On the religious supporters, this is 11 years old and was about a different sex offender but same concept.
https://www.patheos.com/blogs/lovejoyfeminism/2015/05/josh-duggar-and-the-tale-of-two-boxes.html
I agree with the point that he is bright but lacks a depth of understanding, some of the points he makes come across like a sixth former who is new to these ideas, almost like he stalled there. I don't think that's because he isn't clever enough to gain the depth of understanding if he wanted to - which makes me think he doesn't have interest in that, he's more interested in using it to bamboozle people who assume that the fact he's bright means that what he says is intelligent. There is a sort of admiration which comes with the combination of being bright and extroverted at school, and if he does have narcissistic tendencies then it's possible that he valued that admiration far more than he ever valued the pursuit of knowledge itself.
I think he has been extremely carefully planning his entire public image from about 2010 onwards. He doesn't strike me as impulsive in this manner at all. I believe the younger version of him and all the drugs etc probably was more authentic, mainly because it's quite difficult to have a lot of control over your actions when you're using that much, and if he was originally just looking for attention it is fairly easy to get attention by being controversial. They say no addict ever really recovers, they just swap one addiction for another, and I wouldn't be surprised if he swapped drug addiction for power, and wanted a slice of this new internet celebrity thing. He does seem to have a knack for spotting where the trend is going in this sense and jumping on it. Basically once he realised he wouldn't have the control over the way he presented himself with the channel 4 etc media appearances and moved to Youtube, that seems to be where the master plan started out. I know there have been various analyses, podcasts discussing this whole "journey" etc in the past - I think Conspirituality's section on him was especially good - but the shift was quite clear, it was when he went away from TV media to youtube that his whole focus changed. He got a following easily because he was known, and then he has systematically jumped onto different bandwagons one by one, chasing views and followers.
I remember it being bizarre, because there was a period about 20 years ago where he seemed to be on TV and in "celeb" news etc all the time and his image was very chaotic, like he was modelling himself on some kind of drug addled caricature of a rockstar, he was always saying or doing something outrageous and getting fired from things or criticised for some stunt or another, and then whether it was because I had DS1 so I stopped paying attention to that kind of stuff, or whether it was around that time he stopped appearing on those kinds of things, I don't know. But certainly in my awareness he seemed to dwindle and disappear for a few years, and then a couple of years before COVID - maybe 2016 or so? - he seemed to pop back up but online this time, and rather than being chaotic, controversial and unwashed, he had adopted this new-age persona which was all about rehabilitation from addiction, clean living, "natural" health and how we need to all be kind, and governments/capitalism is all evil and the "old way" and we need to work towards a "new way", themes like that. He had some Facebook page which would regurgitate a constant churn all this new age clickbait, and I found it really bizarre because the British opinion of him still seemed to be "Oh god not that unwashed edgelord loser", to the point his new age stuff almost looked like parody, but the Americans, or anyone my mum's age for example (people who were not watching MTV and E4 in the 00s) who had only come across this new version of him seemed to take it fully at face value and their impression seemed to be "What a nice man!" 🧐
I probably found it weird because of the sort of U-turn he did (which he explained with rehab) but also, because my mum is really into new age spirituality I already had a level of familiarity with it, and the way he was engaging with it was extremely surface level. It wasn't in any way the kind of journey people usually go on when they discover that kind of thing for real. You watch any video of any actual buddhist convert explaining what led to their conversion and it will have more depth and more humanity. He didn't have any of that - it was all soundbites crafted around ideas which almost anybody would agree with, and wrapped in his usual word salad.
If he was a fictional character he would not be believable.