Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For feeling anxious about having to see my sister over the holidays?

9 replies

polkadottedelphant · 10/11/2026 07:28

Growing up my older sister and I were never close. We're both very different people even though we're only about a year and a half apart. We have basically polar opposite styles, interests, personalities, etc. -- we don't even look like we're related. Anyway, as one might assume, this caused a lot of fighting and tension in our relationship growing up. I have two other younger sisters (I'm the older middle child, as our family has four girls) but I never really fought with them like I would with my older sister. All of this to say, throughout my childhood and into my adult years, I haven't really had a relationship with her, and if we did have one, it was weak and strained at best.

I also fought a lot with my parents as a kid. They would tell me that they wished I would be more like my older sister (who was kind of the poster child in our family growing up) and that they wished I were different and born to another family or not at all. I, in turn, would cuss them out or say equal things back. I recognize now that aspects of my relationship with my parents were somewhat verbally abusive on both ends, but over the years we've, for the most part, figured our issues out. We've gone to counseling, talked about a lot of things together, and I truly feel that our relationship has grown and been repaired.

This fighting led to a lot of strain in my relationship with my sister because she didn't fight with my parents, so she didn't really understand how or why that was happening. After a fight, she would usually come to my room to yell at me about how I was an ungrateful daughter, and I didn't deserve parents like the ones I had. My family was also very religious growing up, and while I am still religious myself, my sister was (and to some extent is) the kind of Christian who would almost shame you for not being perfect. She would tell me things like "God is ashamed of you," "God doesn't want a daughter like you, who cusses out their parents," or even "You're not going to heaven," -- which was extremely harmful to the very anxious, worrisome, and depressed teen I was.

When I was a junior in high school, I also learned that I have Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD), which is a personality disorder in which the person suffering from it has severe difficulties with regulating emotions, has a very unstable sense of self, and often ends up having difficulty maintaining healthy relationships due to these things. I'm not saying this to excuse my actions whatsoever, but it explains a lot about my relationship with my parents throughout my childhood.

Anyways, I never told my sister that I was diagnosed because, as I said, we didn't have a good relationship and I just didn't share stuff like that with her. (TBH I think the main reason I didn't was that when I was diagnosed with ADHD in middle school, I refused to tell her for so long because she would make fun of kids' disorders/disabilities/etc. When my parents finally forced me to tell her it wasn't my choice, they made me she immediately began making fun of me, literally proving my point right. Not only that, but my ADHD literally became a source of bullying she used for me.)

So back to the story, the week before she left for college was rough. My parents and I had been fighting a lot, and things just weren't in a good place in our house. I remember she had been really mad at me too for all the fighting that had been going on, and the day before she was going to leave, she came down to talk to me. She basically came into my room and told me that she didn't want a relationship with me anymore, not that we had had one for a long time. She said that she genuinely didn't enjoy being around me and wished I wasn't her sister. She also said that I must've been demon-possessed based on the way I would fight with my parents. And remember, that not only was I a religious person, but also had a mood disorder she didn't know about going on in the background, so the fact that she had just accused me of that was INSANE. I was just bawling, and I remember telling my parents what she had said, and they were like, yeah, she was out of line for saying you were possessed, that's not true, but that's fair that she doesn't want a relationship with you.

That night she came back again to my room to say "goodbye," but I refused to talk to her for obvious reasons. I felt really bad about it though, so I got up early in the morning to say goodbye to her because even though I was so hurt by her, I didn't want to let her just leave for college without saying goodbye. So I woke up at 3am to say goodbye to her before her flight, and when she came down the stairs and I told her that I was sorry if I had hurt her and that I hoped she had the best time at college she just looked me in the eye and told me that if I had wanted to fix their relationship so badly that I should have talked to her the night before.

Since then we've been pretty much no contact. Sure, we see each other for holidays and stuff, but it's awkward, and we don't really talk. Everyone in my family is still cool with her, but I just feel so alienated and when I try to bring up actual conversations with her she just ignores me or changes the topic and leaves. It's kind of brought me to dread the holidays or times when our whole family will get together because I don't want to be around her, even if I'm fine with my parents and younger sisters.

Now this isn't to say that I don't love her and wish her the best in life; I really do. I just find it very hard to be around her because of her beliefs, perspectives, etc. She's still an extremely religious person in the judgy sense, while I guess I would describe myself as religious but in a loving way. I don't know if that makes sense, but basically when she sees people who are different than her, her first instinct is to judge, while I guess mine is to show them love because that's literally who I've always been to my family.

Anyway, I guess my question is AIBU for not looking forward to having to see her and interact with her for the holidays? I also just genuinely don't understand how we're ever going to fix our relationship since she doesn't seem interested in doing so, even though I want so badly to feel like sisters again.

OP posts:
BMW6 · 10/11/2026 07:36

Anyway, I guess my question is AIBU for not looking forward to having to see her and interact with her for the holidays? I also just genuinely don't understand how we're ever going to fix our relationship since she doesn't seem interested in doing so, even though I want so badly to feel like sisters again.

