Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Russell Brand video circa 2002. Shows some background to how he became who he is

83 replies

SummaNites · 09/11/2026 16:54

Documentary from 2002 (I think), presented by Brand. Setting up a boxing fight with his father to sort out his 'daddy issues'.

It's really illuminating, and shows his attitude to women has been of very long standing. He really is a deeply weird and imo, dangerous person. No concept of boundaries at all.

It is not an easy watch, so please beware if it may cause issues for you.

I suppose the AIBU is - I think people should watch this (if they can stomach it), to understand more about people like Brand.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vIynOOwD3CQ

OP posts:
Lexibletheflexible · 10/11/2026 14:08

TheCappyEffect · 09/11/2026 18:59

I’m not defending him or making excuses for him, but I do wonder how much his childhood and his relationship with his father played a part in shaping the person he is today. Being exposed to sexual things at such an early age must have had some impact on how he viewed sex, relationships and women. I wonder whether some of those early experiences contributed to his attitude towards women and his understanding of boundaries. It doesn’t excuse his behaviour, but I do think our upbringing and experiences can have a profound effect on the adults we become.

It's sexual abuse

ElectricThrowAddict · 10/11/2026 14:06

It is well known that many perpetrators of sexual offences were themselves offended against at some point.

That is an incredibly sad fact. It does not excuse the perpetrators at all, but it does help us to understand in some way, how and why people may behave as they do.

It is the same pattern as families where parents physical abuse or neglect children - they were once children who were abused or neglected themselves.

What we should seek to understand better is why some people who have experienced these abuses go ok to offend against others, while many do not. What are the factors that change the risks. What can we do to break cycles and patterns and equip those with adverse experiences to forge a different path.

In my own extended family we have examples of people with addiction issues, criminal records and marital breakdown where it is very easy to see why they are how they are. What is less easily explained is why and how their siblings have managed to go on to live full and stable lives and be good and present parents to their own children.

Missohnoyoubetterdont · 10/11/2026 11:36

No one is excusing his behaviour, it’s typical MN that people fail to read the posts correctly or twist them for an argument. Is either that or they just don’t have the intelligence to process the subject matter correctly.

Irridescence · 10/11/2026 10:00

One other thing that he inherited from his father was authenticity- by that I mean RB showed us exactly who he was and he gained a career from it. He even said he raped somebody once in a comedy show with Richard Herring. His father also showed his authentic monstrous self yesterday by calling his son the victim and that the jury was corrupt. His father is a seedy old man, and RB is his middle aged replica.

Isittimeformynapyet · 10/11/2026 10:00

TheCappyEffect · 09/11/2026 21:03

@BoredZelda read it again 🙄 instead of coming for me I said I wonder if ….I’m not defending anybody or making excuses. Yes he was an adult etc, the point I was trying to make albeit poorly 🙄, is the damage parents can cause. I’m damaged, my son is damaged, nothing sexual like RB & his father may I add!, but behaviours have left lasting damage and trauma.

Just to reiterate, I’m not defending anyone or making excuses.

Instead of using words like "defending" or "excusing" use the word "explaining".

His father's vile disrespect and treatment of women goes some way towards explaining how the son could possibly enter adulthood believing that he's not in the wrong.

He was incorrect about that. And it's now been explained to him in no uncertain terms by a long prison sentence.

BAM! 👊🏻

devonsevon11 · 10/11/2026 09:53

I’ve just watched the first 10 minutes of the YouTube clip.

There’s something very grotesque about Russell and his father.

Firstly, that man is not a dad. He is completely disinterested and always has been. Talks about leaving and having no contact and not even knowing how old Russell was when he began seeing him (sporadically) again. Muses on how Russell would get upset when he was late like he finds this surprising. When Russell says that there is nothing to avenge from his childhood his dad quickly says he agrees. He thinks he’s done nothing wrong, doesn’t see that he could have done better. Says “1 in 3 marriages end up with someone leaving” like that makes it ok.

They both have very similar voices, very high pitched and I’m not sure if this is natural or not, possibly Russell emulating his dad?

I don’t know, but either way, his dad is awful. A massive failure as a father and a complete unwillingness to accept that.

The footage of Russell knocking on his mums
door and asking her to go and see the fight….again, I just found it grotesque. He looks a lot
worse than he did latterly. He looked a lot more polished when he was more successful and had his teeth done, wore make up, hair not so lank and dirty looking. I was surprised just how bad and unhealthy he looked. Also the way he was with his mum…he just seemed so lacking and begging for attention. Although from what I understand his mum was very loving and attentive and certainly I could see that her house was full of photos of him.

I had to stop watching at that point. Something about it just made me uncomfortable.

@Redbagsyes i would agree that he is bright
but not educated. He could have done more with his life. I also feel that everything is so performative with him, he’s just not in the same sphere as genuinely intelligent, educated
people who don’t need to rant and rave like him.

I think he’s incredibly damaged. But I guess so is his dad. Doesn’t excuse it.

