Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

16 year old stepson's reaction to the Russel Brand sentencing

156 replies

inthisdayandage27 · 09/11/2026 20:30

Name change as I'm absolutely shocked actually.

My 16 year old stepson's reaction to the Russel Brand sentencing over dinner tonight was "Well, most women lie about it, don't they?"

I said "You can't seriously think that can you?"

He replies "Well you think that about men" (Which made little sense, but..)

We sort of left it like that because I was dumbstruck that he could think that.

Now, I have a slightly younger son who I hope will have absorbed some respect of women from me (and I sure will be having a chat with him) but more worrying I have a 12 year old daughter too. The step kids (both boys) are here half the time.

I'm honestly not sure how to go about this as I am hands off parenting with step kids (thinking they had sensible parents although I do worry my partner isn't as liberal as I am with his thinking).

I think having a chat to his mum would be over stepping the mark but I feel I can't leave this.

OP posts:
Lexibletheflexible · 10/11/2026 09:15

One thing I discussed with my son and his friend who is staying with us about this is their confusion on how to navigate respecting someone's autonomy, particularly them as young men respecting that women can make competent choices versus understanding when someone (sober) may not have all the power they need to make a truly informed choice.

This sprung from the RB sentencing, but sort of evolved to situations where someone might appear consenting, even enthusiastically so, but the chances of them feeling negatively about it later on (even years later) is high.

We discussed the fact that saying no, even though someone has said yes, or even initiated the interaction, is still respecting their autonomy. You're just realising your own autonomy, too.

tamade · 10/11/2026 09:04

A lot of teenagers speak in extremes, especially if they are unsure of the ground they are on.
My own interpretation is that their brains are still developing particularly reasoning and they are unconsciously employing a negotiating position fallacy, sort of the inverse of the middle ground fallacy, whereby the more extreme the starting claim the less likely they will have to concede all the way to a complete withdrawal.
So a small minority becomes most.

Unless there is a pattern of contempt for women I would not consider this problematic.

EverybodyLTB · 10/11/2026 08:54

So you can’t have an open conversation with his father, your husband, about being what (you’ve skirted around but sounds like) misogynistic views? Your first port of call is to contact his mum? Mate, you’ve married the problem! You’ve got a 12 year old daughter in a house with a misogynistic 16 year old boy. Is your husband her biological father? Fucking hell, I’d be hugely worried.

frozendaisy · 10/11/2026 08:49

A powerful, historically untouchable man, has been thrown in jail, even with his ample resources for historical sexual offences.

Of course the swamp of online manosphere is going to go on overdrive trying to defend him, undermine his victims.

Parents nowadays are not just parenting against the general societal consensus, which let’s face it in the past, actually largely still, was heavily biased towards letting men have control over women, now it has shifted to online. And there are very effective communicators online who can talk the talk.

I think it’s good that SS has said what he said, his parents (and you @inthisdayandage27) need to know what he thinks. What is influencing him.

Expecting 16 year olds to be able to have the maturity to be immune to the poison they see and hear all the time from online, to peers, to other adults is naive.

Opening up a dialogue, building trust and talking through opinions is always a good thing even if there are bumps along the way.

My parents never had to talk to me about photographs of my vagina but we have had to talk about dic pics (and flap snaps) to our teens (that was fun!).

A lot of males are being convinced that women still “ask for it”, that they are owed extreme sex (even before they have had a relationship in some cases), that their failures are someone else’s fault.

Russel Brand isn’t the only rich and powerful predator who should be in jail. But he’s one of the only ones who they could actually get a case to court. And that’s part of the problem, many women are believed when they report rape, but getting a conviction “beyond reasonable doubt” is a different level. It’s hard.

Yes some women lie, but no where near the number who walk around daily knowing their rape will never get a conviction and have to live with that trauma for the rest of their lives.

When you have husbands drugging their wives and inviting other numerous men to use them sexually whilst unconscious and no one in this sphere of fucking evil says a word about it to anyone - and the social defence boils down to “yeah but but but some women lie” - come on guys is that all you can manage?

TotaleclipseinFrance · 10/11/2026 08:16

Lugol · 10/11/2026 07:51

And you're one of those who thinks women lie about being raped.

Are you a man?

Yes.
I do think that a very small percentage of women lie, because they do.

Not a man.

Do you seriously believe no women has ever lied about being raped?

I mean really?

I'm not saying that you are stupid at all but I am saying that to put forward the idea that women never, ever lie about being raped is stupid because in a small amount of cases they do lie.

Why are you even arguing about this? Most people would agree my stance is reasonable.