Of course YANBU for dreading seeing her - you don't like her and for very good reason and the feeling is mutual.

You CANNOT "fix" this relationship - you don't like each other!
Just tolerate each other, be polite, avoid her whenever possible.

You are crying for the moon. Give it up and move on.

Octonaut4Life · 10/11/2026 07:52

It's interesting to me that nothing in your post suggests you've ever really tried to consider this from your sister's point of view. Your relationship with your parents as a teen sounds incredibly toxic and disruptive. I'm sure that was awful to be in the same house as. You're obviously very hurt by your sister's behaviour but your behaviour sounds just as bad and you've never tried to talk to her about it or apologise for the kind of atmosphere that you created in the house? Yes okay she was judgy and mean, she was a teenager - most of them are at some point. I honestly think you need to at least try to be the bigger person, apologise, and talk to her about it. That doesn't mean you have to suddenly be besties but it would defuse the bad atmosphere on holidays.

thepariscrimefiles · 10/11/2026 07:58

Despite or maybe because of her religion, your sister is a horrible, judgemental and cruel bitch and you are not being unreasonable to dread seeing her.

How on earth does she think that, as a Christian, it was fine for her to bully and taunt children with disabilities? What sort of god does she worship? You obviously live in the USA and I am constantly baffled how MAGA christians in particular seem to break most of the 10 commandments on a regular basis, particularly the ones instructing christians not to kill, steal or commit adultery.

You have been very forgiving to your parents who did nothing to protect you from your evil older sister. I think that your life would be better if you distanced yourself from your sister and your parents but I understand if you don't want to do that.

EnjoythemoneyJane · 10/11/2026 08:01

The only thing you can do is tell her you’re sorry things ended between you the way they did, and that you’d like to try to repair the relationship. If you choose to do this, though, don’t expect any admissions of culpability on her part. She’ll almost certainly want you to take all the blame and grovel for her forgiveness, and you’ll have to put up with her berating you for your behaviour all over again.

It sounds like your difficulties and your relationship with your parents growing up affected your whole household, so in some respects I can understand why she might be bitter about that. As much as it was a horrible time for you, it must have been hard for your sisters. But you also describe her as a pretty intolerant, nasty, judgmental person and the kind of ‘Christian’ that wields god as a threat and punishment, so it’s unlikely she’ll want to meet you halfway or do the kind of introspection or growth that will allow your relationship to move forward from this.

How old are you all, out of interest?

angelasim · 10/11/2026 08:41

You need to make peace with having the disfunctional family you were born into. Enjoy the bits you can enjoy and accept the rest.

MarcellaGrace · 10/11/2026 08:54

Either (1) address it with her, (2) just acknowledge you don’t like one another and tolerate her presence over Christmas, or (3) choose to do something different this year and not spend it with your family.

rolloverbeethoven · 10/11/2026 09:06

I may have missed it, but how long ago was all this? She may have changed a lot since then. I can only suggest that you treat her like you would a guest who you don't know well, keep it polite but light. If she wants a deep and meaningful she'll have to instigate it. I hope you have a peaceful and pleasant Christmas OP, and well done for getting yourself into a better place mentally 💐

SlightlyTerrifiedButPolite · 11/11/2026 07:40

YANBU for dreading seeing her but I think you might need some professional support in figuring out how to mend this which is sensitive to your BPD. Do you have a therapist?

I can speak to this from the perspective of someone whose sister has BPD. It obviously manifests differently in everyone. She was diagnosed around 11 but my parents kept it secret (partly because they were afraid of her). She terrorised the household and ran rings around us all. My parents didn’t tell me until I was 33 and things had come to a head when she came off her medication. She is NC with me and my brother but speaks to my parents (before she was NC with everyone but me, before than everyone but my brother).

Knowing her diagnosis helped her behaviour seem less bewildering but it doesn’t stop her behaviour hurting me. It did help me change my response to her and actually it’s made it easier to find peace in us not having a relationship. You can’t change someone.

I feel for you as BPD at least for my sister has been a horrendous affliction with devastating impact on her life and I do understand how you feel emotional pain with an intensity neurotypical people can’t understand. That’s why my advice would be to explore some of these issues with your sister with a psychologist who understands BPD. Remember you can’t change someone. If you really want a relationship you might have to suck it up and eat some humble pie without any accountability from your sister, but given your emotional vulnerability if she can’t be trusted to behave in a way that understands that perhaps it is better that you keep things at surface level? To start with you just want to get to a point where you know you can be in the same room as each other without a blow up and to stick to niceties - yes that’s not a close sisterly relationship but it’s an improvement and it hopefully won’t be that hard to achieve. It might be for the both of you that that is the best way to have a relationship

Pinadaqx2 · 11/11/2026 08:03

@polkadottedelphant "cuss them out" 😂😂😂😂😂 theres a phrase I don't read on MN ever!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page