I found it interesting (and surprising) when the expert (psychologist) said that very few men have good relationships with their fathers. A very dear friend of mine (male) had an absent father and remembers the exact situation Russell describes -
waiting with his coat on for his father who never turned up. The father then moved on, had a new family and stopped all contact with my friend from when he was around 5 years old.

I met my friend at uni. Lovely guy but he did eventually drop out of uni. He didn’t get a degree but he found a job and has been there ever since and has worked his way up to management. He has struggled with both drugs and alcohol but always kept his job etc. I guess very much a functioning alcoholic. In his mid 30s he got married and had 3 children, 2 boys and a girl. The boys are 11 and 9
and he is the most devoted dad I have ever seen. No longer drinks or does drugs. His kids are his life.

Anecdotal, obviously, but does show that these cycles can be broken. Russell’s son is young so who knows what type of relationship they will have or would have had and what the impact of his
jail sentence will be on that relationship. I do feel that Russell’s ego would be an issue in all his relationships but I’m no expert.

Lovechicken · 10/11/2026 09:49

Missey85 · 10/11/2026 07:03

It's a worrying state of affairs when so many women are making up excuses for him! 🤮

Indeed. I was quite shocked at some of the support for him on SM this morning.

The god squad blaming the victims for their “debauchery”. Only safe sex is that within marriage. RB is ok because he’s repented etc.

The conspiracy theorists who say “they” are out to get him because he spoke up against big Pharma.

The mind boggles. Also agree with a PP that he will have an easy time in jail. He’s got the money to pay for “security”. He will be protected by the inmates who control the jail as he will arrange for them/their families, to get money. There’ll be no beatings/attacks or “lag justice” for him sadly.

Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · 10/11/2026 09:41

valentinka31 · 10/11/2026 09:24

Clearly his dad is the horrific originator of all of this. He gets his son having sex with women while he too is in the room having sex with others (RB’s comment ‘you were busy’ made me feel sick). Then he mocks him for attaching feelings of affection to sex. He’s done this. The dad.

Well I agree totally that his Dad shaped his attitude to women and sex.
But you can't lay all the blame on his Dad. Because Brand was encouraged and enabled and actually admired throughout his career by countless other people who reinforced his behaviour and attitudes.

And at the end of the day Brand is a sentient human being who chose to rape and sexually assault women and reduce women to the status of his sexual play things. He knows right from wrong. From what he has said he knows consent is important. But he deliberately chose not to recognise the right of a woman to say no when it came to his interaction with them.

BananaPeels · 10/11/2026 09:28

There will always be people who see things in black and white and others who see the shades of grey. His behaviour and crimes were awful but we can still feel sympathy for the young man who was brought up like that. We can want justice for his victims and not victim blame whilst thinking some girls need better education to avoid putting themselves in vulnerable situations and to be alert to glaring red flags. All things can be true at once. Unless we talk about it, we can’t prevent it happening again.

Redbags · 10/11/2026 09:27

devonsevon11 · 10/11/2026 09:23

This is something I find very odd about him.

He has a good vocabulary and is never lost for words. He talks very fast and fairly eloquently..,,but it is very difficult to follow and I think he makes people feel that if they can’t keep up that’s their fault.

He preaches and pontificates and he seems to avoid noticeably contradicting himself, but it is all politician speak and he doesn’t ever actually seem to really say anything.

He’s manipulative and somewhat convincing…..but I really don’t know if he is genuinely intelligent or not.

as I said below, he has gone from atheist to Buddhist to Christian and has pontificated loudly about all of them. I believe he does do his “research” and is able to speak extensively on these topics….but is he just regurgitating words? I suspect he is, but he does it “well”. He doesn’t stumble over himself etc.

But I’ll admit I haven’t listened to him enough to really know. I find him too difficult to listen to. Too fast, frantic and needlessly wordy.

I think he is "bright" but not educated. He's quick thinking but he doesn't have knowledge or depth of understanding. Possibly his MH conditions contribute to the way his views are constantly changing, which means they never gain any depth.

valentinka31 · 10/11/2026 09:24

Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · 09/11/2026 17:06

I got as far as his reminiscences about him and his Dad with the prostitutes when they went on holiday together when he was still a young guy and I couldn't watch any more OP.
It was actually really really distressing.
It shows how attitudes to women are passed on through the generations.

Clearly his dad is the horrific originator of all of this. He gets his son having sex with women while he too is in the room having sex with others (RB’s comment ‘you were busy’ made me feel sick). Then he mocks him for attaching feelings of affection to sex. He’s done this. The dad.

devonsevon11 · 10/11/2026 09:23

Theroadt · 10/11/2026 08:21

“erudite”? He never presented as educated imho

This is something I find very odd about him.

He has a good vocabulary and is never lost for words. He talks very fast and fairly eloquently..,,but it is very difficult to follow and I think he makes people feel that if they can’t keep up that’s their fault.

He preaches and pontificates and he seems to avoid noticeably contradicting himself, but it is all politician speak and he doesn’t ever actually seem to really say anything.

He’s manipulative and somewhat convincing…..but I really don’t know if he is genuinely intelligent or not.

as I said below, he has gone from atheist to Buddhist to Christian and has pontificated loudly about all of them. I believe he does do his “research” and is able to speak extensively on these topics….but is he just regurgitating words? I suspect he is, but he does it “well”. He doesn’t stumble over himself etc.

