem to suit girls better, and while I hate to say it, the old "it's ok for girls to study but it's not cool for boys" is tsill there.

DelectableMe · 10/11/2026 15:57

HewasH2O · 10/11/2026 14:50

It's quite hard to imagine, isn't it, that your dinky little boy might not be such a delicate little flower by the time he's 10 or 11, isn't it? Exactly the same applies to your little girl. Stereotyping at infant school is such a bad idea.

You may be surprised how different they both are in a couple of years. Perhaps your little girl will be the one who needs the privileges private education brings, but your entire budget has been blown because her brother got there first.

Yes, that's the problem. She's only 5. She can change a huge amount.

DelectableMe · 10/11/2026 15:56

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 10/11/2026 14:39

@Gill123789yours sound much like mine, except two boys. My older child is more emotional (and physically small) and I worry about him getting eaten alive at a big high school.

He's very young. You've got plenty of time to encourage and develop his resilience and self confidence before he goes to secondary.

bingoringos · 10/11/2026 15:42

A sporty dc like your dd would benefit from private.

bingoringos · 10/11/2026 15:37

I think it only makes sense if one gets into the grammar and one needs more help and is struggling or if one has SEN needs. Sending someone who is clever seems a bit pointless to me as they will still do well in a good state.

ACynicalDad · 10/11/2026 15:33

I'd only do this if he could get a scholarship that covered most of the fees.

OutAndAbouting · 10/11/2026 15:28

MarcellaGrace · 10/11/2026 09:39

There’s never an excuse for private education.

... in your opinion ...!!

PurplGirl · 10/11/2026 15:17

NoWireHangersEver · 10/11/2026 09:09

No it's not fair, and 5 is way too young to assess future academic potential. You're basically imposing your own experiences and stereotypes on her

this ⬆️

HewasH2O · 10/11/2026 14:50

It's quite hard to imagine, isn't it, that your dinky little boy might not be such a delicate little flower by the time he's 10 or 11, isn't it? Exactly the same applies to your little girl. Stereotyping at infant school is such a bad idea.

You may be surprised how different they both are in a couple of years. Perhaps your little girl will be the one who needs the privileges private education brings, but your entire budget has been blown because her brother got there first.

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 10/11/2026 14:50

@Janusnot all grammars a single sex. I was at all girls and I think that was positive. I wouldn't want to see my boy at an all boys. I think boys need the influence of girls while growing up, in a way girls can benefit from being free from distraction.

OP posts:
Notmycircusnotmyotter · 10/11/2026 14:39

@Gill123789yours sound much like mine, except two boys. My older child is more emotional (and physically small) and I worry about him getting eaten alive at a big high school.

OP posts:
Janus · 10/11/2026 14:33

I did post earlier but I also want to ask what is the obsession with grammar schools? My brother and I both went to grammar schools and we both had aspects we didn’t like there. For me an all girls school was a bullying nightmare but I think that wouldn’t be tolerated so much these days although I never told school and not sure I would do even if it was stricter. Both of us agree that going to a same sex school was a disaster socially! Neither of us really saw much of the opposite and I think it’s affected both of us, particularly in the teenage years. I simply had no idea how to talk to a boy when I left, my brother the same for a girl! I think it’s bloody unhealthy for your most formative teenage years to spend a vast part of your day with just all girls or all boys. That was my experience anyway! I’d go for a good state school over grammar any day and did for ours, they didn’t even sit the 11+.

PumpkinsForLife · 10/11/2026 14:13

Unless one has SEN requirements that make it "necessary", I don't think this is acceptable. You can make just as valid a case that a less academic child needs private school as you can the more academic one.

I think it's very convenient that everyone who admits to doing this conveniently knows that their other child would "thrive anywhere". Especially when it's people like OP making that claim about a 5 year old! It's a lie they tell themselves to make them feel better.

HewasH2O · 10/11/2026 14:02

Scrap the prep school. Set aside equal amounts for both children. Don't assume that they will both get into a grammar school.

Biggles27 · 10/11/2026 13:53

I did state from 11 (ie year 7) my brother did public boarding school from private prep so all the way through. I survived.

But would I do it if I’d had two children? probably not as the extras that private schools offer are difficult to see and not be receiving.

I’m on the fence as I’ve been in that same situation and am not traumatised in any way but I wouldn’t do that if I’d had two children 🤷‍♂️

SpunkyLimePlayer · 10/11/2026 13:36

This is so strange - you seem to be viewing very young children, their potential and their character as fixed entities and self-fulfilling prophecies. There are arguments and scenarios where it can work and be ok to do one thing for one and one for another. Your arguments are certainly not that.