What are you trying to do? Shame me into agreeing with you? Never going to happen.
So unless you want this pointless back and forth please don't bother to reply.

Blueseaurchin · 10/11/2026 08:03

His father needs to have a serious talk with him.

Sparklybanana · 10/11/2026 07:54

Ask your stepson whether he would come forward easily to tell the world that he had been raped by a well known man who potentially can destroy his career or would he suck it up and accept it in order to move on with life in general. Maybe if he considers it from the other perspective he'd be more empathetic.

As Jimmy Carr said - Russell Brands understanding of sex and consent is going to change vastly over the coming weeks....

Wish44 · 10/11/2026 07:52

OP your very first reaction was to blame his mum and not even put the dad in the mix. You will be modelling this mindset to your step son in so many many ways -

what does your household look like? Housework/ mental load / finances etc- the best thing you can do for stepson is show him an equal relationship with your partner.

when i am involved in any situations like this i reverse the sexes in my head to examine for bias as they are everywhere and deeply entrenched in society.

Lugol · 10/11/2026 07:51

TotaleclipseinFrance · 10/11/2026 07:18

Your post is ridiculous. It really is.

For some reason your comprehension is off. Too early? No coffee yet?

You sound like one of those people who upon a woman says she's been raped would instantly lock the guy up, no trial, nothing.

That's not how it works.

And yes there ARE a very small number of women who lie. A very small number.

I'm not going to deny this to bow down to your bullying tone.

THAT'S why we have juries.

And you're one of those who thinks women lie about being raped.

Are you a man?

Herewegoagain127 · 10/11/2026 07:44

Wilderness181 · 09/11/2026 21:47

To be fair he probably has been stitched up with the rape conviction but not by the woman, it’s the establishment that wanted rid of him.

A groupie pursues him for sex and goes through with it willingly on more than 1 occasion. 15 years later she tells someone in the media who facilitates a police report.

In court she states she said no to a particularly activity whereas Brand claims she said yes.

I of course have no idea what the truth is from that day nearly 20 years ago however to jail someone for over a decade and take him away from his family and children on the basis of that seems extreme.

It later transpires that the testimony that was taken as being entirely factual by the court came from someone with, in the judges own words, “lengthy mental health and addiction problems”.

They wanted rid of him. They were OK when he was the darling of the left wing but as soon as his politics flipped they went for him.

Of course none of that takes away from the fact that people should always respect each other. It just looks extremely questionable at a time where the UK is seeing more and more politically motivated court action.

You really think Brand is that influential on British politics someone has fabricated a rape conviction to “get rid of him”?

what’s the point? Why are our Tommeh, Lawrence fox, Farage and the rest of them still out there? Surely they’re more of a threat than some shitty comedian who’s gone all Trumpy.

do you also think the historic claims against glitter, Harris et al are also fabricated to “get rid of them”?

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 10/11/2026 07:38

inthisdayandage27 · 09/11/2026 21:01

Ok I think I was still in shock. It's a task for his father to talk to his son. And a task for me to talk to his father.

Your first reaction is 1) to go on Mumsnet, 2) then go to the boy's mother - obviously nothing wrong with using Mumsnet as a sounding board. But you haven't even spoken with your DH and the boy's father. And if you think the boy's attitude has been 'inherited' from his father, rather than toxic social media, the that raises a different raft of issues

MandemChickenShop · 10/11/2026 07:33

16 year old pushing boundaries/ your buttons.

use it as a opportunity to encourage enthusiastic consent

WildLeader · 10/11/2026 07:27

Zuve · 09/11/2026 20:36

Oh, I would just leave it. You could say, that he has been found guilty by a court of law,by Judge and jury.

A jury with EIGHT men on it.

Firesidechatter · 10/11/2026 07:25

TotaleclipseinFrance · 10/11/2026 06:56

This is ridiculous.
My post is balanced and considerate.

Your reading comprehension of it is off.

On balance simply means that I've weighed it up in my own mind and thought this woman is telling the truth as any intelligent person will do. It's considering the evidence.

I'm not responsible for any woman not reporting rape so you can feck right off with that accusation. Bloody cheek.

How do you weigh it up in your own mind? The trial was not broadcast live so very little has been revealed to the public? It was four weeks long and lasted approximately 5 hours a day, that’s 100 hours in total,, only a fraction, a tiny tiny fraction of that has been published.

as much as I applaud you promoting yourself to decide, I simply don’t see how it’s feasible?