But I’ll admit I haven’t listened to him enough to really know. I find him too difficult to listen to. Too fast, frantic and needlessly wordy.

Missohnoyoubetterdont · 10/11/2026 09:19

Wow. That’s a hard watch. I totally understand what pp are saying, it’s not an excuse but it totally makes sense to how his demeanour and attitude to and around women. Really shocking.

EnjoythemoneyJane · 10/11/2026 08:54

I think people are struggling to understand the difference between reasons and excuses.

Agree, @TheGreatDownandOut, and other posters are catching unfair flak for it.

This video in no way excuses his crimes, but it’s certainly very illuminating in terms of how his formative experiences influenced the man/rapist and abuser he became. A little boy desperate for attention from an absent, deadbeat dad describes their first truly bonding experience as side-by-side sex with prostitutes while he was still a schoolboy.

When the psychologist suggests many sons and fathers can only communicate over hobbies such as woodwork, Brand suggests women - specifically with ‘big titties’ - are his equivalent of a shared interest with his dad. So basically women as woodwork, serving as tools to facilitate his relationship with his father. You couldn’t fucking make it up.

His view of women as no more than objects for his gratification was clearly built on a foundation laid down very early on by his father. Acknowledging this is not excusing or explaining away the gravity of the crimes he chose to commit - again and again - as a grown man.

ElectricThrowAddict · 10/11/2026 08:25

That video is gross.

The clip where he says that his dad gave him.mosogynistic views and created a situation where the only way to impress him was by womanising....or similar words...is so messed up!

Theroadt · 10/11/2026 08:21

BoredZelda · 09/11/2026 20:50

“I’m not defending him but”…..

Except, this is defending him and making excuses for him. He was an adult, who lived in a society where he would have to be incredibly ignorant not to know his behaviour was not acceptable. For someone so erudite, who went through rehab (which takes a lot of self reflection and exploration of past issues), it’s laughable to even hint at his daddy issues had a bearing on him being a rapist.

“erudite”? He never presented as educated imho

Portugal1987 · 10/11/2026 08:15

TheCappyEffect · 09/11/2026 22:38

Oh please ffs that’s not what I’m saying 🙄

I totally get what you’re saying.

It’s possible to hold someone accountable for their own actions, while also acknowledging that parents/upbrtmay have had an influence.

the two aren’t mutually exclusive. He still belongs in jail AND his parents should be ashamed.

TheGreatDownandOut · 10/11/2026 07:57

It’s also a well known fact that many abusers were themselves abused. This doesn’t put them beyond the reach of the justice system - but it does help to understand abuse cycles

TheGreatDownandOut · 10/11/2026 07:56

devonsevon11 · 10/11/2026 01:34

Oh ffs.

These strawman arguements are so tiresome and really ruin intelligent discussions.

Bore off with your “so according to you…”

Thats absolutely not what she said and you know it. Youre being inflammatory and ridiculous.

It’s really tiresome isn’t it? I think people are struggling to understand the difference between reasons and excuses. The OP is offering reasons. This doesn’t absolve Brand in anyway. And it won’t, he’s been sentenced to jail time - but I do believe it’s prudent to understand why people commit the crimes they do if nothing other than rehabilitation or in some cases, prevention. Brand will not spend the rest of his life in prison. At some point, he will be back out in society.

GnomeDePlume · 10/11/2026 07:44

@BertieBotts what you described about RB being mesmerising really chimed with me.

A senior director at a company where I worked was like that. It was very strange to be a bystander when he was using his charm on someone. It was like a beam of light. If you werent in the beam you couldnt feel the charm.

PerdreLeBleu · 10/11/2026 07:18

Missey85 · 10/11/2026 06:59

I imagine Katy Perry figured it out and that's why she divorced the pervert

He famously ended it with her via text.

TheAbsentRoyalUmberella · 10/11/2026 07:07

I don't see anyone making any excuses either

BananaPeels · 10/11/2026 07:06

Missey85 · 10/11/2026 07:03

It's a worrying state of affairs when so many women are making up excuses for him! 🤮

I don’t see attempting to understand why someone is the way they are is excusing him. It is actually very important- how do you prevent things like this happening again?. If anyone has observed this when he was younger, should or could someone have stepped in?

TheAbsentRoyalUmberella · 10/11/2026 07:04

Vile vile dad I do think his dad is so incredibly twisted he believes it when he says Russel has done nothing wrong

Floristian · 10/11/2026 07:04

TheCappyEffect · 09/11/2026 21:03

@BoredZelda read it again 🙄 instead of coming for me I said I wonder if ….I’m not defending anybody or making excuses. Yes he was an adult etc, the point I was trying to make albeit poorly 🙄, is the damage parents can cause. I’m damaged, my son is damaged, nothing sexual like RB & his father may I add!, but behaviours have left lasting damage and trauma.

Just to reiterate, I’m not defending anyone or making excuses.

I understand what you're saying, and you're not defending him at all.