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 10/11/2026 13:34

I've taken on board risks of resentment and difficult family relationships. I've also taken on board the risk of perceived misogyny. I would be interested if people would be so opposed if it was the other way round. I imagine some would, some wouldn't.

I've responded further up that it will be either or both, unless one gets into grammar and the other doesn't, at which point it will be a very open family conversation where all views are considered.

A few have said I obviously favour my son. Completely untrue. If anything, I lean towards my easy, chilled, hilarious daughter, despite loving them equally.

I will do all I can to get them the best educations possible - ideally selective and independent.

Thanks everyone for views. You've confirmed the place I started but after going down prep school rabbit holes last night I needed the kick today. Very much appreciated.

OP posts:
MyballsareSandy2015 · 10/11/2026 13:30

My brother moved from state to private when he was about 7 … he was disruptive and a bit wild at school and my parents wanted a stricter environment for him. It worked! He thrived.

I’ve never had a problem with being left in state education … I have a completely different personality to him and thrived in my own way there.

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 10/11/2026 13:27

Tintarella · 10/11/2026 12:05

Desperately unfair to label your daughter sporty but academically unexceptional - and make a decision of this magnitude about her future- at the ripe old age of 5. I think in your position I would move to a place where they both could have a shot at a good grammar.

You're probably right and I've taken this on board.

It wasn't a criticism of my daughter - she's bloody brilliant. Her emotional intelligence is impressive, she's a total powerhouse who could swim well by 3. She's fast and strong with an epic over arm. Ideally she would get into women's cricket but I know I mustn't micromanage too much 😂. She may well be more than capable academically and I will make sure she absolutely has the same in terms of resources for tutors etc.

OP posts:
HeyThereDelila · 10/11/2026 13:26

They both sound bright; I really don’t understand why you’re choosing your DS for private over your DD. Move to a better secondary school catchment or aim to get both in to grammars with tutoring - they’ll do very well.

Sounds like your DS wouldn’t benefit from the sport etc at private anyway, but your DD would. Private does not mean better academically nowadays.

You can’t treat them differently.

MajorProcrastination · 10/11/2026 13:23

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 10/11/2026 11:54

Writing off the state sector in modern days, with huge class sizes and not enough SEN support, with teachers leaving in droves.. is categorically not writing off the 93% of children who aren't at private.

But you are comfortable with "writing off" one of your children and not the other? My children are teenagers or 20 and of them and their peers, there's no notable advantage to those who went to either a local private school or went away to a private 6th form. They had good exeperiences but they've not had better A levels or got into better univeristy courses than their friends who are the same age in state school.

The major difference to the outcomes of most young people is how engaged their families are, how supportive their parents are. Your kids have got that.

You can choose what you want for your own children, I just saw a glaring assumption in your post about the state school experience NOW, not just in the 90s and 00s.

Muchtoomuchtodo · 10/11/2026 13:19

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 10/11/2026 11:08

I've spent the morning researching and have made a 5 year plan to support them both.

Not far from where we live is a grammar area with outstanding state schools as a fall back. It's also beautiful with large houses that can be done up.

It seems the obvious choice to save hard over the next couple of years for the new house while really focussing on both children's strengths (reading and wide vocab a priority for both), introducing verbal and non-verbal reasoning from year 3/4, tutoring for grammar and moving house to the grammar area when DS is around 9.

If DS gets into grammar and DD doesn't I'll reopen the private option for her. If neither get in, it will either be the great states or less prestigious private for both.

Thanks for everyone's input.

Gosh, a couple of hours this morning to come up with a 5 year plan that has massive implications for you, your dp and dc! That’s extremely fast to do a u-turn!

Retiring at 55 isn’t the norm, and living in small houses is pretty typical too, so the adjustments that you might end up making aren’t too radical!

Please just enjoy your dc and stop microanalysing them.

YenSon · 10/11/2026 13:04

Slightyamusedandsilly · 10/11/2026 09:20

Why is it always the boy that 'needs' private though?

I have (older) friends. DS went to private. He is successful in what he does. DD went to state. She is now a lead medical consultant.

I was horrified when they admitted little Johnny would be private and little Emma would be private. So sexist.

It's either both or neither. Way to set up your children for a life of sibling rivalry, favouritism and fractured sibling relationships.

I worked in a high performing state primary school in an affluent area. What sometimes happened for those inclined, was at some point in KS2 their child would leave to go to a prep school, or they’d go after Y6. One family had 4 children. All 3 sons went to prep in Y3 or Y4. Not the daughter though. She had to stay in state school. She told me that only the boys in her family went to private school. She was the brightest button out of the lot of them.