TotaleclipseinFrance · 10/11/2026 07:18

Lugol · 10/11/2026 07:06

No you wrote a lot of stuff about how "you're not saying" she lied "she convinced" a jury she's not lying and "on balance" you believe her BUT...

You think women lie about being raped.

It's screaming out of the words you wrote.

Your post is ridiculous. It really is.

For some reason your comprehension is off. Too early? No coffee yet?

You sound like one of those people who upon a woman says she's been raped would instantly lock the guy up, no trial, nothing.

That's not how it works.

And yes there ARE a very small number of women who lie. A very small number.

I'm not going to deny this to bow down to your bullying tone.

THAT'S why we have juries.

Lugol · 10/11/2026 07:06

TotaleclipseinFrance · 10/11/2026 06:56

This is ridiculous.
My post is balanced and considerate.

Your reading comprehension of it is off.

On balance simply means that I've weighed it up in my own mind and thought this woman is telling the truth as any intelligent person will do. It's considering the evidence.

I'm not responsible for any woman not reporting rape so you can feck right off with that accusation. Bloody cheek.

No you wrote a lot of stuff about how "you're not saying" she lied "she convinced" a jury she's not lying and "on balance" you believe her BUT...

You think women lie about being raped.

It's screaming out of the words you wrote.

TotaleclipseinFrance · 10/11/2026 06:56

Lugol · 10/11/2026 06:42

You write like you think women lie about being raped most of the time.

On balance you think the woman is telling the truth?

A court, Judge and jury heard all the evidence and there was no doubt she was telling the truth.

Imagine being brave enough to put yourself through everything that woman and the rest of them did to bring that man to justice, actually managing to obtain a conviction (given how pitifully small conviction rates are) and STILL being accused of being a liar.

No wonder women don't report rape with views like yours.

This is ridiculous.
My post is balanced and considerate.

Your reading comprehension of it is off.

On balance simply means that I've weighed it up in my own mind and thought this woman is telling the truth as any intelligent person will do. It's considering the evidence.

I'm not responsible for any woman not reporting rape so you can feck right off with that accusation. Bloody cheek.

HalzTangz · 10/11/2026 06:49

Was his dad there at the time, if so, what did he say about his son's comment? His dad needs to be speaking with him, and having the conversation with his mother also

TheAbsentRoyalUmberella · 10/11/2026 06:48

I'm not sure this one falls under the remit of all women lie etc.

This has been tested in court who would want to put themselves through it...I would arm myself with all the counter arguments and next time gently in a non confrontational way gently take him through asking questions ...it's a wider service to society to anyones daughters ...

malificent7 · 10/11/2026 06:43

Not nice but no need to ltb as some on here are suggesting!

Lugol · 10/11/2026 06:42

TotaleclipseinFrance · 09/11/2026 21:24

I'm not saying she lying at all, she has convinced a jury she is not and on balance I think that she is telling the truth but I do think that it's a bit unimaginative to say that reasons as to why she would lie don't exist because clearly they do.

I mean clearly people lie about all sorts of stuff all the time.

You write like you think women lie about being raped most of the time.

On balance you think the woman is telling the truth?

A court, Judge and jury heard all the evidence and there was no doubt she was telling the truth.

Imagine being brave enough to put yourself through everything that woman and the rest of them did to bring that man to justice, actually managing to obtain a conviction (given how pitifully small conviction rates are) and STILL being accused of being a liar.

No wonder women don't report rape with views like yours.

LaidOnYourBackWithTheBoyWithTheArabStrap · 10/11/2026 06:39

You’re right to be concerned and disgusted by your stepson’s reaction to this. However, instead of talking to his mother about it you should talk to his father, who is presumably in his life and yours and he should deal with it. For 2 reason: he is the boy’s father and it’s his responsibility, and it’s the responsibility of all men to call out these attitudes and behaviours of other men and boys whenever they see it. It can’t always be our responsibility as women like everything else seems to be . If your partner isn’t likely to do that then you have a far bigger problem than your stepson tbh.

Lhori · 10/11/2026 06:34

Show him the Judge's description of the anal rape and ask him if he really thinks that is ok? If he is going to spout opinions about this, he needs to be aware of the facts so he is aware of what he is siding with. People were like this about Jimmy Savile and it was pretty embarrassing for them.

Nugg · 10/11/2026 06:19

@LiquoriceAllsorts2not remotely that. I asked her to elaborate on what she meant, to clarify what had happened to her, asked her if she’d actually read anything about the court case and the things that the victims had said and what he was actually found guilty of and we discussed the difference which was phenomenal as she then realised.

bellinisurge · 10/11/2026 06:18

His father needs to deal with it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread